-Caveat Lector-


    FRIDAY
APRIL 16
1999      �

Alan Keyes is a nationally syndicated radio talk-show host. His WorldNetDaily
column appears every Friday.
You can hear his radio program over the internet via Real Audio.


Kosovo and an American contradiction

------------------------------------------------------------------------

What is the connection between the NATO action and the ambitions of some to
establish a world government?

One of the questions that I have been asking myself about the NATO action is
why the whole idea of it seems wrong to me, and makes me so uncomfortable. I
believe it is because, at bottom, the understanding throughout my entire life
that has been the foundation of my thinking about international relations was
precisely that -- international. The subject was "international relations."
Implied is that we have a world composed of sovereign nations, and that we
are dealing with the relations among these sovereign nations and with the
strategic and political environment that results from these relationships.
Insofar as there is an international community, it is a community composed of
these nations working out, in mutually agreeable ways, the terms on which
they will conduct business with one another.

The basic assumption of this whole way of thinking is that those nations are
defined, they have boundaries and jurisdictions, and that by and large they
have within those jurisdictions the ability to order their affairs according
to their institutions, laws and practices -- up to and including some
institutions, laws and practices that we would consider oppressive, even
evil. It has been an important principle of international relations that such
matters are concerns of the particular country, and while another state might
do its best, if help was asked for, to help develop better institutions,
there was one thing it would not do -- go into another country and force
change. This was not acceptable, because it was aggression -- the use by one
country of force, without prior provocation of attack or threat, to impose
that country's will on another country. However valid and wonderful the
intended change might be thought to be, such forcible imposition of it on
another country has been universally deemed wrong by the international
community.

There are those who don't believe this, and who believe that we are moving
toward a fundamentally new kind of global unity. They say that our increasing
interdependence, particularly in finance, trade, technology and
communication, make the nation state obsolete. This view has had its
implications in economic and civic life already. Now, with the NATO
intervention in Kosovo, I think we are seeing for the first time a use of
force that is based upon the presumption that it is legitimate for a state or
group of states to intervene in the internal affairs of another state without
any real threat, military or otherwise, but simply on the grounds that the
state is not accepting an authority represented by the intervening states. In
this case, NATO is intervening to enforce Yugoslavia's acceptance of NATO's
authority and the terms of the Rambouillet Agreement, and to enforce that
acceptance with bombing and whatever else is necessary until the government
of Yugoslavia submits.

NATO is no longer acting as a cooperative defense force, which has been its
defining character since its inception. Its role is being redefined so that
it is now acting as the executive agent of a presumed authority to impose
upon a nation state a certain form for arranging its internal institutions -
otherwise known as a form of government. NATO is acting as the executive
agent for a presumed authority to impose in Yugoslavia a certain form of
government.

President Clinton has invoked humanitarian concerns in order to justify
NATO's use of force in the name of this presumed authority. But when you
examine these arguments on humanitarian grounds, they don't hold water. This
leads me to ask what else is going on here. The argument we are being given
seems to be a pretext, rather than a real motivation, cause or explanation.
So what is the real rubric under which NATO is acting?

The real rubric seems to be a putative authority to require that in
Yugoslavia a certain internal arrangement be accepted. NATO is insisting on
the ability to dispose of the governmental structures within Yugoslavia in a
way that seems right to the alliance. NATO is thus unwilling to continue
leaving such questions to be settled by peaceful, and sometimes other than
peaceful, means by people within the boundaries of the nation itself.

The dangers implied by this way of thinking are clear. The pretext of human
rights and abuse of ethnic minorities has been used by bad folks as well as
by good. Contrary to what Bill Clinton said, the Second World War wasn't
caused by ethnic strife in the Balkans. However, ethnic claims were involved
in its origin. We forget this, because our memory of Hitler is predominantly
a memory of his perpetration of the Holocaust. But the pretext for his
aggressions -- the aggressions that actually brought war on in Europe -- was,
among other things, mistreatment of ethnic Germans in the countries against
which he took his aggressive stances, including Czechoslovakia and Poland.
Hitler gave speeches intended to foment the frothing passions of the German
people, in which he played upon the humiliation involved in the mistreatment
of these ethnic German minorities and their inability to join with and enjoy
the proper relation with the German "Volk."

One of the explicit reasons that the principle of non-aggression was
established in the wake of the Second World War was to prevent unscrupulous
men like Hitler from exploiting the fact that boundaries cut through ethnic
groups in various parts of the world, and using that fact as a pretext to
advance their ambitions, or to impose their political will by wars of
aggression.

