Miretpl commented on code in PR #70242:
URL: https://github.com/apache/airflow/pull/70242#discussion_r3641000045


##########
chart/newsfragments/70242.doc.rst:
##########
@@ -0,0 +1 @@
+Document how to rotate the Fernet key when deploying with the Helm chart.

Review Comment:
   Newsfragment rather not needed for only doc change.



##########
chart/docs/production-guide.rst:
##########
@@ -260,6 +260,82 @@ generated using the secret key has a short expiry time 
though. Make sure that ti
 that you run Airflow components on is synchronized (for example using ntpd). 
You might get
 "forbidden" errors when the logs are accessed otherwise.
 
+Fernet Key
+----------
+
+Airflow uses a Fernet key to encrypt sensitive data, such as connection 
passwords, stored in the metadata database.
+See :doc:`Fernet <apache-airflow:security/secrets/fernet>` for background on 
how this works. If you do not provide a
+key, the chart generates one and stores it in the 
``<RELEASE_NAME>-fernet-key`` Kubernetes Secret the first time you
+run ``helm install``.
+
+.. warning::
+
+   The chart only creates that Secret on ``helm install`` -- it is not 
re-created or otherwise updated by
+   ``helm upgrade``. This applies both to the auto-generated key and to a key 
you pass through ``fernetKey`` in the
+   values file, so neither can be changed by re-running ``helm upgrade``. To 
rotate the Fernet key you need to manage
+   the Secret yourself, as described below.
+
+To provide your own key, either set ``fernetKey`` in the values file:
+
+.. code-block:: yaml
+   :caption: values.yaml
+
+   fernetKey: <fernet_key>
+
+.. warning::
+
+   Due to security concerns, it is advised to use a Kubernetes Secret instead 
of setting the Fernet key directly in
+   the values file. Never commit a ``values.yaml`` containing a plaintext 
Fernet key to version control.
+
+or create your own Kubernetes Secret containing a ``fernet-key`` key with a 
base64-encoded value, and point the chart at it with ``fernetKeySecretName``:
+
+.. code-block:: bash
+
+   kubectl create secret generic my-fernet-key 
--from-literal="fernet-key=<fernet_key>"
+
+.. code-block:: yaml
+   :caption: values.yaml
+
+   fernetKeySecretName: my-fernet-key
+
+.. note::
+
+   ``kubectl create secret`` only creates an object in the cluster -- it is 
not tracked anywhere else. Manage this
+   Secret through your normal Infrastructure-as-Code process (for example a 
GitOps repository, a Sealed Secret, or

Review Comment:
   ```suggestion
      Secret through your Infrastructure-as-a-Code process (for example, a 
GitOps repository, a Sealed Secret, or
   ```



##########
chart/docs/production-guide.rst:
##########
@@ -260,6 +260,82 @@ generated using the secret key has a short expiry time 
though. Make sure that ti
 that you run Airflow components on is synchronized (for example using ntpd). 
You might get
 "forbidden" errors when the logs are accessed otherwise.
 
