cxx122 opened a new issue, #15198:
URL: https://github.com/apache/tvm/issues/15198

   The optimization of schedule for data reuse will bring a certain loss of 
precision, and functions such as tir.sin will amplify the loss later.
   
   ```
   def te_test():
       data_pad = te.placeholder([100], name='data_pad')
       ic = te.reduce_axis([0, 100], name='ic')
       conv2d_NCHWc = te.compute([1], lambda oc_chunk: te.sum(data_pad[ic], 
axis=[ic]), name='conv2d_NCHWc')
       inline_tensor = te.compute([1], lambda ax1: tir.sin(conv2d_NCHWc[ax1]), 
name='inline_tensor')
       return [data_pad, conv2d_NCHWc, inline_tensor]
   ```
   
   ### Actual behavior
   
   ```
   Not equal to tolerance rtol=1e-05, atol=1e-07
   
   Mismatched elements: 1 / 1 (100%)
   Max absolute difference: 1.3440847e-05
   Max relative difference: 2.8351633e-05
    x: array([0.474063], dtype=float32)
    y: array([0.474077], dtype=float32)
   @main = primfn(data_pad_1: handle, conv2d_NCHWc_1: handle, inline_tensor_1: 
handle) -> ()
     attr = {"from_legacy_te_schedule": True, "global_symbol": "main", 
"tir.noalias": True}
     buffers = {data_pad: Buffer(data_pad_2: Pointer(float32), float32, [100], 
[]),
                conv2d_NCHWc: Buffer(conv2d_NCHWc_2: Pointer(float32), float32, 
[1], []),
                inline_tensor: Buffer(inline_tensor_2: Pointer(float32), 
float32, [1], [])}
     buffer_map = {data_pad_1: data_pad, conv2d_NCHWc_1: conv2d_NCHWc, 
inline_tensor_1: inline_tensor}
     preflattened_buffer_map = {data_pad_1: data_pad_3: Buffer(data_pad_2, 
float32, [100], []), conv2d_NCHWc_1: conv2d_NCHWc_3: Buffer(conv2d_NCHWc_2, 
float32, [1], []), inline_tensor_1: inline_tensor_3: Buffer(inline_tensor_2, 
float32, [1], [])} {
     allocate(conv2d_NCHWc.rf: Pointer(global float32), float32, [20]), 
storage_scope = global {
       for (oc_chunk.ic.outer.fused: int32, 0, 20) "parallel" {
         let cse_var_1: int32 = (oc_chunk.ic.outer.fused*5)
          {
           conv2d_NCHWc.rf_1: Buffer(conv2d_NCHWc.rf, float32, [20], [], 
align=64)[oc_chunk.ic.outer.fused] = 0f32
