commits  

Messages by Date

• 2026/09/01 Re: [PR] refactor(schema): schema util contracts, dead API and folds [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/09/01 Re: [PR] [HUDI-18888] fix(streamer): downgrade source-emitted V2 checkpoint to V1 for v6 writes [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/09/01 Re: [PR] feat(utilities): add fail-fast continuous mode for HoodieMultiTableStreamer [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/09/01 Re: [PR] refactor(schema): schema util contracts, dead API and folds [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/09/01 Re: [PR] refactor(schema): schema util contracts, dead API and folds [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/09/01 [PR] feat(utilities): add fail-fast continuous mode for HoodieMultiTableSt… [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/09/01 Re: [PR] refactor(schema): dissolve AvroSchemaUtils, dedupe compat [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/09/01 Re: [PR] refactor(schema): schema util contracts, dead API and folds [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/09/01 Re: [PR] feat(variant): infer shredding schemas by default on Spark 4.1+ [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/09/01 Re: [PR] feat(variant): infer shredding schemas by default on Spark 4.1+ [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/09/01 Re: [PR] refactor(schema): dissolve AvroSchemaUtils, dedupe compat [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/09/01 [PR] chore(trino): advance trino master pin to 40b70400a8a6 [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/09/01 Re: [PR] perf(spark): restore Catalyst fast-paths for SimpleKeyGen/Nonpartitioned bulk insert [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/09/01 Re: [PR] refactor(schema): schema util contracts, dead API and folds [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/09/01 Re: [PR] perf(spark): restore Catalyst fast-paths for SimpleKeyGen/Nonpartitioned bulk insert [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/09/01 Re: [PR] refactor(schema): dissolve AvroSchemaUtils, dedupe compat [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/09/01 Re: [PR] feat(variant): infer shredding schemas by default on Spark 4.1+ [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/09/01 Re: [PR] refactor(schema): schema util contracts, dead API and folds [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/09/01 Re: [PR] [MINOR] Release every client resource on close even when an earlier one fails [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/09/01 Re: [PR] refactor(schema): schema util contracts, dead API and folds [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/09/01 [PR] 16639 schema utils b [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/09/01 Re: [PR] [MINOR] Do not return a negative Spark partition when a hash is Integer.MIN_VALUE [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/09/01 Re: [PR] 16639 schema utils a [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/09/01 Re: [PR] [MINOR] Release every client resource on close even when an earlier one fails [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/09/01 (hudi) branch master updated: fix(variant): project PushVariantIntoScan struct paths in the ... (#19783) vhs
• 2026/09/01 Re: [PR] [MINOR] Release every client resource on close even when an earlier one fails [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/09/01 [PR] 16639 schema utils a [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/09/01 Re: [I] Revisit TestData methods [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/09/01 Re: [PR] feat(flink): add partitioned rli boostrap operator [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/09/01 Re: [PR] feat(variant): infer shredding schemas by default on Spark 4.1+ [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/09/01 Re: [PR] feat(variant): infer shredding schemas by default on Spark 4.1+ [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/09/01 Re: [PR] [MINOR] Release every client resource on close even when an earlier one fails [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/09/01 Re: [PR] feat(variant): infer shredding schemas by default on Spark 4.1+ [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/09/01 Re: [PR] feat(variant): infer shredding schemas by default on Spark 4.1+ [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/09/01 Re: [PR] perf(spark): restore Catalyst fast-paths for SimpleKeyGen/Nonpartitioned bulk insert [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/09/01 Re: [PR] feat(variant): infer shredding schemas by default on Spark 4.1+ [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/09/01 Re: [PR] perf(spark): restore Catalyst fast-paths for SimpleKeyGen/Nonpartitioned bulk insert [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/09/01 Re: [PR] feat(variant): infer shredding schemas by default on Spark 4.1+ [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/09/01 (hudi) branch variant-shredding-inference-default-on deleted (was 404c531ada8d) vhs
• 2026/09/01 (hudi) branch variant-shredding-inference-default-on created (now 404c531ada8d) vhs
• 2026/09/01 (hudi) 01/01: fix(spark3): reject shredded variant struct reads vhs
