Vielen Dank für die Nachricht! Ich bin am ersten Werktag nach dem 15.04. wieder erreichbar. Die Nachricht wird nicht weitergeleitet.
Mit besten Grüßen Zoe Schubert Am 28.03.2022 um 05:22 schrieb Pat Riva via Crm-sig <crm-sig@ics.forth.gr>: > Hello all, > > Continuing the series of e-votes to complete outstanding homework. > > Following the discussion of F28 during SIG 52 in February, further editing of > the final two paragraphs of the proposed scope note of F28 Expression > Creation remained. > > > On further analysis, the path information presented in the last paragraph of > the F28 scope note seems better placed under R2 is derivation of (for works) > and F27 Work Creation (as recently e-voted). > > > This vote is for the related changes to F28, R2 and F27. > Please vote Yes to accept the revised scope notes, or No to not accept them. > If voting no, please explain. > I will summarize votes to the list on April 3. > > > a) Full scope note of F28 Expression Creation > (first 3 paragraphs accepted in February and given for context) > 4th paragraph: revised text proposed, to be voted, points to usage of the new > R76 property > 5th paragraph: move first sentence to F27, path explanation to R2, see parts > b) and c) > > > Scope note: This class comprises activities that result in instances of F2 > Expression coming into existence. An instance of F2 Expression is considered > to be created when it is captured on a carrier other than the creator’s brain. > Although F2 Expression is an abstract entity, a conceptual object, the > creation of an expression inevitably also affects the physical world: when > you scribble the first draft of a poem on a sheet of paper, you produce an > instance of F3 Manifestation and an instance of F5 Item. F28 Expression > Creation is a subclass of E12 Production because the recording of the > expression causes a physical modification of the E18 Physical Thing that > serves as the carrier. The creation of an instance of F2 Expression coincides > with the creation of the first instance of F3 Manifestation that R4 embodies > (is embodied in) this instance of F2 Expression. > The P2 has type (is type of) property can be used to specify the type of the > instance of F28 Expression Creation (i.e., activities such as translating, > revising, or arranging music are types of creation process). The type of the > process is distinct from the type of result even though the typology > frequently used for instances of the resulting F2 Expressions may imply the > category of the instance of the F28 Expression Creation. > An instance of F28 Expression Creation may use as source material one or more > specific instances of F2 Expression. When the source expression is documented > this is also expressed by the property R76 is derivative of (has derivative). > In the situation where an expression of one instance of F1 Work serves as > source material for the creation of the first expression of a new instance of > F1 Work, the relationship between the works is indicated using the property > R2 is derivative of (has derivative) between the two instances of F1 Work. > Path: F1 Work(1). R3 is realised in: F2 Expression(1). P16i was used for: F28 > Expression Creation. R17 created: F2 Expression(2). R3i realises: F1 Work(2). > R2 is derivative of: F1 Work(1). > > > > > b) Addition to the scope note of R2 is derivative of (has derivative) > -Add 2nd paragraph explaining the path showing the derivation of one work > from another. > -Add mention at the end of the first paragraph that the property is > asymmetric and irreflexive (following the pattern established with issue 517) > > > Scope note: This property associates an instance of F1 Work which modifies > the content of another instance of F1 Work with the latter. This property is > transitive, asymmetric and irreflexive. > The inverse of this property is equivalent to the developed path: F1 Work(1). > R3 is realised in: F2 Expression(1). P16i was used for: F28 Expression > Creation. R17 created: F2 Expression(2). R3i realises: F1 Work(2). That is, > F1 Work(1). R2i has derivative: F1 Work (2), without needing to specify the > specific expressions involved in the derivation. > The property R2.1 has type of this property allows for specifying the kind of > derivation, such as adaptation, summarisation, etc. > > > c) Addition to the scope note of F27 Work Creation, last paragraph > > -The addition points to the use of R2 to document work creation based on > another work. > (the starting point is the scope note as modified by the preceding e-vote > ending March 20, 2022) > > > Scope note: This class comprises activities by which instances of F1 Work > come into existence. An instance of F27 Work Creation can serve to document > the period a work was coming into existence and the circumstances of it, when > these are known. > An instance of F27 Work Creation marks the initial creation of an instance of > F1 Work through expressions or other externalisations that are sufficiently > elaborated so that the characteristic conceptual identity of the work could > be recognized as existing. > In many cases this will coincide with the first known complete > externalisation of an expression of the work. In other cases, the initial > creation of an instance of F1 Work may be inferred from multiple, or later, > expressions or other forms of evidence. For instance, commissioning of a work > may explicitly be agreed on after the presentation of an already complete and > detailed elaboration of the work that was not made public. Performances may > be prior to written expressions, as in the case of Shakespeare’s works. > The work, as an intellectual construction, may evolve from its initial > creation onwards, until the last known expression of it. > An instance of E39 Actor with which a work is associated through the chain of > properties F1 Work. R16i was created by: F27 Work Creation. P14 carried out > by: E39 Actor corresponds to the notion of the “creator” of the work. > In the situation where an expression of one instance of F1 Work serves as > source material for the creation of the first expression of a new instance of > F1 Work, the relationship between the works is indicated using the property > R2 is derivative of (has derivative) between the two instances of F1 Work. > > > > > Pat Riva > Acting University Librarian / Bibliothécaire en chef par intérim > Concordia University / Université Concordia > 1455 de Maisonneuve West, LB-331 > Montréal, Québec H3G 1M8 > Canada > pat.r...@concordia.ca > > _______________________________________________ > Crm-sig mailing list > Crm-sig@ics.forth.gr > http://lists.ics.forth.gr/mailman/listinfo/crm-sig
_______________________________________________ Crm-sig mailing list Crm-sig@ics.forth.gr http://lists.ics.forth.gr/mailman/listinfo/crm-sig
