-Caveat Lector-

from:
http://www.sfbg.com/News/33/24/Features/foi1.html
<A HREF="http://www.sfbg.com/News/33/24/Features/foi1.html">SFBG News: March
17, 1999: Freedom of Informati </A>
-----
March 17, 1999 sfbg.com

FOI:
The closed-door king
Willie Brown's reign of secrecy and the case for a sunshine initiative.
By Randall Lyman

Nothing in writing
Willie Brown keeps very few records of anything -- so the public can't
find out what he's up to.
By Savannah Blackwell

FOI '99 Task Force

Editor and publisher: Bruce B. Brugmann

Project editor: Tamara Thompson

Reporters: Heather Abel, Savannah Blackwell, Lucia Hwang, Randall Lyman,
Bob Porterfield, Tim Redmond, Gabriel Roth, Angela Rowen, A. Clay
Thompson, Tali Woodward

Researchers: Debbie Finney, Jeff St. John

The closed-door king
Willie Brown's reign of secrecy and the case for a sunshine initiative.
Randall Lyman

Item: For months last year, the San Francisco City Attorney's Office
negotiated in secret with Tele-Communications Inc. (TCI) on the effect
its merger with AT&T would have on San Francisco's cable TV franchise.
The merger offered the city its second opportunity in three years to
renegotiate the contract for what may be the worst cable TV service in
the state. Instead, the City Attorney's Office presented the Board of
Supervisors with a take-it-or-leave-it giveaway settlement that let TCI
off the hook for long-promised service improvements -- and the public
had no idea what position the city took or what else went on during the
backroom negotiations. The key decisions were, and remain, completely
secret.

So the taxpayers have no way of knowing what the city gave away.

Item: In February 1999, the Committee to Stop the Giveaway filed a
complaint with the Sunshine Ordinance Task Force, charging that the
Department of Elections refused to release public records and attempted
to cover up evidence that it committed election fraud in connection with
the June 1997 vote authorizing construction of a proposed 49ers
stadium-mall complex. But the task force had a problem: the City
Attorney's Office, which would normally assist the task force in
investigating such a complaint, had to recuse itself because it was
charged in the complaint with aiding the DOE in its cover-up -- and
there was no procedure for the task force to hire an independent
counsel.

Item: Last summer Mayor Willie Brown, who for years represented Pacific
Gas and Electric Co. as a private attorney, cut a backroom deal with the
utility that prevented the city from buying the Hunters Point power
plant and establishing a public-power beachhead in the city. The deal
infuriated Hunters Point activists, cost the city millions, and
perpetuated PG&E's illegal monopoly and the Raker Act scandal.

When we asked for the records of the negotiations, Brown told us no such
documents existed.

Item: In 1997 the Mayor's Fiscal Advisory Committee -- an influential
group of downtown corporate leaders that advises the mayor on fiscal
policy -- renamed itself the Municipal Fiscal Advisory Committee to the
Mayor in an effort to exempt itself from the Sunshine Ordinance's
open-meeting requirements. MFAC members "don't work for the Mayor's
Office, so they aren't burdened with all that Sunshine nonsense," Mayor
Brown said at the time.

THERE IS A PATTERN here, and it's not pretty.

Six years after the passage of San Francisco's landmark open meetings
and public records law -- the Sunshine Ordinance -- official secrecy is
alive and well at city hall.

In his reign of secrecy Mayor Brown has given away more city money in
more backroom deals -- the TCI-AT&T cable franchise, the 49ers
stadium-mall, the Presidio privatization, the Mission Bay development,
and the list goes on -- than any administration since World War II,
awarding tens of millions of dollars' worth of contracts without
competitive bidding or public review.

These deals are changing the face of San Francisco -- and yet residents
are usually given so little information, and so little input, that it's
impossible to figure out what's going on.

"Not in my lifetime or in my studies of the history of San Francisco's
mayors have I ever heard of something like this," former sup. Angela
Alioto told us, "short of Mayor McCarthy, and that was back in 1909, and
in the end a lot of people ended up in San Quentin."

