Unfortuneately, I agree that this is a very narrow case-- in the minds of the Justices who signed it.  Many of Scalia's pot-shots about the logical consequences of the decision are stronger than I would like. The enforceable distinction the swing votes probably saw between Lawrence and e.g. the DADT policy, gay marriage, is the total privacy of the personal actions protected.
Malla Pollack
Visiting, Univ. of Oregon, Law
541-346-1599
[EMAIL PROTECTED]

Reply via email to