           conv2d_NCHWc.rf_1[oc_chunk.ic.outer.fused] = 
(conv2d_NCHWc.rf_1[oc_chunk.ic.outer.fused] + data_pad[cse_var_1])
           conv2d_NCHWc.rf_1[oc_chunk.ic.outer.fused] = 
(conv2d_NCHWc.rf_1[oc_chunk.ic.outer.fused] + data_pad[(cse_var_1 + 1)])
           conv2d_NCHWc.rf_1[oc_chunk.ic.outer.fused] = 
(conv2d_NCHWc.rf_1[oc_chunk.ic.outer.fused] + data_pad[(cse_var_1 + 2)])
           conv2d_NCHWc.rf_1[oc_chunk.ic.outer.fused] = 
(conv2d_NCHWc.rf_1[oc_chunk.ic.outer.fused] + data_pad[(cse_var_1 + 3)])
           conv2d_NCHWc.rf_1[oc_chunk.ic.outer.fused] = 
(conv2d_NCHWc.rf_1[oc_chunk.ic.outer.fused] + data_pad[(cse_var_1 + 4)])
         }
       }
       conv2d_NCHWc[0] = 0f32
       conv2d_NCHWc[0] = (conv2d_NCHWc[0] + conv2d_NCHWc.rf_1[0])
       conv2d_NCHWc[0] = (conv2d_NCHWc[0] + conv2d_NCHWc.rf_1[1])
       conv2d_NCHWc[0] = (conv2d_NCHWc[0] + conv2d_NCHWc.rf_1[2])
       conv2d_NCHWc[0] = (conv2d_NCHWc[0] + conv2d_NCHWc.rf_1[3])
       conv2d_NCHWc[0] = (conv2d_NCHWc[0] + conv2d_NCHWc.rf_1[4])
       conv2d_NCHWc[0] = (conv2d_NCHWc[0] + conv2d_NCHWc.rf_1[5])
       conv2d_NCHWc[0] = (conv2d_NCHWc[0] + conv2d_NCHWc.rf_1[6])
       conv2d_NCHWc[0] = (conv2d_NCHWc[0] + conv2d_NCHWc.rf_1[7])
       conv2d_NCHWc[0] = (conv2d_NCHWc[0] + conv2d_NCHWc.rf_1[8])
       conv2d_NCHWc[0] = (conv2d_NCHWc[0] + conv2d_NCHWc.rf_1[9])
       conv2d_NCHWc[0] = (conv2d_NCHWc[0] + conv2d_NCHWc.rf_1[10])
       conv2d_NCHWc[0] = (conv2d_NCHWc[0] + conv2d_NCHWc.rf_1[11])
       conv2d_NCHWc[0] = (conv2d_NCHWc[0] + conv2d_NCHWc.rf_1[12])
       conv2d_NCHWc[0] = (conv2d_NCHWc[0] + conv2d_NCHWc.rf_1[13])
       conv2d_NCHWc[0] = (conv2d_NCHWc[0] + conv2d_NCHWc.rf_1[14])
       conv2d_NCHWc[0] = (conv2d_NCHWc[0] + conv2d_NCHWc.rf_1[15])
       conv2d_NCHWc[0] = (conv2d_NCHWc[0] + conv2d_NCHWc.rf_1[16])
       conv2d_NCHWc[0] = (conv2d_NCHWc[0] + conv2d_NCHWc.rf_1[17])
       conv2d_NCHWc[0] = (conv2d_NCHWc[0] + conv2d_NCHWc.rf_1[18])
       conv2d_NCHWc[0] = (conv2d_NCHWc[0] + conv2d_NCHWc.rf_1[19])
       inline_tensor[0] = @tir.sin(conv2d_NCHWc[0], dtype=float32)
     }
   }
   ```
   
