Hi Marius,

I think your analysis misses a great deal. It's part of what bothered me so 
much about the original article: I expect the average person thinking about 
this business casually to dramatically underestimate the costs and 
overestimate the revenue. You probably haven't been through the process of 
running your own office with a team of employees, and so haven't been 
confronted with the variety of costs and time involved, much less running 
your own coworking space with the variety of additional costs for providing 
services and helping to build a sense of community and a liveliness. Until 
you've been through it, most of those costs don't jump out at you. But I 
don't expect a journalist, whose job it is to dig in and try to get an 
objective picture of things (in my naive idealistic view of journalism)--to 
make the same mistake. 

It wouldn't normally bother me so much, except that this topic hits close 
to home and it is a domain where there's already a ready bias in the 
direction showed by the journalist that I would love to be set right, 
rather than reinforced. Coworking is a domain, in my experience, almost 
unparalleled in the "for-profit" world, where the people who run the 
businesses do put social welfare at a premium and try to figure out how to 
do good while also doing good business, and so this particular charge, that 
they're doing the opposite, when it's bases on back-of-the-napkin analysis 
and selective consideration of the evidence that grossly misrepresents what 
we do, hits a nerve.

Even if you're talking about a space that has 100 full-time members at $200 
per member in a big city, you are very likely not looking at a coworking 
space where the owners are making what they could make as an employee, 
given their level of expertise. Yes, they might be bringing in $20,000 / 
month (plus more for events, meeting room rentals, other add on services). 
But how much are they spending on a lease that can accommodate that many 
members? How much on supplies and upkeep? How much on marketing and other 
services they must pay for? How much on the maybe four employees' salaries 
who help manage the space? It would be EASY to have $20,000 in revenue each 
month and still spend more. In a major city for a space in a good location, 
just the four employees and the lease might cost more than that. It usually 
won't, because most coworking spaces just can't succeed at the prices they 
charge for memberships without getting screaming good deals on their spaces 
and working really hard to get employees in it in part because they want to 
do something they believe in rather than just to earn the kind of money 
they'd be able to earn outside this industry. 

Yes, of course there are *some* people getting rich in the coworking 
business (I can now say, only because I read some articles about WeWork). 
But name an industry where *some people* aren't getting rich? I'm not happy 
about it, but the percentage in this particular industry is probably about 
as low as it gets for a new industry getting the attention that coworking 
gets.

I'm obviously overly agitated about this particular issue and it is great 
to get your input. But just to give a better sense as to why this article 
aggravated me so much.

Best,
Will

On Sunday, February 8, 2015 at 9:29:11 PM UTC+1, Jerome wrote:
>
> 100 members are a lot for most spaces.
>
> Jerome
> www.BLANKSPACES.com
>
> On Feb 8, 2015, at 10:57 AM, Marius Amado-Alves <[email protected] 
> <javascript:>> wrote:
>
> Hmm, you're right my statement was kind of confusing--because I have used 
> low ballpark figures (200$ city, 100$ village). Such values are on the fair 
> side. Social enough in spirit (meaning you're not rolling in bank notes).
>
> Nevertheless I feel it can be lowered still. 100 members at 200$ equals 
> 20000$ cash monthly, which kind of sounds much more than "enough" at many 
> locations.
>
> Extremely dependent on location, this business, and on time too. Like 
> realestate I guess. Still studying this.
>
> *  *  *
>
> I read the article! After all it's Sunday, and I took a break. The article 
> is sensationalist and lacking, like most media. What it lacks is the 
> (necessary) integrative view of coworking. But the details are right, and 
> have the potential to scare away some people, maybe atract others, while 
> yet infuriating others... The article also sounds confusing. On one hand it 
> sounds partial against coworking, maybe the author had a bad experience. On 
> the other hand it depicts coworking as a very profitable business, which 
> maybe will send investors that way (only to close doors after a year 
> because they ignore the community aspect).
>
>  -- 
> Visit this forum on the web at http://discuss.coworking.com
> --- 
> You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups 
> "Coworking" group.
> To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an 
> email to [email protected] <javascript:>.
> For more options, visit https://groups.google.com/d/optout.
>
>

-- 
Visit this forum on the web at http://discuss.coworking.com
--- 
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups 
"Coworking" group.
To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email 
to [email protected].
For more options, visit https://groups.google.com/d/optout.

Reply via email to