-Caveat Lector-

Of course, the media NEVER tries to influence its readers/viewers to arrive
at a pre-conceived conclusion (that fostered by the media).  I don't know
anything about the issue, specifically, but this just smacks of trial by
the media whereas there are courts that have the job of determining these
things.

As in the Clinton, O.J., and other issues, I'm all in favour of restricting
media coverage of events UNTIL they are resolved.  As seen in numerous
posts in lists such as these and in other press reporting, there's plenty
of time to go back an do an independent review later on.

FAIR article follows "ACTION ALERT"
~~~~~~~~~~~~
A<>E<>R

The only real voyage of discovery consists not in seeking new landscapes
but in having new eyes. -Marcel Proust

----------
: From: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
: To: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
: Subject: [FAIR-L] ACTION ALERT: ABC Airs Abu-Jamal Segment
: Date: Thursday, December 10, 1998 9:19 AM
:
:
:                ------------------------------------------
:                                  FAIR-L
:                     Fairness & Accuracy in Reporting
:                Media analysis, critiques and news reports
:                ------------------------------------------
:
:
:
:     FAIR ACTION ALERT: ABC Airs Abu-Jamal Segment;
: Sam Donaldson calls for inmate's execution, calls supporters ignorant
:
: On August 14, FAIR asked media activists to write to ABC News producer
: Harry Phillips concerning a special segment Phillips was preparing
: about death row inmate Mumia Abu-Jamal.
:
: Noting FAIR's criticism of biased coverage of Abu-Jamal's case over
: the years ( http://www.fair.org/extra/9511/mumia.html ), media activists
: wrote to Phillips to express their hopes for a fair, balanced account
: of his controversial case.
:
: On Wednesday, December 9, ABC aired the segment about Abu-Jamal on
: 20/20. Philadelphia Inquirer reporter Jennifer Weiner interviewed
: ABC's Sam Donaldson about the matter. Her article, appearing in the
: December 9 issue of the paper
: ( http://www.phillynews.com/inquirer/98/Dec/09/lifestyle/JENN09.htm ),
: includes the following quote from Donaldson:
:
:       "Everything that we looked at compellingly points to the fact
: that Mumia shot [Philadelphia police officer Daniel ] Faulkner in cold
: blood . . . and was convicted properly, and was sentenced according to
: the laws of the state of Pennsylvania," Donaldson said in a telephone
: interview yesterday. "And as far as I'm concerned, as long as it's on
: the books, the death sentence has to be carried out."
:
: Donaldson also says: "The people who support his release don't do so
: from a position of knowledge."  He continued: "They either oppose the
: death penalty, or they're campus rebels, or they're African-American
: activists who believe that a black man was railroaded, and will
: continue to believe it, no matter what's presented to them."
:
: To declare that "everything" in the record supports the belief that
: Abu-Jamal is guilty of 1st degree murder sugggests that ABC looked
: only at evidence that fit in with their preconceived conclusion to the
: story--despite efforts by  numerous activists to ensure the network
: was aware of contrary facts.  Donaldson's assertion that
: "African-American activists" will refuse to believe the evidence
: smacks of racism.  And the statement that Abu-Jamal was "properly
: convicted" by a court that demonstrated obvious prejudice indicates a
: dismayingly low standard for capital justice.
:
: FAIR hopes people were able to tune in tonight to the program, and
: will contact ABC directly with your response. (If you miss it, try
: checking ABC's website at http://www.abcnews.com/onair/2020/index.html
: for transcripts or other information.)
:
:     Stay tuned for FAIR's response to the segment.
:
:
: ABC News- 20/20
: 77 W. 66th Street
: New York, NY 10023
:
: Phone   212-456-2020 (20/20)
:              202-222-7090 (Sam Donaldson)
:              212-456-4000 (Roone Arledge, ABC News chair)
:                  212-456-7777 (ABC News general number)
:
:
: Fax       212-456-6533
:
: e-mail    mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] (ABC News)
:              mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] (20/20)
:
: Please send copies of email correspondence (including any responses
: from ABC) to [EMAIL PROTECTED] .
:
: Media contact: Steve Rendall ( mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] )
:
:
:                                ----------
:
:
: Feel free to respond to FAIR([EMAIL PROTECTED]). We can't reply to
: everything, but we will look at each message. We especially appreciate
: documented example of media bias or censorship. All messages to the
: 'FAIR-L' list will be forwarded to the editor of the list.
:
: Also, feel free to spread this message around. Put it on conferences
: where it is appropriate. We depend on word of mouth to get our message
: out, so please let others know about FAIR and this mailing list.
:
: Don't miss a single e-mail from FAIR-L.
: To subscribe to FAIR-L send a "subscribe FAIR-L  enter your full name"
: command to [EMAIL PROTECTED]
:
: The subscriber list is kept confidential, so no need to worry about
: spammers.
