OK all, I'm trying to help here. I'm giving a clear description of a 
problem, the hardware it affects, and the proposed solution.

PROBLEM: 
  Installer kernel hangs at IDE probe when the ali15x3 driver is 
  loaded and attempts to probe devices. The last few lines of output 
  are:

[...etc...]
ALI15X3: IDE controller on PCI bus 00 dev 78
PCI: No IRQ known for interrupt pin A of device 00:0f.0. Please try 
using
pci=biosirq.
ALI15X3: chipset revision 195
ALI15X3: not 100% native mode: will probe irqs later

  That's it, it hangs dead at this point where it would normally probe 
  the ide devices. The alt1 kernel which uses generic, non-dma IDEPCI 
  does boot but does not support kernel pcmcia or any filesystem but 
  ext2. :( Kernel options pci=biosirq and ide=nodma do nothing to 
  prevent this lockup.


HARDWARE:
  Fujitsu Lifebook P-2040, which uses an ALi 1533 PCI bridge and
  ALi 5229 IDE controller. 

SOLUTION PROPOSED:  
  Unset CONFIG_BLK_DEV_ALI15X3=y (and CONFIG_WDC_ALI15X3=y, if 
  configured) in the .config for the install kernel and recompile it 
  without ali15x3 support.

REASONING: 
  The features of the ali15x3 driver are not necessary to the
  install process, and the alt1 kernel is not sufficiently feature
  complete for laptop installations (i.e. no kernel pcmcia support, no
  journaling or encrypted filesystems supported).


Here's the part where I complain about the Mandrake bug reporting
process:  This is my third report of this bug here - I haven't recieved
a reply or response or any acknowledgment at all, either privately or on
the list.  Please note that I did not come here first - I tried to jump
through the bugzilla hoops, the mandrakeexpert hoops, and even the
mandrakeforum hoops - my bugzilla account can't post new bugs (I did
search for dupes and found none), mandrakeexpert won't let me post a
question to mdk employees (despite the US$80 donation I made when I
downloaded 8.1 instead of purchasing a retail box), and I never recieved
my mandrakeforum password when I tried to register (twice!).

Please restore my faith in this organization by at least replying to 
this message, even if only to say "**** off!" - that would be better 
than silence.

Thanks,
-Isaac




Reply via email to