-Caveat Lector-

Dear List,

I received this letter recently and thought it important to forward. I have
edited it for length, but the full text is at the urls below.

Sincerely,  Neil Brick


all accusations are alleged


"Problems for Victims of  Ritual Abuse in San Diego, California"

http://truthbeknown2000.tripod.com/Truthbeknown2000/

Link in upper right corner to "Problems for Victims of Ritual Abuse in San
Diego, California"

It's web-page is: http://truthbeknown2000.tripod.com/Truthbeknown2000/id2.html

PROBLEMS FOR VICTIMS OF RITUAL ABUSE IN SAN DIEGO, CALIFORNIA

Opinion Piece Submitted to the San Diego Union-Tribune, by Ellen Lacter,
Ph.D. on 9-29-2000

Mark Sauer's 9-24-00 article, "A Web of Intrigue", in the San Diego
Union-Tribune is his most recent in a series of articles misrepresenting the
facts on the subject of child ritual abuse and attacking advocates for ritual
abuse victims....

Sauer's factual misrepresentations of 9-24-00 are as follows:

1. Sauer claims the debate over satanic ritual abuse ended in the mid-1990's
when it was "discredited by mental- health experts and the courts". The truth
is that psychological and legal evidence of the existence of satanic ritual
abuse is substantial and that the debate is alive and well.

A review of the empirical evidence of ritual abuse can be found in a  book by
James Randolph Noblitt and Pamela Sue Perskin (Cult and Ritual Abuse, 2000,
Chapter 6). One national survey of 2709 clinical psychologists showed that
30% claimed to have seen at least one case of "ritualistic or religion-based
abuse" and 93% of these
psychologists believed the harm actually occurred (Reference: Goodman,
Qin, Bottoms, and Shaver, 1994,  "Characteristics and Sources of Allegations
of Ritualistic Child Abuse: Final Report to the National Center on Child
Abuse and Neglect").

The American Psychiatric Press published a text in 1997 explaining the
importance of correct assessment and treatment of ritualistic abuse survivors
(The Dilemma of Ritual Abuse: Cautions and Guides for Therapists, edited by
G.A. Fraser).

Numerous court decisions (criminal, family, juvenile, and civil) have been
based on findings of ritual abuse. For example, on February 27, 1999, the
Honorable Warren K. Urbom, Senior United States District Judge, Omaha,
Nebraska, awarded a million dollar civil judgement to Paul Bonacci against
Larry King (not the well-known talk-show host, Larry King), based on King's
sexual abuse (including pornography and orgies) and false imprisonment, of
Bonacci as a child, in the infamous Franklin satanic cult/sex/drug ring case.
Further information on this case can be found in the book, "The Franklin
Cover-Up", by John De Camp....

The court finding list is archived, periodically updated, and published  on
the world-wide web by "Karen Curio Jones". Under this pseudonym, "Jones" has
devoted herself to raising public awareness of child ritual abuse on the
Internet for the past five years. Sauer claims to expose "Jones'" identity in
his 9-24-00 article.

Sauer globally denies the existence of satanic ritual abuse while our recent
history is marred with undeniable cases of mass suicide/homicide by other
kinds of cults and
underground groups. This past summer,  almost 1000 people were found murdered
by an underground cult in Uganda, "Movement for the Restoration of  the Ten
Commandments of God". Last year, in Rancho Sante Fe, 39 people
suicided from the cult, "Heaven's  Gate". In Jonestown, 22 years ago, more
than 900 people mass-suicided and were murdered of "The People's Temple".
Devastating world events originate in underground groups, such as the Third
Reich and Ku Klux Klan. High school students are taught to remember the Nazi
death camps lest
such atrocities repeat themselves....

2. Sauer cites the McMartin Pre-school acquittals as evidence that  ritual
abuse does not exist. He omits any mention of the post-trial geological
survey under the school's foundation that yielded convincing corroboration of
the children's reports of being taken through underground tunnels (See "The
Dark Tunnels of McMartin", by  Summit, R.C., 1994, The Journal of
Psychohistory, 21(4), 397-416.)

3. Sauer cites the "10-year investigation" by Special FBI Agent Ken Lanning
that concluded that satanic ritual abuse does not exist. Sauer fails to
mention that Lanning is a very controversial figure. Noblitt and Perskin
(2000,  see above) state: "In reality, there is no such study... my office
contacted the FBI and requested a copy of the alleged study. The bureau
responded in writing indicating that no such  study existed." (See page 179
of their book).

