>From LinguaFranca.CoM

GOING PUBLIC

What makes a public intellectual? The answer is hazy. Clearly Henry Louis
Gates Jr. is one: He goes on TV and writes for The New Yorker. But Noam
Chomsky is one, too, and he does neither. Must the intellectual deal with
public issues, as William Julius Wilson does, or may he or she simply take
academic subjects to the public, � la Stephen Hawking? Are the fame of
Camille Paglia and the influence of Milton Friedman really the same thing?

The problem with the term�and any term that embraces both Umberto Eco and
Arianna Huffington can safely be said to have a problem�is that it has so
many contradictory connotations. "Public" can refer to the nation or the
neighborhood, the illiterate hordes or the readership of The New York
Review of Books. One public intellectual may wish to bestow the ideas of
the scholars on the masses, another to force the ideas of the masses on the
scholars.

And now, to add to the confusion, Florida Atlantic University in Boca Raton
is turning the public intellectual into an academic degree. Beginning this
fall, bright, adventurous men and women with the conviction that the social
order would profit from their input may pursue a Ph.D. in FAU�s Public
Intellectuals Program�and for only $8,700 a year ($2,500 for Florida
residents).

A Ph.D. in being a public intellectual? It sounds strange. After all, the
doctorate traditionally signals one�s expertise in a specific field of
research. But FAU is up to something different: Its degree is defined in
terms of the recipient�s ambitions, not his or her knowledge. Still, the
standard features of a graduate program are in place. In the awkward prose
of university administration, the course catalog describes an
interdisciplinary curriculum "beyond the margins of purely discipline-based
research"; it includes areas of concentration such as "Race and Ethnic
Conflict," "Media and Popular Culture," "Public Policy and the Concept of
the Public," and "Creative Strategies" (which the catalog defines as
tactics for "catching the imagination of people, if not the conscience of
cultures"). The degree requirements include two written qualifying exams
and a dissertation, the latter supervised by a multidisciplinary committee
drawn from FAU�s forty-five-member arts and letters faculty (who, truth be
told, are hardly household names). Don�t expect to leave Boca Raton in less
than four years.

A Ph.D. in being a public intellectual? Florida Atlantic University�s new
program may become the breeding ground for future Umberto Ecos and Arianna
Huffingtons.

The person in charge of educating public intellectuals is Teresa Brennan, a
Cambridge-educated social theorist, whose abstruse-sounding books include
History After Lacan and The Interpretation of the Flesh: Freud and
Femininity�works, she insists, that actually reflect "a real unfashionable
commitment to clarity." Brennan, a spectacularly well-networked (though not
publicly famous) scholar, who trained in psychoanalysis and worked in
politics before she turned to scholarship, didn�t begin her own graduate
studies till she was in her mid-thirties. As she worked on her degree,
Brennan says, she met people who were drifting reluctantly into
professional academia�one of her fellow students had wanted to work for the
United Nations but "ended up as an assistant professor somewhere."

What such people needed, she thought, was a different kind of graduate
program. By a lucky coincidence, that was what FAU needed, too, according
to Dorothy Stetson, the school�s humanities chair. In 1991, now-deceased
local businessman Charles Schmidt had donated $10 million to support a
humanities grad school at Florida Atlantic, in honor of his late wife,
Dorothy. But as a state institution, Stetson says, FAU had to find
something that wouldn�t compete with existing doctoral programs at other
state schools. Enter Brennan, who left a visiting post at Cornell to become
the first Schmidt Distinguished Professor of Humanities.

Already, Brennan has drawn a raft of name-brand thinkers as visiting
faculty or guest lecturers, including Cornell intellectual historian Susan
Buck-Morss, Harvard philosopher K. Anthony Appiah, Harvard theologian
Cornel West, and historian and well-known critic of the academy Russell
Jacoby ("It�s a natural for me," says Jacoby, author of The Last
Intellectuals). The curriculum advisory board includes Harvard feminist
Alice Jardine and the peripatetic Stanley Fish, who will also pop in and
teach. Nonacademic board members include the writer and AIDS activist
Jeffrey Escoffier, the labor lawyer Thomas Geoghegan, and the anti-biotech
crusader Jeremy Rifkin.

Having a Ph.D. in chemistry may make you a chemist, but does having a Ph.D.
in public intellectualism make you a public intellectual? Maybe not. But
the goal of the program is not to accredit a new generation of George
Will�style pundits; rather, Brennan says, it aims to train intellectually
oriented people to go out into public life. The idea, she says, is in part
to give students support from people who are already out in the world,
through instruction, mentoring, and hands-on practicum courses (a seminar
in how to start an environmental recycling business, for example). She
envisions graduates becoming journalists, documentary filmmakers, museum
directors, clergy, community organizers, and labor organizers, among other
things. Fish goes so far as to imagine "a public intellectual working in a
brokerage firm."

Beyond elevated notions of service and progress, there is another good
reason for sending Ph.D.�s out into public life: It may help get rid of
them.

Though the first batch of students�expected to number about twenty�has yet
to be chosen, Brennan hopes it will include both people "who have been
involved in some public-intellectual profession" and "people fresh from
their first degrees, who...want to have an impact outside the academy."

"It�s important to stress here that this is not an anti-intellectual
program," Brennan says. Despite its extra-academic aims, the program
intends to be heavy on scholarship and theory. "The emphasis, as I read the
literature, is on extraordinarily advanced work," boasts Fish. "Teresa has
invited people whose work is regarded as the most advanced and difficult."

Which is not to say that the curriculum doesn�t threaten to veer into
squidginess here and there. Anti-genital-mutilation activist Nawal El
Saadawi, for instance, will offer a course this fall called Creativity and
Dissidence, which the catalog promises "will be built on continuous open
and free discussion, on our experiences of life, and on how different
forces stifle our creative powers."

But beyond elevated notions of service and progress, there is another good
reason for sending Ph.D.�s out into public life: It may help get rid of
them. With academic employment prospects in the humanities resembling
dinner prospects during the great potato famine, even some skeptics are
willing to give Florida Atlantic�s plans the benefit of the doubt. At best,
FAU might draw doctoral candidates away from glutted disciplinary programs
elsewhere; even if it doesn�t, it could provide other schools with a
blueprint for workfare for budding scholars. Pointing Ph.D.�s toward the
larger world may or may not help the world, but at least it will give them
somewhere to go.

TOM SCOCCA

Return to Home Page
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Copyright � 1999 Lingua Franca, Inc. All rights reserved.




~~~~~~~~~~~~
A<>E<>R

The only real voyage of discovery consists not in seeking
new landscapes but in having new eyes. -Marcel Proust
+ + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + +
Every great advance in natural knowledge has involved
the absolute rejection of authority. -Thomas Huxley
+ + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + +
Forwarded as information only; no endorsement to be presumed
+ + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + +
In accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. section 107, this material
is distributed without charge or profit to those who have
expressed a prior interest in receiving this type of information
for non-profit research and educational purposes only.



Reply via email to