-Caveat Lector-
What Makes Mainstream Media Mainstream
(From a talk at Z Media Institute June 1997)
By Noam Chomsky
<http://www.zmag.org/chomsky/articles/z9710-mainstream-media.html>
Part of the reason why I write about the media is because I am interested in the whole
intellectual
culture, and the part of it that is easiest to study is the media. It comes out every
day. You can
do a systematic investigation. You can compare yesterday�s version to today�s version.
There is a
lot of evidence about what�s played up and what isn�t and the way things are
structured.
My impression is the media aren�t very different from scholarship or from, say,
journals of
intellectual opinion�there are some extra constraints�but it�s not radically
different. They
interact, which is why people go up and back quite easily among them.
You look at the media, or at any institution you want to understand. You ask questions
about its
internal institutional structure. You want to know something about their setting in
the broader
society. How do they relate to other systems of power and authority? If you�re lucky,
there is an
internal record from leading people in the information system which tells you what
they are up to
(it is sort of a doctrinal system). That doesn�t mean the public relations handouts
but what they
say to each other about what they are up to. There is quite a lot of interesting
documentation.
Those are three major sources of information about the nature of the media. You want
to study them
the way, say, a scientist would study some complex molecule or something. You take a
look at the
structure and then make some hypothesis based on the structure as to what the media
product is
likely to look like. Then you investigate the media product and see how well it
conforms to the
hypotheses. Virtually all work in media analysis is this last part�trying to study
carefully just
what the media product is and whether it conforms to obvious assumptions about the
nature and
structure of the media.
Well, what do you find? First of all, you find that there are different media which do
different
things, like the entertainment/Hollywood, soap operas, and so on, or even most of the
newspapers in
the country (the overwhelming majority of them). They are directing the mass audience.
There is another sector of the media, the elite media, sometimes called the
agenda-setting media
because they are the ones with the big resources, they set the framework in which
everyone else
operates. The New York Times and CBS, that kind of thing. Their audience is mostly
privileged
people. The people who read the New York Times�people who are wealthy or part of what
is sometimes
called the political class�they are actually involved in the political system in an
ongoing fashion.
They are basically managers of one sort or another. They can be political managers,
business
managers (like corporate executives or that sort of thing), doctoral managers (like
university
professors), or other journalists who are involved in organizing the way people think
and look at
things.
The elite media set a framework within which others operate. If you are watching the
Associated
Press, who grind out a constant flow of news, in the mid-afternoon it breaks and there
is something
that comes along every day that says "Notice to Editors: Tomorrow�s New York Times is
going to have
the following stories on the front page." The point of that is, if you�re an editor of
a newspaper
in Dayton, Ohio and you don�t have the resources to figure out what the news is, or
you don�t want
to think about it anyway, this tells you what the news is. These are the stories for
the quarter
page that you are going to devote to something other than local affairs or diverting
your audience.
These are the stories that you put there because that�s what the New York Times tells
us is what
you�re supposed to care about tomorrow. If you are an editor in Dayton, Ohio, you
would sort of have
to do that, because you don�t have much else in the way of resources. If you get off
line, if you�re
producing stories that the big press doesn�t like, you�ll hear about it pretty soon.
In fact, what
just happened at San Jose Mercury News is a dramatic example of this. So there are a
lot of ways in
which power plays can drive you right back into line if you move out. If you try to
break the mold,
you�re not going to last long. That framework works pretty well, and it is
understandable that it is
just a reflection of obvious power structures.
The real mass media are basically trying to divert people. Let them do something else,
but don�t
bother us (us being the people who run the show). Let them get interested in
professional sports,
for example. Let everybody be crazed about professional sports or sex scandals or the
personalities
and their problems or something like that. Anything, as long as it isn�t serious. Of
course, the
serious stuff is for the big guys. "We" take care of that.
What are the elite media, the agenda-setting ones? The New York Times and CBS, for
example. Well,
first of all, they are major, very profitable, corporations. Furthermore, most of them
are either
linked to, or outright owned by, much bigger corporations, like General Electric,
Westinghouse, and
so on. They are way up at the top of the power structure of the private economy which
is a very
tyrannical structure. Corporations are basically tyrannies, hierarchic, controled from
above. If you
don�t like what they are doing you get out. The major media are just part of that
system.
