I think Tara hit the majority of the points that I would.

When I tell people about what goes on at IndyHall, I describe it like this:

If you were working in a coffee shop (or desk share, or incubator, or
anything else like that) you're taking care of problem 1) getting out of the
house, but not necessarily problem 2) being around people.

In a coffee shop (or the other scenarios), you are guaranteed being
surrounded by BODIES, but not necessarily like minded, intelligent,
creative, and interesting people. Sure, they MIGHT be there, but since
that's not priority number one...its a crap shoot.

At a coworking space, there's a different kind of energy due to shared
interest, and because of a community, you get a shared mentality of "I make
a living doing what I love, and I think others should make a living doing
what they love, too".

NOTE: I said make a living. There's nothing wrong with making money. Gotta
have a roof over your head and food on the table, right? Otherwise you've
lost the other pillar: sustainability.

Sure, the goals vary from space to space. I know at IndyHall, our goals
aren't maximizing profit. It's maximizing resources for the community that
uses the space. Sure, if the resources are maximized, use will be as well,
and the space will make more money. But that's secondary. Part of the "nerd
values" that Tara mentioned is "doing well by doing good".

Personally, I LOVE being at our coworking space, I love telling people about
it, I love seeing peoples reactions the first time they see it, walk through
the door, spend a day...that's all awesome. The fact that I may make some
money, someday, on top of that is a bonus.

Mind you...my pockets ARENT deep. My name isn't Sergey Brin or Larry Page. I
don't have infinite money to drop into this space. I don't have infinite
time to devote to the space. So back to the sustainability pillar...we HAVE
to start paying ourselves at some point.

This for profit vs non profit discussion has come up before. Like Tara said,
nothing says coworking can't be commercial. It's when commercial becomes
priority one over the other 4 shared goals that it starts to fall apart (or,
at least, becomes much harder to hold together when everyone is staring at a
bottom line).

xray, I'm curious what your current work situation is and what drew you to
coworking?

