Again, you miss the mark.  A fine-trim carpenter would use a small
hammer (or nail gun) and be most productive.  A carpenter doing framing
would need a large hammer (or larger nail gun). It is important to
select the right tools for the tasks performed.  That is not whining,
but is called professionalism.

It appears that your experience with computers is limited to a short
list of tasks. If you are productive with a smallish, single monitor,
bully for you.

Thank you,
 
Mark Snyder
-----Original Message-----
I suppose I really should know better than to question the size of
someone's tools.

Were this a carpentry list, and I dared suggest those with smaller
hammers were just as productive as those with bigger ones, I imagine
the small firestorm from a very few people would be about the same.
And god forbid I suggest those with  TWO hammers weren't outproducing
those with only one. But where would it end? Surely the guys with
THREE hammers would be deeply offended at any suggestion they weren't
any better than the guys with only two!

BTW There are actually lots of studies that can be designed to show
more (or bigger) monitors mean higher scores on certain tests.
Here's one: http://research.microsoft.com/displayarticle.aspx?id=433

Here's another which is probably closer to the mark:
http://www.useit.com/alertbox/screen-productivity.html

>It's a classic mistake for people who are new to usability to test
individual system features as opposed to higher-level tasks that users
want to perform.

In other words, you can whine all day about how some part of your
specific job would be made tougher if you had to sit closer to a
smaller screen, but that doesn't prove your point. Don't worry, I'm
not suggesting you give up your bigger (or multiple) monitors, heck, I
wish I had a wraparound monitor here. But there have been
coders/editors/carpenters that came before you with much smaller tools
and they still had no trouble coding/editing/hammering rings around
you, regardless how big your monitor(s) are.


*************************************************************************
**  List info, subscription management, list rules, archives, privacy  **
**  policy, calmness, a member map, and more at http://www.cguys.org/  **
*************************************************************************

Reply via email to