• 2026/09/01 Re: [PR] chore(trino): advance trino master pin to 40b70400a8a6 [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/09/01 Re: [PR] feat(variant): infer shredding schemas by default on Spark 4.1+ [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/09/01 (hudi) branch master updated: chore(trino): advance trino master pin to 40b70400a8a6 (#19807) vhs
• 2026/09/01 Re: [PR] chore(trino): advance trino master pin to 40b70400a8a6 [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/09/01 Re: [PR] [HUDI-736] Simplify ReflectionUtils#getTopLevelClassesInClasspath [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/09/01 Re: [PR] [HUDI-736] Simplify ReflectionUtils#getTopLevelClassesInClasspath [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/09/01 Re: [PR] [MINOR] Release every client resource on close even when an earlier one fails [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/09/01 Re: [PR] [MINOR] Release every client resource on close even when an earlier one fails [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/09/01 Re: [PR] [HUDI-736] Simplify ReflectionUtils#getTopLevelClassesInClasspath [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/09/01 Re: [I] Pin nested-shredded variant base files through the Spark-native internal read path; extend the full-variant rewrite to struct paths if red [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/09/01 Re: [PR] fix(variant): project PushVariantIntoScan struct paths in the ... [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/09/01 Re: [I] Revisit TestData methods [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/09/01 Re: [PR] feat(variant): infer shredding schemas by default on Spark 4.1+ [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/09/01 Re: [PR] feat(variant): infer shredding schemas by default on Spark 4.1+ [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/09/01 Re: [PR] chore(trino): advance trino master pin to 40b70400a8a6 [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/09/01 Re: [PR] feat(variant): infer shredding schemas by default on Spark 4.1+ [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/09/01 [PR] feat(variant): infer shredding schemas by default on Spark 4.1+ [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/09/01 Re: [PR] [DNM] Release 1.2.1 staging [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/09/01 Re: [PR] chore(trino): advance trino master pin to 40b70400a8a6 [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/09/01 Re: [PR] [HUDI-736] Simplify ReflectionUtils#getTopLevelClassesInClasspath [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/09/01 Re: [I] Decouple hive from bundle test [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/09/01 Re: [I] Add more tests to TestCOWDataSource for TimestampbasedKeyGen [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/09/01 Re: [I] Use Command line options instead of positional arguments when launching spark applications from various CLI commands [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/09/01 Re: [I] Replace variables/comments named "data files" to "base file" [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/09/01 Re: [PR] fix(variant): project PushVariantIntoScan struct paths in the ... [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/09/01 Re: [PR] [DNM] Release 1.2.1 staging [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/09/01 Re: [PR] [DNM] Release 1.2.1 staging [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/09/01 Re: [PR] fix(variant): project PushVariantIntoScan struct paths in the ... [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/09/01 Re: [PR] [DNM] Release 1.2.1 staging [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/09/01 Re: [PR] [BUG] Fix delete_partition followed by re-insert silently loses data under NBCC [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/09/01 Re: [PR] [MINOR] Do not return a negative Spark partition when a hash is Integer.MIN_VALUE [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/09/01 Re: [PR] [MINOR] Do not return a negative Spark partition when a hash is Integer.MIN_VALUE [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/09/01 Re: [PR] feat(flink): add partitioned rli boostrap operator [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/09/01 Re: [PR] fix(variant): project PushVariantIntoScan struct paths in the ... [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/09/01 Re: [PR] fix(variant): project PushVariantIntoScan struct paths in the ... [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/09/01 Re: [PR] [BUG] Fix delete_partition followed by re-insert silently loses data under NBCC [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/09/01 Re: [PR] [MINOR] Do not return a negative Spark partition when a hash is Integer.MIN_VALUE [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/09/01 Re: [PR] [MINOR] Do not return a negative Spark partition when a hash is Integer.MIN_VALUE [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/09/01 Re: [PR] [MINOR] Do not return a negative Spark partition when a hash is Integer.MIN_VALUE [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/09/01 Re: [I] support collect