Since 1993 the Sunshine Ordinance has done a lot to ensure that the
city's business is conducted in the open, but officials from Mayor Brown
and his department heads on down have found a variety of ways to avoid
the ordinance's requirements.

That's why a new voter initiative is being proposed that would require
city hall to conduct even more of its business in public view and would
put San Francisco back in the forefront of advocacy for open government.
The Sunshine Initiative, drafted by the grassroots coalition San
Franciscans for Sunshine (SFS), would amend the Sunshine Ordinance to
fix weaknesses and plug loopholes that enable the city's elected
officials, departments, commissions, and other agencies to skirt the
law's intent.

Terry Francke, general counsel of the California First Amendment
Coalition (CFAC) and author of the Sunshine Ordinance, told the Bay
Guardian that the time is ripe for a major reform of the law. "The
ordinance has had a good trial run," he said. "Those who care about
sunshine can tell what works and what doesn't. And an initiative appears
necessary because there's no longer the will among the supervisors to
follow through with the fine tuning."

SFS intends to place the initiative on the November ballot through a
petition campaign it expects to launch in April or May.

"At the same time we're developing the language of the initiative, we
are also building a campaign structure," SFS cochair Ross Mirkarimi
said. "In the near future we expect to hire a campaign staff person, and
we'll be shopping the initiative language around to like-minded
advocates so they're all on board and included in the coalition effort."


SFS is a coalition of community activists from neighborhood,
environmental, and good-government organizations. Its members include
former supervisor Angela Alioto and representatives from the California
First Amendment Coalition, the Bay Guardian, San Francisco Tomorrow, the
Sierra Club, the Coalition for San Francisco Neighborhoods, the Greater
West Portal Neighborhood Association, San Franciscans for Public Power,
Religious Witness with Homeless People, the Harvey Milk
Lesbian/Gay/Bisexual/Transgender Democratic Club, and the northern
California chapter of the Society of Professional Journalists, which
sponsored the city's Sunshine Ordinance.

"There have been a lot of ideas from a lot of different people," said
San Francisco lawyer Stephen Leblanc, a member of ACT UP/Golden Gate and
one of the main drafters of the initiative, along with Bay Guardian
attorney Tom Burke.

Since September the Sunshine Ordinance Task Force, which oversees
implementation and enforcement of the law, has been holding hearings on
the proposed amendments to ensure that the initiative addresses as many
problems and loopholes in the ordinance as possible.

"The hearings have been very helpful because the Sunshine Ordinance Task
Force is the body that's directly on the firing line, that has to deal
with the ordinance as it is," said Rick Knee, an SFS steering committee
member who has represented the coalition at the task force hearings.
"They know its strengths and weaknesses, so the hearings help, because
the task force knows exactly what needs to be fixed in the ordinance."

The initiative would take the Sunshine Ordinance out of the city's
Administrative Code and place it in the City Charter, where it could
only be amended by a two-thirds majority of voters -- a shield against
tampering by the lawmakers it holds accountable: the mayor and the
supervisors.

The Sunshine Initiative focuses on seven key areas: enforcement,
sole-source contracts, the city attorney's conflict of interest, public
records, records of meetings, nongovernmental organizations, and the
city's dealings with agencies not covered by the Sunshine Ordinance.

Here are some of the key problems, and the ways the initiative would
address them:

* There's no effective enforcement of the existing sunshine law. Since
August 1998 the Coalition on Homelessness has been trying to obtain
documents that would reveal how the city developed its new policies on
police handling of public drunkenness, policies the coalition has
criticized as tantamount to the criminalization of homelessness.
However, various city departments have refused to release the requested
documents, describing them as part of the deliberative process and
therefore exempt from disclosure. In other words, the Sunshine
Ordinance, which was drafted precisely to allow public input into the
development of policy, was twisted to prevent that input and to withhold
information even after the questioned policies were implemented.

In February the coalition formally complained to the Sunshine Ordinance
Task Force, which is scheduled to hold a hearing on the complaint March
23.

