-Caveat Lector- Treason in America -- From Aaron Burr to Averell Harriman ANTON CHAITKIN (C)1984 New Benjamin Franklin House P. O. Box 20551 New York, New York 10023 ISBN 0-933488-32-7 --[17b]-- This book has been out of print for years, but a new second edition is just out. Highly recommended, there are charts, pix and more. Only $15.00 retail. Om K ----- First Battle For The American West John Wesley Powell's "Report on the Arid Lands" was presented on April 1, 1878, to Interior Secretary Carl Schurz, who promptly ordered it printed and distributed to the Congress. The battle was now joined. The headquarters of the shut-the-West forces was the home of Mr. Henry Adams on H Street in Washington. Here gathered an intimate circle of anglophile strategists taking part in the showdown: Interior Secretary Carl Schurz; New York Congressman Abram Hewitt, the National Democratic Chairman, who guided the British-backed Specie Resumption Act through Congress; Clarence King, leader of one of the Western surveys; and Othniel C. Marsh, the nephew of Anglo-American banker George Peabody and a friend of the top racial ideologues in British science, Thomas Huxley and Charles Darwin. On April 3, 1878, the 80-year-old Smithsonian Secretary Joseph Henry died. Henry had also been president of the National Academy of Sciences, where he was immediately succeeded by Othniel C. Marsh, who was notorious as an opponent of geologist Ferdinand Hayden. On June 20, 1878, Congressman Abram Hewitt inserted a clause in a general appropriations bill referring the question of the Western surveys to the National Academy of Science for advice and suggestions to the Congress. In August 1878, Academy President Othniel Marsh appointed a committee to "investigate" the surveys; all committee members were opponents of Hayden, who stood for development of the West. Prominent on Marsh's committee was a close friend of Marsh and Adams, astronomer Simon Newcomb, of whom we shall hear more later on. While Secretary Schurz and John Wesley Powell worked closely together to soften up the Congress, the Academy prepared a report calling for all the Western surveys to be consolidated under Carl Schurz's Interior Department, eliminating Hayden's role, and for the appointment of a Public Lands Commission to implement Powell's Arid Lands concepts as the new national policy. The Academy report was ready on November 6, 1878. On November 16 a formal organization of the anti-development forces was established under the name of the Cosmos Club. Harvard University's own biography(6) of Henry Adams describes the policy warfare: Inevitably Henry Adams became involved in the rivalries arising from the overlapping of the surveys and the differences in their methods. There were differences also over the political and economic implications of their work, especially over Powell's revolutionary proposals for conservation of the Western lands. The clash of rival ambitions erupted into violent public controversy.... [Othniel] Marsh, sponsored by [Clarence] King and Powell, had just succeeded Joseph Henry as President of the National Academy of Science and Adams was drawn into his camp in opposition to Ferdinand Hayden.... Scientists leagued with their chiefs until the behind-the-scenes activities in the clubs of Washington resembled rival conspiracies, as they jockeyed for control of the proposed reorganization of the Surveys. It was natural that King and his allies should gravitate into a scientific and social organization of their own, especially when it became obvious that their group would carry the day.... the Cosmos Club. Its purpose was "to bind the scientific men of Washington by a social tie and thus promote that solidarity which is important to their proper work and influence." Major Powell . . . became the first President. Henry Adams joined the original promoters as an "author" . . . and was made a member of the first Committee on Admissions. Among the many notable founders, beside King and Powell, were men like Spencer Baird, [the new] Secretary of the Smithsonian.... Year by year the roster came to include many other distinguished friends and acquaintances of Henry Adams: Francis Walker, Superintendent of the Census.... [astronomers] Samuel Pierpont Langley, and Simon Newcomb.... The excitement over the impending consolidation grew fiercer from day to day with Hayden's "spies" reportedlly tracking down every rumor. King hurried in and out of town at frequent intervals, making his headquarters at the Adamses. Why Hayden's American nationalist "spies" were to prove less effective than their British opposite numbers may be explained in part by the formidable connections of geologist/raconteur Clarence King. King was a real gentleman: "I wish it could be intimated in my life and engraved on my tombstone that I am to the last fibre aristocratic in belief, that I think that the only fine thing to do with the masses is to govern and educate them into some semblance of their social superiors."(7) Clarence King's social superiority began with his grandfather, Samuel King, senior partner of the King & Talbot China-trading firm in New York. Around 1806, old Samuel King hired a cousin of his named David Olyphant (1789-1851) into the firm; David's father had emigrated from Scotland and changed his family name from that of his uncle, Lord Oliphant. >From the King firm, David Olyphant struck out on his own, eventually hiring Clarence Kings father James R. King and uncle Charles W. King into his new Olyphant and Company, China traders. Clarence's father and uncle spent most of their lives in China, his father dying in Amoy in 1851. By all testimony, the Olyphant firm was the only American-based China trading company which did not traffic in opium. Rather, Olyphant and the King brothers imported something possibly even more deadly into China, under the polite title of "missionaries." These men of the cloth, chosen, sponsored and delivered by Olyphant and Company, performed for the British secret service precisely the same function as that of cousin Laurence Oliphant�"irregular' warfare against the central authority of the Chinese Empire, to open China for looting. Following the success of the British in the 1842 Opium War, Boston opium syndicate representative Caleb Cushing negotiated a treaty allowing his friends the same privileges in China as the British had acquired. Cushing's "diplomacy," backed by gunboats threatening a new war, was carried out largely through the mediation of two Olyphant-imported missionaries, Peter Parker and Elijah Bridgman, as translators and advisors. In 1834, Reverend Bridgman had formed the Society for the Diffusion of Useful Knowledge, along with co-director Rev. Karl Gutzlaff� a Prussian national who was otherwise the director of British military intelligence for the China Region. In the 1850s, Gutzlaff and his staff "converted" thousands of Chinese into an imitation-Christian communal cult, and directed them as a powerful army into battle against the Chinese Emperor; this was the Taiping Rebellion. Clarence King's Uncle Charles had an ungentlemanly experience in 1837, when he sailed an Olyphant company ship toward Japan carrying Reverends Bridgman and Gutzlaff, hoping to land and somehow begin the process of opening up Japan as the British had done to China. The Japanese were rightly suspicious of such "religious" overtures, having suffered