o-nikolas commented on PR #1423:
URL: https://github.com/apache/airflow-site/pull/1423#issuecomment-3955002963
> Look at the header of ecosystem page. We have exactly **0** decision
making into what goes in there and exactly **0** responsibility for it as PMC.
This is very clear at the ecosystem page:
Yes, I'm aware, I was thinking out loud on whether we should consider
changing this :slightly_smiling_face:
> If we were to `vet` and decide on what we add and aprove here then:
>
> * we would have to agree on criteria
>
> * and the way to evaluate it
>
> * and have at least a commitee to decide what should be and what
should not be linked here.
Agreed :relaxed: I'm not sure we'd need a committee, but some simple set of
criteria to follow at least.
>
> If you have some concrete proposals @o-nikolas - I think starting a
discussion on devlist is a good point - ideally wiht some ideas how to do it,
but also this bears some responsibilities on the PMC. If we set some criteria,
we need to execute those criteria and have some responsibility to verify those
and keep them verified. Those pages can change any time and start linking to
any content (say adult content) - so if we do it, we need to have some ways ot
verify if they have not changed. IMHO any proposal to verify and approve such
content should also include ways and processes how we keep them following it.
And any proposal here is welcome - but whatever we write in the preamble of the
page, we should stick to it.
>
> Currently it's "sole discretion". which is an easy solutioin and the only
one that we can currently commit to. But if there are any other proposals, I
think posting them on devlist is a good idea.
Yes of course, happy to post on the devlist, just wanted to test the waters
and comment here beside an example when it was top of mind. Though, I get the
sense that this wouldn't be received very well, so I'm happy to drop it. I just
think times are changing, with AI we could find ourselves having a page with
hundreds of tools that were each created in a few days or hours cluttering up
this page. But we can see how it plays out, thanks for the thoughts @potiuk
:smile:
--
This is an automated message from the Apache Git Service.
To respond to the message, please log on to GitHub and use the
URL above to go to the specific comment.
To unsubscribe, e-mail: [email protected]
For queries about this service, please contact Infrastructure at:
[email protected]
