skorchir opened a new issue, #14715: URL: https://github.com/apache/cloudstack/issues/14715
### problem `registerTemplate` and `registerIso` declare their `url` parameter with `length = 2048`, and `VMTemplateVO` maps the column with `length = 2048`. The column itself is `VARCHAR(1024)`: #8675 (the fix for #8669, released in 4.19.1) widened it from 255 to 1024 in `schema-41900to41910.sql`, and no later upgrade script changes it. A URL of 1025 to 2048 characters therefore passes the API's length check and fails afterwards, when the template row is written. The caller gets a generic internal error that names neither the URL nor a limit: seen in practice with a presigned URL of about 1700 characters, which came back as HTTP 530 with `cserrorcode` 4250. The cause given here is from reading the source. URLs of that length are ordinary for object storage. An S3 presigned URL signed with temporary credentials (an instance role, a task role, an assumed role) carries an `X-Amz-Security-Token` of about a thousand characters and usually comes to 1500–1800 characters in all. The same object signed with a long-lived access key gives a URL of 500–600 characters, which registers. #8669 was this trigger at the old 255 limit. The sibling columns were widened to 2048 back in 4.8 (`schema-471to480.sql`: `template_store_ref.url`, `volume_store_ref.url`, `volume_store_ref.download_url`, `upload.url`, `image_store.url`). `vm_template.url` is the one left behind. ### versions Read in the source at tags 4.20.0.0 and 4.23.0.0 and on `main` (2026-11-16): `RegisterTemplateCmd`, `RegisterIsoCmd`, `VMTemplateVO`, `schema-41900to41910.sql`. By the upgrade scripts, every release from 4.19.1 on has the 1024 column. ### The steps to reproduce the bug 1. Take any reachable template URL and pad its query string until the whole URL is longer than 1024 characters and shorter than 2048 (or presign an S3 object with temporary credentials). 2. Call `registerTemplate` (or `registerIso`) with it. 3. The call fails with a generic internal error instead of registering the template. A URL of 1024 characters or fewer for the same object registers. ### What to do about it? Widen `vm_template.url` to `VARCHAR(2048)` in an upgrade script, so the column matches the API parameter, the VO and the sibling tables. Failing that, lower the parameter's `length` to 1024 so the API refuses the URL with a message that names the limit. -- This is an automated message from the Apache Git Service. To respond to the message, please log on to GitHub and use the URL above to go to the specific comment. To unsubscribe, e-mail: [email protected] For queries about this service, please contact Infrastructure at: [email protected]