colums stats for native lance logs [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/09/01 Re: [I] Support collect colums stats for native ORC logs [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/09/01 Re: [PR] fix(variant): project PushVariantIntoScan struct paths in the ... [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/09/01 Re: [PR] refactor(reader): Use reader context API for legacy scanner delete re… [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/09/01 Re: [PR] [MINOR] Do not return a negative Spark partition when a hash is Integer.MIN_VALUE [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/09/01 Re: [PR] [BUG] Fix delete_partition followed by re-insert silently loses data under NBCC [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/09/01 Re: [PR] [BUG] Fix delete_partition followed by re-insert silently loses data under NBCC [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/08/31 [PR] [BUG] Fix delete_partition followed by re-insert silently loses data under NBCC [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/08/31 Re: [PR] [DNM] Release 1.2.1 staging [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/08/31 Re: [PR] [MINOR] Do not return a negative Spark partition when a hash is Integer.MIN_VALUE [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/08/31 Re: [PR] feat(flink): add partitioned rli boostrap operator [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/08/31 Re: [PR] feat(flink): add partitioned rli boostrap operator [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/08/31 Re: [PR] feat(flink): add partitioned rli boostrap operator [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/08/31 Re: [PR] [HUDI-18888] fix(streamer): downgrade source-emitted V2 checkpoint to V1 for v6 writes [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/08/31 Re: [PR] feat(flink): add partitioned rli boostrap operator [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/08/31 [PR] feat(flink): add partitioned rli boostrap operator [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/08/31 Re: [PR] refactor(reader): Use reader context API for legacy scanner delete re… [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/08/31 Re: [I] [BUG] delete_partition followed by re-insert silently loses data under Non-Blocking Concurrency Control [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/08/31 Re: [PR] [MINOR] Do not return a negative Spark partition when a hash is Integer.MIN_VALUE [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/08/31 Re: [PR] [MINOR] Do not return a negative Spark partition when a hash is Integer.MIN_VALUE [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/08/31 Re: [PR] feat: Add ClusteringGroupWriter SPI for pluggable clustering writes [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/08/31 Re: [PR] fix(nbcc): reject insert overwrite combined with non-blocking concurrency control [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/08/31 Re: [PR] [MINOR] Release every client resource on close even when an earlier one fails [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/08/31 Re: [PR] [DNM] Release 1.2.1 staging [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/08/31 Re: [PR] [HUDI-736] Simplify ReflectionUtils#getTopLevelClassesInClasspath [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/08/31 Re: [PR] feat(storage): support separate zstd level for native parquet logs [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/08/31 Re: [PR] fix(bulk-insert): add write config constructors to all sort mode partitioners [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/08/31 Re: [PR] fix(utilities): validate the common partitions before failing on a partition mismatch [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/08/31 Re: [PR] [MINOR] Do not return a negative Spark partition when a hash is Integer.MIN_VALUE [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/08/31 Re: [PR] fix(metadata): use committed Spark write statuses after retries [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/08/31 Re: [PR] feat(spark): support clustering for LSM tables [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/08/31 Re: [PR] fix(metadata): indexing action initializes the partition it asked for [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/08/31 Re: [PR] refactor(reader): Use reader context API for legacy scanner delete re… [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/08/31 Re: [PR] docs(cli): document all 106 CLI commands [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/08/31 Re: [PR] fix(metrics): handle stale DistributedRegistry across SparkContext restarts. [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/08/31 Re: [PR] fix(lock): unify default FS lock path and make CLI lock config take effect [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/08/31 Re: [PR] refactor(reader): Use reader context API for legacy scanner delete re… [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/08/31 (hudi) 01/01: chore(trino): advance trino master pin to 40b70400a8a6 github-bot
• 2026/08/31 (hudi) branch bot/trino-pin updated (2ce6a675158e -> 8a3e1083769c) github-bot