grievously at the hands of the Jesuits, and King's party was fired upon and driven away. Geology Meets the Noble Savage On Nov. 26, 1878, ten days after the formation of the Cosmos Club, Othniel Marsh delivered the report of the National Academy of Sciences to the U. S. Congress. The expected violent reaction came from Western congressmen and the Western press. The House of Representatives bills to implement the: "reforms" bypassed the Western-controlled Public Lands Committee, being steered instead to the Appropriations Committee where Henry Adams' man Abram Hewitt was on the job. The Senate defeated the reforms, while the House voted to consolidate the surveys and appoint a public lands commission. The Senate then voted to kill all other surveys but Hayden's. Yet on March 3, 1879, after months of wearing and confusing political combat against Abram Hewitt and the Cosmos Club, the Westerners were defeated. Congress passed the consolidation on March 3, 1879, terminating the work of Ferdinand Hayden and creating the United States Geological Survey (USGS). Clarence King was appointed the first USGS Director. By John Wesley Powell's own specific request to the chairman of the House Appropriation Committee, there was in the final bill an almost unnoticed item: "For completing and preparing for publication the contributions to North American Ethnology, under the Smithsonian Institution: $20,000." The artifacts collected during Powell's surveys of the Rocky Mountains were to be given a home in a new organization, the Bureau of American Ethnology. Thus Powell's survey was converted into a sub-department of the Smithsonian Institution, out from under Congressional supervision. Powell was now the chief ethnologist. The gentleman, Clarence King, paid little attention to his new post and resigned in 1881 to pursue speculation in Mexican mining ventures, backed by Henry Adams, Boston's Lee, Higginson and Co., and British investors. John Wesley Powell was now appointed director of the U.S. Geological Survey; and directed both geology and Indian anthropology with the same goal in mind: stopping the westward march of American civilization. Smithsonian's Curious Mission to Indians Under John Wesley Powell's leadership in its Bureau of American Ethnology (BAE), the Smithsonian Institution intensified its anti-civilization work among the American Indians. Powell's viewpoint is stated in his survey report of 1878 to the Secretary of the Interior: . . .We must either deal with the Indian as he is, looking to the slow but irresistible influence of civilization . . . to effect a change, or we must seduce him to abject slavery. The attempt to transform a savage into a civilized man by a law, a policy, an administration, or a great conversion . . . in a few months or in a few years, is an impossibility clearly appreciated by scientific ethnologists who understand the institutions and social conditions of the Indians. Powell's political standpoint becomes even clearer in the Smithsonian's own history of their anthropological engineering: Through the BAE and as director of the U.S. Geological Survey from 1881 to 1894, he fought two of the most powerful, complementary dynamics in American culture: unplanned settlement, with its destructive impact on Indian peoples and the natural environment; and well-intentioned but ignorant efforts to "save" the Indian through conversion to Christianity and civilization.(8) At least one of Powell's field agents perhaps began his work by honestly inquiring into the nature of the Indians' culture. James O. Dorsey, a former missionary, was "inclined to see civilized notions of monotheism in primitive religions." Thus, Dorsey's investigations displeased thedirector, who ordered him to undertake a "special study" of anthropology� which meant reading Morgan's "Ancient Society. ". . . Once accomodated to the Morgan/Powell framework, though, Dorsey's empirical work yielded . . . confirmation of Powell's vision of primitive belief.... For three centuries, hasty observers had written of Indian belief in a single "Great Spirit." Taking this as a sign of preparation for Christianity, generations of missionaries had sought to impose their God on it. Now the work of the [reprogrammed] missionary Dorsey had finally exploded the myth: The savage mind knew no such concept. Nevertheless, Dorsey was "never a member of Powell's inner group...." Two other Smithsonian agents, Frank Hamilton Cushing and James Mooney, did show that zeal for protecting�or promoting�savagery which the feudal minds directing them could really appreciate. As the Smithsonian chroniclers put it, "The age of science and industry left little room for imagination, mystery and romance.... From the forest and savagery [Man] learns the secret of regeneration and prosperity." Frank Cushing became a Bow Priest among the Zuni Indians in New Mexico, and was written up in Eastern newspapers as the "White Indian." By virtue of his office . . . Cushing aligned himself with the traditional tribal leadership in battles against other Zuni families and "progressive" White influences, such as missionaries, traders, politicians, and Army personnel [emphasis added].... There is no question that Cushing bullied the Zunis for information. There was an especially painful dilemma for men [like Cushing] who sensed the barrenness and irreverence of their own civilization. In order to bring regenerating knowledge to their own people, they necessarily violated trusts to others.... Cushing's . . . message was this: A truly rich culture must not deny the deep mythological . . . wellsprings of the soul.... The poetic and artistic powers of man exist independently of positive rational knowledge, and they constitute an equally valid, necessary, and deeply satisfying mode of dealing with the cosmos. The scientific world of observation and deduction that was in the making with such fanfare ... was tragically limiting and impoverished.... James Mooney's first field work was among the Eastern Cherokees in North Carolina. Mooney astutely but sympathetically took advantage of the social disintegration and economic poverty of the Cherokees.... He soon discovered that the combination of sincere interest and calculated flattery . . . opened the way to establishing the individual informant relationships . . . [such as when] priests form personal friendships and thus are led to divulge their secrets to each other for their mutual advantage . . . when one shaman meets another.... What type of "shaman" was James Mooney? He asserted that "the religion of to-day has developed from the cruder superstitions of yesterday, and Christianity itself is but an outgrowth and enlargement of the beliefs and ceremonies which have been preserved by the Indian in their more ancient form."(9) But his religious interest was quite action-oriented, as Mooney explains: "In the fall of 1890 [I] was preparing to go to Indian Territory, to continue researches among the Cherokee, when the Ghost Dance began to attract attention, and permission was asked and received to investigate the subject also among the wilder tribes in the Western part of the territory.... It soon became evident that there was more in the Ghost Dance than had been suspected .... The investigation ... has extended over a period of more than three years . . . the dance . . . is developing new features at every performance."