Adam Williamson wrote:

I don't like it. In most cases, it would be a needless extra step, and
could well cause confusion. I think the current ploy of just trying to
get the right default for each piece of hardware is correct.


Why make it a supplementary step ?
At the end of the install, there is table with all detected devices and for each one, a configuration button, despite the installer indicates a default setting. It is already the case for the graphics card and the network. For the sound card, you would press "configure", then it would play a song, do you hear it ? "yes" -> let's continue "no" -> it tries the other driver. A user, even newbie, is not dumb, when things are explained the simple way : step 1 : OSS, do you hear sound ? step 2: Alsa : do you hear sound ? I think it is not confusing and on the contrary a good way to deal with particular hardware that could not be tested. And it would not be a supplementary step, just the new feature of the "Configure" button.


Moreover, this could be integrated to soundrake : make it clearer about the two kinds of driver and offer a testing procedure for sound.

Eric



Reply via email to