On Jun 15, 2012, at 5:31 AM, Matthew Farrellee wrote: > On 06/15/2012 12:49 AM, Ziliang Guo wrote: >> While configuring the test submit machines for NEOS, I ran into what >> appears to be an error or oversight in the documentation, or a bug in >> Condor. In section 3.3.1.2 of the manual where we talk about daemon >> specific configuration, where we use DAEMON.KNOB to specify the daemon >> the knob is affecting, we use the examples MASTER.HIGHPORT/LOWPORT and >> NEGOTIATOR.HIGHPORT/LOWPORT. When I attempted to do >> NEGOTIATOR.HIGHPORT/LOWPORT, the negotiator seemingly ignored the >> configuration option as the negotiator bound to something completely >> outside my range. The people I've spoken with theorize that this is >> because the master is the one creating ports and handing them to the >> children, and since the HIGHPORT/LOWPORT values were negotiator >> specific, the master ignored them. If this is the case, then >> DAEMON.HIGHPORT/LOWPORT would seem more appropriate in the section of >> nonsensical daemon specific knob examples. >> >> My question basically is, was the intent that the master would honor >> the daemon specific HIGHPORT/LOWPORT knobs for each specified daemon? >> If so, fine, then we have a bug. If not, then it's probably a good >> idea to edit the manual to not use HIGHPORT/LOWPORT as examples of >> valid daemon specific knobs. Of course it's entirely possible that >> this was valid in the past sometime if the daemons were in charge of >> creating their own ports to listen on, but I'm finding that the >> networking section of the documentation can be very, spotty and >> crufty. > > Even if it was intended for DAEMON.HIGH/LOWPORT to work, we should accept it > doesn't and fix the documentation to use another example. > > HIGH/LOWPORT is on the deprecated spectrum. IN/OUT_HIGH/LOWPORT were the > replacements, and they should be on the deprecated spectrum now that we have > SHARED_PORT. > > Please file a doc ticket for this and other spotty/crufty things you ran into. >
If SHARED_PORT is "the new way", can we make it default? Brian _______________________________________________ Condor-devel mailing list Condor-devel@cs.wisc.edu https://lists.cs.wisc.edu/mailman/listinfo/condor-devel