(10) The Smithsonian historian tells some of what Mooney did: Among the Arapaho, Sioux, Kiowa, and Cheyenne.... [He] became one of the first ethnologists to use a gramaphone in the field.... At the ceremonies Mooney carefully watched face and body movements, the gestures of the medicine men, and the symptoms and timing of trances [emphasis added]. His research . . . and his pilgrimage . . . to Wovoka, the Paiute prophet [the Ghost Dance "messiah"] . . . in Nevada, convinced Mooney that the dance was a ceremony of peace and brotherhood, a movement of cultural revitalization.... The Ghost-Dance religion was a "revolution" that came "but once in the life of a race" . . . the tribes . . . all shared the messianic faith as "the only viable alternative in a world of insufferable oppression." The Ghost Dance religion was organized throughout the American West, from the Mississippi River to the West Coast, in a matter of months. The dancers were hypnotized and driven into a state of hysteria and shock, then informed by the practitioners that the shirt they were wearing during the dance had magical properties which would make the wearer immune to the white man's bullets. During the "Ghost Dance troubles" of 1890, Sitting Bull, an acquaintance of James Mooney since at least 1872, was arrested for urging a renewed Indian war against whites. He had earlier escaped to Canada, and to British protection, after having served 0 as medicine man for the Sioux in their battle with General George: Custer's troops at Little Big Horn, Montana, in 1876. In 1890, however, Sitting Bull was arrested along with many armed followers Ghost Dancers. At Wounded Knee in South Dakota, the crazed, suicidal Indians began wildly shooting at the arresting troops, and scores of Indians, men, women and children were shot down by the soldiers. As with the White Dog cult mentioned in Chapter 16, it is reasonable to ask about the Ghost Dance�whose "religion" was it? One's suspicions about the role of James-Mooney (and others of his profession) in this Khomeini-like setup of the Indians for slaughter, are increased in view of Mooney's testimony before a Smithsonian internal investigating committee, where he betrays his hatred for assimilated Indians: When I went to [the Kiowas] there were not a half dozen families in the tribe living in houses. They were all in tipis and in tipi camps.... There were not a dozen men who ever wore a hat. They had feathers in their hair, and they painted their faces whenever they went anyplace. The man with whom I made my home . . . had eight rings in one ear and five in the other.... He never went to a military post, or to a dance, or to anything else without spending a couple of hours to dress and paint up. Now he is in a - house, and has chickens and a corn field, and stoves and clocks and beds; and he has taken out his rings and cut his hair, and he looks like a dilapidated tramp. The Smithsonian historian praises Cushing and Mooney for being pioneers in the practice of modern anthropology, where "the anthropologist must suspend . . . inherited notions of social organization, scientific knowledge, artistic beauty, even moral categories.... It involved willingness to doubt and surrender . . . the hard-won certainties of industrial civilization." The 1903 Smithsonian investigation at which Mooney testified was used by Columbia University Prof. Franz Boas to demonstrate that the profession of anthropology would be more efficient�and subject to absolutely no government scrutiny� if it were brought out of the Smithsonian and planted in the universities. There it has remained until the present day, a "science of man" which opposes itself to the study of history, an academic endeavor whose professors on all continents are repeatedly found to be busying themselves with the intimate affairs of terrorist and radical separatist groups. A Ghost Dance For The Whole World? Suspicions as to who was responsible for the criminal manipulation of the Indians, rise to the level of evidence for criminal prosecution, when the anthropologists and related personnel in and around the Smithsonian Institution are investigated. During the 1880s, a certain very odd transatlantic club was formed, in England and America, which included in its ranks all of the leading individuals connected with the practice of anthropology in America. This club, using newly developed techniques of psychology and organization, would serve as an advance detachment in the war of the old European feudalists against the American System. Around its central core members, the British Foreign Office would construct a deadly transatlantic political machine to demoralize and divert the United States from it commitment to global technological development, and to close the American West to further settlement. The British club in question was the Society for Psychic Research. Its early American members included: Simon Newcomb, Canadian immigrant astronomer, Harvard professor of "British School" economics, a president of the American Association for the Advancement of Science, the first president of the American branch of the Society for Psychic Research; William J. McGee, Simon Newcomb's son-in-law, assistant to John Wesley Powell, who took over from Powell as Smithsonian Ethnologist-in-Charge in the 1890s; founder and first president of the American Anthropological Associaton; founder of the 20th} century Conservation movement; Grove K Gilbert, geologist, Powell's right-hand-man on his Western surveys, president of the Cosmos Club in 1894; Samuel F. Emmons, geologist, practical leader of Clarence King's Western survey team, Massachusetts neighbor of Henry Adams; Raphael Pumpelly, Powell's assistant; James Kidder, Smithsonian official, a Cosmos Club founder; R. W. Shufeldt, Smithsonian official; Henry Holt, publisher of Henry Adams; Samuel Pierpont Langley, astronomer, aviation experimenter in competition with the Wright brothers, secretary (director) of the Smithsonian Institution from 1887 to 1906, simultaneously the second president of the American branch of the Society of Psychic Research; Frederick W. Putnam, director of Harvard's Peabody Museum and professor of anthropology, co-sponsor with Smithsonian of Lewis Henry Morgan's work, the curator of the American Museum of Natural History in New York, created the anthropology program at University of California; Asa Gray, Harvard botanist, champion of Darwinian evolution; Thomas Wentworth Higginson, financier for Clarence King, organizer of the Massacusetts Disunion [sic] Convention in 1857; Frederick A.P. Barnard, president of Columbia University (1864-89), president and chancellor of Mississippi University during secession; David Starr Jordan, founding president of Stanford University, founder of the Sierra Club; Andrew D. White, founder and first president of Cornell University, intimate of the Russian aristocracy, Venetian-trained theological expert, historian of the supposed war between "science" and "theology," a founder and the first president of the American Historical Association, the founder of the Carnegie Institution of Washington, regent of the Smithsonian Institution; Gardiner G. Hubbard, regent of the Smithsonian Institution, founder and first president of the National Geographic Society, the founder of the magazine Science, which became the organ of the American Association for the Advancement of Science, creator of the American Bell