But even if the task force finds that the city withheld the documents
unlawfully, it has no authority to order the city to release them to the
Coalition on Homelessness. If the city still refuses to turn them over
after the hearing, the coalition will have no recourse except to sue the
city for their release -- and a lawsuit is a difficult, time-consuming,
and expensive process.

In many cases people seeking records can't afford legal counsel -- so
they simply give up, and the documents remain secret.

Like the state's open government laws -- the Brown Act and the
California Public Records Act -- the Sunshine Ordinance contains no
provisions compelling officials to actually obey the law.

Changing that is a top priority for the initiative's backers. "The issue
we're grappling with most in drafting the initiative is that under the
Sunshine Ordinance there is currently no real right of appeal for a
citizen complaining about a violation of the ordinance," SFS's Leblanc
said. "We want a more definitive appeals process so that a citizen can
get an order from some other authority."

In a recent statewide survey on freedom of information issues (see
"Sunshine Support," page 17), 78 percent of the respondents favored some
kind of civil or criminal penalties against officials who improperly
deny a public records request; 54 percent "strongly favored" such
penalties. And 77 percent favored making the government pay attorneys'
fees if a person is forced to sue.

In Sacramento, at least, there are efforts by legislators to strengthen
enforcement of the state's public records law. State Senator Byron
Sher's much awaited S.B. 48 would enable a citizen to appeal directly to
the state attorney general for a speedy decision on whether an agency
violated the CPRA (see "The State of Access," page 28).

However, while S.B. 48 would provide a remedy in cases where both the
Sunshine Ordinance and the CPRA have been violated, key portions of the
ordinance extend beyond the provisions of the CPRA and, consequently,
beyond the remedies available through S.B. 48.

The Sunshine Initiative would not give the sunshine task force the
authority to impose fines or other sanctions, but it would authorize a
court to fine an agency that violates the ordinance. And it does include
other sticks and carrots to ensure that city officials obey the law. It
would, for example, define willful violation of the ordinance as
official misconduct and authorize the city Ethics Commission to
investigate such cases.

"Any person found guilty of official misconduct by the Ethics Commission
shall forfeit his or her office and shall be forever after disbarred and
disqualified from being elected, appointed or employed" by the city, the
initiative states.

It would also require all department heads and elected officials to sign
an annual affidavit or declaration that they have read the Sunshine
Ordinance and received training on it provided by the city attorney and
the task force. The affidavit would be a public record.

The initiative would allocate to the task force the staff time and
resources it needs to function as an effective open-government watchdog,
and it could also raise the status of the task force to that of a
commission. The initiative is also expected to transfer responsibility
for administering the task force from the Mayor's Office to the Board of
Supervisors.

* Millions of dollars are going to secret sole-source contracts. Rarely
in San Francisco history have so few given away so much to so many.

The city handed its lucrative cable television franchise from Viacom to
TCI after secret negotiations and without the benefit of a single public
hearing (see "Cable Cover-Up?," 4/24/96), and now, in the wake of the
TCI-AT&T merger, it's again handing off the franchise without public
hearings or input. Mayor Brown has also made the Treasure Island
Redevelopment Authority, which is responsible for awarding big-money
contracts to develop the former navy base, accountable only to him. An
underground parking garage is already under construction in Golden Gate
Park -- apparently on the mayor's orders, without any public meetings or
hearings, and without a single document authorizing work to begin or
describing the scope of the work (see "Stealth Garage," 3/3/99).

In many cases such as these the contracts are negotiated secretly with
single bidders. There are no public-policy reasons to keep the city's
negotiating stance secret in these deals -- and plenty of reasons not
to.

"In giving out contracts without competitive bidding, not only do you
ignore that the City Charter mandates competitive bidding, but as a
result you also violate the Sunshine Ordinance, because no one knows
anything about who's getting the contracts or about the legitimacy of
their offers," Alioto noted.

Even when a contract is put out to bid, the city often negotiates the
contract behind closed doors, with ruinous results. A prime example is
the contract between the Department of Public Works and New York-based
street furniture maker Adshel, which gives Adshel an exclusive 20-year,
multimillion-dollar contract to supply 1,000 pedestal-mounted news racks
that will replace virtually all freestanding racks in the city.