What about their institutional setting? Well, that�s more or less the same. What they
interact with
and relate to is other major power centers�the government, other corporations, or the
universities.
Because the media are a doctrinal system they interact closely with the universities.
Say you are a
reporter writing a story on Southeast Asia or Africa, or something like that. You�re
supposed to go
over to the big university and find an expert who will tell you what to write, or else
go to one of
the foundations, like Brookings Institute or American Enterprise Institute and they
will give you
the words to say. These outside institutions are very similar to the media.
The universities, for example, are not independent institutions. There may be
independent people
scattered around in them but that is true of the media as well. And it�s generally
true of
corporations. It�s true of Fascist states, for that matter. But the institution itself
is parasitic.
It�s dependent on outside sources of support and those sources of support, such as
private wealth,
big corporations with grants, and the government (which is so closely interlinked with
corporate
power you can barely distinguish them), they are essentially what the universities are
in the middle
of. People within them, who don�t adjust to that structure, who don�t accept it and
internalize it
(you can�t really work with it unless you internalize it, and believe it); people who
don�t do that
are likely to be weeded out along the way, starting from kindergarten, all the way up.
There are all
sorts of filtering devices to get rid of people who are a pain in the neck and think
independently.
Those of you who have been through college know that the educational system is very
highly geared to
rewarding conformity and obedience; if you don�t do that, you are a troublemaker. So,
it is kind of
a filtering device which ends up with people who really honestly (they aren�t lying)
internalize the
framework of belief and attitudes of the surrounding power system in the society. The
elite
institutions like, say, Harvard and Princeton and the small upscale colleges, for
example, are very
much geared to socialization. If you go through a place like Harvard, most of what
goes on there is
teaching manners; how to behave like a member of the upper classes, how to think the
right thoughts,
and so on.
If you�ve read George Orwell�s Animal Farm which he wrote in the mid-1940s, it was a
satire on the
Soviet Union, a totalitarian state. It was a big hit. Everybody loved it. Turns out he
wrote an
introduction to Animal Farm which was suppressed. It only appeared 30 years later.
Someone had found
it in his papers. The introduction to Animal Farm was about "Literary Censorship in
England" and
what it says is that obviously this book is ridiculing the Soviet Union and its
totalitarian
structure. But he said England is not all that different. We don�t have the KGB on our
neck, but the
end result comes out pretty much the same. People who have independent ideas or who
think the wrong
kind of thoughts are cut out.
He talks a little, only two sentences, about the institutional structure. He asks, why
does this
happen? Well, one, because the press is owned by wealthy people who only want certain
things to
reach the public. The other thing he says is that when you go through the elite
education system,
when you go through the proper schools in Oxford, you learn that there are certain
things it�s not
proper to say and there are certain thoughts that are not proper to have. That is the
socialization
role of elite institutions and if you don�t adapt to that, you�re usually out. Those
two sentences
more or less tell the story.
When you critique the media and you say, look, here is what Anthony Lewis or somebody
else is
writing, they get very angry. They say, quite correctly, "nobody ever tells me what to
write. I
write anything I like. All this business about pressures and constraints is nonsense
because I�m
never under any pressure." Which is completely true, but the point is that they
wouldn�t be there
unless they had already demonstrated that nobody has to tell them what to write
because they are
going say the right thing. If they had started off at the Metro desk, or something,
and had pursued
the wrong kind of stories, they never would have made it to the positions where they
can now say
anything they like. The same is mostly true of university faculty in the more
ideological
disciplines. They have been through the socialization system.
Okay, you look at the structure of that whole system. What do you expect the news to
be like? Well,
it�s pretty obvious. Take the New York Times. It�s a corporation and sells a product.
The product is
audiences. They don�t make money when you buy the newspaper. They are happy to put it
on the
worldwide web for free. They actually lose money when you buy the newspaper. But the
audience is the
product. The product is privileged people, just like the people who are writing the
newspapers, you
know, top-level decision-making people in society. You have to sell a product to a
market, and the
market is, of course, advertisers (that is, other businesses). Whether it is
television or
newspapers, or whatever, they are selling audiences. Corporations sell audiences to
other
corporations. In the case of the elite media, it�s big businesses.
