-Caveat Lector-
With Freeh, Mistrust Was Mutual
By John F. Harris and David A. Vise
Washington Post Staff Writers
Wednesday, January 10, 2001 ; Page A01
Third in a series of occasional articles
In the early days, back in the summer of 1993, the relationship
between President Clinton and FBI Director Louis J. Freeh began
filled with promise. On the day Clinton nominated Freeh, he went
on CNN and called the then-federal judge an "amazing man" and "my
kind of guy."
Freeh, for his part, was similarly impressed, close associates
recall. He took the job after a two-hour meeting with Clinton in
which the president pledged that he valued FBI independence as
much as Freeh did. Addressing Freeh's concerns about the demands
of the job, Clinton assured the father of a growing family of
boys that he, too, was a family man who appreciated the need for
time at home.
It was a case, both men later would conclude, of first
impressions being spectacularly wrong. Within a year, the
relationship would become troubled. And within a few years,
according to many associates of both men, it would turn downright
rancid. At issue was a fundamental question: Was the FBI a loyal
part of the administration or a hostile force against it?
The story of their mounting distrust is an emblematic tale of the
Clinton era. While he soared high in the public approval
ratings, this president often felt besieged by hostile personal
and institutional forces within Washington. And while he
fashioned himself an activist president -- unafraid, for
instance, to boldly wield executive power on issues ranging from
public land to tobacco -- he often seethed at his impotence in
controlling a Justice Department and FBI ostensibly under his
command.
Clinton, say advisers, believes Freeh ran a deeply politicized
agency that under the guise of independence turned itself into an
unaccountable force -- one that often was overtly antagonistic to
Clinton on such issues as the 1996 Democratic fundraising
controversies. Freeh, those close to him say, came to regard
Clinton as an untrustworthy character, whose scandals dishonored
the presidency.
So sour did the relationship become that most people who had a
close view make no effort to put an upbeat gloss on it.
"There is obviously a very large amount of hostility and
suspicion between them," said Harvard Law School professor Philip
Heymann, a former senior Justice Department official in the
Clinton administration.
"I think Clinton felt there was some type of vendetta," said
former FBI deputy director Robert M. Bryant. For his part,
Bryant said Freeh "doesn't respect him, but I don't think he
hates him."
Both the president and Freeh declined to comment on their
relationship.
Tension Had Repercussions Despite the intensity of feeling, the
Clinton-Freeh conflict is in many respects an untold story.
Unlike the operatic battle between Clinton and independent
counsel Kenneth W. Starr, the chronic tension between the White
House and the FBI mostly smoldered beneath the surface, erupting
only occasionally into headlines.
Yet, in many ways, the FBI-White House relationship had wider
repercussions. Starr's work mostly affected Clinton personally,
but the White House-FBI tensions colored policy discussions,
particularly in the area of national security. On numerous
occasions, Clinton and White House officials learned from the
news media about cases the FBI was working on that they believed
had national security implications.
In 1997, friends recalled Clinton sputtering in a profane rage
when he and White House national security adviser Samuel R.
"Sandy" Berger read in the newspaper that the FBI was
investigating suspicions that China may have been using
surreptitious political contributions to buy influence and
facilitate espionage in Washington. It soon became clear that
the FBI -- which is part of the Justice Department -- had briefed
members of Congress, but not the White House, on the incendiary
case.
Berger's deputy, James Steinberg, recalled that the problem of
insufficient information-sharing was commonplace. He said the
issue has become more acute now that the FBI is routinely
involved in areas relating to U.S. interests abroad, including
espionage, global money-laundering and international terrorism
cases.
"I don't think it is a question of personalities, but an
underlying set of understandings that need to be worked out," he
said. Although the FBI followed its traditional instinct not to
share law enforcement information, Steinberg said, that is not
practical in the national security realm unless "there is an
overwhelmingly compelling reason not to share the information."
The FBI believes it had precisely such a reason in the case of
China's questionable fundraising activities: White House
officials or Clinton himself might eventually be implicated in
the investigation. The fundraising controversy is at the heart
of the ill will Clinton feels toward Freeh. Freeh wrote a memo
bluntly disagreeing with Attorney General Janet Reno's contention
that an independent counsel was not merited to investigate
Democratic fundraising. Although those close to Freeh say he
kept his views private for several years, Clinton aides believe
Freeh ultimately took the initiative in leaking the memo to the
news media and congressional Republicans.