The contract, which allows Adshel to earn revenue by selling
illuminated, billboard-size ads on the backs of nearly half the "ped
mounts," was negotiated without any input from publishers, many of whom
could lose circulation and consequently be driven out of business by the
contract (see On Guard, 4/1/98). The ordinance also gives nearly
unfettered decision-making powers to the director of the DPW,
effectively giving control of sidewalk newspaper distribution to the
mayor, who appoints the director. Ten newspapers have challenged the
constitutionality of the ordinance in two separate federal lawsuits (see
On Guard, 1/13/99 and 2/10/99).

Secrecy and exclusion have been city hall's method for pushing through
the news-rack ordinance and the Adshel contract. In January 1997 Mayor
Brown called the publishers of several newspapers into his office
(including the Chronicle, the Examiner, the Bay Guardian, and the SF
Weekly) and promised to give them 30 days to review a draft of a
proposed news-rack ordinance before it was introduced at the board. The
review never happened and publishers were only informed afterward that
the ordinance had been introduced by then-board president Barbara
Kaufman.

In a similar move in December 1998, Kaufman attempted to sneak through
another ordinance, this time to authorize the Adshel contract, even
though there had been no public review of the contract at all (see On
Guard, 12/16/98). The DPW refused to release any draft contracts or
documents pertaining to the negotiations, saying that "the public
interest in nondisclosure outweighs the public interest in disclosure."

Consequently, there is no way to know what position the city took or
what concessions it made in negotiating the deal.

The DPW had also infuriated publishers last August by stacking a new
News Rack Advisory Committee with supporters of the DPW-Adshel deal and
appointing no representatives from local newspapers with the greatest
news-rack circulation, including gay/lesbian, community, and
neighborhood publications.

Instead of consulting publishers, the city hired an outside attorney for
advice, Stanford professor and law school dean Kathleen Sullivan, who so
far has been paid $5,000 for her work. The Bay Guardian requested
documents describing her work on the ordinance; the DPW sent us copies
of her invoices but deleted that information from them.

On the rare occasions when the city released information about a deal
while negotiations were still in progress -- for example, those with
Olympia and York on Yerba Buena Gardens and Catellus Corp. on Mission
Bay -- the input from neighborhood groups and activists enabled the city
to negotiate a better deal, one that benefited local communities rather
than an out-of-town developer.

The Sunshine Initiative includes language approved by the task force
last year that would close loopholes in the Sunshine Ordinance
pertaining to city contracts, bids, and proposals. It would require
disclosure of documents related to city leases or permits with a value
of $500,000 or more and a term of one year of more, as well as documents
related to franchise agreements, such as TCI's cable contract. It would
require the city to make public any draft contracts or other documents
exchanged between the city and a sole-source contractor with which it is
negotiating, and if no documents are exchanged, it would require the
city's negotiators to prepare weekly summaries of the parties'
positions.

The initiative would require that new sole-source contracts be released
to the public 30 days before they are approved or signed. It would also
require each city department to submit a report to the Board of
Supervisors at the end of each fiscal year, listing all sole-source
contracts entered into during that year.

For contracts awarded through competitive bidding, the initiative would
require the city to release the bid scoring sheets as well as the names
of the evaluators and their individual ratings and comments. The need
for public access to scoring sheets became clear in 1996, after the Bay
Guardian learned of improprieties in the bidding process for a contract
to study the possible municipalization of PG&E's power system. After
fighting to obtain access to the scoring sheets, the Bay Guardian found
that city officials involved in evaluating the contract bids had given a
highly qualified firm an inappropriately low score. The evidence showed
the officials had manipulated the process to reject the firm, which was
sympathetic to public power, and hire a company with ties to PG&E
instead (see "PG&E Takes a Hit," 12/13/95).

* The Sunshine Ordinance Task Force has no access to independent legal
counsel. The sunshine task force has to rely on the city attorney for
legal advice. But the city attorney has an inherent conflict of interest
when investigating complaints that municipal officials or agencies have
violated the Sunshine Ordinance.

That's because the City Attorney's Office, by definition, represents
city agencies, in effect acting as their legal defense and consulting
firm.