4. Sauer refers to the 1991-1992 San Diego County Grand Jury "that  blasted
the child protection system after investigating wide-ranging allegations of
zealous social workers removing children from their homes without cause".
Sauer has widely publicized the findings of that Grand Jury over the years.
Sauer fails to mention the 1992-1993 San Diego County Grand Jury Report that
strongly criticized the 1991-1992 report as not being "in the best interest
of threatened children", as misrepresenting facts, and as having caused a
dramatic decline in the number of children removed from abusive and
neglectful homes in San Diego County, while these numbers climbed in other
California counties. The latter report also cites preliminary evidence of an
increase in infants' and  children's deaths caused by abuse and neglect in
San Diego County following the former Grand Jury report, although the numbers
were too small for statistical analysis. Sauer has failed to draw media
attention to the second Grand Jury report over the years. Such is an
unconscionable omission.

5. Sauer sympathetically portrays Carol Hopkins, one of the leaders of  the
1991-1992 Grand Jury. Sauer fails to mention that Hopkins was a member and
central figure of that Grand Jury, denounced by the 1992-1993 Grand Jury for
increasing the risk to children and misrepresenting the facts on child
abuse.....

6. Sauer also glorifies Elizabeth Loftus as "an internationally known expert
on the workings of memory". Sauer writes that Loftus "has testified for the
defense in many trials (including the Akiki case), explaining how memories -
especially those of young children - can be manipulated, even by well-meaning
people". Sauer neglects to explain that Loftus and the "False Memory Syndrome
Foundation", with which she has been affiliated, have come under serious
attack from numerous psychologists and organizations. A formal complaint was
lodged with the American Psychological Association (APA) in December, 1995,
against Loftus alleging that she deliberately misrepresented facts in her
published statements about two legal cases involving delayed memories, a
serious breach of professional ethics. Loftus resigned from the APA a month
later, claiming her resignation was unrelated to the complaint.

7. Sauer writes that "Loftus said she recently was invited to deliver the
keynote address at a convention of the New Zealand Psychology Society and
arrived to find herself the center of controversy. Accusations that she
conspires to protect child molesters, many fueled by Curio's ["Jones'"]
Internet postings, led to a story in the Wellington Evening Post and stoked
the talk-show fires." Sauer is attempting to paint "Jones", a small player,
as the source of high-profile Loftus' long-term high-profile problems.
Essentially all specialists in child abuse and memory research are aware of
the controversy surrounding Elizabeth Loftus.

8. Sauer portrays Michael Aquino as an innocent victim of "Karen Curio
Jones". Michael Aquino founded the "Temple of Set", which Sauer characterizes
as "a quasi-religious institution that many consider satanic". This clearly
evades the truth. In the Winter of 1989-1990, the California Office of
Criminal Justice Planning, under
Governor Pete Wilson, published a Research Update (Volume 1, Number 6)
which states: "Founded in 1975 by a dissident member of the Church of Satan,
Michael Aquino, the Temple of Set is the second largest of all contemporary
organized Satanic churches. The Temple of Set is a religious society
dedicated to Set, the ancient Egyptian god believed by some to be the model
for the Christian Satan. Aquino's many writings, especially The Book of
Coming Forth by Night, develops a sophisticated form of Satanism far beyond
that of LaVey's Church. Among its teachings is the belief that
Judeo-Christian religions have established Satan as a "straw man" to justify
their guilt for man's ejection from the Garden of Eden. Not much more is
known about Setians as the society is secret and most of its writings are not
available to the public at large" (p. 17).

Sauer writes, "In the late 1980s, Aquino was investigated in a
McMartin/Akiki-type case centering on allegations of satanic abuse at a
day-care center at San Francisco's Presidio military base" and "Aquino, who
was a lieutenant colonel, was questioned because of his satanic beliefs". To
dismiss the Presidio case as unfounded, Sauer places it in the same category
of the two other cases he already discredited. He then expresses sympathy for
Aquino because his satanic beliefs may have raised the suspicions of the
investigators. Sauer ignores that satanic practices have been found to be an
element in many cases of convicted child abuse.

Sauer omits important evidence of Aquino's involvement in the Presidio case.
The United States Army Criminal Investigation Command (CID) stated that
Michael Aquino was the subject of an investigation for sexual child abuse and
related crimes in the Presidio case (www.illusions.com/opf/aquino02.htm).
Aquino brought an action against Secretary Michael Stone of the Army to
remove his name from the title block of that investigation.