Telephone system, father-in-law: and patron of Alexander G. Bell; Gifford Pinchot, founder of the U.S. Forest Service; John Dewey, Pestalozzian reformer of the U.S. educational system; Clarence Darrow, attorney in Scopes trial regarding Darwinian evolution;and Theodore Roosevelt, President of the United States (1901-09). The purported business of the Society for Psychic Research was to hold seances, to talk to the dead relatives of invited participants, to command tables to float in the air, to render the mind blank and have spirits move one's pen in "automatic writing," to wander in haunted houses, and so forth. The practical theme of the Society's work was psychological experimentation, on two levels. First, to study the extent of power over men's minds that could be achieved with hypnosis and hysteria-induced trances. Second, to try to break down the subject-victim's faith in rationality, in the lawfulness of nature, and in the coherence: of his own mind. Swiss psychologist Carl Jung, an early-twentieth-century member of the Society, explained the logic of this experimentation: If we plump a good physicist down in the deceptive, magical darkness of a spiritualist seance, with hysterical ; mediums plying their trade with all the incredible refinement many of them have at their command, his observation will 0 be no more acute than a layman's. Everything will depend on the strength of his prejudice [sic] for or against.... The twilight atmosphere is so essential . . . an integral component of any nocturnal, numinous experience is the 0 dimming of consciousness, the feeling that one is in the grips of something greater than oneself, the impossibility ' of exercising criticism and the paralysis of the will. Under the impact of the expierence reason evaporates and another power takes control a most singular feeling which one . . . . hoards up as a treasure no matter how much one's reason may protest. That indeed, is the uncomprehended purpose of the experience to make us feel the overpowering presence of a mystery(11) In his essay "On Occultism," Jung says, Primitive superstition lies just below the surface of even the most tough-minded individuals, and it is precesely those who most fight against it who are the first to succumb to its suggestive effects. When therefore a serious experiment with all the authority of science behind it touches this readiness, it will inevitably give rise to an emotion which either accepts or rejects it with a good deal of affectivity. Harvard experimental psychologist Win James (1842-I910), the founder of the American branch of this British organization, wrote of a "hypnogogic" state in which the subject can be Caught on the road to sleep and suspended�that is prevented from deep sleep. If the mind of the subject is caught at just this point and given a suggestion, it immediately acts on that idea. Everything depends on the subject allowing himself to be entranced and hardly anything on the operator, except that he must engender the subject's trust and fix attention on the relaxed condition. In his book Principles of Psychology, published by Henry Holt, William James asks us to Put a man into a perfect chaos of phenomena�sounds, sights, feelings and if the man continued to exist, and to be rational at all, his attention would doubtless find for him a way to make up some kind of rhythmic regularity, which he would impute to the things about him, so as to imagine that he had discovered some laws of sequence in this mad new world.... The world of living realities as contrasted with unrealities is thus anchored in the Ego.... That is the hook from which the rest dangles, the absolute support. A transatlantic organization was thus created, targeting the minds, the sense of identity, the rationality, of such individuals as scientists, statesmen, and Indian tribal leaders, reviving old methods for achieving the feudal goal of forcing an end to the dangerous American faith in unlimited progress. Prelude: Henry James, Sr. Is 'Vastated' What kind of Americans would cooperate in such a project? The American side of the story begins with the unfortunate person of Henry James, Sr. (1811-82), the father of the Society's American founder William James. Henry James, Sr., was the son of immigrant landowner Billy James of Albany. The James family's considerable power and wealth was built up within the social and political orbit of the Van Rensselaers, whose patroon system held sway in the New York State capital region until well into the nineteenth century. The Jameses were an important part of the local political machine built by Aaron Burr and the Van Rensselaers' Scottish Rite. o A daughter of Billy James (thus an aunt of Harvard psychologist William James) married "Prince" John Van Buren, son of President Martin Van Buren. o Billy James himself was the principal trustee, financier, and, with the Van Rensselaer family, the practical owner of Union College, where anthropologist Lewis Henry Morgan and young Henry James, Sr., both got their philosophical grounding. o The family tutor for Scottish Rite leader Stephen Van Rensselaer was also hired to work with Henry James, and remained his lifelong intimate friend; the tutor was Joseph Henry, who was later chosen-the first secretary of the Smithsonian Institution. Henry James was a somewhat spoiled, somewhat independent-minded young radical, who began falling away from his training for the Presbyterian ministry while in college. He became acquainted with Ralph Waldo Emerson and was charmed by Emerson's soulful talk and the exciting reach of his contacts in literature and society. When Henry's son William James was born in 1842, Emerson was his godfather. In the spring of 1844, Henry James was visiting in England with East India Company intelligence officer John Stuart Mill, racialist writer Thomas Carlyle, and other friends of Emerson's. As Henry James told the story, one evening after dinner- in this company, he suddenly lost control of his mind and his will. He felt threatened by "malevolent spirits lurking in the room"; he was for no apparent reason "reduced to terror and fear." He felt the urge to run upstairs to his wife for help, but overcame this urge. Mr. James was referred to certain physicians, who said he had "overworked his brain" and prescribed a rest at a particular "water-cure" spa. He later described his feelings just after My catastrophe.... The curse of mankind ... is its sense of selfhood, and the absurd, abominable opiniona- tiveness it engenders. How sweet it would be to find oneself no longer man, but one of those innocent and ignorant sheep pasturing upon that placid hillside, and drinking in eternal dew and freshness from Nature's lavish bosom.... My studious mental activity had [been] a mere "castle in the air," and the castle had vanished in a brief moment of time. . . . I never felt again the most passing impulse, even, to look where it stood.... Truth indeed! How should a beggar like me be expected to discover it?