Well, what do you expect to happen? What would you predict about the nature of the
media product,
given that set of circumstances? What would be the null hypothesis, the kind of
conjecture that
you�d make assuming nothing further. The obvious assumption is that the product of the
media, what
appears, what doesn�t appear, the way it is slanted, will reflect the interest of the
buyers and
sellers, the institutions, and the power systems that are around them. If that
wouldn�t happen, it
would be kind of a miracle.
Okay, then comes the hard work. You ask, does it work the way you predict? Well, you
can judge for
yourselves. There�s lots of material on this obvious hypothesis, which has been
subjected to the
hardest tests anybody can think of, and still stands up remarkably well. You virtually
never find
anything in the social sciences that so strongly supports any conclusion, which is not
a big
surprise, because it would be miraculous if it didn�t hold up given the way the forces
are
operating.
The next thing you discover is that this whole topic is completely taboo. If you go to
the Kennedy
School of Government or Stanford, or somewhere, and you study journalism and
communications or
academic political science, and so on, these questions are not likely to appear. That
is, the
hypothesis that anyone would come across without even knowing anything that is not
allowed to be
expressed, and the evidence bearing on it cannot be discussed. Well, you predict that
too. If you
look at the institutional structure, you would say, yeah, sure, that�s got to happen
because why
should these guys want to be exposed? Why should they allow critical analysis of what
they are up to
take place? The answer is, there is no reason why they should allow that and, in fact,
they don�t.
Again, it is not purposeful censorship. It is just that you don�t make it to those
positions. That
includes the left (what is called the left), as well as the right. Unless you have
been adequately
socialized and trained so that there are some thoughts you just don�t have, because if
you did have
them, you wouldn�t be there. So you have a second order of prediction which is that
the first order
of prediction is not allowed into the discussion.
The last thing to look at is the doctrinal framework in which this proceeds. Do people
at high
levels in the information system, including the media and advertising and academic
political science
and so on, do these people have a picture of what ought to happen when they are
writing for each
other (not when they are making graduation speeches)? When you make a commencement
speech, it is
pretty words and stuff. But when they are writing for one another, what do people say
about it?
There are basically three currents to look at. One is the public relations industry,
you know, the
main business propaganda industry. So what are the leaders of the PR industry saying?
Second place
to look is at what are called public intellectuals, big thinkers, people who write the
"op eds" and
that sort of thing. What do they say? The people who write impressive books about the
nature of
democracy and that sort of business. The third thing you look at is the academic
stream,
particularly that part of political science which is concerned with communications and
information
and that stuff which has been a branch of political science for the last 70 or 80
years.
So, look at those three things and see what they say, and look at the leading figures
who have
written about this. They all say (I�m partly quoting), the general population is
"ignorant and
meddlesome outsiders." We have to keep them out of the public arena because they are
too stupid and
if they get involved they will just make trouble. Their job is to be "spectators," not
"participants."
They are allowed to vote every once in a while, pick out one of us smart guys. But
then they are
supposed to go home and do something else like watch football or whatever it may be.
But the
"ignorant and meddlesome outsiders" have to be observers not participants. The
participants are what
are called the "responsible men" and, of course, the writer is always one of them. You
never ask the
question, why am I a "responsible man" and somebody else is in jail? The answer is
pretty obvious.
It�s because you are obedient and subordinate to power and that other person may be
independent, and
so on. But you don�t ask, of course. So there are the smart guys who are supposed to
run the show
and the rest of them are supposed to be out, and we should not succumb to (I�m quoting
from an
academic article) "democratic dogmatisms about men being the best judges of their own
interest."
They are not. They are terrible judges of their own interests so we have do it for
them for their
own benefit.
Actually, it is very similar to Leninism. We do things for you and we are doing it in
the interest
of everyone, and so on. I suspect that�s part of the reason why it�s been so easy
historically for
people to shift up and back from being, sort of enthusiastic Stalinists to being big
supporters of
U.S. power. People switch very quickly from one position to the other, and my
suspicion is that it�s
because basically it is the same position. You�re not making much of a switch. You�re
just making a
different estimate of where power lies. One point you think it�s here, another point
you think it�s
there. You take the same position.