+Fernet Key
+----------
+
+Airflow uses a Fernet key to encrypt sensitive data, such as connection 
passwords, stored in the metadata database.
+See :doc:`Fernet <apache-airflow:security/secrets/fernet>` for background on 
how this works. If you do not provide a
+key, the chart generates one and stores it in the 
``<RELEASE_NAME>-fernet-key`` Kubernetes Secret the first time you
+run ``helm install``.
+
+.. warning::
+
+   The chart only creates that Secret on ``helm install`` -- it is not 
re-created or otherwise updated by
+   ``helm upgrade``. This applies both to the auto-generated key and to a key 
you pass through ``fernetKey`` in the
+   values file, so neither can be changed by re-running ``helm upgrade``. To 
rotate the Fernet key you need to manage
+   the Secret yourself, as described below.
+
+To provide your own key, either set ``fernetKey`` in the values file:
+
+.. code-block:: yaml
+   :caption: values.yaml
+
+   fernetKey: <fernet_key>
+
+.. warning::
+
+   Due to security concerns, it is advised to use a Kubernetes Secret instead 
of setting the Fernet key directly in
+   the values file. Never commit a ``values.yaml`` containing a plaintext 
Fernet key to version control.
+
+or create your own Kubernetes Secret containing a ``fernet-key`` key with a 
base64-encoded value, and point the chart at it with ``fernetKeySecretName``:
+
+.. code-block:: bash
+
+   kubectl create secret generic my-fernet-key 
--from-literal="fernet-key=<fernet_key>"
+
+.. code-block:: yaml
+   :caption: values.yaml
+
+   fernetKeySecretName: my-fernet-key
+
+.. note::
+
+   ``kubectl create secret`` only creates an object in the cluster -- it is 
not tracked anywhere else. Manage this
+   Secret through your normal Infrastructure-as-Code process (for example a 
GitOps repository, a Sealed Secret, or
+   an External Secrets Operator resource) so it is not lost on a cluster 
migration or a full redeploy.
+
+Rotating the Fernet key
+^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
+
+Once connections, variables and triggers have been encrypted with a Fernet 
key, changing the key outright makes the
+existing encrypted values unreadable. To rotate the key without losing access 
to them, follow the same procedure as
+:doc:`Rotating encryption keys <apache-airflow:security/secrets/fernet>`, 
applied to the Kubernetes Secret that backs
+``AIRFLOW__CORE__FERNET_KEY``:
+
+#. Make sure you are using a self-managed Secret through 
``fernetKeySecretName`` -- as noted above, the
+   chart-generated Secret cannot be updated through ``helm upgrade``.
+#. Update the ``fernet-key`` value in that Secret to a comma-separated list 
``new_fernet_key,old_fernet_key``, using
+   the same ``kubectl create secret`` command as above with ``--dry-run=client 
-o yaml`` piped into ``kubectl apply``
+   so it updates the existing Secret in place instead of failing because it 
already exists:
+
+   .. code-block:: bash
+
+      kubectl create secret generic my-fernet-key \
+        --from-literal="fernet-key=new_fernet_key,old_fernet_key" \
+        --dry-run=client -o yaml | kubectl apply -f -
+
+   Then restart the Airflow components (for example with ``kubectl rollout 
restart``) so they pick up the new value --
+   Kubernetes does not refresh environment variables sourced from a Secret in 
already-running pods.

Review Comment:
   ```suggestion
      Then restart the Airflow components (for example with ``kubectl rollout 
restart``) so they pick up the new value
   ```
   I would say that this is generic Kubernetes knowledge, and it is rather 
unlikely for people without it to try to rotate Fernet Key.



##########
chart/docs/production-guide.rst:
##########
@@ -260,6 +260,82 @@ generated using the secret key has a short expiry time 
though. Make sure that ti
 that you run Airflow components on is synchronized (for example using ntpd). 
You might get
 "forbidden" errors when the logs are accessed otherwise.
 
+Fernet Key
+----------
+
+Airflow uses a Fernet key to encrypt sensitive data, such as connection 
passwords, stored in the metadata database.
+See :doc:`Fernet <apache-airflow:security/secrets/fernet>` for background on 
how this works. If you do not provide a
+key, the chart generates one and stores it in the 
``<RELEASE_NAME>-fernet-key`` Kubernetes Secret the first time you
+run ``helm install``.
+
+.. warning::
+
+   The chart only creates that Secret on ``helm install`` -- it is not 
re-created or otherwise updated by
+   ``helm upgrade``. This applies both to the auto-generated key and to a key 
you pass through ``fernetKey`` in the
+   values file, so neither can be changed by re-running ``helm upgrade``. To 
rotate the Fernet key you need to manage
+   the Secret yourself, as described below.

