In discussing YARN-1295 it's become clear that I'm confused about the
outcome of the "Next releases" thread.  I had assumed there would be
patch releases to 2.2, and indeed one would be coming out early Q1.
Is this correct?

If so, then things seem a little messed-up right now in 2.2-land.
There already is a branch-2.2.1, but there hasn't been a release.  And
branch-2.2 has Maven version 2.2.2-SNAPSHOT.  Due to the "2.3 rename"
a few weeks ago, it might be that the first patch release for 2.2
needs to be 2.2.2.  But if so, notice these lists of fixes for 2.2.1:

  https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/YARN/fixforversion/12325667
  https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/HDFS/fixforversion/12325666

Do these need to have their fix-versions updated?

  Raymie


P.S. While we're on the subject of point releases, let me check my assumptions.

I assumed that, for release x.y.z, fixes deemed to be "critical bug
fixes" would be put into branch-x.y as a matter of course.  The Maven
release-number in branch-x.y would be x.y.(z+1)-SNAPSHOT, and JIRAs
(to be) committed to branch-x.y would have x.y.(z+1) as one of their
fix-versions.

When enough fixes have accumulated to warrant a release, or when a fix
comes up that is critical enough to warrant an immediate release, then
branch-x-y is branched to branch-x.y.(z+1), and a release is made.

(As Hadoop itself moves from x.y to x.(y+1) and then x.(y+2), the
threshold for what is considered to be a "critical bug" would
naturally start to rise, as the effort of back-porting goes up.)

Do I have it right?

Reply via email to