Op 11 nov. 2012 17:27 schreef "Steffen Schwigon" <s...@renormalist.net>
het volgende:

> A matrix like
>   http://matrix.cpantesters.org/?dist=Data-DPath-0.47
> potentially covers 500 combinations.
>
> And they are only comprehensible because they are in 2 dimensions.
>
> What you want adds new dimensions, a hypercube of the test matrix.
>
> That's where noise starts.

I understand that it is not needed to see all install failures for all
possible permutations of module versions. I think it IS very good
information to see if your module fails to install because of the
latest versions of CPAN modules are giving issues. So if an upstream
module gives test failures on some platforms, this can be very good
info for a module author. One of the possibilities would then be to
fix the upstream module, or of course you can choose to see if you can
do without the dependency, or select an alternate one.

The same for when one of the upstream modules start changing and
introduce failures in the chain. As a downstream module author, this
might be very interesting news, but in the current situation you would
not see this.

For instance about six weeks ago, the Variable::Magic module started
to give test failures. As a result, DBIx::Class was not installable
from CPAN. As a DBIx::Class author or if you're interested in the
module, this would be very good information I think.

<rant>Of course, for this to work, it test reports should be visible
at all in the first place! The XML::Compile::WSS module last visible
tests are from 1.01.
http://www.cpantesters.org/distro/X/XML-Compile-WSS.html#XML-Compile-WSS-1.01
- 1.02 or later, released on October 22nd, does not have any visble
test reports! This is not because they have not been submitted, but
because they are not visible on the cpan-testers website. According to
the CPAN testers leaderboard, no tests in November have been submitted
at all. I reported this earlier in September; I (and more people)
offered help before. I run a smoker on a VPS for which I pay money. At
this time it does not seem to be a wise investment. At the moment I
think there are only a couple of options: either you (dagolden and
barbie) fix the cpan-testers website soon(ish) and yes I do understand
you are busy, or you allow other people to help fix the issue maybe
even by using the alternative put in place by Slaven, or people like
me will start losing interest and turn off their smokers. I think this
is very bad for the project.</rant>

--
Mike

Reply via email to