potiuk commented on PR #37609:
URL: https://github.com/apache/airflow/pull/37609#issuecomment-1966554895

   Looks like Chat-GPT generated response. No time to read it, so I shortened 
it with Chat GPT:
   
   ```
   Initially skeptical of Airflow, I found it cumbersome and lacking conceptual 
integrity, akin to scattered building blocks without a coherent design. 
However, a revelation came when I unearthed a pure Python solution buried deep 
within Airflow's documentation, utilizing only the @dag and @task decorators. 
This discovery transformed my perception, turning Airflow from an annoyance to 
an indispensable tool. Motivated by this experience, I crafted a new 
introductory approach, emphasizing the simplicity and power of the decorators. 
Despite suggestions to include the >> operator, I found it confounding and 
incongruent with typical programming flow. Presenting both approaches risks 
confusing new users with unnecessary choices, particularly through a GUI 
interface. Therefore, I advocate for a streamlined introduction focused solely 
on the decorators, aligning with Airflow's architectural elegance and ensuring 
a smoother entry for newcomers without unnecessary complexity.
   ```
   
   This has been discussed multiple times and your point of view is only of 
yours. Airflow has multiple different kind of users - both experienced 
Pythonistas and people who are just data scientists and don't care too much 
about python - they want to put their DAGs from existing building blocks (i.e. 
operators) 
   
   That's why - what we are asking you to make the first page in the way that 
appeal to both kind of users - and the tab switching of different ways of 
programming with Airflow is a good idea. You have to accept the fact of life 
that other people have different experiences and think differently - and 
Airflow does not have to respond to your mindset only, but also to other 
mindsets and our direction guiding you there make it so. Even if not perfectly 
fitting either, making it appealing to both is our goal.
   
   Kind request to adjust to those expectations.
   
   
   
   
   
   


-- 
This is an automated message from the Apache Git Service.
To respond to the message, please log on to GitHub and use the
URL above to go to the specific comment.

To unsubscribe, e-mail: [email protected]

For queries about this service, please contact Infrastructure at:
[email protected]

Reply via email to