Review Comment:
   ```suggestion
      The chart only creates that Secret on ``helm install`` -- it is not 
re-created or otherwise updated by
      ``helm upgrade``. This applies both to the auto-generated key and to a 
key you pass through ``fernetKey`` in the values file. To rotate the Fernet 
key, you need to manage the Secret yourself, as described below.
   ```



##########
chart/docs/production-guide.rst:
##########
@@ -260,6 +260,82 @@ generated using the secret key has a short expiry time 
though. Make sure that ti
 that you run Airflow components on is synchronized (for example using ntpd). 
You might get
 "forbidden" errors when the logs are accessed otherwise.
 
+Fernet Key
+----------
+
+Airflow uses a Fernet key to encrypt sensitive data, such as connection 
passwords, stored in the metadata database.
+See :doc:`Fernet <apache-airflow:security/secrets/fernet>` for background on 
how this works. If you do not provide a
+key, the chart generates one and stores it in the 
``<RELEASE_NAME>-fernet-key`` Kubernetes Secret the first time you
+run ``helm install``.
+
+.. warning::
+
+   The chart only creates that Secret on ``helm install`` -- it is not 
re-created or otherwise updated by
+   ``helm upgrade``. This applies both to the auto-generated key and to a key 
you pass through ``fernetKey`` in the
+   values file, so neither can be changed by re-running ``helm upgrade``. To 
rotate the Fernet key you need to manage
+   the Secret yourself, as described below.
+
+To provide your own key, either set ``fernetKey`` in the values file:
+
+.. code-block:: yaml
+   :caption: values.yaml
+
+   fernetKey: <fernet_key>
+
+.. warning::
+
+   Due to security concerns, it is advised to use a Kubernetes Secret instead 
of setting the Fernet key directly in
+   the values file. Never commit a ``values.yaml`` containing a plaintext 
Fernet key to version control.
+
+or create your own Kubernetes Secret containing a ``fernet-key`` key with a 
base64-encoded value, and point the chart at it with ``fernetKeySecretName``:
+
+.. code-block:: bash
+
+   kubectl create secret generic my-fernet-key 
--from-literal="fernet-key=<fernet_key>"
+
+.. code-block:: yaml
+   :caption: values.yaml
+
+   fernetKeySecretName: my-fernet-key
+
+.. note::
+
+   ``kubectl create secret`` only creates an object in the cluster -- it is 
not tracked anywhere else. Manage this
+   Secret through your normal Infrastructure-as-Code process (for example a 
GitOps repository, a Sealed Secret, or
+   an External Secrets Operator resource) so it is not lost on a cluster 
migration or a full redeploy.
+
+Rotating the Fernet key
+^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
+
+Once connections, variables and triggers have been encrypted with a Fernet 
key, changing the key outright makes the
+existing encrypted values unreadable. To rotate the key without losing access 
to them, follow the same procedure as
+:doc:`Rotating encryption keys <apache-airflow:security/secrets/fernet>`, 
applied to the Kubernetes Secret that backs
+``AIRFLOW__CORE__FERNET_KEY``:
+
+#. Make sure you are using a self-managed Secret through 
``fernetKeySecretName`` -- as noted above, the
+   chart-generated Secret cannot be updated through ``helm upgrade``.
+#. Update the ``fernet-key`` value in that Secret to a comma-separated list 
``new_fernet_key,old_fernet_key``, using
+   the same ``kubectl create secret`` command as above with ``--dry-run=client 
-o yaml`` piped into ``kubectl apply``
+   so it updates the existing Secret in place instead of failing because it 
already exists:
+
+   .. code-block:: bash
+
+      kubectl create secret generic my-fernet-key \
+        --from-literal="fernet-key=new_fernet_key,old_fernet_key" \
+        --dry-run=client -o yaml | kubectl apply -f -
+
+   Then restart the Airflow components (for example with ``kubectl rollout 
restart``) so they pick up the new value --
+   Kubernetes does not refresh environment variables sourced from a Secret in 
already-running pods.
+#. Run ``airflow rotate-fernet-key`` to re-encrypt existing connections, 
variables and triggers with the new key.
+#. Update the Secret again, the same way, so it only contains 
``new_fernet_key``, and restart the components once
+   more:

Review Comment:
   ```suggestion
   #. Update the Secret, so it only contains ``new_fernet_key``, and restart 
the components once more:
   ```



##########
chart/docs/production-guide.rst:
##########
@@ -260,6 +260,82 @@ generated using the secret key has a short expiry time 
though. Make sure that ti
 that you run Airflow components on is synchronized (for example using ntpd). 
You might get
 "forbidden" errors when the logs are accessed otherwise.
 
+Fernet Key
+----------
+
+Airflow uses a Fernet key to encrypt sensitive data, such as connection 
passwords, stored in the metadata database.
+See :doc:`Fernet <apache-airflow:security/secrets/fernet>` for background on 
how this works. If you do not provide a
+key, the chart generates one and stores it in the 
``<RELEASE_NAME>-fernet-key`` Kubernetes Secret the first time you
+run ``helm install``.
+
+.. warning::
+
+   The chart only creates that Secret on ``helm install`` -- it is not 
re-created or otherwise updated by
+   ``helm upgrade``. This applies both to the auto-generated key and to a key 
you pass through ``fernetKey`` in the
+   values file, so neither can be changed by re-running ``helm upgrade``. To 
rotate the Fernet key you need to manage
+   the Secret yourself, as described below.
+
+To provide your own key, either set ``fernetKey`` in the values file:
+
+.. code-block:: yaml
+   :caption: values.yaml
+
+   fernetKey: <fernet_key>
+
+.. warning::
+
+   Due to security concerns, it is advised to use a Kubernetes Secret instead 
of setting the Fernet key directly in
+   the values file. Never commit a ``values.yaml`` containing a plaintext 
Fernet key to version control.
+
+or create your own Kubernetes Secret containing a ``fernet-key`` key with a 
base64-encoded value, and point the chart at it with ``fernetKeySecretName``:
+
+.. code-block:: bash
+
+   kubectl create secret generic my-fernet-key 
--from-literal="fernet-key=<fernet_key>"
+
+.. code-block:: yaml
+   :caption: values.yaml
+
+   fernetKeySecretName: my-fernet-key
+
+.. note::
+
+   ``kubectl create secret`` only creates an object in the cluster -- it is 
not tracked anywhere else. Manage this
+   Secret through your normal Infrastructure-as-Code process (for example a 
GitOps repository, a Sealed Secret, or
+   an External Secrets Operator resource) so it is not lost on a cluster 
migration or a full redeploy.
+
+Rotating the Fernet key
+^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
+
+Once connections, variables and triggers have been encrypted with a Fernet 
key, changing the key outright makes the
+existing encrypted values unreadable. To rotate the key without losing access 
to them, follow the same procedure as
+:doc:`Rotating encryption keys <apache-airflow:security/secrets/fernet>`, 
applied to the Kubernetes Secret that backs
+``AIRFLOW__CORE__FERNET_KEY``:
+
+#. Make sure you are using a self-managed Secret through 
``fernetKeySecretName`` -- as noted above, the
+   chart-generated Secret cannot be updated through ``helm upgrade``.
+#. Update the ``fernet-key`` value in that Secret to a comma-separated list 
``new_fernet_key,old_fernet_key``, using
+   the same ``kubectl create secret`` command as above with ``--dry-run=client 
-o yaml`` piped into ``kubectl apply``
+   so it updates the existing Secret in place instead of failing because it 
already exists:
+
+   .. code-block:: bash
+
+      kubectl create secret generic my-fernet-key \
+        --from-literal="fernet-key=new_fernet_key,old_fernet_key" \
+        --dry-run=client -o yaml | kubectl apply -f -
+
+   Then restart the Airflow components (for example with ``kubectl rollout 
restart``) so they pick up the new value --
+   Kubernetes does not refresh environment variables sourced from a Secret in 
already-running pods.
+#. Run ``airflow rotate-fernet-key`` to re-encrypt existing connections, 
variables and triggers with the new key.