The 1991 Appellate decision of the United States District Court allowed the
title block to stand, finding that: "The facts in the administrative record
support the conclusion that the CID decision not to remove plaintiff's
[Aquino's] name from the title block was not arbitrary or capricious. There
was sufficient evidence from which the Army decision maker could determine
that probable cause existed to believe  that the plaintiff committed the
offenses". (reference: Aquino vs. Stone 768 F.Supp. 529).

Sauer includes a quote by Aquino portraying him as a concerned husband/father
threatened by the Internet postings of "Karen Curio Jones"; "My basic
interest was to identify an anonymous person who, because of his/her
obsessions and delusions, might pose a threat to the safety of myself and my
family."

What is the likelihood that Aquino, a man who has publicly exposed himself as
a Satanist, considers "Jones" a threat to his safety and family vs. Aquino
being motivated to silence "Jones" through a law suit? Sauer omits reference
to Aquino's highly publicized law suit against an Internet service provider
www5.electriciti.com/curious/) that threatens first amendment freedom of
speech....

9. Sauer paints "Jones" as a dangerous "cyberstalker", yet quotes Detective
Susan McCrary about "Jones": "She hasn't made any physical threats.
Everything's been done in a public forum" (San Diego State Police Department
(SDSU). Sauer paints Loftus, Hopkins, Aquino, and others as "Jones'" innocent
victims. Yet, one need not dig very deeply into Sauer's article to discover
otherwise....

10. Sauer writes that Jones ignored his requests to interview her for his
article and that "whatever motivates her remains pretty much a secret".

It is no surprise that "Jones" refused an interview with Sauer. I would too.
Anyone with knowledge of Sauer's slanted reporting on child abuse issues will
refuse an interview with him....

11. Sauer refers to quotes by Aquino and Hopkins in an effort to portray
"Jones" as deluded. Sauer writes that Aquino said; "Now that this person has
been identified, that 'faceless' threat no longer exists. She is now just
another woman with 'satanic ritual-abuse' sexual fantasies." Sauer writes
that Hopkins likens "Jones" to "the mythical Japanese soldier stumbling out
of the jungle still fighting World War II." Sauer's representation of "Jones"
in this manner and reliance on these suspect sources for his psychological
opinions of "Jones" raises important questions about his motives.

Under the guise of objective reporting, Sauer has used his 9-24-00 article to
launch a personal assault on "Karen Curio Jones" and her advocacy for victims
of ritual abuse. He writes; "Who is Curio and why is she saying such nasty
things about us [emphasis added] on the Internet?" "Us" represents Sauer,
Hopkins, Loftus, and  Aquino. An 8-20-98 San Diego Reader article, "The
Memory Wars" describes a social relationship between Sauer, Hopkins, and
Loftus. Should Sauer publish an ostensibly objective newspaper article when
he feels personally attacked by one of the players and is on a friendly basis
with her opponents?....

Ellen P. Lacter, Ph.D., Clinical Psychologist, California

<A HREF="http://www.ctrl.org/">www.ctrl.org</A>
DECLARATION & DISCLAIMER
==========
CTRL is a discussion & informational exchange list. Proselytizing propagandic
screeds are unwelcomed. Substance�not soap-boxing�please!  These are
sordid matters and 'conspiracy theory'�with its many half-truths, mis-
directions and outright frauds�is used politically by different groups with
major and minor effects spread throughout the spectrum of time and thought.
That being said, CTRLgives no endorsement to the validity of posts, and
always suggests to readers; be wary of what you read. CTRL gives no
credence to Holocaust denial and nazi's need not apply.

Let us please be civil and as always, Caveat Lector.
========================================================================
Archives Available at:
http://peach.ease.lsoft.com/archives/ctrl.html
 <A HREF="http://peach.ease.lsoft.com/archives/ctrl.html">Archives of
[EMAIL PROTECTED]</A>

http:[EMAIL PROTECTED]/
 <A HREF="http:[EMAIL PROTECTED]/">ctrl</A>
========================================================================
To subscribe to Conspiracy Theory Research List[CTRL] send email:
SUBSCRIBE CTRL [to:] [EMAIL PROTECTED]

To UNsubscribe to Conspiracy Theory Research List[CTRL] send email:
SIGNOFF CTRL [to:] [EMAIL PROTECTED]

Om

Reply via email to