-Caveat Lector-

>From FrontPagemag.CoM


The War on Rudy Giuliani

by John Podhoretz

The Weekly Standard | April 12, 1999

RUDOLPH GIULIANI'S FAVORITE MOVIE IS THE GODFATHER, and you need only
summon up some of its best-known lines to understand his extraordinary
style of governance. When Giuliani finds himself embroiled in a political
squabble with another elected official, he and his team "go to the
mattresses"�they hunker down, refuse to negotiate, and begin a war. This is
true of any political squabble, major or minor�whether it's a fight over
welfare reform with legislators in Albany or a ridiculous row with New York
governor George Pataki over which highway in the city should be named after
Joe DiMaggio. To the mattresses they go.

Giuliani's insistence on lockstep loyalty from his staff calls to mind
Michael. Corleone's admonition to his older brother Fredo that he is never
to take sides against the family again�ever. And his loyalty to those who
are loyal to him is like the Godfather's promise to the undertaker who
seeks his help in avenging his daughter's honor: Your enemies will become
my enemies�and then they will fear you.

Indeed, in the course of his five-plus years as the mayor of New York City,
Giuliani has been the entire Corleone family wrapped up in one person�which
is ironic, since in his years as U.S. Attorney for the Southern District of
New York, he was one of the masterminds behind the slow, deliberate
destruction of the Mafia. At once, Giuliani is cool and calculating like
Michael, charismatic and clever like Vito, and prone to sudden rages and
instant passions like Sonny.

For eight weeks now, ever since four policemen fired 41 bullets at an
unarmed African immigrant named Amadou Diallo, hitting him nineteen times
and killing him, Giuliani has been quiet, subdued, controlled�like the
Corleone family consigliere. But as the Diallo killing has mutated into the
worst crisis of his mayoralty, the question is whether the most effective
and transformative municipal chief executive of the past 50 years has
himself mutated into the hapless and feckless Fredo, the incompetent
Corleone. Which would be his worst fear.

At first blush, the Diallo killing would not have seemed the most
appropriate rallying point for a war on Rudy Giuliani. The four cops were
searching for a serial rapist on the night of February 4 and followed
Diallo into the vestibule of a tenement apartment building in the Soundview
section of the Bronx. What happened afterwards isn't clear; the police
officers have not spoken about the case, and nobody actually saw the
shooting, though nine witnesses claim to have heard shouting and gunfire.
But it does seem to be the case that the officers believed Diallo had a gun
and was about to open fire. Their response was a hailstorm of 41 bullets.
Two of the officers fired off every one of the sixteen bullets in their
Glock 9mm pistols�which meant they each had to squeeze the trigger 16 times
in three to five seconds. That would seem to suggest the officers were in a
heightened, adrenalized, state brought on by fear, panic, whatever. What it
does not suggest is a deliberate murder of an unarmed man, who turned out
to have had no history of trouble with police in the two years he had been
living in the United States,

The killing was so grotesque that it immediately captured the attention of
the city. The mayor and police commissioner Howard Safir expressed their
profound sorrow, offered to pay for the funeral and for the travel expenses
of Diallo's parents (his mother lives in his native Guinea, his father in
Vietnam). And then they could say little else. Because the four officers
who shot Diallo�under investigation by a grand jury that has just indicted
them for second-degree murder�clammed up in accordance with their Fifth
Amendment rights and have remained mute ever since.

What the mayor and police chief did do, as they do reflexively whenever
there are charges of police misconduct in New York, was defend the NYPD.
The actions of four cops, they have said in a hundred different ways since
the Diallo shooting, should not tarnish the reputations or the hard work of
the other 38,000 NYPD officers, who put their lives on the line on some
very mean streets every day.

This is not just pious talk on Giuliani's part. When he took office at the
beginning of 1994, the NYPD was reeling from the four years it spent under
the dominion of David Dinkins. The two incidents that probably cost Dinkins
his job both involved the NYPD, and in both cases Dinkins seemed to accept
the idea that police officers were part of the problem, not part of the
solution.

First, Dinkins ordered the police not to intervene in 1991 while
African-Americans in the Brooklyn neighborhood of Crown Heights went on a
three-day rampage against Hasidic Jews after a station wagon driven by a
Hasid ran over a seven-year-old boy. Eighty-one Jews were injured and one
killed as the cops stood around and did nothing. The next year, Dinkins
chose to believe accounts by residents in Washington Heights that an NYPD
officer named Michael O'Keefe had executed a drug runner named Jose "Kiko"
Garcia in cold blood. O'Keefe said he had been fighting for his life in
hand-to-hand combat. An extensive forensic investigation revealed that the
cop was telling the truth, and the story had been ginned up by drug bosses
in the neighborhood who were concerned about increased police scrutiny of
their nefarious doings.

Under Dinkins, the city's police officers felt they were working for a
mayor who didn't really trust or respect them�and this at the height of the
crack epidemic, when crazed rock-heads and gangbangers fighting over turf
went on a killing and crime spree the likes of which this city had never
seen.