Review Comment:
   ```suggestion
   #. Run ``airflow rotate-fernet-key``, in one of the Airflow components pods, 
to re-encrypt existing connections, variables and triggers with the new key.
   ```



##########
chart/docs/production-guide.rst:
##########
@@ -260,6 +260,82 @@ generated using the secret key has a short expiry time 
though. Make sure that ti
 that you run Airflow components on is synchronized (for example using ntpd). 
You might get
 "forbidden" errors when the logs are accessed otherwise.
 
+Fernet Key
+----------
+
+Airflow uses a Fernet key to encrypt sensitive data, such as connection 
passwords, stored in the metadata database.
+See :doc:`Fernet <apache-airflow:security/secrets/fernet>` for background on 
how this works. If you do not provide a
+key, the chart generates one and stores it in the 
``<RELEASE_NAME>-fernet-key`` Kubernetes Secret the first time you
+run ``helm install``.
+
+.. warning::
+
+   The chart only creates that Secret on ``helm install`` -- it is not 
re-created or otherwise updated by
+   ``helm upgrade``. This applies both to the auto-generated key and to a key 
you pass through ``fernetKey`` in the
+   values file, so neither can be changed by re-running ``helm upgrade``. To 
rotate the Fernet key you need to manage
+   the Secret yourself, as described below.
+
+To provide your own key, either set ``fernetKey`` in the values file:
+
+.. code-block:: yaml
+   :caption: values.yaml
+
+   fernetKey: <fernet_key>
+
+.. warning::
+
+   Due to security concerns, it is advised to use a Kubernetes Secret instead 
of setting the Fernet key directly in
+   the values file. Never commit a ``values.yaml`` containing a plaintext 
Fernet key to version control.
+
+or create your own Kubernetes Secret containing a ``fernet-key`` key with a 
base64-encoded value, and point the chart at it with ``fernetKeySecretName``:
+
+.. code-block:: bash
+
+   kubectl create secret generic my-fernet-key 
--from-literal="fernet-key=<fernet_key>"
+
+.. code-block:: yaml
+   :caption: values.yaml
+
+   fernetKeySecretName: my-fernet-key
+
+.. note::
+
+   ``kubectl create secret`` only creates an object in the cluster -- it is 
not tracked anywhere else. Manage this
+   Secret through your normal Infrastructure-as-Code process (for example a 
GitOps repository, a Sealed Secret, or
+   an External Secrets Operator resource) so it is not lost on a cluster 
migration or a full redeploy.
+
+Rotating the Fernet key
+^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
+
+Once connections, variables and triggers have been encrypted with a Fernet 
key, changing the key outright makes the
+existing encrypted values unreadable. To rotate the key without losing access 
to them, follow the same procedure as
+:doc:`Rotating encryption keys <apache-airflow:security/secrets/fernet>`, 
applied to the Kubernetes Secret that backs
+``AIRFLOW__CORE__FERNET_KEY``:
+
+#. Make sure you are using a self-managed Secret through 
``fernetKeySecretName`` -- as noted above, the
+   chart-generated Secret cannot be updated through ``helm upgrade``.

Review Comment:
   ```suggestion
   #. Make sure you are using a self-managed Secret through 
``fernetKeySecretName``
   ```
   This information is close enough to this part of the text that it doesn't 
need to be repeated.



-- 
This is an automated message from the Apache Git Service.
To respond to the message, please log on to GitHub and use the
URL above to go to the specific comment.

To unsubscribe, e-mail: [email protected]

For queries about this service, please contact Infrastructure at:
[email protected]

Reply via email to