Now the JUDGE gets to decide what SCIENTIFIC evidence is "admissible" in
court in support of victims' claims against big corporations ...


High Court Limits 'Junk Science'

By RICHARD CARELLI
.c The Associated Press

WASHINGTON (AP) -- The Supreme Court gave American businesses more ammunition
to fend off product-liability lawsuits Tuesday by extending the reach of
guidelines that let trial judges exclude ``junk science'' as evidence.

Those guidelines, fashioned in a key 1993 decision, also apply to the planned
testimony of all expert witnesses, the court said in a decision insurers
predicted could play a huge role in anticipated lawsuits over Year 2000
computer woes.

``We conclude that (the 1993 ruling's) general holding .

The decision ended a family's lawsuit against a tire manufacturer over a 1993
Alabama traffic accident that killed one person and injured seven others.

The justices voted 8-1 in separate ruling that a federal trial judge correctly
barred an engineer from testifying that he believed a defect had caused a tire
blowout and the accident. Breyer said the trial judge, acting in his role as
gatekeeper, rightly doubted whether the engineer's methodology could reliably
determine the cause of the tire's failure.

``It's a really bad day for consumers,'' said Gerson Smoger, a Dallas attorney
with Trial Lawyers for Public Justice. ``It enhances judicial power at the
expense of letting juries assess the credibility of evidence.''

But Craig Berrington, general counsel of the American Insurance Association,
called the decision ``a sweeping victory for honest trials and honest
decisions.''

He said the ruling could reduce the number of anticipated lawsuits over Year
2000 computer problems. ``In the vast majority of these disputes, the expert
testimony of software engineers or computer science experts will be
essential'' to claims of alleged design defects, Berrington said.

The nation's highest court in 1993 told judges deciding on the admissibility
of expert evidence to consider whether the theory or technique had been
tested, whether it was reviewed by other experts, its possible rate of error
and whether it was generally accepted by the scientific community.

The guidelines, aimed at ensuring that planned testimony is both relevant and
reliable, apply directly to federal courts only but most state courts model
their rules after their federal counterparts.

A trial judge trying to decide whether to admit the testimony of a
nonscientific expert witness -- such as an engineer or computer software
designer -- ``may consider one or more of the specific factors ... when doing
so will help determine that testimony's reliability,'' Breyer said.

But the ruling also emphasized that trial judges have broad discretion in
making such determinations and that appeals courts can overrule them only if
they find an ``abuse of discretion'' -- a legal standard difficult to meet.

Beyond engineers, the decision did not attempt to pin down just what expert
witnesses might be affected. ``We can neither rule out, nor rule in, for all
cases and for all time the applicability of the (1993 guidelines),'' Breyer
said. ``Too much depends upon the particular circumstances of the particular
case at issue.''

In the Alabama case, the 11th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals had ruled that the
1993 guidelines do not apply to nonscientific testimony. Its ruling gave the
Patrick Carmichael family another chance to show that engineer David Carlson's
testimony should have been allowed in their lawsuit against the Kumho Tire Co.

But Tuesday's ruling said the appeals court was wrong.

Breyer said the trial court ``decision in this case -- not to admit certain
expert testimony -- was within its discretion and therefore lawful.''

One Carmichael family member was killed and seven were injured when one of a
minivan's tires blew failed, the driver lost control and the van overturned in
Baldwin County, Ala.

Justice John Paul Stevens agreed that the rules for scientific testimony apply
to nonscientific testimony as well, but said the 11th Circuit court should
first decide whether the trial judge correctly excluded the engineer's planned
testimony.



Reply via email to