So, maybe I'm saying something naive, but isn't the difference between the two mechanisms mostly there to distinguish between JNI libraries and non-JNI libraries?

E.g. maybe we should add JNI somewhere in one of the factory (the one used by System.loadLibrary) and then document what are the differences between JNI and non-JNI libraries. We could even have different NativeLibrary impl for these two cases.

Seems to me that JNI libs feature:

* extra restrictions (cannot load same library in multiple loaders)
* auto-unloading guarantees (classloader-driven)

Or are there cases where you envision more mix and match? E.g. JNI libraries w/o auto-unloading?

Maurizio

On 18/03/2020 16:32, Mandy Chung wrote:


On 3/18/20 8:59 AM, Alan Bateman wrote:
On 17/03/2020 23:09, Mandy Chung wrote:

I have similar comment to myself and didn't come up good static factory method names.   I give it a try again: what about newNativeLibraries and newNativeLibrariesWithNoAutoUnload?
Would newTrustedNativeLibraries work? Everything else in the updated webrev looks good.

"no auto unload" is also important.  what about "newTrustedNativeLibrariesNoAutoUnload" a bit long?

Mandy

Reply via email to