-Caveat Lector- : Christ came from Arabia? : By Khaled Ahmed : : Book Reviews : : WHO WAS JESUS? A CONSPIRACY IN JERUSALEM : by Kamal Salibi : I.B. Tauris; Distributed by Vanguard Books Lahore; : Pp200; Original Price �12.95; Special Price �6.50 : : Kamal Salibi is a Lebanese-Christian scholar who first became known for his book The :Bible : Came from Arabia in 1985. His expertise lies in knowing the towns and villages of :Saudi : Arabia and Yemen closely enough to equate them with the place-names featuring in the : Bible. He repeats his claim once again in the present book based on St Paul's :Epistle to : the Galatians in which Paul writes that, after converting miraculously from a : Christian-baiting Jew, the first place he visited was Arabia and not Jerusalem. :Salibi : claims that he went to Hijaz in Saudi Arabia to consult the single Aramaic injil :(Gospel) : mentioned in the Quran and noted by Hadith as being in the possession of Varaqah bin : Nawfal in the times of Muhammad PBUH 500 years later. : : This happened 500 years before the advent of Islam. It is known that the language :spoken : by Christ was Aramaic which was the idiom then current in Arabia. The Bible says that : Jesus or Jeshu came from Galilee (al-Jalil in Arabic) which is located by the Jews in : Israel. According to Salibi, al-Jalil is a town in present-day Taif in Hijaz, and :this is : where Jeshu was born as a Jew. From here he went to Jerusalem to announce his :prophethood : among the Jewish nation awaiting their Messiah. Salibi examines the verses of the :Quran to : conclude that the prophet Issa mentioned in the Quran was not Jeshu of the Bible but : another prophet who proclaimed himself 400 years earlier than Jeshu. The Quran :described : Issa as a virgin-born prophet who liberalised the strict faith of the Torah and fell :foul : of the Jews. It was Issa who also predicted the coming of Ahmad, the other name of : Muhammad PBUH. : : The book is a fascinating examination of the four Gospels of the New Testament. It :relies : on modern Christian scholarship to point out the contradictions contained in them. It : analyses the contents of the Acts of the Apostles and Epistles of Paul to conclude :that : the New Testament 'joined' the two narratives of Jeshu and Issa for reasons of :politics : among the disciples of Christ. It is well known that the Gospels of Matthew, Mark, :Luke : and John are not compatible in their detail and that the first three are called :Synoptic : because of their minimal concordance while the Gospel of John is treated separately : because of its radical departure. The Gospels mix Jeshu, who has a father and :brothers, : with Issa, who has no father and no brothers. John goes so far as to not even :mention the : name of Maryam as Jeshu's mother while others admit his carpenter father while :bowing to : the Quranic version of the virgin birth. : : The Issa of Varaqah bin Nawfal was the one known to Muhammad PBUH, and the injil :mentioned : in the Quran was a single document. The other source confirming the presence of this :injil : was the Negus of Ethiopia who recognised Muhammad as the new Prophet on the basis of :its : text. The reference in the Quran to the changing of injil by Christians is actually a : reference to the fusion of Jeshu and Issa in the four Gospels of the New Testament. :This : has resulted in the Muslim faith in the one injil (no longer extant) mentioned in the : Quran and narrated to Muhammad PBUH by Varaqah bin Nawfal, a close relative of his :wife : Khadija. This injil was written in Aramaic, the mother tongue of Christ, and was :relied : upon by Varaqah in lieu of the four originally Greek injils then followed in Hijaz :among : orthodox Christians. Salibi thinks that unless one separates the two persons known as : Jeshu and Issa the problem of the double narrative in the Gospels cannot be resolved. : : Christ is also called Nazarene connecting him to Nazereth in present-day Israel. :Salibi : thinks that Issa and his followers were called Nazerenes because of the town in :Hijaz they : came from, al-Nasira, which still exists in Saudi Arabia. Jeshu is claimed to be :from the : line of David and therefore entitled to be the king-prophet of Israel. Internal :evidence : also suggests that he was from the tribe of Levi. In the post-crucifixion politics :that : developed between Paul on the one hand and James the brother of Jeshu and the :disciples on : the other, royal descent became an important factor. Since Paul was spreading the :message : among the Gentiles of the West, his thinking was different from James and the :apostles of : Jerusalem. One difference that became marked in later times was Paul's refusal to :accept : circumcision for his Western converts insisted upon by James. Paul states in Epistle :to : the Galatians that the apostles in Jerusalem composed their differences with him only : after he offered them the much-needed funds he had collected in the West. : : According to Salibi, Paul's journey to Arabia acquainted him not only with the :Aramaic : gospel which talked of Issa but also other scriptures that had elevated Issa to the :level : of God. The Quran points to this cult when it says that some