Since the city and its various departments are the only entities that
can potentially violate the ordinance, the City Attorney's Office finds
itself in the conflicting position of investigating its own clients.

So when the City Attorney's Office gives the sunshine task force legal
help in its investigation of a city agency's alleged violation, it in
principle is going against one of its other clients. Under state bar
rules, no private law firm would be allowed to do this.

The city attorney has hindered the task force from releasing documents
it intended to make public: in January the City Attorney's Office
unexpectedly told the task force it could not immediately release a
draft of its own recommendations for amending the Sunshine Ordinance,
arrived at through public hearings, because the recommendations
constituted a confidential "attorney-client work product."

Occasionally the city attorney is named in a complaint, potentially
placing the office in the position of both investigating and defending
itself. This situation occurred last month, when the Committee to Stop
the Giveaway filed a complaint against both the Department of Elections
and the city attorney. The complaint alleged that the DOE, relying on
the city attorney's advice, illegally withheld documents that would show
how the DOE defrauded voters in connection with the June 1997 elections,
when voters narrowly approved two ballot measures authorizing
construction of the 49ers stadium-mall complex. The City Attorney's
Office had to recuse itself from the investigation, which ended with DOE
director Naomi Nishioka finally agreeing to the task force's request to
continue looking for requested documents that a hearing revealed the DOE
possessed, despite its earlier claims.

To get around this inherent problem, the Sunshine Initiative would
enable the task force to hire outside counsel on a temporary, limited
basis in the event it determines that the City Attorney's Office has a
conflict of interest.

"When there is no conflict, the task force would continue to rely on the
advice of the deputy city attorney," attorney Burke, one of the
principal drafters of the amendments, said. "This solves the problem
with the conflict of interest while putting a cap on concerns that the
initiative is going to cost a lot of money."

* There's no way to keep track of the city's records -- and sometimes
they disappear. When Mayor Art Agnos left office in 1991, his staff
carted away almost all of his mayoral records, leaving the
administration of incoming mayor Frank Jordan with precious little
information to guide it. Agnos, however, was only doing what his
predecessor, Dianne Feinstein, had done to him.

"I had to fish out of a trash can the file on [Mayor George] Moscone's
and Harvey Milk's funeral," a former Agnos staffer told the Bay
Guardian.

Following tradition, Jordan trashed all his mayoral files before Brown
took office. Brown may well do the same. The mayor's files -- documents
that ought to be public records -- have no formal legal protection.

That's just one of the many problems with the way the city tracks (or,
more often, fails to track) its own records. There is no central
inventory. Records are duplicated, stored in obscure places, and
sometimes lost.

That's a civic disaster: Public records are the best, and sometimes
only, way for citizens to learn what happened at a board or commission
meeting, especially if it was long ago. Records also may provide the
only source of detailed information about city policies and programs.

Because of the importance and the wide range of problems associated with
public records, most of the SFS amendments address public-records
issues.

The keystone amendment would require that each city agency and
department compile an index of the records it keeps. The master index,
to be maintained by the city administrator, would not list individual
records but rather types of records, serving as a guide to where various
types of records are located. The index would also be maintained by the
Sunshine Ordinance Task Force.

A master index would also offer two side benefits: it would reveal
needless and costly duplication in the collection and storage of
information, and it could be the basis for a city publication listing
available records (which could be sold to recoup the costs of producing
it).

The Sunshine Initiative would also save citizens money directly by
eliminating current charges for redacting certain information from
documents. State law does not authorize such a fee; San Francisco law
does. The initiative would allow the city to charge citizens only the
direct cost of photocopying records and forbid it from charging for
labor costs, as it does now.

In the statewide FOI survey, 78 percent of the respondents said the
government should not be allowed to charge more than direct duplication
costs for records.

An equal number said the government should make its budgets and other
public records available electronically, so citizens can access them
from home computers. The Sunshine Initiative sets minimum standards for
departmental posting of agendas, minutes, and other public records on
the city's official Web site (www.ci.sf.ca.gov).