NATO appears to be disregarding this principle of non-aggression, and
reestablishing the notion that those who have the strength to do so have the
right to intervene in order to react to what they regard as the mistreatment
of ethnic minorities. I believe that this will be a very dangerous and
destabilizing precedent throughout the world. The result could very well be
that the fragile advances that have been made in international stability
since the Second World War will be utterly undone, and we will be thrown into
a period of incessant warfare over the course of the 21st Century.

Some have attempted to justify NATO's intervention on the grounds that there
is a general right to intervene whenever a government uses force against its
people. This justification is incoherent. All government is about the use of
force against the people governed -- under, of course, certain circumstances.
According to the American understanding, that use of force is not legitimate
unless it is based on the consent of the governed. This is not just "our
way," it is in fact the right basis in principle for the foundation of
governments. But I do not and never have subscribed to the view -- and will
adamantly oppose its adoption by this country -- that we have the right to
use force to impose our understanding of legitimacy on countries around the
world.

Many countries -- indeed, most countries -- are not based upon this right
principle of just government. They are not based on consent of the governed;
they are based on other things. Many are based on fear and force, and some of
them are based on other forms of manipulation. But it is not right for the
United States to impose by force on other countries our understanding of
legitimate government. Such imposition of that legitimate understanding by
force would be a contradiction. We would be acting in a way that contradicts
the understanding that you can only govern by consent. We would be governing
by force in order to impose government by consent. We should not involve
ourselves in building an imperialist foreign policy on this contradiction.

I opposed communism because it was an intrinsically bad form of government.
But if an intrinsically bad form of government exists somewhere, and people
are putting up with it, then while I pray to God for them in the hope that
they will change, I will not endorse conquering that country in order to
impose a better form of government. We had to oppose the communists because
they were trying by force to impose that system on other countries. We do not
ourselves have that right, any more than the communists did. It would violate
the very principle we seek to defend.

By example, by judicious government of our own conduct in our relations with
other nations and our internal affairs, by working cooperatively with those
who are seeking in their own countries to promote and advance better
institutions -- in all of these ways I believe we should act aggressively and
vigorously to advance the cause of legitimate and decent government. But to
go to war in order to impose our idea of governmental legitimacy on other
countries is wrong. We should not in any way adopt such a practice as a
principle of our politics.

So when the right of intervention is claimed because a government has used
force against its people, we must disagree. All governments, everywhere in
the world, use force against their own people. Some of them do so to a lesser
extent, some to a greater, and many of them in ways that are illegitimate
because they are not based on respect for human rights and human dignity.
This is true, sad, tragic and terrible, and we should work in every way to
try to overturn it -- except through the imposition of force. Because by
doing so we involve ourselves in a deep contradiction. We attempt to
establish by illegitimate means what we call a legitimate government, and yet
the international situation resulting overall would be guided by our example
of tyranny, totally in contradiction with the principle we articulate.

The NATO intervention is a hubristic and dangerous bid to establish a
precedent for de facto world government. We must do everything we can to turn
our leaders away from this ambition, and to direct them instead toward the
humble project of learning the hard-earned lessons of their predecessors and
applying those lessons with prudence.

 NOTICE: In accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107,
this material is distributed without profit to those who
have expressed a prior interest in receiving the included
information for research and educational purposes. For
more information go to: http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/17/107.shtml


DECLARATION & DISCLAIMER
==========
CTRL is a discussion and informational exchange list. Proselyzting propagandic
screeds are not allowed. Substance�not soapboxing!  These are sordid matters
and 'conspiracy theory', with its many half-truths, misdirections and outright
frauds is used politically  by different groups with major and minor effects
spread throughout the spectrum of time and thought. That being said, CTRL
gives no endorsement to the validity of posts, and always suggests to readers;
be wary of what you read. CTRL gives no credeence to Holocaust denial and
nazi's need not apply.

Let us please be civil and as always, Caveat Lector.
========================================================================
Archives Available at:
http://home.ease.lsoft.com/archives/CTRL.html

http:[EMAIL PROTECTED]/
========================================================================
To subscribe to Conspiracy Theory Research List[CTRL] send email:
SUBSCRIBE CTRL [to:] [EMAIL PROTECTED]

To UNsubscribe to Conspiracy Theory Research List[CTRL] send email:
SIGNOFF CTRL [to:] [EMAIL PROTECTED]

Om

Reply via email to