followers of Issa had :started : worshipping him as god. The Quran also develops the doctrines of wahdat and shirk :against : this apotheosis. It condemns the designation of Issa as Son of God. Paul is supposed :to : have used Arabian-Aramaic scriptures to invent his composite personality of Christ. :The : cult of Issa the God developed in Arabia as a fertility rite. Al-Issa the god was : developed from the ancient divinity of Al-Ais which means 'semen'. His temple was in :the : south at Tubalah in the province of Asir and was called Kaaba al-Yamaniya (the :southern : Kaaba). The divinity was called Dhu Khalasah (redeemer) and was a sculpture of white :stone : representing a phallus topped with a crown. Prophet Muhammad PBUH is said to have :sent his : warriors to destroy the 'second Kaaba' after coming to power. But the cult was :resurrected : later and the 'second Kaaba' in Asir was finally destroyed by the Wahabi warriors in :1815. : : It was not only Paul who could read Aramaic. John, Luke and Matthew too could read :the : Aramaic scriptures. They too are supposed to have benefited from these scriptures in :the : fusion of the three identities they produced in the person of Christ in their :Gospels. : Matthew's concept of Jesus as a repository of Kingdom, Power and the Glory is :supposed to : have been derived from Dhu Khalasah's attributes of marut (dominion) hayl (power) and : misbah (glory). His adoption of the Trinity is also taken by Salibi to be a :borrowing from : the cult of Al-Issa or Dhu Khalasah. : : But while these borrowings were against the Quran, there were many elements the :Apostles : took from the Aramaic injil that the Quran supports. John for instance, whose Gospel :is : considered 'gnostic' and set apart from the other three, took the Quranic word used :to : describe Issa, kalimah (speech), and translated it as Greek logos (word), thus :cleverly : linking up with the Old Testament symbol of pre-creation. This means that the Quran :had : used some of the words contained in the Aramaic injil it considered authentic. :Salibi has : not pointed this out but one can explain the famous phrase used by Luke:24: 'Indeed :it is : easier for a camel to pass through the eye of the needle than someone who is rich to :enter : the Kingdom of God'. The Quran, which came 500 years later, used the same camel :simile to : describe the fate of the arrogant (the rich can be arrogant?) in Aaraf:40: 'Nor will :they : enter the Garden until the camel can pass through the eye of the needle'. Some :scholars : have marvelled at the Quranic borrowing from Luke, but Salibi's research offers a :good : explanation. It is quite possible that Luke's borrowing of the phrase comes from the :same : early source as the Quran's, the Quran of course being a continuation of the :authentic : injil (Gospel) in which Prophet Issa had predicted the coming of Prophet Muhammad :PBUH. : : As explained by Salibi, the Jesus or Jeshu of the Gospels is a composite figure which : contains the attributes of the Jeshu of Arabia, fused with the Issa of the Aramaic :injil, : and Al-Issa the god. All the three arose in Arabia, which is sought to be proved on :the : basis of Salibi's research into the place-names of Saudi Arabia. His linking of the :Torah : geography to that of present-day Saudi Arabia has upset the Christian narrative as :well as : the post-Quranic Muslim narrative. His earlier book explained even the Old Testament : references to misr (Egypt) as references to locations in Arabia which the Christian :and : Muslim orthodoxy will find difficult to accept, but his work will always continue to : arouse interest. Much of his present book is based on earlier investigation of the : Gospels, but much of it is also based on plausible constructs. As a Christian he :believes : in the historical Christ but his effort at reconciliation of Biblical contradictions :has : made the present work possible. : : <A HREF="http://www.ctrl.org/">www.ctrl.org</A> DECLARATION & DISCLAIMER ========== CTRL is a discussion & informational exchange list. Proselytizing propagandic screeds are unwelcomed. Substance�not soap-boxing�please! These are sordid matters and 'conspiracy theory'�with its many half-truths, mis- directions and outright frauds�is used politically by different groups with major and minor effects spread throughout the spectrum of time and thought. That being said, CTRLgives no endorsement to the validity of posts, and always suggests to readers; be wary of what you read. CTRL gives no credence to Holocaust denial and nazi's need not apply. Let us please be civil and as always, Caveat Lector. ======================================================================== Archives Available at: http://peach.ease.lsoft.com/archives/ctrl.html <A HREF="http://peach.ease.lsoft.com/archives/ctrl.html">Archives of [EMAIL PROTECTED]</A> http:[EMAIL PROTECTED]/ <A HREF="http:[EMAIL PROTECTED]/">ctrl</A> ======================================================================== To subscribe to Conspiracy Theory Research List[CTRL] send email: SUBSCRIBE CTRL [to:] [EMAIL PROTECTED] To UNsubscribe to Conspiracy Theory Research List[CTRL] send email: SIGNOFF CTRL [to:] [EMAIL PROTECTED] Om
