|
The 9-11 Commission Charade
by Rep. Ron Paul,
MD by Rep. Ron Paul, MD
   
The
9-11 Commission report, released late last month, has disrupted the
normally quiet Washington August. Various congressional committees
are holding hearings on the report this week, even though Congress
is not in session, in an attempt to show the government is �doing
something� about terrorism in an election year. The Commission
recommendations themselves have been accepted reverently and without
question, as if handed down from on high.
But
what exactly is going on here? These hearings amount to nothing more
than current government officials meeting with former government
officials, many of whom now lobby government officials, and agreeing
that we need more government! The current and past architects of the
very bureaucracy that failed Americans so badly on September 11th
three years ago are now meeting to recommend more bureaucracy. Why
on earth do we assume that former government officials, some of whom
are self-interested government lobbyists, suddenly become wise,
benevolent, and politically neutral when they retire? Why do we look
to former bureaucrats to address a bureaucratic failure?
The
9-11 Commission report is several hundred pages worth of
recommendations to make government larger and more intrusive. Does
this surprise anyone? It was written by people who cannot imagine
any solution not coming from government. One thing you definitely
will not see in the Commission report is a single critique of our
interventionist foreign policy, which is the real source of most
anti-American feelings around the globe.
The
Commissioners recommend the government spend billions of dollars
spreading pro-US propaganda overseas, as if that will convince the
world to love us. What we have forgotten in the years since the end
of the Cold War is that actions speak louder than words. The US
didn't need propaganda in the captive nations of Eastern Europe
during the Cold War because people knew us by our deeds. They could
see the difference between the United States and their Soviet
overlords. That is why, given the first chance, they chose freedom.
Yet everything we have done in response to the 9-11 attacks, from
the Patriot Act to the war in Iraq, has reduced freedom in America.
Spending more money abroad or restricting liberties at home will do
nothing to deter terrorists, yet this is exactly what the 9-11
Commission recommends.
Our nation will be safer only when
government does less, not more. Rather than asking ourselves what
Congress or the president should be doing about terrorism, we ought
to ask what government should stop doing. It should stop spending
trillions of dollars on unconstitutional programs that detract from
basic government functions like national defense and border
security. It should stop meddling in the internal affairs of foreign
nations, but instead demonstrate by example the superiority of
freedom, capitalism, and an open society. It should stop engaging in
nation-building, and stop trying to create democratic societies
through military force. It should stop militarizing future enemies,
as we did by supplying money and weapons to characters like Bin
Laden and Saddam Hussein. It should stop entangling the American
people in unholy alliances like the UN and NATO, and pledge that our
armed forces will never serve under foreign command. It should stop
committing American troops to useless, expensive, and troublesome
assignments overseas, and instead commit the Department of Defense
to actually defending America. It should stop interfering with the
2nd amendment rights of private citizens and businesses seeking to
defend themselves.
More
than anything, our federal government should stop deluding us that
more government is the answer. We have far more to fear from an
unaccountable government at home than from any foreign
terrorist.
August 24, 2004
Dr. Ron Paul
is a Republican member of Congress from Texas.
Ron Paul
Archives
|