Giuliani's primary challenge upon taking office was raising the morale and
effectiveness of the NYPD. In part he has done so by refusing to kowtow to
the rhetoric and tactics of those who allege that the city's police
routinely brutalize minorities. And he has treated with barely disguised
contempt those, like the influential Harlem minister Calvin Butts, who
issue forth the preposterous claim that the crime drop in the city since
Giuliani took office is due to feel-good "Stop the Violence" rallies in
minority neighborhoods�or even more ridiculously, give the credit to David
Dinkins, who signed into law the 1990 bill that expanded the police
department.

The turnaround in the city's crime statistics since 1994 is an oft-told
story, but every time you look at the numbers, they still have the power to
make your jaw drop. Overall, the city's crime rate has plunged 50 percent
in the past five years. And nowhere is the crime drop more pronounced and
wondrous than in minority neighborhoods.

Just a few of these numbers: On Manhattan's Lower East Side, the murder
rate dropped 81 percent in five years, rape 60 percent, burglary 72
percent. In East New York, one of Brooklyn's worst neighborhoods, the
murder drop is 67 percent; nearby, in Brownsville, murders decreased by 65
percent, burglaries by 56 percent. In Washington Heights, murders declined
by 82 percent, rapes by 61 percent, burglaries by 72 percent.

Some of this is attributable to tougher prison sentences and national
trends for which Giuliani cannot take credit (though New York's crime drop
is itself a big contributor to that trend). Still, the New York City
success story has much to do with the approach to policing introduced under
Giuliani.

The governing idea of the Giuliani NYPD is that the police can extirpate
crime at its source rather than simply responding to criminal activity
after it happens. Twice weekly, on the eighth floor of police headquarters,
the top brass have a three-hour meeting called Compstat. Using matching
databases, they look at crime activity in the previous few days throughout
the city and deploy resources to challenge crime where it's spiking. For
example, say there's a rash of burglaries in a given housing project.
Police will cross-check that database with a database of parolees, and then
look to see whether any of the parolees are new to the area. If so, they'll
go and check it out�and more often than not, nab their man. Sounds logical,
but it hadn't been done before.

Giuliani is proud of the NYPD; together with the billions of dollars thrown
off by the Wall Street boom of the 1990s, it is responsible for turning New
York into a safe and prosperous city. (The municipal budget surplus this
year will hover somewhere around $2 billion.) But that is not the only fact
he has on his side in defense of his NYPD.

The police department has grown by 3,000 officers since 1991, and arrests
have skyrocketed from 309,000 in 1995 to 403,000 in 1998. Even so, police
shootings of all kinds have steeply declined. In 1995, there were 344
police shootings; in 1998, the number was 249. In 1996, 30 of those
shootings were fatal; in 1998, 19 were. The rate of fatal police shootings
(.48 per 1,000 cops in 1998) in New, York is lower than in Chicago, Dallas,
Miami, Philadelphia, and Washington, D.C.

Alas, numbers aren't very material when bad things happen�and when bad
things happen in New York, they happen in outsize (41 bullets) ways. Two
years ago, police officers in Queens arrested and then brutalized a Haitian
man named Abner Louima in the station house in unspeakable ways. That
incident brought a blast of anger from the mayor, who appointed a
commission to look into the conduct of the NYPD as a result.

But when the commission issued a report�which said, in essence, that it
should become a permanent quasi-governmental body investigating the conduct
of the NYPD�Giuliani responded with another blast of anger, this time at
the commission. He wanted the group to give the great majority of New York
cops a clean bill of health, which would have been a rational finding given
all the evidence.

The mayor was furious with the commission because he believed it was doing
the dirty work of those who make a living by defaming the police�people
like Al Sharpton. Sharpton became one of the "advisers" to Abner Louima,
and it was certainly one of Louima's advisers who told him to tell the
press and investigators that when the cops were torturing him, they said,
"It's Giuliani time." It was the crusading anti-cop journalist Peter Noel
of The Village Voice who discovered (to Noel's regret) that Louima had
lied; the cops had said no such thing.

It hasn't been a good year for Sharpton. The revelation of the Louima lie
came around the same time that a jury finally found Sharpton liable for the
disgustingly false 1987 accusation that an assistant district attorney had
raped the fake victim Tawana Brawley. Nonetheless, within a day of the
Diallo shooting, Sharpton had become the Diallo family "spokesman." Like
his friend Don King, who is always in the vicinity when a boxing match
looks like it is fixed, Sharpton has an amazing talent for getting himself
involved in racially charged incidents in New York City�and charging them
up still further, to the point that people actually get killed. (In 1995,
Sharpton helped organize protests in Harlem against a discount store called
Freddy's Fashion Mart, which was white-owned. Matters got so ugly that
somebody torched the place. Seven people died in the blaze.)

In the days immediately following the Diallo shooting, Giuliani and police
commissioner Howard Safir were quiet, sober, and restrained. The mayor in
particular expressed his sorrow and surprise, but still urged the city not
to turn on its cops. And Giuliani, a man not accustomed to suffering
slights easily, spent the week after Diallo's death being slighted again
and again. The family would not meet with him, clearly on Sharpton's
orders, unless he agreed to suspend the cops�which would have been a clear
violation of their rights in the absence of an indictment or other
admission of guilt. He was heckled and screamed at when he arrived at the
city's main mosque for a memorial service at which he did not speak.