• 2026/08/31 Re: [PR] refactor(reader): Use reader context API for legacy scanner delete re… [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/08/31 (hudi) branch master updated: fix(core): record the ordering field when upgrading a table from version 1 (#19803) yihua
• 2026/08/31 Re: [PR] [DNM] Release 1.2.1 staging [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/08/31 Re: [PR] refactor(reader): Use reader context API for legacy scanner delete re… [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/08/31 Re: [PR] fix(core): record the ordering field when upgrading a table from version 1 [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/08/31 (hudi) branch branch-0.x updated: fix(core): record the ordering field when upgrading a table from version 1 (#19739) yihua
• 2026/08/31 Re: [PR] fix(variant): project PushVariantIntoScan struct paths in the ... [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/08/31 Re: [PR] fix(core): record the ordering field when upgrading a table from version 1 [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/08/31 [PR] refactor(reader): Use reader context API for legacy scanner delete re… [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/08/31 Re: [PR] feat(spark): support clustering for LSM tables [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/08/31 Re: [PR] feat(metadata): add standalone metadata table services tool [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/08/31 Re: [PR] docs: add batch vector search demo + notebook for RFC-102 [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/08/31 Re: [PR] [DNM] Release 1.2.1 staging [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/08/31 Re: [PR] fix(variant): project PushVariantIntoScan struct paths in the ... [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/08/31 Re: [PR] fix(variant): project PushVariantIntoScan struct paths in the ... [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/08/31 Re: [PR] fix(variant): project PushVariantIntoScan struct paths in the ... [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/08/31 Re: [PR] feat(spark): support clustering for LSM tables [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/08/31 Re: [PR] feat(spark): support clustering for LSM tables [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/08/31 Re: [PR] feat(metadata): add standalone metadata table services tool [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/08/31 Re: [PR] feat(metadata): add standalone metadata table services tool [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/08/31 Re: [PR] docs: add batch vector search demo + notebook for RFC-102 [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/08/31 Re: [PR] fix(core): record the ordering field when upgrading a table from version 1 [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/08/31 Re: [PR] fix(core): record the ordering field when upgrading a table from version 1 [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/08/31 Re: [PR] fix(core): record the ordering field when upgrading a table from version 1 [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/08/31 Re: [PR] fix(core): record the ordering field when upgrading a table from version 1 [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/08/31 Re: [PR] docs: add batch vector search demo + notebook for RFC-102 [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/08/31 Re: [PR] [DNM] Release 1.2.1 staging [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/08/31 Re: [PR] fix(core): record the ordering field when upgrading a table from version 1 [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/08/31 Re: [PR] fix(core): record the ordering field when upgrading a table from version 1 [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/08/31 Re: [PR] fix(core): record the ordering field when upgrading a table from version 1 [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/08/31 [PR] fix(core): record the ordering field when upgrading a table from version 1 [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/08/31 Re: [PR] feat(core): serve Hudi metadata tables through reader v2, sharded and memory-bounded [hudi-rs] via GitHub
• 2026/08/31 Re: [PR] (WIP) benchmark: [RFC-98] COW table read performance comparison [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/08/31 Re: [PR] [HUDI-18888] fix(streamer): downgrade source-emitted V2 checkpoint to V1 for v6 writes [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/08/31 [PR] feat(index): add IVF RaBitQ vector indexing [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/08/31 (hudi) branch master updated: fix(common): prevent multi-table commits failing with metrics enabled (#19787) danny0405
• 2026/08/31 Re: [PR] feat: Add ClusteringGroupWriter SPI for pluggable clustering writes [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/08/31 Re: [PR] feat(spark): support clustering for LSM tables [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/08/31 (hudi) branch asf-site updated: docs(record-merger): document projection compatibility and mandatory merge fields (#19586) vhs