@PAR SUB = How did all this evolve? It has an interesting history. A lot of it comes
out of the
first World War, which is a big turning point. It changed the position of the United
States in the
world considerably. In the 18th century the U.S. was already the richest place in the
world. The
quality of life, health, and longevity was not achieved by the upper classes in
Britain until the
early 20th century, let alone anybody else in the world. The U.S. was extraordinarily
wealthy, with
huge advantages, and, by the end of the 19th century, it had by far the biggest
economy in the
world. But it was not a big player on the world scene. U.S. power extended to the
Caribbean Islands,
parts of the Pacific, but not much farther.
During the first World War, the relations changed. And they changed more dramatically
during the
second World War. After the second World War the U.S. more or less took over the
world. But after
first World War there was already a change and the U.S. shifted from being a debtor to
a creditor
nation. It wasn�t huge, like Britain, but it became a substantial actor in the world
for the first
time. That was one change, but there were other changes.
The first World War was the first time there was highly organized state propaganda.
The British had
a Ministry of Information, and they really needed it because they had to get the U.S.
into the war
or else they were in bad trouble. The Ministry of Information was mainly geared to
sending
propaganda, including huge fabrications about "Hun" atrocities, and so on. They were
targeting
American intellectuals on the reasonable assumption that these are the people who are
most gullible
and most likely to believe propaganda. They are also the ones that disseminate it
through their own
system. So it was mostly geared to American intellectuals and it worked very well. The
British
Ministry of Information documents (a lot have been released) show their goal was, as
they put it, to
control the thought of the entire world, a minor goal, but mainly the U.S. They didn�t
care much
what people thought in India. This Ministry of Information was extremely successful in
deluding hot
shot American intellectuals into accepting British propaganda fabrications. They were
very proud of
that. Properly so, it saved their lives. They would have lost the first World War
otherwise.
In the U.S., there was a counterpart. Woodrow Wilson was elected in 1916 on an
anti-war platform.
The U.S. was a very pacifist country. It has always been. People don�t want to go
fight foreign
wars. The country was very much opposed to the first World War and Wilson was, in
fact, elected on
an anti-war position. "Peace without victory" was the slogan. But he was intending to
go to war. So
the question was, how do you get the pacifist population to become raving anti-German
lunatics so
they want to go kill all the Germans? That requires propaganda. So they set up the
first and really
only major state propaganda agency in U.S. history. The Committee on Public
Information it was
called (nice Orwellian title), called also the Creel Commission. The guy who ran it
was named Creel.
The task of this commission was to propagandize the population into a jingoist
hysteria. It worked
incredibly well. Within a few months there was a raving war hysteria and the U.S. was
able to go to
war.
A lot of people were impressed by these achievements. One person impressed, and this
had some
implications for the future, was Hitler. If you read Mein Kampf, he concludes, with
some
justification, that Germany lost the first World War because it lost the propaganda
battle. They
could not begin to compete with British and American propaganda which absolutely
overwhelmed them.
He pledges that next time around they�ll have their own propaganda system, which they
did during the
second World War. More important for us, the American business community was also very
impressed
with the propaganda effort. They had a problem at that time. The country was becoming
formally more
democratic. A lot more people were able to vote and that sort of thing. The country
was becoming
wealthier and more people could participate and a lot of new immigrants were coming
in, and so on.
So what do you do? It�s going to be harder to run things as a private club. Therefore,
obviously,
you have to control what people think. There had been public relation specialists but
there was
never a public relations industry. There was a guy hired to make Rockefeller�s image
look prettier
and that sort of thing. But this huge public relations industry, which is a U.S.
invention and a
monstrous industry, came out of the first World War. The leading figures were people
in the Creel
Commission. In fact, the main one, Edward Bernays, comes right out of the Creel
Commission. He has a
book that came out right afterwards called Propaganda. The term "propaganda,"
incidentally, did not
have negative connotations in those days. It was during the second World War that the
term became
taboo because it was connected with Germany, and all those bad things. But in this
period, the term
propaganda just meant information or something like that. So he wrote a book called
Propaganda
around 1925, and it starts off by saying he is applying the lessons of the first World
War. The
propaganda system of the first World War and this commission that he was part of
showed, he says, it
is possible to "regiment the public mind every bit as much as an army regiments their
bodies." These
new techniques of regimentation of minds, he said, had to be used by the intelligent
minorities in
order to make sure that the slobs stay on the right course. We can do it now because
we have these
new techniques.