For nearly two months, the mayor has been accused by all and sundry of
gross insensitivity. The Diallo killing has become the rallying cry for
those who want to argue that the NYPD systematically targets black people.
New York Times columnist Bob Herbert puts it this way: "Police misconduct
[is] so widespread and at times so insanely violent that it has brought a
new kind of terror to the streets of New York."

This is absurd�it's so much safer on the streets of New York these days,
especially in minority neighborhoods, that Herbert really deserves to be
sent to a rhetoric-sensitivity seminar. Still, Herbert�s view is what has
motivated a ludicrous moral pageant in front of police headquarters
orchestrated by Sharpton�in which more than 1,000 people have been arrested
in the past two weeks in an entirely cost-free display of civil
disobedience. (The arrestees are brought to a precinct, issued a bench
warrant, and freed; and the charges are certain to be dismissed.) The
protesters wanted to express their disgust with the police department that
has made New York City livable again.

But that's not quite it. What the protesters really want to do is
delegitimize the mayoralty of Rudolph Giuliani. And here's where the story
gets especially interesting, because the forces arrayed against Giuliani
have problems with him that have nothing whatever to do with policing and
everything to do with his ideas about governance.

Giuliani, who is fearless and combative in a most unusual way, has
systematically taken on the prevailing ideological power structure in the
city of New York over the past five years. Ever since the 1960s, New York
has been governed by a weird and immensely powerful public�private
partnership. The outrageously corrupt public-sector unions worked in
lockstep with city agencies and the city council to expand benefits while
simultaneously diminishing union responsibility. Activists have colluded
with judges to force city agencies into consent decrees that require the
agencies to give taxpayer money to the activists�who then live
parasitically off the agencies they are supposed to monitor.

Giuliani will have none of this. He has gone to the mattresses�trying to
sell off city hospitals, laying off thousands of city workers in the teeth
of concerted opposition, refusing to sign new consent decrees and fighting
old ones in court, and insisting on accountability throughout the city
bureaucracy. This all ties into his central message, which is that New York
City can again be a paragon of civic order. His most concerted enemy in the
city is the head of the New York Civil Liberties Union, Norman Siegel, who
dislikes every single thing the mayor does from trying to close down shops
that distribute pornography in family neighborhoods to arresting vagrants
on quality-of-life offenses.

Libertarians revile Giuliani, who sees his primary task not as defending
the rights of individuals to do anything and everything they want to do on
the streets of New York but as reestablishing the principle that the first
freedom is the freedom from the Hobbesian state of nature into which New
York had fallen.

If Giuliani finds his political career damaged beyond his ability to repair
it by the Diallo matter, that will be genuinely unfortunate. He has been an
extraordinary public official by any reckoning, with a rare grasp of the
interplay between politics and ideas and an ever rarer grasp of how to
translate ideas into policy.

But there is much more at stake in the Diallo crisis than Giuliani's own
career. What is happening in New York City right now is an effort to
discredit the ideas and policies of the Giuliani administration�to
discredit a specific kind of conservative governance whose success is a
dagger pointed at the heart of American liberalism. Giuliani obviously
didn't handle the Diallo incident perfectly�to do so would probably have
required someone other than a Corleone. But if conservatives don't defend
him and his achievement, what public official who follows will be brave
enough to take on the demagogues who thrive, like Al Sharpton, on disorder
and chaos?



� 1999 Newscorp, Inc.

E N D




~~~~~~~~~~~~
A<>E<>R

The only real voyage of discovery consists not in seeking
new landscapes but in having new eyes. -Marcel Proust
+ + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + +
Every great advance in natural knowledge has involved
the absolute rejection of authority. -Thomas Huxley
+ + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + +
Forwarded as information only; no endorsement to be presumed
+ + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + +
In accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. section 107, this material
is distributed without charge or profit to those who have
expressed a prior interest in receiving this type of information
for non-profit research and educational purposes only.

DECLARATION & DISCLAIMER
==========
CTRL is a discussion and informational exchange list. Proselyzting propagandic
screeds are not allowed. Substance�not soapboxing!  These are sordid matters
and 'conspiracy theory', with its many half-truths, misdirections and outright
frauds is used politically  by different groups with major and minor effects
spread throughout the spectrum of time and thought. That being said, CTRL
gives no endorsement to the validity of posts, and always suggests to readers;
be wary of what you read. CTRL gives no credeence to Holocaust denial and
nazi's need not apply.

Let us please be civil and as always, Caveat Lector.
========================================================================
Archives Available at:
http://home.ease.lsoft.com/archives/CTRL.html

http:[EMAIL PROTECTED]/
========================================================================
To subscribe to Conspiracy Theory Research List[CTRL] send email:
SUBSCRIBE CTRL [to:] [EMAIL PROTECTED]

To UNsubscribe to Conspiracy Theory Research List[CTRL] send email:
SIGNOFF CTRL [to:] [EMAIL PROTECTED]

Om

Reply via email to