(12) Relief from this tortured trance-like state came from a gracious lady who suddenly appeared at the water-cure spa. She explained to him that he had undergone a "vastation," that is, that his brain had been washed clean of arrogant male-type notions of selfhood. She introduced him to the spiritualist philosophy of Emanuel Swedenborg, the eighteenth-century London-based Swedish mystic. Henry James rushed off to London and was initiated into the selfless mysteries taught by Dr. Garth Wilkinson, a hypnotist, an Aryan master-race theorist, and a leader of the Swedenborg cult in England. Dr. Wilkinson was a friend and professional collaborator of the royal family's top espionage agent Laurence Oliphant, who would meet with Henry James and Emerson a decade later in New York. >From that time forward, Henry James, Sr., was devoted to the philosophy of his own "vastation": that men may be transformed through hypnosis, through giving up and defeating the Tyranny of Reason, into seekers after mystery and communication with dead people. Not surprisingly, he became also a socialist, a critic of the Arrogance of industrial capitalist development Henry James, Sr. had one son whom he named Wilkinson; another was William James, the Harvard experimental psychologist and founder of the American branch of the British Society for Psychic Research; and another son, the effete novelist Henry James, who lived abroad as an anti-American Englishman The Project From Palmerston to Balfour The "psychic research" project which dominated the Washington scientific community in the 1880s and 1890s was organized in the household of Mr. and Mrs. William Cowper-Temple (later Baron and Lady Mount-Temple): the Broadlands estate of Lord Palmerston, Cowper-Temple's stepfather. Broadlands was the continuous setting for seances from the 1850s and 1860s, when Laurence Oliphant had brought back spiritualist "religion" to Prime Minister Palmerston from the British diplomatic corps in and around the Ottoman Empire. The Cowper-Temples were Oliphant's great patrons in the 1870s when he was based in the spiritualist commune in upstate New York. Mrs. Cowper-Temple was as much of an avid patroness, a mother figure, to Pre-Raphaelite feudalist John Ruskin and his projects as she was to Laurence Oliphant. One day in 1874, the Cowper-Temples received at Broadlands a party of particularly enthusiastic spiritualists including Edmund Gurney, Mrs. Cowper-Temple's nephew; Gurney's friend Frederick Meyers, the homosexual protege of John Ruskin; the Rev. Stainton Moses, John Ruskin's psychic medium; and George Wyld of the Theosophical Society. At this meeting a powerful spiritualist organization was projected. Frederick Meyers then went to Cambridge University professor Henry Sidgwick and proposed that such an organization be established in and about Cambridge, based on that university's recent decades of "spookery." We saw the Cambridge Ghost Club, in Chapter 16, as the source for a questionaire attached to an 1859 book on spiritualism by Robert Dale Owen. Not only spooks of the graveyard variety, but espionage agents for overseas British Empire work had long been cultivated at the school. The elite Cambridge Conversazione Society, better known as The Apostles, was founded in 1820 at St. John's College, Cambridge. Student-members of this radical nihilist group had gone forth to Spain in the 1830s under the close supervision of John Stuart Mill, to lead an armed insurrection against the Spanish king. b the 1837-38 rebellion in Canada, two Apostles crossed the Atlantic to deal with the troubled colony as military intelligence officials. The host for Henry Adams' aristocratic initiation party, Monckton Milnes, was an Apostle. The environment for such a group became even more congenial during the 1870s following the revolutionizing of St. John's College's curriculum and social life by the school's "freethinking" Master, William Henry Bateson. Henry Sidgwick, Cambridge professor of moral philosophy, - was well placed to inaugurate the Society for Psychic Research as its first president in 1882. He was an Apostle; he would eventually be the tutor and the great inspiration for the twentieth-century radical leader Lord Bertrand Russell. Sidgwick was also the teacher, the tutor and eventually the brother-in-law of Arthur J. Balfour (1848-1930). Mr. Balfour himself was president of the Society for Psychic Research in 1893, and for about the first 30 years the Society's presidency was always in the hands of a member of Balfour's immediate family or the circle of his intimate friends. This transatlantic strategic project was logically Balfour's personal affair, since Balfour and his family, the Cecils, directed the foreign policy and the intelligence activities of Great Britain more or less continuously from 1878 to 1918. Arthur Balfour's father, a Scot enriched by the East India Company, died early and Balfour was raised by his Cecil mother and her relatives. The mother's brother was Robert Cecil, l the third Lord Salisbury. Uncle Salisbury was first made foreign minister in 1878, and leader of the Conservative Party in 1881; he was prime minister from 1885 to 1892, and again from 1895 until his death in 1902. Nephew Arthur, serving first as Salisbury's closest aide, entered the cabinet in 1887; he was Lord of the Treasury in 1891, Prime Minister in the crucial years 1902 to 1905, First Lord of the Admiralty in 1914, and Foreign Minister from 1916 to 1919 during World War I. The Cecil family, known as one of the key "Venetian" elements in the British aristocracy, gained such power that in 1900 the British government received the popular nickname "The Hotel Cecil, Unlimited," recalling the family's similarly great power in the time of Queen Elizabeth I. At the turn of the twentieth century, under Prime Minister Salisbury, Cecils or their spouses ran the Treasury, the Navy, the planning in the foreign ministry, and the leadership of the Parliament. The Project's Motivation Among the important members of the Society for Psychic Research in the 1880s, two in particular deserve mention as leaders in the mind-bending warfare which was the society's purpose: William Bateson, son of the Master of St. John's College, Cambridge; young William was a biologist and theorist of racial purification, or "eugenics"�he coined the word "genetics"; his son, anthropologist Gregory Bateson, became the prime organizer of the California LSD culture and the husband of anthropologist Margaret Mead, herself an American leader of the Psychic Research Society in the 1940s. John Ruskin (1819-1900), a partisan of Venetian anti-Renaissance philosophy, who set the moral tone for the Society: ". . . The Americans, as a nation set their trust in liberty and equality, of which I detest the one, and deny the possibility of the other." Ruskin's sense of the proper relationship between man and nature is today the background ethic of the environmentalist movement: And in the case of the old families, which . . . however decadent, still truly are, the noblest monumental architec- ture of the kingdom living temples of sacred tradition and hero's religion, so much land ought to be granted to them in perpetuity as mar enable them to live thereon with all circumstances of state and outward nobleness.... Their income must be fixed, and paid them by the state, as the King's is.... Their land ... should be ... kept in conditions of natural grace . . . [under] such agriculture as develops the happiest peasant life . . . agriculture which . . . must reject the aid of all mechanism except that of instruments guided solely by the human hand, or by the animal; or directly natural forces. In his book "The Foundations of Belief," Arthur Balfour purports to explain the message of science. He puts forth without apology a viewpoint