• 2026/08/31 Re: [PR] feat(spark): support clustering for LSM tables [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/08/31 Re: [PR] fix(metadata): use committed Spark write statuses after retries [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/08/31 [PR] fix(metadata): use committed Spark write statuses after retries [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/08/31 Re: [PR] fix(metadata): use committed Spark write statuses after retries [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/08/31 Re: [PR] fix(variant): project PushVariantIntoScan struct paths in the ... [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/08/31 Re: [PR] feat(spark): support clustering for LSM tables [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/08/31 Re: [PR] feat(spark): support clustering for LSM tables [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/08/31 Re: [PR] fix(variant): project PushVariantIntoScan struct paths in the ... [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/08/31 Re: [PR] docs(rfc): RFC-109 native vector search support in Apache Hudi [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/08/31 Re: [PR] fix(metadata): use committed Spark write statuses after retries [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/08/31 Re: [PR] fix(cli): repair the hudi-cli tests and re-enable the module in CI [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/08/31 Re: [PR] docs(cleaning): document partition TTL [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/08/31 Re: [PR] docs(rfc): RFC-109 native vector search support in Apache Hudi [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/08/31 Re: [PR] docs(record-merger): document projection compatibility and mandatory merge fields [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/08/31 Re: [PR] [DNM] Release 1.2.1 staging [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/08/31 Re: [PR] fix(common): preserve null values in configured ordering fields [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/08/31 Re: [PR] fix(metrics): handle stale DistributedRegistry across SparkContext restarts. [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/08/31 Re: [PR] fix(metadata): use committed Spark write statuses after retries [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/08/31 Re: [PR] docs(rfc): RFC-109 native vector search support in Apache Hudi [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/08/31 Re: [PR] docs(rfc): RFC-109 native vector search support in Apache Hudi [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/08/31 Re: [PR] feat(index): add IVF RaBitQ vector indexing [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/08/31 Re: [PR] fix(build): tidy shade config drift ahead of hoisting the POM flags [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/08/31 Re: [PR] feat(index): add IVF RaBitQ vector indexing [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/08/31 Re: [I] Unsynchronized `LocalRegistry.clear()` can NPE mid-commit and truncate the completed commit metadata file, permanently breaking the table [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/08/31 Re: [PR] feat(index): add IVF RaBitQ vector indexing [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/08/31 Re: [PR] fix(metadata): use committed Spark write statuses after retries [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/08/31 Re: [PR] fix(metadata): use committed Spark write statuses after retries [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/08/31 Re: [PR] feat(index): add IVF RaBitQ vector indexing [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/08/31 Re: [PR] docs(rfc): RFC-109 native vector search support in Apache Hudi [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/08/31 Re: [PR] docs(rfc): RFC-109 native vector search support in Apache Hudi [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/08/31 Re: [PR] docs(rfc): RFC-109 native vector search support in Apache Hudi [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/08/31 Re: [PR] docs(rfc): RFC-109 native vector search support in Apache Hudi [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/08/31 Re: [PR] fix(metadata): use committed Spark write statuses after retries [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/08/31 Re: [PR] docs(rfc): RFC-109 native vector search support in Apache Hudi [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/08/31 Re: [PR] fix(common): preserve null values in configured ordering fields [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/08/31 Re: [PR] fix(metadata): use committed Spark write statuses after retries [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/08/31 Re: [PR] docs(rfc): RFC-109 native vector search support in Apache Hudi [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/08/31 Re: [PR] docs(rfc): RFC-109 native vector search support in Apache Hudi [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/08/31 Re: [PR] feat(flink): add new RocksDBPartitionedIndexBackend [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/08/31 (hudi) branch master updated: fix(build): tidy shade config drift ahead of hoisting the POM flags (#19492) vhs
• 2026/08/31 Re: [PR] fix(common): preserve null values in configured ordering fields [hudi] via GitHub
• 2026/08/31 Re: [PR] fix(common): preserve null values in configured ordering fields [hudi] via GitHub

• Earlier messages
• Later messages