Michael Bromwich, a former Justice Department inspector general,
said that Clinton "feels betrayed" by Freeh. "He appointed this
guy to the highest position he ever had in government, and the
guy has done nothing but haunt him and torment him, particularly
on the campaign finance matter," he said.
But Clinton confidants said the relationship was irreparably
strained even before the fundraising contretemps. Clinton had
for some time been suspicious of Freeh, aides said, because of
the FBI's aggressive investigation of the Whitewater land deal
that led to the appointment of an independent counsel. After
Republicans won control of Congress in 1994, Clinton believed
Freeh became far more responsive to GOP leaders than to his own
superiors in the administration.
But the relationship "went nuclear" in June 1996, a former
Clinton aide said, after disclosures that a mid-level White House
aide, Craig Livingstone, had improperly collected hundreds of FBI
files at the White House. Deeply embarrassed, White House aides
blamed a "bureaucratic snafu." Freeh compounded the political
damage with a statement saying "the FBI and I were victimized" by
the White House. Ultimately, an independent counsel found no
illegality, but White House aides viewed Freeh's statement as the
act of a consummately self-protective man.
After the fallout from the China fundraising allegations, Freeh
and Clinton never met alone, sources said. Freeh and Reno began
meeting regularly with Berger to review cases, though White House
sources said poor information flow remained an occasional
problem.
At least from the White House vantage point, the tension raised a
larger question with a troubling historical echo: Is the FBI held
accountable for the power it wields?
Several current and former Clinton aides invoked the name of
legendary FBI Director J. Edgar Hoover in discussing Freeh.
Although none asserted that Freeh had committed similar abuses --
Hoover held presidents and lawmakers under his sway with his
thick dossiers of personal information -- they believe Freeh's
reign offered reminders of the FBI's institutional tendency to
insulate itself from effective oversight.
White House Chief of Staff John D. Podesta, who said he
maintained a civil working relationship with Freeh, last year was
caught unaware that the FBI was developing its "Carnivore" system
for monitoring e-mail traffic. The sophisticated computer
surveillance program raised complicated issues of civil liberties
that White House officials said they should have had the right to
review. Instead, Podesta and others at the White House said they
learned about Carnivore in the news media.
"No institution should be unaccountable," Podesta said.
"Clearly, the White House should not be, but neither should the
FBI or the Justice Department or the Congress."
The distinction, Podesta said, is in preserving independence on
specific criminal cases, while having coordination on larger
issues of law enforcement policy: "I believe in the investigative
independence of police agencies. They shouldn't be directed by
political institutions or political considerations. But if under
that guise you remove all accountability, you can really set
yourself up for trouble."
Clinton and some of his senior aides believe that -- owing to the
support Freeh has cultivated among Republicans in Congress -- the
FBI routinely sails through storms that would have forced major
upheavals at other agencies.
In recent years, questions have been raised about FBI procedures
and competence over such episodes as the incorrect naming of
Richard Jewell as a suspect in the Atlanta Olympics bombing, the
mishandling of evidence at FBI crime labs and the heavy-handed
tactics used against nuclear scientist Wen Ho Lee before the
espionage case against him collapsed. FBI officials note that
these cases all drew ample criticism and oversight, including 19
congressional hearings on the Lee case, and resulted in reforms.
But they scarcely diminished Freeh's standing with GOP lawmakers
or hurt the agency's ability to win sizable budget increases.
White House aides are constantly compiling new stories they say
illustrate the agency's impertinence. Recently, senior aides
said they learned of Freeh's letter to Clinton opposing a pardon
for Leonard Peltier -- convicted of murdering two FBI agents in
1975 -- when it was posted on the Web site of Rep. Henry J.
Hyde (R-Ill.). FBI officials said the letter was hand-delivered
to the White House.