so alien to the American, so repulsive to the human way of viewing man's condition and prospects, that one must be struck with alarm: Consider that Balfour's siding with Nature, as against Man the "pretentious intruder," is the core philosophy of the environmentalist movment of the 20th century: Man, so far as natural science by itself is able to teach us, is no longer the final cause of the universe, the Heaven-descended heir of all the ages. His very existence is an accident, his story a brief and transitory episode in the life of one of the meanest of the planets. Of the combination of causes which first converted a dead organic compound into the living progenitors of humanity, science, indeed, as yet knows nothing. It is enough that it is from such beginnings�famine, disease, and mutual slaughter, fit nurses for the future lords of creation�have gradually evolved, after infinite travail, a race [i.e., mankind] with conscience enough to feel that it is vile, and intelligence enough to know that it is insignificant. We survey the past, and see that its history is of blood and tears, of helpless blundering, of wild revolt, of stupid acquiescence, of empty aspirations. We sound the future, and learn that after a period, long compared with the individual life, but short indeed compared with the divisions of time open to our investigation, the energies of our system will decay, the glory of the sun will be dimmed, and the earth, tideless and inert, will no longer tolerate the race which has for a moment disturbed its solitude. Man will go down into the pit, and all his thoughts will perish. The uneasy consciousness, which in this obscure corner has for a brief space broken the contented silence of the universe, will be at rest. Matter will know itself no longer. Imperishable monuments and immortal deeds, death itself, and love stronger than death, will be as though they had never been. Nor will anything that is be better or be worse for all that the labor, genius, devotion, and suffering of man have striven through countless generations to effect.(13) Compare these words of Balfour with those of another 20th-century European politician: In attempting to rebel against the iron logic of Nature, man comes into conflict with the principles to which he owes his very existence as a human being. Thus his action in defiance of Nature is bound to lead to his own downfall. To this we hear the objection . . . "But man conquers - Nature!" Millions thoughtlessly babble this . . . nonsense, and end by really imagining themselves as a sort of conqueror of Nature.... But quite apart from the fact that man has never once yet conquered Nature, but at most has caught hold of and tried to lift one corner and another of her vast, gigantic veil; that in fact he invents nothing but merely discovers things; that he does not rule Nature, but has only risen, by knowing certain natural laws and secrets, to dominate other living creatures that lack this knowledge.... The latter quote is from Adolf Hitler, in "Mein Kampf"; we have deleted from the passage Hitler's obscene anti-Semitic epithets. We will not so edit the remarks of our more "stylish" Psychic Researchers. In a letter to Harvard Professor Charles Eliot Norton on the subject of gnosticism, John Ruskin asserts: "I've become a Pagan, too; and am trying hard to get some substantial hope of seeing Diana in the pure glades; or Mercury in the clouds (Hermes, I mean, not that rascally Jew-God of the Latins)." Lord Balfour's family-approved biographer relates that his Lordship "told [Chaim] Weizmann that he had once had a long talk with Cosima Wagner at Bayreuth and 'shared many of her anti-Semitic postulates."' In an 1899 letter, Balfour complains about a party in which "the Hebrews were in an actual majority� and tho' I have no prejudices against the race (quite the contrary) I began to understand the point of view of those who object to alien immigration!"(14) The views here expressed by the Psychic project leader are entirely in accord with his famous 1917 Balfour Declaration, pledging that the Jewish people will be welcome in British-ruled Palestine, not in England. His sponsorship of Britain's immigration restriction laws ultimately had most evil consequences for Jews attempting to flee. This British gentleman, Dr. Richard Hodgson, had previously been assigned by- the Society in England, and by the British authorities, to discredit the psychic claims of Madame Helena Blavatsky, leader of the Theosophical Society, when she began intriguing in India for a pro-Russian revolution against British Rule. Dr. Hodgson then came across the sea to manage all of the practical affairs of the Society in America, as its secretary, from shortly after its inception until his death in 1906. In the late 1880s, the secretary of the Smithsonian Institution, Samuel P. Langley, was also the president of the American branch of Lord Balfour's Society for Psychic Research. Dr. Langley's sense of national and moral identity has been pinpointed for posterity by his biographer, aide, and closest personal associate, Cyrus Adler. We are told that Samuel Langley made a yearly trip to England, that he went often to the home of the crude feudal racialist writer Thomas Carlyle, and that he would sit at Carlyle's feet for hours, drinking in the master's wisdom without speaking a word. Back in the U.S.A., Dr. Langley's employees were busy in two crucial projects for the destruction of the American West. First, Smithsonian ethnologists who the Institution admits were in "battles against . . . White influences" including "Army personnel, " were studying how Indians could be put into trances, armed, and sent into suicidal warfare against U.S. troops. The Ghost Dance Religion, created in 1890, spread like wildfire across half a continent. After the disaster at Wounded Knee, Wovoka, the Paiute prophet taken up as the "messiah," made a sad national tour telling Indians that someone had twisted his words, had used his sayings falsely to spread the Ghost Dance religion. Perhaps today the Smithsonian Institution could tell us who was responsible? At the same time, Smithsonian Ethnologist-In-Charge John Wesley Powell was still the director of the U. S. Geological Survey, attempting by political means to prohibit the settlement of the West. Following a severe blizzard and drought in 1886, Western congressmen were anxious to get government help in starting up the irrigation projects necessary for the orderly development of the region. In March 1888, a resolution was submitted by Sen. William M. Stewart of Nevada, asking the Interior Department if a survey for reservoirs and canals could not be done. Senator Stewart had been the author of the final form of the 15th Amendment to the U.S. Constitution, guaranteeing blacks the right to vote; he was fighting for the growth of his state through mining and agriculture. Powell and the Anglo-American machine went into action� before the new states of Montana, Idaho, North and South Dakota, Washington, and Wyoming, all admitted to the Union in 1889 or 1890, were represented in the legislative process. In October of 1888, a rider was attached to a general appropriations bill, giving Powell the right to conduct a grand irrigation survey. Just as in 1879, the move bypassed the pro-Western Public Lands Committee. Included in the legislation was a clause temporarily withdrawing from