-Caveat Lector- from: http://www.zolatimes.com/V3.13/pageone.html <A HREF="http://www.zolatimes.com/V3.13/pageone.html">Laissez Faire City Times - Volume 3 Issue 13</A> ----- The Laissez Faire City Times March 29, 1999 - Volume 3, Issue 13 Editor & Chief: Emile Zola ------------------------------------------------------------------------ Questions About the "Right to Die" by Peter Topolewski There is an ironic and distinct possibility that by the next mid-century, when the average life span in the West has hit 150 and sex for all the old cronies jacked-up on Viagra is again a bore, the generation taken closer than any before it to the cusp of immortality could be begging with all its youthful spirit for a quick death. If right to death proponents of the future hope to have any success arguing on behalf of healthy seniors sick of living, they�ll need to make significant improvements upon the euthanasia campaign of the 20th century. This campaign was born of nebulous arguments that have continually failed logical and ethical trial, and we see that today killing in mercy has become the monstrosity opponents warned us about, and which proponents assured us could never happen. Despite proponents� platitudes to the contrary, euthanasia studies from Holland indicate that euthanasia was never about just the terminally ill, and the motives seem to have little to do with mercy or a person�s right to choose death. The pro-euthanasia argument generally centers upon two key ideas. The first is a person�s right to die. This right has been established upon a heap of groundless assumptions, beginning with the characterization that the right to die has evolved from the right to life. The right to die is apparently, as is the right to life, an absolute right of the individual, and as such entitles the individual with absolute autonomy. Euthanasia proponents ignore the philosophical question of how individuals having no part in their initial existence can lay claim to such rights � that is, they refuse to address from where such rights might originate. Even discounting this problem, there remain conspicuously unanswered questions of how the right to die evolved from the right to life, and on what grounds it can be called absolute. In a society of equals, how can an individual claim absolute autonomy? These questions do not often arise in euthanasia debates. And the less the better, it seems, for proponents, for then discussion generally focuses on what has become the heart of euthanasia: why those wishing to exercise it must be mercifully granted their right to death. We are told that no matter our preconceptions, the 20th century doctor�s job is not to preserve life but above all to relieve suffering by all means available to him. Inducing death is of course a "means" to relieve suffering, and proponents justify this by proffering definitions of suffering. Unmitigated pain is probably the most significant component of suffering, but one that is admittedly subjective and dependent upon the sufferer's assessment. One of the first people assisted in suicide under Oregon�s new euthanasia law was, according to the first doctor who examined her, not suffering from pain but depression. With assisted suicide advocates working diligently, the woman was quickly enough led to doctors more open to believing her side of the story. She met her end shortly thereafter. Mental distress is another form of suffering that euthanasia seeks to relieve. Loss of control over bodily functions (which can be measured) and loss of cognitive existence (which cannot) lead to a sense of diminished dignity of life, say euthanasia advocates. The feeling that the dignity of one�s life has diminished is entirely non-quantifiable, but nevertheless it is a feeling that in all likelihood nearly the entire population of the world has felt at one time or another. We are reminded, however, that when wondering which life to preserve and which to terminate, doctors (but first society in general) must consider the quality of the life in question. Never mind the droves of starving and diseased throughout the Third World, the average skid row resident in our very own cities has the right, it seems, to a doctor inquiring as to their desire to die a merciful death. Those in favor of euthanasia claim that when deciding who stays and who goes, the doctor must differentiate between living and (mere) existence, though no empirical difference between these has ever been established. Presumably the difference lies in one�s capacity to contribute to one�s physical, intellectual, and spiritual well being. The capacity to contribute to two of three of these is wholly immeasurable. Although the criteria for euthanasia appear to leave the mercy killing door open to almost all comers � as it should if people are to have freedom to exercise their absolute right to die � proponents assure the non-believers that proper rules are in place to ensure only qualified candidates get to arrange their own demise. To eliminate opportunities for zealous doctors and weary families to pull the plug, euthanasia rule number one states that induced death must be undertaken at the explicit and express request of the patient. And to eliminate any nuts who simply want someone else