YES Thank you for writing this up, George!
On Sun, Nov 6, 2022 at 7:15 AM Athanasios Velios via Crm-sig < [email protected]> wrote: > YES > > On 01/11/2022 09:48, George Bruseker via Crm-sig wrote: > > Dear all, > > > > I propose the deletion of the following properties of CRMdig. The reason > > that each should be deleted is listed beside it, but there are two > > basic, principled reasons for the proposal: > > > > 1) the property can be modelled using a more generic pattern from > > CRMbase or CRMdig without loss of semantic valence > > 2) the property violates a CIDOC CRM modelling principle / best > > practice, an alternative mode of expressing it already exists using > > standard modelling in CRM and SHOULD be employed > > > > Therefore, if our proposal is done correctly removing all these > > properties will serve to a) make the model lighter but just as > > semantically powerful, b) accord with CRM SIG general modelling > > principles and c) serve better as a middle level domain ontology for its > > area of scope. > > > > Martin Doerr, Rob Sanderson and Nicola Carboni have all contributed over > > time to this review or properties alongside myself as proposer. Any > > mistakes being mine. > > > > With that as background here are the proposed deletions: > > > > *Delete:* L4 has preferred label: inconsistent with the rest of CRM, > > redundant to other ontologies > > > > *Keep until D11/D9 revision is understood*: L20 has created: because D9 > > is removed (but see also D11) > > > > *Keep, not marginal: *L24 created logfile: creates a file of type > > ‘logfile’ (used to separate derivative output from automated provenance > > reporting.) > > > > *Delete:* L29 has responsible organization: unnecessary sub property > > just use p14 > > *Delete:* L30 has operator: unnecessary sub property just use p14 > > > > *Delete: *L31 has starting date-time: inconsistent modelling, use time > > span like everyone else > > *Delete: *L32: has ending date time: inconsistent modelling, use time > > span like everyone else > > > > *Delete:* L33: has maker: this property violates event modelling. If it > > continues to exist then E73 should have ‘has author’ (local project > > requirements...) > > > > *Delete:* L34 has contractor: unnecessary sub property of an unnecessary > > subproperty, use p14 > > > > *Delete: *L35 has commissioner: unnecessary sub property, use p14 > > > > *Delete: *L47 has comment: not ontological at all > > > > *Delete: *L51 has first name: inconsistent non ontological modelling, > > anathema! > > *Delete: *L52 has last name: see above > > *Delete: *L53 is not uniquely identified by: this is not a way to encode > > a negation and does not say anything (see also neg properties question) > > *Delete: *L55 has inventory number: this is not ontological, please use > > standard modelling > > *Delete: *L56 has pixel width: no standard modelling, use dimension > > *Delete: *L57 has pixel height: non standard modelling, use dimension > > *Delete: *L59 has serial number: non standard modelling, use E42 > > > > *Delete: *L61 was on going at: again non standard time modelling for > > convenience sake > > > > This is a first list to which others may be added. At this time, I am > > happy to propose the above list for deletion as hopefully relatively > > uncontroversial. > > > > You can find the specification for CRMdig here: > > https://cidoc-crm.org/crmdig/sites/default/files/CRMdig_v3.2.1.pdf > > <https://cidoc-crm.org/crmdig/sites/default/files/CRMdig_v3.2.1.pdf> > > > > To read more on these properties. > > > > I call a vote now, ending on Nov 11. Please vote by answering YES to > > this emaill thread if you agree to these deletions or NO. If you vote > > NO, please indicate if you vote NO to all or if you vote NO to some part > > of the proposal. > > > > Thanks in advance for your interest and participation. > > > > Best, > > > > George > > Vice Chair CRM SIG > > > > > > -- > > George Bruseker, PhD > > Chief Executive Officer > > Takin.solutions Ltd. > > https://www.takin.solutions/ <https://www.takin.solutions/> > > > > _______________________________________________ > > Crm-sig mailing list > > [email protected] > > http://lists.ics.forth.gr/mailman/listinfo/crm-sig > _______________________________________________ > Crm-sig mailing list > [email protected] > http://lists.ics.forth.gr/mailman/listinfo/crm-sig > -- Rob Sanderson Director for Cultural Heritage Metadata Yale University
_______________________________________________ Crm-sig mailing list [email protected] http://lists.ics.forth.gr/mailman/listinfo/crm-sig