settlement all lands "made susceptible of irrigation" by the reservoirs and canals whose locations the survey would select; this was intended as a guard against speculators' monopolizing the irrigated land in advance. Powell now announced that there must be a complete topographical, hydrographical, and engineering survey of the whole region before any irrigation, or settlement, could occur. He said these could be accomplished in only six or seven years, at a cost of $5 to $7 million. But when congressmen asked him to start with a request for half a million, Powell claimed that there weren't enough trained men available to make use of so large an appropriation. The administration of President Grover Cleveland ruled that by the terms of the congressional resolution, all land claims that had been filed after Oct. 2, 1888 were invalid, and then withdrew 850 million acres, or one and a third million square miles, two-fifths of the nation's area, from entry by American settlers. The quandary the American nationalists now found themselves in has been aptly described in an anti-development Powell biography which is actually boasting of his audacity: "The President would obviously not restore any lands until they were certified to him [as ready for occupancy] by Major John Wesley Powell. Major John Wesley Powell would not certify any lands until his survey worked them over. And his survey was apparently going to take forever.... He could dictate ... the precise pattern that future settlement [if any] would take.''(15) It is interesting to note that the land now resting under the absolute control of Powell's Survey was exactly the area of the spread of the Ghost Dance Religion. Seeing that their legitimate demand for federal irrigation to spur growth had been turned into a complete shutdown of westward migration, the Western congressmen, led by Nevada's Senator Stewart, began a counterattack. A Senate bill in summer of 1890 reversed the land freeze. In their zeal to break Powell, the senators included an unfortunate clause ending all funding for hydrographic work. In 1891 the Geological Survey was cut back, and Congress for the first time took precise control over what the survey was supposed to do. By 1894, his land operations cut to the bone, Powell resigned from the Geological Survey. In the 1890s, the new states of the West looked forward to the growth that could make them powerful contributors to the world position of the republic. Their advocates had won a battle, but they had not eliminated the enemy's operation. A decade later, a rising group of anti-development men, tied by money, philosophy and personal association to the feudal oligarchs of Europe, would see to it that the West would not reach its goal. Instead, the Conservationists would help to develop a political movement which the United States and the whole civilized world would have to fight against in World War II. A Digression: How Henry Adams Falsified American History. It is always astonishing, while researching some of the turning points in American history, while investigating key individuals involved in directing crucial events, to find that historians have never trod on this particular ground before. Why not? The facts are there. Family records, correspondence and national archival materials are in most cases readily available for the pursuit of stories�despite the fact that influential people often resort to hiring their own biographers to obscure the record of their deeds. With Henry Adams, we come closer to the answer to this question. We have seen that he was assigned by Albert Gallatin's family the task of presenting to the world a cleaned-up version of the life of that most insidious enemy of the American republic. Adams took on some other such assignments as well, involving particularly sensitive issues of emphasis and interpretation, founding a Harvard school of history which "reformed" America's story to suit the "reformers" of its political and economic system. In a letter to anthropologist Lewis Henry Morgan, announcing that he would patronize Morgan's forthcoming book, Ancient Society, Henry Adams discloses certain racial views which throw a good deal of light on his historical method. [Your work] must be the foundation of all future work in American historical science.... I have lost and shall lose no opportunity to impress on our scientific men and institutions the need of a careful scientific inquiry into the laws and usages of the village Indians.... Your influence might be decisive in organizing such an undertaking. You would find active sympathy from men like Prof. Marsh, Clarence King . . . [geologist Rafael] Pumpelly, and I doubt not the whole Smithsonian connection, as well as Major Powell and our various engineering or surveying parties. The work should be started at once, and its objects defined and explained so that inquirers and travellers may understand the aims proposed. If you will take the lead in it, I believe something might be accomplished.... I noticed with pleasure a remark of yours . . . on the influence of domestic animals in developing the Aryan race.... The Aryans are the creators of civil law. The Aryan mind seems to have a natural bent towards it. ... (16) In other locations, Adams speaks of "A Polish Jew fresh from Warsaw or Cracow . . . a furtive Yacoob or Ysaac still reeking of the Ghetto, snarling a weird Yiddish.";(17) "I have now seen enough of Jews and Moors to entertain more liberal views in regard to the Inquisition, and to feel that, though the ignorant may murmur, the Spaniards saw and pursued a noble aim."(18) "Poor Boston has fairly run up against it in the form of its particular Irish maggot, rather lower than the Jew, but more or less the same in appetite for cheese."(19) To keep "the ignorant" from "murmuring," Adams edited and published, concurrently with the Gallatin assignment, certain Documents Relating to New England Federalism; later he wrote detailed histories of the administrations of Presidents Thomas Jefferson and James Madison. In these volumes Adams presents the story of the elite Bostonians of the Essex Junto, their attempts to create a Northern secessionist movement before and during the War of 1812, and the patriotic actions of John Quincy Adams in countering this treason. Henry Adams appears rhetorically to take the part of his grandfather. But by a clever device of dishonest narration, he rips the heart out of the story, a device supplied courtesy of England's Lord Salisbury. Following the victory over the pro-development Westerners in 1879, Adams sailed for England. There he requested of the British Foreign Minister, Robert Cecil, Lord Salisbury, special permission to abrogate the British law banning inspection of historical documents later than 1802. When Salisbury made an exception for this safe individual, Adams responded with a letter to Salisbury's private secretary: I . . . ask you to say to Lord Salisbury that I fully appreciate the exceptional liberality of this favor... . Perhaps it has for me only one disadvantage; if I find [among the British archives] anything to rouse my patriotic indignation, I shall hardly feel equal to doing it justice. One can't properly abuse a country which is so good-natured about it(20). What Adams and the British archivist together found, was a carefully sanitized tale of espionage, involving a certain Canadian adventurer named John