This is the main manual of the public relations industry. Bernays is kind of the guru.
He was an
authentic Roosevelt/Kennedy liberal. He also engineered the public relations effort
behind the
U.S.-backed coup which overthrew the democratic government of Guatemala.
His major coup, the one that really propelled him into fame in the late 1920s, was
getting women to
smoke. Women didn�t smoke in those days and he ran huge campaigns for Chesterfield.
You know all the
techniques�models and movie stars with cigarettes coming out of their mouths and that
kind of thing.
He got enormous praise for that. So he became a leading figure of the industry, and
his book was the
real manual.
Another member of the Creel Commission was Walter Lippmann, the most respected figure
in American
journalism for about half a century (I mean serious American journalism, serious think
pieces). He
also wrote what are called progressive essays on democracy, regarded as progressive
back in the
1920s. He was, again, applying the lessons of the work on propaganda very explicitly.
He says there
is a new art in democracy called manufacture of consent. That is his phrase. Edward
Herman and I
borrowed it for our book, but it comes from Lippmann. So, he says, there is this new
art in the
method of democracy, "manufacture of consent." By manufacturing consent, you can
overcome the fact
that formally a lot of people have the right to vote. We can make it irrelevant
because we can
manufacture consent and make sure that their choices and attitudes will be structured
in such a way
that they will always do what we tell them, even if they have a formal way to
participate. So we�ll
have a real democracy. It will work properly. That�s applying the lessons of the
propaganda agency.
Academic social science and political science comes out of the same thing. The founder
of what�s
called communications and academic political science is Harold Glasswell. His main
achievement was a
book, a study of propaganda. He says, very frankly, the things I was quoting
before�those things
about not succumbing to democratic dogmatism, that comes from academic political
science (Lasswell
and others). Again, drawing the lessons from the war time experience, political
parties drew the
same lessons, especially the conservative party in England. Their early documents,
just being
released, show they also recognized the achievements of the British Ministry of
Information. They
recognized that the country was getting more democratized and it wouldn�t be a private
men�s club.
So the conclusion was, as they put it, politics has to become political warfare,
applying the
mechanisms of propaganda that worked so brilliantly during the first World War towards
controlling
people�s thoughts.
That�s the doctrinal side and it coincides with the institutional structure. It
strengthens the
predictions about the way the thing should work. And the predictions are well
confirmed. But these
conclusions, also, are not allowed to be discussed. This is all now part of mainstream
literature
but it is only for people on the inside. When you go to college, you don�t read the
classics about
how to control peoples minds.
Just like you don�t read what James Madison said during the constitutional convention
about how the
main goal of the new system has to be "to protect the minority of the opulent against
the majority,"
and has to be designed so that it achieves that end. This is the founding of the
constitutional
system, so nobody studies it. You can�t even find it in the academic scholarship
unless you really
look hard.
That is roughly the picture, as I see it, of the way the system is institutionally,
the doctrines
that lie behind it, the way it comes out. There is another part directed to the
"ignorant
meddlesome" outsiders. That is mainly using diversion of one kind or another. From
that, I think,
you can predict what you would expect to find.
DECLARATION & DISCLAIMER
==========
CTRL is a discussion and informational exchange list. Proselyzting propagandic
screeds are not allowed. Substance�not soapboxing! These are sordid matters
and 'conspiracy theory', with its many half-truths, misdirections and outright
frauds is used politically by different groups with major and minor effects
spread throughout the spectrum of time and thought. That being said, CTRL
gives no endorsement to the validity of posts, and always suggests to readers;
be wary of what you read. CTRL gives no credeence to Holocaust denial and
nazi's need not apply.
Let us please be civil and as always, Caveat Lector.
========================================================================
Archives Available at:
http://home.ease.lsoft.com/archives/CTRL.html
http:[EMAIL PROTECTED]/
========================================================================
To subscribe to Conspiracy Theory Research List[CTRL] send email:
SUBSCRIBE CTRL [to:] [EMAIL PROTECTED]
To UNsubscribe to Conspiracy Theory Research List[CTRL] send email:
SIGNOFF CTRL [to:] [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Om