Another important provision of the Sunshine Initiative would make all
records of the mayor and department heads public property -- ensuring
that neither Mayor Brown, his successors, nor their department head
appointees can take their official records with them when they leave
office.

* Nonprofit organizations that get big city contracts operate with
little or no sunshine. When ACT UP/Golden Gate and other AIDS activists
tried last year to find out whether money received by the San Francisco
AIDS Foundation was in fact being used to benefit patients, rather than
to cover salaries and administrative costs, they hit a brick wall.
Foundation representatives said information about grants and donors was
confidential.

The AIDS Foundation receives more than $1 million in city funds each
year, but the exact amount remains a secret (see "Secret Agencies,"
1/14/98, and "Follow Your Money," in the Bay Guardian's 1997 Freedom of
Information issue, 3/12/97).

That's just one example of the wide range of private nonprofits that
essentially operate as arms of the city. In an era when more and more
public services are privatized, those nonprofits are using taxpayer
money to provide services once offered by local government -- and
they're not subject to the sunshine laws.

The activists got some relief from a bill sponsored by Sup. Tom Ammiano
and passed by the board June 1, 1998. Ammiano worked for a year with a
task force of AIDS activists, nonprofit representatives, and others to
hammer out legislation that would have mandated greater openness while
still preserving confidential donor information -- only to have the bill
gutted in a single Finance Committee meeting by Sup. Kaufman (see
"Charity Case," 6/3/98).

Acting at the behest of political consultant Robert Barnes, who
represented several nonprofits on the task force that opposed the
legislation, Kaufman proposed several amendments that seriously weakened
the bill and threatened to kill the bill in committee if the amendments
were not adopted.

In the original version of the legislation, nonprofits receiving more
than $100,000 in city funds would have been subject to the
greater-openness requirements. Kaufman changed the threshold to $250,000
-- eliminating more than 70 percent of the agencies the law was intended
to cover.

Kaufman also removed a provision for independent dispute resolution by
the Sunshine Ordinance Task Force and added language making a city
agency that contracts with a nonprofit the arbiter of its own disputes
-- ruling out any independent review process.

This watered-down version of the ordinance was passed by the board last
year. The Sunshine Initiative is expected to beef up the ordinance by
restoring some of the deleted and diluted provisions and requiring that
any records "made available to the governing board" of a nonprofit
receiving city funds "be likewise available to the public."

* City partnerships with state and federal agencies aren't covered by
sunshine laws. When activists began pushing the privatized Presidio
Trust to open the Presidio's Wherry Housing to homeless people in 1996,
the trust insisted that the housing units were too run-down and that the
park should not be used for private housing anyway. In August 1998,
however, the Bay Guardian learned that the trust's executive director,
James Meadows, had cut a deal with several colleges and universities
(including UCSF, San Francisco State University, Golden Gate University,
and City College of San Francisco) to lease up to 100 Wherry units to
students at market rates -- despite the fact that voters had passed
Proposition L, urging the Presidio Trust to turn the buildings into
housing for the homeless (see "No Quarter," 9/2/98).

That deal was negotiated entirely in secret, with no public input or
oversight.

The city often gets involved in partnerships with federal and state
agencies, such as the Presidio Trust, that consider themselves exempt
from -- or simply refuse to obey -- state public-records and
open-meetings laws, leaving San Franciscans with no input into, or even
prior information about, policies that often have a significant impact
on the city.

Though the Sunshine Initiative can't force federal and state agencies to
follow local laws, it would make it "the policy of the City and County
of San Francisco to ensure opportunities for informed civic
participation embodied in this Ordinance to all local, state, regional
and federal agencies and institutions with which it maintains continuing
legal and political relationships."

City officials and representatives, it states, "shall continually,
consistently and assertively work to seek commitments to enact open
meetings, public information and citizen comment policies by these
agencies and institutions," including the Presidio Trust, the San
Francisco Unified School District, the San Francisco Housing Authority,
the Treasure Island Development Authority, and the San Francisco
Redevelopment Authority.