:
:
: You may leave the list at any time by sending a "SIGNOFF FAIR-L"
: command to [EMAIL PROTECTED]
:
: Please support FAIR by becoming a member.
: You will receive FAIR's magazine, EXTRA! and its newsletter, EXTRA!
: Update. You can become a member by calling 1-800-847-3993 from 9 to
: 5 Eastern Time (be sure to tell them you got the information
: on-line) or by sending $19 with your name and address to:
:
:                     FAIR/EXTRA! Subscription Service
:                               P.O. Box 170
:                          Congers, NY 10920-9930
:
:
:                                   FAIR
:                              (212) 633-6700
:                           http://www.fair.org/
:                           E-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
:
: list administrators: [EMAIL PROTECTED]

>From FAIR  http://www.fair.org/extra/9511/mumia.html

Extra!, November/December 1995

Witness for the Prosecution:

NPR Slants the Case Against Mumia Abu-Jamal

By Jim Naureckas

After attacks from police groups, National Public Radio quickly backed away
from its plan to air commentaries by Pennsylvania death row inmate Mumia
Abu-Jamal. Jamal, an African-American journalist, received a death sentence
after being convicted in the December 1981 shooting death of Philadelphia
police officer Daniel Faulkner--in a trial marred by gross procedural
errors.

NPR vice president Bill Buzenberg explained the 1994 decision not to air
Jamal by saying it was "not appropriate to use someone in the commentator's
role who is the focal point of a highly polarized and political controversy
without at the same time providing the context of the controversy and
without other voices involved in that controversy."

Many of those who had hoped Jamal's commentaries would give mainstream
audiences a rare insider's view of death row were curious to hear how NPR
would cover Jamal as a news story. The answer: It didn't. From May 1994,
when NPR announced the cancellation of the commentaries, until August 17,
1995, Jamal's scheduled execution date, Nexis transcripts reveal not a word
on NPR about this "highly polarized and political controversy."

As the execution date approached, the case garnered increasing attention,
until NPR's silence became deafening. Only on August 19, after Jamal had
won a stay to complete his appeals, did NPR air a story on his case--a
lengthy feature by NPR's Scott Simon. But rather than dealing with the
controversy in a balanced fashion, Simon skillfully provided a brief for
the prosecution under the pretense of covering both sides.

Disputed Facts

Simon's presentation of the "facts" is carefully constructed to evoke pity
for Faulkner and hatred for Jamal, presenting prosecution claims as
undisputed fact. In a detailed enumeration of Faulkner's wounds, for
example, Simon states that Faulkner was "shot once in the back at close
range"--even though the officer's jacket showed no trace of the gunshot
residue that such a shot would have left.

After describing Faulkner's shooting, Simon reveals that Faulkner also shot
Jamal--with the obvious implication that the officer fired in self-defense.
Jamal's lawyers' contention that Faulkner fired the first shot that night
is never mentioned, nor does Simon note that the prosecution's version of
how Jamal was shot does not match the path the bullet took through his
body.

Faulkner was shot after he pulled over William Cook, Jamal's brother, on a
traffic violation. Simon notes that there was "some sort of struggle"
between Faulkner and Cook; he doesn't mention that this struggle, according
to one witness, amounted to Faulkner beating Cook in the head with his
flashlight.

False Witnesses

In outlining the evidence against Jamal--ostensibly for the purpose of
explaining why Jamal needed a good lawyer--Simon says: "Three eyewitnesses
in different locations who did not know each other came forward and
identified Mumia Abu-Jamal was the man they had seen at the shooting."

In fact, only two eyewitnesses--out of at least 10 people at the
scene--positively identified Jamal as the shooter. Simon appears to be
hiding behind the phrase "seen at the shooting"--his third witness actually
initially identified Jamal as being the driver of the pulled-over car, not
as the shooter.

Of two witnesses who identified Jamal, whose veracity Simon has implicitly
vouched for, one was a prostitute whose story progressively changed after
repeated arrests by police. The other witness was a convicted arsonist on
probation whose story also changed to match the police version.

Simon does note later that "over the years," people have come forward to
say they saw the shooter flee the scene--which would clear Jamal, since he
collapsed to the pavement after being shot by Faulkner. In fact, police
inquiries immediately after the shooting turned up witnesses who said they
saw someone fleeing the scene.

Simon also notes that a gun registered to Jamal was found at the scene of
the shooting. But he fails to mention that the police never performed
elementary tests to determine whether the gun had been fired, or if Jamal
was the one who fired it.

