Thanks for the quick response, Jim. We're good with all items, but hold off on a revised I-D until I finish the full review (tomorrow, I expect).
> — Section 7 — > > COSE_MAC is used for all other cases. These > include a requirement for multiple recipients, the key being unknown, > or a recipient algorithm of other than direct. > > ‘Tis a total nit, but you changed “and” to “or” here, and I think the change > was incorrect, and the > original “and” was correct — the “other cases” include all three of the > examples. > > [JLS] This change was made in response to a WG comment. I believe that "or" > is correct here > as there are three different cases being listed rather than a combination of > the three cases. As I say, it's a total nit, so I'm not going to say more than this, but a container (here, "all other cases") contains the union of what's in it. My shopping list includes cauliflower and spinach (not "or"), and your vineyard grows (perhaps) Zinfandel and Pinot Noir (not "or"). And COSE_MAC is used for A and B and C, not "or", because it's used for all of them. Anyway, 'nuff said here. Barry _______________________________________________ COSE mailing list [email protected] https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/cose