These complaints, though, glide past an obvious question: If
Clinton was unhappy with Freeh, why did he not fire him or insist
that Reno rein him in? The answer, according to several sources
who discussed the issue with Clinton, is that he would have
relished dismissing Freeh, and strongly considered letting Reno
go after the first term -- in part because he felt she was too
passive in supervising Freeh. But, on the defensive over ethics
for much of his term, the president concluded that the uproar
that would ensue from either action was not worth it, sources
said.
Instead, feelings got conveyed through not-so-subtle signals.
Reno was left dangling for a month in 1996 before Clinton said
she could stay. In 1997, when press secretary Michael McCurry was
asked whether Freeh had Clinton's confidence, he responded with a
masterpiece of faint praise -- saying Clinton thought Freeh was
"leading that agency as best he can. . . . You take [that]
whatever way you want to take it."
But occasionally the guise of cordiality dropped altogether.
When a reporter in 1999 pressed Clinton about fundraising
controversies, he shot back: "Yeah, the FBI wants you to write
about that rather than write about Waco."
A Lack of Understanding Clinton, according to a former aide,
often lamented that he rejected the best advice given by his
first-term counsel, Bernard Nussbaum, to fight the naming of a
Whitewater independent counsel, and accepted the worst advice,
the recommendation to hire Freeh.
Freeh supporters say that Clinton -- despite his 1993 assurances
to Freeh -- did not appreciate what it meant to have an
independent FBI. The director felt so strongly about this that he
turned in his White House pass -- as a result he was required to
sign in and out each time he visited. He did this in part so
that he could document his White House visits if questions about
the propriety of his contacts were raised later, sources said.
This also was a way of showing he was serious about independence
and would not permit the agency's reputation to be scuffed by a
president accused of using local law enforcement officials to
ferry women and conceal questionable conduct when he was governor
of Arkansas. "We are not the Arkansas state police," Bryant
said.
But nor, in the White House view, should the FBI be a free agent.
Podesta said this is a lesson the incoming administration, which
Freeh will continue to serve as he continues in his 10-year
appointment, would be wise to heed: "The FBI director works for
the attorney general, and the attorney general works for the
president. . . . To permit the bureau to operate with a total
hands-off policy is to reinvite the abuses of the Hoover era."
Jamie Gorelick, a former deputy attorney general, acknowledged
that such a dysfunctional relationship comes at a cost. "There
were some lost opportunities there for better, closer policy
coordination," she said. "There were people in the foreign policy
arena who felt they couldn't have the kind of conversations with
the FBI they needed to have to be maximally effective."
Gorelick attributed the soured relationship to two dynamic and
ambitious personalities who understood each other not at all.
"It was just a bridge too far," she said. "They had conflicting
mutual expectations and inaccurate mutual perceptions."
=================================================================
Kadosh, Kadosh, Kadosh, YHVH, TZEVAOT
FROM THE DESK OF:
*Michael Spitzer* <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
The Best Way To Destroy Enemies Is To Change Them To Friends
=================================================================
<A HREF="http://www.ctrl.org/">www.ctrl.org</A>
DECLARATION & DISCLAIMER
==========
CTRL is a discussion & informational exchange list. Proselytizing propagandic
screeds are unwelcomed. Substance�not soap-boxing�please! These are
sordid matters and 'conspiracy theory'�with its many half-truths, mis-
directions and outright frauds�is used politically by different groups with
major and minor effects spread throughout the spectrum of time and thought.
That being said, CTRLgives no endorsement to the validity of posts, and
always suggests to readers; be wary of what you read. CTRL gives no
credence to Holocaust denial and nazi's need not apply.
Let us please be civil and as always, Caveat Lector.
========================================================================
Archives Available at:
http://peach.ease.lsoft.com/archives/ctrl.html
<A HREF="http://peach.ease.lsoft.com/archives/ctrl.html">Archives of
[EMAIL PROTECTED]</A>
http:[EMAIL PROTECTED]/
<A HREF="http:[EMAIL PROTECTED]/">ctrl</A>
========================================================================
To subscribe to Conspiracy Theory Research List[CTRL] send email:
SUBSCRIBE CTRL [to:] [EMAIL PROTECTED]
To UNsubscribe to Conspiracy Theory Research List[CTRL] send email:
SIGNOFF CTRL [to:] [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Om