City representatives would be required to file copies of all written
communications to and from these agencies with the clerk of the Board of
Supervisors, and "to the extent not prohibited by law, any meeting of
the governing body of any such agency and institution at which City
officers, agents or representatives are present in their official
capacities shall be open to the public."

* Agendas and minutes are still not easily accessible. Although the
Board of Supervisors, its committees, and some city agencies now provide
timely and detailed agendas and minutes of their meetings, many agencies
still do not, or do not make them easily accessible to the public.

The Sunshine Initiative would require that all boards and commissions
named in the City Charter record each regular and special meeting on
video- or audiotape and make the tapes accessible as public records,
reviewable on tape players provided by the city.

It would also require all boards and commissions to keep detailed
minutes of their meetings, including such important information as the
roll call vote on each item considered and the amount of time spent in
closed session.
Nothing to hide


The Sunshine Ordinance was originally just one element of a six-part
"good-government package" sponsored by then-supervisor Roberta
Achtenberg.

It was the only one of the sextuplets to survive. Two that died would
have required supervisors appointed by the mayor to fill a board
vacancy, and any supervisor ascending to the mayor's office (as
Feinstein did after Moscone's 1978 assassination) to be confirmed by
voters after a few months. A third fatality was a bill that would have
required candidates and political committees to file copies of their
campaign statements on computer diskette.

Two other reforms were resurrected later, but in modified form. One
would have allowed the Board of Supervisors to improve its public
accessibility by holding meetings in the city's neighborhoods. Since
last year Sup. Leland Yee has been spearheading a similar effort. The
fifth reform would have required new bills to be available for public
review at least 30 days before the full board could take any action. The
board's current 30-day rule, introduced in 1995 by Kaufman, then board
president, differs in that it leaves imposition of the review period up
to the discretion of the board president -- discretion that can be
abused to suit the president's political agenda, as Kaufman had done on
numerous occasions (see On Guard, 12/23/98).

That leaves the Sunshine Ordinance as the sole guarantor of openness and
accessibility in city government.

"Rhetoric aside, this is an all-American initiative, San
Francisco-style, meaning that it's consistent with building democracy by
fortifying government accountability and public access," SFS cochair
Mirkarimi said. "It is an honest and commonsensical approach to good
government. I really can't see who would oppose this initiative unless
they had something to hide."



------------------------------------------------------------------------



An initial draft of the initiative can be viewed on sfbg.com at
www.sfbg.com/sunshine/initiative.html. We will post the complete text of
the Sunshine Initiative as soon as it is available.

To get involved with the Sunshine Initiative campaign, contact San
Franciscans for Sunshine at (415) 487-2542 or [EMAIL PROTECTED]

The Sunshine Ordinance Task Force continues its hearings on the
initiative at its next meeting Tues/23, 4 p.m., City Hall, 1 Dr. Carlton
B. Goodlett Place, Room 408, S.F. (415) 554-6171.

sfbg.com
-----
Aloha, He'Ping,
Om, Shalom, Salaam.
Em Hotep, Peace Be,
Omnia Bona Bonis,
All My Relations.
Adieu, Adios, Aloha.
Amen.
Roads End
Kris

DECLARATION & DISCLAIMER
==========
CTRL is a discussion and informational exchange list. Proselyzting propagandic
screeds are not allowed. Substance�not soapboxing!  These are sordid matters
and 'conspiracy theory', with its many half-truths, misdirections and outright
frauds is used politically  by different groups with major and minor effects
spread throughout the spectrum of time and thought. That being said, CTRL
gives no endorsement to the validity of posts, and always suggests to readers;
be wary of what you read. CTRL gives no credeence to Holocaust denial and
nazi's need not apply.

Let us please be civil and as always, Caveat Lector.
========================================================================
Archives Available at:
http://home.ease.lsoft.com/archives/CTRL.html

http:[EMAIL PROTECTED]/
========================================================================
To subscribe to Conspiracy Theory Research List[CTRL] send email:
SUBSCRIBE CTRL [to:] [EMAIL PROTECTED]

To UNsubscribe to Conspiracy Theory Research List[CTRL] send email:
SIGNOFF CTRL [to:] [EMAIL PROTECTED]

Om

Reply via email to