to put them out of their form of misery, the request for assisted suicide must be made by a mature adult who can use their fully possessed decision-making capacity to give the decision careful consideration. As stated, these criteria not only deny children and young adults their absolute right to die, they also suggest that most mentally handicapped, mentally ill, elderly, and indeed most terminally ill patients will be denied euthanasia candidacy. It is hardly surprising then that for all the talk about autonomy and absolute rights the pro-euthanasia movement is suffused with references to 1) a patient�s usefulness to family and society, and 2) the unmitigated pain and suffering the patient places on the family. The truth is that in many cases of euthanasia personal autonomy has little to do with who lives and who dies. In Holland, the world�s leading openly pro-euthanasia nation, euthanasia is not technically legal but the courts look the other way provided doctors follow the established guidelines. Euthanasia is to be used only in cases of unbearable suffering, and doctors who practice it otherwise face criminal charges. These are the regulations that are to eliminate the wrong people being mercy killed for the wrong reasons. Yet according to the Journal of Medical Ethics, in 1995 20 percent of euthanasia cases in Holland took place without the patient�s explicit request. Almost 2/3 of all euthanasia cases were unreported, and in 17 percent of the cases alternative therapies were available. An earlier study found that more than half of Holland�s euthanasia cases go unreported and that at least 1000 occur every year without the patient�s formal request. Claims of and for personal autonomy look a farce in this light, and considering 56 percent of doctors stated they helped speed up the process of dying to save the patients� loss of dignity, so does the rule about "unbearable suffering." Given these progress reports there can be no mistake why euthanasia proposals are often framed around the need to eliminate dogma and belief from the arena of our dramatically evolving medical abilities. We as a society are implored to change our value systems to reflect the changing medical scene, the social and economic realities, the growing cost of health care and the cost effectiveness of medical services. When the message and the reality are boiled down, we find that euthanasia is about autonomy � mainly the doctors�. Euthanasia is about the power to eliminate the natural, and what in euthanasia literature is so often called the inevitable, process of death. Euthanasia is the power to make the natural unnatural, to remove the uncertainty from the inevitable and make it certain. There seems something twisted in doctors, the preservers of life, willfully delivering death, feeling fit to judge the inestimable contingencies buried in the minds of the ill and perhaps not so ill. Dr. Kevorkian, America�s number one euthanasia practitioner, has been called a serial killer. Is he merciful? Or is he getting a thrill out of holding life at his mercy? Since we cannot create life, only pass it on, our ability to destroy life is in many eyes our ultimate power. In the name of mercy it has proven to be a very seductive and infectious one. -30- from The Laissez Faire City Times, Vol 3, No 13, March 29, 1999 ------------------------------------------------------------------------ Published by Laissez Faire City Netcasting Group, Inc. Copyright 1998 - Trademark Registered with LFC Public Registrar All Rights Reserved Disclaimer The Laissez Faire City Times is a private newspaper. Although it is published by a corporation domiciled within the sovereign domain of Laissez Faire City, it is not an "official organ" of the city or its founding trust. Just as the New York Times is unaffiliated with the city of New York, the City Times is only one of what may be several news publications located in, or domiciled at, Laissez Faire City proper. For information about LFC, please contact [EMAIL PROTECTED] ----- Aloha, He'Ping, Om, Shalom, Salaam. Em Hotep, Peace Be, Omnia Bona Bonis, All My Relations. Adieu, Adios, Aloha. Amen. Roads End Kris DECLARATION & DISCLAIMER ========== CTRL is a discussion and informational exchange list. Proselyzting propagandic screeds are not allowed. Substance�not soapboxing! These are sordid matters and 'conspiracy theory', with its many half-truths, misdirections and outright frauds is used politically by different groups with major and minor effects spread throughout the spectrum of time and thought. That being said, CTRL gives no endorsement to the validity of posts, and always suggests to readers; be wary of what you read. CTRL gives no credeence to Holocaust denial and nazi's need not apply. Let us please be civil and as always, Caveat Lector. ======================================================================== Archives Available at: http://home.ease.lsoft.com/archives/CTRL.html http:[EMAIL PROTECTED]/ ======================================================================== To subscribe to Conspiracy Theory Research List[CTRL] send email: SUBSCRIBE CTRL [to:] [EMAIL PROTECTED] To UNsubscribe to Conspiracy Theory Research List[CTRL] send email: SIGNOFF CTRL [to:] [EMAIL PROTECTED] Om