Henry. This individual came down to Boston on his own initiative to evaluate and manipulate the antigovernment feelings of the Boston merchant crowd, then tried to blackmiail the British government to keep him quiet about his activities. Whether this story is true or false, the sensation and noise surrounding its telling diverts the attention of readers from what is properly the central question about the Essex Junto Bostonians: Were they, themselves, agents of the British empire? Since they had entered into very profitable criminal activities with the British, such as selling opium in China, were they not conscious, witting, traitors against their own country? What were the historical and continuing ties of the Boston "first families" to the British Foreign Office and other foreign oligarchical agencies? Adams carefully avoids all questions of family history that might lead to embarrassing answers. Again, concerning the treason of Aaron Burr, historian Henry Adams appears to attack the villain�but the edge on the story is blunted by his invention of a "more guilty" party in the case. General James Wilkinson, who broke Burr's 1806-7 Western secession conspiracy by informing President-Jefferson about it, was assaulted by Henry Adams as the lowest, vilest character, a paid spy of the Spanish, a double traitor who dragged down the "romantic" Burr to save himself. Burr's family ties to the leading oligarchs and espionage-masters of Europe are not disclosed. Though this hyper-villification of General Wilkinson was begun in 1807 by Burr himself and his co-conspirator, British military intelligence officer James Workman, historians in the past century have unquestioningly taken Henry Adams' lead on the Burr case. As Adams lays down the line: "The conspiracy of Burr was a mere episode, which had little direct connection with foreign or domestic politics.... " Henry Adams also set the tone for Eastern Establishment history on what is perhaps the central question of the American Civil War: Who created and led the Southern secession movement, and for what purposes? In his biography(2l) of John Randolph of Roanoke, Adams attacks that pathetic Virginia congressional leader with unbridled fury. Randolph's bitter oratorical contests with Northern congressmen, his role in turning John C. Calhoun from nationalism toward Southern separatism, and his personal eccentricities�even his reputed sexual impotence became fundamental early causes of the Southern rebellion thanks to Henry Adams' pen. The fact that John Randolph was actually raised by a stepfather, St. George Tucker, whose nephew was Chairman of the British East India Company, and whose whole family connived at creating an anti-American movement in Virginia�Randolph was raised to despise America and worship the British aristocracy; and the fact-that Randolph's flaming battles with his "arch-enemy, " Boston's anti-South Congressman Josiah Quincy, were entirely for public consumption�the two Union-haters were privately so close that they exchanged and cared for each other's minor child-wards; these elementary facts of family business were not to be allowed to disturb the smooth fabric of what came to be known as the great "sectional" North versus South tragedy of the Civil War. The greatest crime was that Henry Adams betrayed his own family's republican heritage; he painstakingly covered up the uglier family-related truths of Anglo-American political history; but he was the prototypical blueblood, insisting that "family," or race, was so supremely important. pps. pp 426-472 --(notes)-- 1. Samuels; Ernest, Henry Adams The Middle Years, The Belknap Press of Harvard University Press, Cambridge, Massachusetts, 1958, p. 32. 2. Adams, Henry, The Education of Henry Adams, Houghton Mifflin Company, Boston, 1974, pp. 137-140. 3. Taylor, Anne, Laurence Oliphant, Oxford University Press, Oxford, England, 1982, pp. 29-30. 4. Henry Adams to his brother Brooks Adams, Feb. 18, 1909, quoted in Dusinberre, William, Henry Adams�TheMythofFailure, University Press of Virginia, Charlottesville, Virginia, 1980, pp. 29-31. 5. Adams, Henry, Critique of Brooks Adams' manuscript biography of John Quincy Adams, quoted in Dusinberre, Henry Adams, p. 31. 6. Samuels, Henry Adams, pp. 35-37. 7. Clarence King in a memo to lames D. Hague, quoted in Bartlett, Richard, Great Surveys of the American West, University of Oklahoma Press, Norman, Oklahoma, 1962. 8. Hinsley, Curtis M., Jr., Savages and Scientists, Smithsonian Institution Press, Washington, D. C., 1981, p. 150 ff., for this and the quotes immediately following. 9. Mooney, James, "Sacred Formulas of the Cherokees," in Bureau of American Ecology, Annual Report for l886, Washington, D. C., 1891, p. 319. 10. Mooney, James, "The Ghost-Dance Religion and the Sioux Outbreak of 1890," in Bureau of American Ethnology, Annual Report for 1893, Washhington,D.C.,1896,Part 2, p. 653 11. Jung, Carl G., "Synchronicity An Acausal Connecting Principle," in The Collected Works of C. G. Jung, Bolligen Series XX, Princeton University Press, Princeton, New Jersey, 1973, Vol. VIII, p. 25. 12. Austin, Warren, The Elder William]ames, Mamillan and Company, New York, 1934; pp. 56-57. 13. Quoted in Young, Kenneth, Arthur James Balfour: The Happy Life of the Politician, Prime Minister, Statesman and Philosopher, 1848-1930, G. Bell and Sons, London, 1963, pp. 56-57. 14. ibid., pp. 257, 139. 15. Stegner, Wallace, Beyond the 100th Meridian,: John Wesley Powell and the Second Opening of the West, Houghton Mifflin Company, Boston, 1954, D. 319. 16. Henry Adams to Lewis Henry Morgan, July 14, 18?7, The Letters of Henry Adams, The Belknap Press of Harvard University Press, Cambridge, Massachusetts, 1982, Vol. II, p. 312. 17. Adams, The Education of Henry Adams, p. 238. 18. Henry Adams to Sir Robert Cunliffe, Nov. 21, 1879, Letters, Vol. II, p. 19. Quoted in Solomon, Barbara Miller, Ancestors and Immigrants: A Changing New England Tradition, Harvard University Press, Cambridge, Massachusetts, 1956, p. 37. 20. Henry Adams to Philip Wodehouse Currie, July 11, 1879, Letters, Vol. 11, p. 364. 21. Adams, Henry, John Randonbh, Houghton Mifflin Company, Boston, 1883. --cont-- Aloha, He'Ping, Om, Shalom, Salaam. Em Hotep, Peace Be, Omnia Bona Bonis, All My Relations. Adieu, Adios, Aloha. Amen. Roads End Kris DECLARATION & DISCLAIMER ========== CTRL is a discussion and informational exchange list. Proselyzting propagandic screeds are not allowed. Substance�not soapboxing! These are sordid matters and 'conspiracy theory', with its many half-truths, misdirections and outright frauds is used politically by different groups with major and minor effects spread throughout the spectrum of time and thought. That being said, CTRL gives no endorsement to the validity of posts, and always suggests to readers; be wary of what you read. CTRL gives no credeence to Holocaust denial and nazi's need not apply. Let us please be civil and as always, Caveat Lector. ======================================================================== Archives Available at: http://home.ease.lsoft.com/archives/CTRL.html http:[EMAIL PROTECTED]/ ======================================================================== To subscribe to Conspiracy Theory Research List[CTRL] send email: SUBSCRIBE CTRL [to:] [EMAIL PROTECTED] To UNsubscribe to Conspiracy Theory Research List[CTRL] send email: SIGNOFF CTRL [to:] [EMAIL PROTECTED] Om
