https://qa.mandrakesoft.com/show_bug.cgi?id=567





------- Additional Comments From [EMAIL PROTECTED]  2002-11-30 19:20 -------
Ok, "urpmi.update cdrom8" worked BUT only after I hand mounted
cdrom1.  This is because I routinely disable supermount on all
my distributions.  Perhaps some previous use of rpmdrake or
urpm* expected a disc to be mounted when it wasn't, errored off,
and left some config file empty.  Maybe dependencies on
supermount actions have crept into the urpm* tools.

--soapbox on--
This whole locking the cdrom drawer business has become quite
the rant with me - in my not-so-humble-this-time opinion a read
only device should *never* lock its media for any reason.  The
OS should be able to deal with the read-only mounted media
disappearing out from under it correctly in all cases (I am an
OS developer: an OS should enable users, never hinder them if
at all possible).  Thus anything that helps lock media in place
is on my hit list.  Disabling supermount is only a partial
solution but it helps.
--soapbox off--

Anyway, having urpm* depend on supermount actions is probably
a bad thing for urpm* stability.  It should be easy to prompt
for a mount (or mount the drive automatically) for each urpm*
command instead of presuming cdroms are still mounted.  (i.e.
the tools should not presume the environment is sane)

I encourage a new test case: install and test distributions
with supermount disabled.

I'll leave it to you all to reassign or close this bug as
appropriate.  If I need to open a new one under urpmi then
send me email.

Duane




------- You are receiving this mail because: -------
You are on the CC list for the bug, or are watching someone who is.

Reply via email to