2009/9/8 David Reyes Samblas Martinez <[email protected]>: > I forget to copy joao too :) > > 2009/9/8 David Reyes Samblas Martinez <[email protected]>: >> 2009/9/7 Risto H. Kurppa <[email protected]>: >>> Hi David! >>> >>> Thanks a lot for your work! Looking forward to see the simple tool up & >>> running! >>> >>> Some comments inline. >>> >>> On Mon, Sep 7, 2009 at 6:26 PM, David Reyes Samblas >>> Martinez<[email protected]> wrote: >>>> -Package filtering:using a config file to block some packages to be >>>> showed the showroom package selector in order to simplify the editors >>>> works. >>>> I consider than devel, docs, fonts, plugins from main packages and >>>> libraries must not appear in a application showroom so using this >>>> principle I have reduced from 8215 to 510 using the filter criteria in >>>> a sql statement[2] on the shrunestable database >>> >>> Looks good to me so far, I also had a look at the SQL statement and >>> looks good. Makes sense to filter away ~everything that is not a 'end >>> user application': filter away all libraries, fonts & stuff, jus like >>> you did. Any changes of posting a list of the 510 accepted packages to >>> a pastebin for example for us to see what gets through. >> attached is a csv file with result of the revised query including the ew >> themes seems that the attachment is 9K too big to pass the filter, you can download here http://www.tuxbrain.com/downloads/package_filtered.csv.tar.bz2 >> >>> >>>> Doubts on how to face the implementation of this: >>>> -two approaches: >>>> -on the import itself, no include this on the database on import >>>> -pros:small and more quick database >>>> -cons:a package not imported will be not posible to be included in >>>> the showroom >>>> -filter it on the showroom editor , build the sql query online using >>>> this "blacklist" file to retry the allowed packages to be included. >>>> -pros:possible to disable/modify the filter by the editor and being >>>> able to include any package on the repo >>>> -cons:big and slow? database, a bit more dificult to implement edit >>>> management part. >>>> This point is the first I will dedicate some time once the approach is >>>> decided, if no input received I will procced with the second approach >>> >>> I don't know. But anywhere there needs to be the possibility to >>> upgrade the database as new apps are added to repository -> it needs >>> to be very automatic. To me it looks like that the filtering would be >>> easiest to do when importing not to bloat the database with unused >>> information. >> I like the joao aproach more comments on his reply. >>> >>>> -Web application (om-showroom it self) >>>> Due the design is still pending I will start development on an an >>>> ugly plain text and html tables without care about, styles, colours >>>> or nothing image/look related , only focusing in that the info can be >>>> shown and edited >>> >>> I agree - but use <div> -tags to make it easy to create a CSS >>> template. Or what do I know about web pages.. >> I will do my best , I hope Victor will be free of his actual boring >> but extremely prioritized tasks to join the party soon, he is the >> html/design guy , he always converts my Quasimodo in Hally Berry :P >>> >>>> For the first release >>>> -Welcome page >>>> -App Navigation: >>>> -the categories will be predefined with the freedesktop.org Main >>>> registered ones[1], if the amount of apps of one category began to >>>> rise then a two level navigation will be implemented using the >>>> additional categories of freedesktop.org too. >>>> -App Details: >>>> -main screenshoot: a predef image will be shown if no one is uploaded >>>> -Short description:based on the package description will be showed >>>> in the applications list during navigation, editable through >>>> application editor no mor e than 255 chars >>>> -Description:description without char descriptions and surely not on >>>> this release but in next ones with wiki formating style. >>>> -package name, source and homepage inherited from packages info >>> >>> Look good! >>> >>>> -comments >>>> -voting >>> >>> I'd be ready to drop this from the first version unless it's very easy >>> to implement. Don't spend too much time on this. >> ok keeping your advice in mind >>> >>>> -more screenshots?(doubt if it will be included on this release) >>> >>> One is good for the first release. >> ok >>> >>>> -additional links?(doubt if it will be included on this release) >>> >>> One is good for the first release. >> one or none :) for first release >>> >>>> -Editor page >>>> -Form for edit all the above with >>>> -Package filtering?(see Package filtering item above) >>>> -Only apps with asociated package are allowed >>>> -clear way to know which packages is already included and what >>>> are pending and what are rejected (must be included on the filter?) >>>> -The fist time an app is included this description will be >>>> filled with the package description >>>> -have in mind the future features, (multi-distro, multi-distro >>>> version.. etc) >>> >>> Looks good. >>> >>> >>>> Well that's all for now, :) I hope my next mail will be with something >>>> to show, in spite it will be ugly :) >>> >>> nice, nice! >>> >>> Please have a look at this: >>> http://aseigo.blogspot.com/2009/01/building-community-around-your-foss.html >>> - I think it's vital that there are more people working on this than >>> you (and entil/Markus) alone! >>> >>> I'd possibly drop themes away.. (regarding e-wm-theme- ) >> themes are a quite visual mod to the neo susceptible to have a >> beautiful screen captures, meanwhile his installation is as easy as an >> opkg install, and someone wants to include it under settings >> cattegory... why not? >>> >>> r >>> >>> -- >>> | risto h. kurppa >>> | risto at kurppa dot fi >>> | http://risto.kurppa.fi >>> >>> _______________________________________________ >>> Openmoko community mailing list >>> [email protected] >>> http://lists.openmoko.org/mailman/listinfo/community >>> >> >> >> >> -- >> David Reyes Samblas Martinez >> http://www.tuxbrain.com >> Open ultraportable & embedded solutions >> Openmoko, Openpandora, Arduino >> Hey, watch out!!! There's a linux in your pocket!!! >> > > > > -- > David Reyes Samblas Martinez > http://www.tuxbrain.com > Open ultraportable & embedded solutions > Openmoko, Openpandora, Arduino > Hey, watch out!!! There's a linux in your pocket!!! >
-- David Reyes Samblas Martinez http://www.tuxbrain.com Open ultraportable & embedded solutions Openmoko, Openpandora, Arduino Hey, watch out!!! There's a linux in your pocket!!! _______________________________________________ Openmoko community mailing list [email protected] http://lists.openmoko.org/mailman/listinfo/community
