> What is the motivation for a government to want a monopoly of business?
> Government ends up granting monopolies after business... who has the maximation of profit/ cornering the market motivation ... eventually gets its way through much lobbying/ dispensing of campaign funds to government etc...
>
> It's the businesses that have the motivation and are constantly proposing mergers, not the other way around...
>
> db


Standards and regulation don't necessarily result in monopolies. They result in the choice of providers whose equipment and products can be used together, instead of like the old railroads which used to have a variety of rail sizes/widths, or video tape [VHS vs Beta] or High Def video [Blue-Ray vs HD DVD]. There a plenty of railroads, many companies sold millions of VHS tapes, and Blue Ray can be used by anyone who wants to use it. We're still waiting for the standards to be followed on the Internet by all parties; the Internet is hit and miss in the US because there are still millions of people who can't get broadband service at a level comparable to that in competing countries. Standards which make things better for the consumer, as well as more efficient to manufacture.

However when a commodity or service becomes so necessary to society, the consumers' interests must supercede the corporate interests for the preservation of a civil society. Water is in danger of becoming an expensive commodity as private companies buy up water supplies in places like Montana and raise prices to a level that creates high profits, and scarcity that endagers an entire region. The Constitution refers to life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness. Where's the chance for life or happiness without good health?

Bottom line is that there would be no need for regulation if corporations didn't go out of the way to abuse workers, as well as customers. Customers sometimes don't have a choice to boycott bad businesses when it's the HMOs or insurance companies that their employers choose for them, or if they can't afford to pay the high rates for health care. Thus, with health insurance, more regulation is necessary because the insurance companies have behaved badly, especially in comparison the the single payer systems elsewhere.

Betty


*************************************************************************
**  List info, subscription management, list rules, archives, privacy  **
**  policy, calmness, a member map, and more at http://www.cguys.org/  **
*************************************************************************

Reply via email to