   ### Environment
   
   Operating System: Ubuntu 18.04
   TVM version: v0.10.dev0
   
   ### Steps to reproduce
   ```
   import tvm
   import json
   import random
   import numpy as np
   from tvm import te
   from tvm import tir
   from tvm import testing
   from tvm import auto_scheduler
   from tvm.auto_scheduler.workload_registry import register_workload_tensors
   
   POLICY_PARAMS = {
       "eps_greedy": 0.05,
       "retry_search_one_round_on_empty": 1,
       "sample_init_min_population": 3,
       "sample_init_use_measured_ratio": 0.2,
       "evolutionary_search_population": 5,
       "evolutionary_search_num_iters": 4,
       "evolutionary_search_mutation_prob": 0.85,
       "cpu_multi_level_tiling_structure": "SSRSRS",
       "gpu_multi_level_tiling_structure": "SSSRRSRS",
       # Notice: the default thread bind policy of GPU assumes the tiling 
structure to have at
       # least 3 spatial tiling levels in outermost
       "max_innermost_split_factor": 64,
       "max_vectorize_size": 16,
       "disable_change_compute_location": 0,
   } 
   
   def te_test():
       data_pad = te.placeholder([100], name='data_pad')
       ic = te.reduce_axis([0, 100], name='ic')
       conv2d_NCHWc = te.compute([1], lambda oc_chunk: te.sum(data_pad[ic], 
axis=[ic]), name='conv2d_NCHWc')
       inline_tensor = te.compute([1], lambda ax1: tir.sin(conv2d_NCHWc[ax1]), 
name='inline_tensor')
       return [data_pad, conv2d_NCHWc, inline_tensor]
   
   # def te_test():
   #     A_1 = te.placeholder([1, 256, 256], name='A')
   #     i = te.reduce_axis([0, 256], name='i')
   #     j = te.reduce_axis([0, 256], name='j')
   #     C = te.compute([1], lambda b : te.sum((A_1[b, i, j]), axis=[i, j]), 
name='C')
   #     inline_tensor = te.compute([1], lambda ax0 : tir.cos(C[ax0]), 
name='inline_tensor')
   #     return [A_1, inline_tensor]
   
   # Get dag and print it.
   
   tensors = te_test()
   dag = auto_scheduler.ComputeDAG(tensors)
   dict = json.loads(tvm.ir.save_json(tensors))
   with open("./saved_json.txt", "w") as file:
       file.write(tvm.ir.save_json(tensors))
   print(dag)
   
   # Get inputs.
   
   inputs = []
   for tensor in dag.tensors:
       shape = [x.value if 'value' in dir(x) and isinstance(x.value, int) else 
1 for x in tensor.shape]
       inputs.append((2 * np.random.uniform(size=shape)+1).astype(tensor.dtype))
   
   # Get program with no schedule.
   
   results = []
   mod_list = []
   pre_schedule_list = dag.apply_steps_from_state(dag.get_init_state())
   pre_mod = tvm.lower(pre_schedule_list[0], pre_schedule_list[1], 
simple_mode=True)
   mod_list.append(pre_mod)
   with tvm.transform.PassContext(opt_level=0):
       mod_exec = tvm.build(pre_mod)
       print(pre_mod)
   
   new_inputs = [tvm.nd.array(x, tvm.cpu()) for x in inputs.copy()]
   mod_exec(*new_inputs)
   result = []
   for x in new_inputs:
       try:
           result.append(x.numpy() if isinstance(
               x, tvm.runtime.NDArray) else x)
       except (ValueError, tvm.TVMError):
           result.append(None)
   results.append(result)
   
   # Get program with schedule.
   
   register_workload_tensors(dag.workload_key(), tensors)
   task = auto_scheduler.SearchTask(workload_key=dag.workload_key(), 
target=tvm.target.Target("llvm"))
   policy = auto_scheduler.SketchPolicy(task, verbose=0, params=POLICY_PARAMS)
   states = policy.sample_initial_population()
   
   for state in states:
       schedule_list = dag.apply_steps_from_state(state)
       mod = tvm.lower(schedule_list[0], schedule_list[1], simple_mode=True)
       mod_list.append(mod)
       with tvm.transform.PassContext(opt_level=0):
           mod_exec = tvm.build(mod)
       
       new_inputs = [tvm.nd.array(x, tvm.cpu()) for x in inputs.copy()]
       mod_exec(*new_inputs)
       result = []
       for x in new_inputs:
           try:
               result.append(x.numpy() if isinstance(
                   x, tvm.runtime.NDArray) else x)
           except (ValueError, tvm.TVMError):
               result.append(None)
       results.append(result)
   
   for i in range(1, len(results)):
       result = results[i]
       for compare_idex in [-1]:
           try:
               tvm.testing.assert_allclose(results[0][compare_idex], 
result[compare_idex])
           except AssertionError as e:
               print(e)
               print(mod_list[i])
               break
   ```
   
   ### Triage
   
   * tune:auto_scheduler
   * tir:schedule 
   * tir:transform      


-- 
This is an automated message from the Apache Git Service.
To respond to the message, please log on to GitHub and use the
URL above to go to the specific comment.

To unsubscribe, e-mail: [email protected]

For queries about this service, please contact Infrastructure at:
[email protected]

Reply via email to