Hello out there,

there's a lot of discussion about the 8-bit-headers in courier going on for several 
months now. When I first got into contact with Courier I also thought that it is a bit 
hard to check the RFCs so strictly. But in the meantime I totally agree to Sam that it 
makes no sense to set up a RFC in a long process and then nobody cares about the RFC 
and just implements a quick and dirty way of processing e-mail. This will counterstike 
some day.

>From my customers I already receive more and more bug reports over the last years 
>about corrupted e-mail which is unreadable, which has weird attachments, which can be 
>read via pop3 but not via imap and so on. And there are a lot of different MTAs, 
>mailservers and clients producing this bugs. This lax checking for RFC conformance is 
>already leading into problems and I think this will become worse in the future.

I think Sam's approach of generating a "corrupted message" report and attaching the 
original mail as a file is perfectly alright. What I want to try is to change the 
content-type of the attached message into "message/rfc822". Most mail clients can 
handle this mime type and just open a new message window for the attached message.

I think this is acceptable for both the users who rely upon e-mail as we have it today 
(lot's of non-conformant messages) and the administrators who have to deal with users 
and bosses who sometimes turn out to be completely information-technology-unaware.

But anyway the users want functionality and don't care about any technical details. 
They want their programs running. If they have to deal with an e-mail which says 
"corrupted message" but let's them open the corrupted message anyway, they have the 
functionality and maybe they become a little more aware of things going on behind 
e-mail. If we're lucky this leads into a more RFC conformant internet as the users 
complain about the "corrupted message" at the right person - the sender of the 
corrupted message.

Regards
Manfred

--

manfred heubach edv und neue medien
Hindenburgstr. 47
D-73728 Esslingen

Tel. +49 711 9315824
Fax  +49 711 9315825
www.heubach-edv.de


Informationstechnologie und Telekommunikation f�r Unternehmen



_______________________________________________
courier-users mailing list
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
Unsubscribe: https://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/courier-users

Reply via email to