Simon does consider the defense's point that the coroner identified the
fatal bullet as coming from a .44 caliber gun, whereas Jamal's gun was a
.38. He then brings on Philadelphia Inquirer reporter Mark Kaufman to rebut
the defense, who says that the coroner later said that the bullet might
have come from a .38 after all--"so I think that there's a lot less there
than meets the eye." Note the reversal here of the burden of proof--the
question Simon's source addresses is not whether the prosecution proved
that the bullet came from Jamal's gun, but whether the defense proved that
it did not come from his gun.

The Unmentioned Confession

Simon also interviews Police Officer Gary Bell, who recounts Jamal's
supposed hospital-bed confession: "I shot the motherfucker, I hope he
dies!" This story has been so thoroughly discredited that even Jamal's
staunchest opponents, such as Philadelphia District Attorney Lynne Abraham,
no longer point to it as an indication of guilt (New York Times, 8/13/95).
Simon therefore has to make a show of challenging Bell's account.

Several minutes after airing Bell's gripping account, Simon asks him why he
waited more than two months to report this vital evidence. Bell responds
that he had been assigned with other officers to look after the widow. "Our
job, at that point, was to stay with her 24 hours a day to take care of
anything--any of her needs that she had.... I don't know if I was just
preoccupied with that, or the whole situation, but I didn't--it didn't dawn
on me to call right away to talk to anybody about it."

A moving story, certainly--but Simon might have followed up by asking Bell
why, in his report to police a week after the shooting, he inexplicably
made no reference to the confession. Or why the officer who was
specifically assigned to guard Jamal, Gary Wakshul, filed a report
immediately afterward that stated that "the negro male made no statements."


Instead, Simon cuts to prosecutor Joseph McGill, who claims that a security
guard "who had no connection with police" had also heard the confession. In
fact, the security guard, Patricia Durham, did know Faulkner, sometimes had
coffee with him, and acknowledged crying when he died. Simon also seems to
endorse McGill's claim that Durham had "reported [the confession] within 24
hours." Durham actually said she had written a handwritten note about the
event within 24 hours--a note that was never produced. Other than this
purported document, she never mentioned the "confession" until after Bell
had.

Silence Equals Guilt

In concluding his report, Simon states, "Mr. Jamal has never said in any
courtroom, article, or interview, what he did, saw or heard the night of
the killing for which he's been convicted." He then plays tape of
Faulkner's widow, Maureen Faulkner, who declares:

I'm challenging him to get up on the stand and tell what happened on
December 9, 1981. He is the only one who has not been heard in fourteen
years. What is Mumia Abu-Jamal afraid of? If he was there at the scene of
the crime, and he did not commit the crime, why doesn't he get up and tell
who did it?

No one can deny the frustration and grief felt by the widow of a police
officer cut down at the age of 25. But why does Simon choose to end his
report by implying that a defendant who exercises his Fifth Amendment
rights is guilty? It is standard practice that defendants do not make
public statements about their cases, since anything they say, as the
Miranda formula famously warns, can be used against them in a court of law.


Following the airing of this report, at least one letter was sent detailing
NPR's omissions and errors. Simon chose not to acknowledge this on the air,
but instead remarked a week later (NPR 8/26/95) that the response of his
audience could best be summarized in one letter. He then read the
listener's letter, which accurately recapitulated the brief for the
prosecution that Simon had presented:

Let me get this straight: It was his registered handgun; he was identified
by three separate witnesses; he was shot by his own purported victim; he
raved about his accomplishment in the hospital; he refuses to discuss his
alleged innocence.

The letter-writer can't help but conclude: "Why the heck are we discussing
this?" Indeed, no other reasonable conclusion is available from the
selective evidence and distortions presented by NPR.

------------------------------------------------------------------------

Greg Bates contributed to this article. Bates is the co-founder of Common
Courage Press, which published Race for Justice: Mumia Abu-Jamal's Fight
Against the Death Penalty.

DECLARATION & DISCLAIMER
==========
CTRL is a discussion and informational exchange list. Proselyzting propagandic
screeds are not allowed. Substance�not soapboxing!  These are sordid matters
and 'conspiracy theory', with its many half-truths, misdirections and outright
frauds is used politically  by different groups with major and minor effects
spread throughout the spectrum of time and thought. That being said, CTRL
gives no endorsement to the validity of posts, and always suggests to readers;
be wary of what you read. CTRL gives no credeence to Holocaust denial and
nazi's need not apply.

Let us please be civil and as always, Caveat Lector.

========================================================================
To subscribe to Conspiracy Theory Research List[CTRL] send email:
SUBSCRIBE CTRL [to:] [EMAIL PROTECTED]

To UNsubscribe to Conspiracy Theory Research List[CTRL] send email:
SIGNOFF CTRL [to:] [EMAIL PROTECTED]

Om

Reply via email to