-Alex

On 10/10/07, Tara Hunt <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:
>
> Hey xray,
>
> You aren't mistaken that there is a marriage between coworking and open
> source...mainly because, well, many of the principles that guide open source
> have also guided what we consider to be coworking. But I also don't think
> that even open source is married to free or non-profit. There are loads of
> open source companies making alot of money. Red Hat sells enterprise level
> solutions to Linux and makes billions. Sun is built around the open-sourced
> Java. Heck, even some of our favorites like Firefox and Wordpress (or at
> least indirectly) are making good bucks. I think it's a bit of a
> misconception that open source = free. Open source != free...Open source =
> open code.
>
> But I would caution the direction of moving coworking into a purely
> transactional realm. That's when it ceases to be coworking. Then it is
> shared office space or execu-centers or, as you indicated, incubators, which
> are great and useful for their own purposes (and in San Francisco alone,
> there are over 200 examples of this)...but they are not coworking.
>
> I'm only speaking personally, but coworking, for me, was partially a
> response to those transactional types of businesses. I wanted to go to an
> office where it felt like I was going to a company of coworkers, not that I
> was just seeking office space. I would have just worked out of my dining
> room and occasionally escaped to coffee shops if it wasn't for coworking.
> It's different and, to me at least, it represents the good principles of
> open source, collaboration, openness, community and sustainability. That is
> why so many of us on the list are protective of the idea. Until you've been
> part of a space, it's really hard to describe the subtle (but huge)
> differences.
>
> I don't know if you were on the list a while back when I posted the 4
> pillars of coworking: collaboration, openness, community and sustainability,
> but many of the current space owners + many in the process of setting up
> spaces seemed to agree that those were what makes coworking different from
> shared offices, execu-suites, et al. None of those denote non-profit. I'm
> not sure if you caught our Nerd Values discussion, but if you didn't, you
> may appreciate it.
>
> Either way, these are only my own experience of coworking and why it is so
> significant. But perhaps others will have something different to share.
>
> Tara
>
>
> On 10/9/07, xray <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:
>
> >
> > So, I'm entirely new to this discussion, and I may be entirely
> > mistaken, but it seems to me that the need for a marriage of "open
> > source" and "coworking" is mistakenly imagined by those who are
> > working in an open source environment.  When you commit yourself to
> > such an ideal, it begins to color everything you think about.  (And it
> > is a high ideal, please, I don't mean to troll or diss it.)  Sure, if
> > you are running a coworking facility of open source developers, maybe
> > the facility needs to have transparency and all the other attributes
> > of open source, just because that ideal is at the root of the way
> > everyone thinks.  That would be great.  But you could also have a
> > coworking facility of lawyers or real estate agents.  They probably
> > wouldn't find it at all incongruent to have profit motives involved.
> > The real estate agents might even want a commission for bringing new
> > coworkers into the community.
> >
> > I see no reason in the world that a coworking facility couldn't be
> > entirely for profit and run in a somewhat "dictatorial" rather than
> > democratic manner, as long as the participants were okay with it.
> > There are condo work spaces as an alternative to owning an entire
> > building and managing it.  Coworking could work in an environment is
> > totally conventional other than the coworking aspect.  Maybe I
> > misunderstand the concept of coworking completely.  Does it require
> > that
> >
> > Let's say someone springs for half a million dollars to provide a
> > facility and amenities, and SELLS space and time to people who want a
> > nice place to work in with other bright people who all need a sense of
> > community.  It's kinda like being back at grad school, in that you're
> > going in to a place where others are doing exciting things perhaps
> > related to what you do... you're sharing facilities you couldn't
> > afford by yourself, and seeing the same people on a regular basis,
> > except now you're making money.  We hope.  What's wrong with that?
> >
> > It might also be like the old concept of a business "incubator,"
> > except that someone sets it up and expects to make a return on their
> > investment.  I'd think it would be way easier to get started if
> > someone just set it up and started selling it, than if you tried to
> > get a bunch of people together to pool resources and build it by
> > committee.
> >
> > As long as there is an honest value offered to the participants, and
> > it helps them to make their lives more enjoyable and their work more
> > profitable, I see nothing wrong with that model.  I think it is okay
> > to make one paradigm shift at a time.  You throw out the old model of
> > either working at a corporate office or at home, and go to a model of
> > coworking.  You don't have to throw out ALL the old models, like
> > expecting to get paid for what you do.  If you have ten people doing
> > one type of work in the same space, and an eleventh person whose work
> > is providing the space, all eleven of them need to make money.  We can
> > hide that behind concepts like "sustainability" but in America,
> > sustainability pretty much means "profitability" for many of us.  Once
> > the money going out has exceeded the capital that started the project
> > and the money coming in, the business is no longer sustainable.
> >
> > When you have a coworking community in someone's home, they are still
> > paying their landlord.  If you have a larger coworking community in a
> > facility like an old warehouse converted to offices and meeting rooms,
> > somebody's got to pay the landlord there, too.  It doesn't mean the
> > landlord would be disqualified from being a coworker in the same space.
> >
> >
> > Citizen Agency (www.citizenagency.com)
> > blog: www.horsepigcow.com
> > phone: 415-694-1951
> > fax: 415-727-5335
> > > >
> >


-- 
-----
-- 
-----
Alex Hillman
web.developer.innovation.consultant
vocal: 484.597.6256
digital: [EMAIL PROTECTED] | skype: dangerouslyawesome
visual: www.weknowhtml.com | www.dangerouslyawesome.com
local: www.indyhall.org

--~--~---------~--~----~------------~-------~--~----~
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups 
"Coworking" group.
To post to this group, send email to [email protected]
To unsubscribe from this group, send email to [EMAIL PROTECTED]
For more options, visit this group at 
http://groups.google.com/group/coworking?hl=en
-~----------~----~----~----~------~----~------~--~---

Reply via email to