-Caveat Lector-
Back to AfP
The Times 08.05.99
Original link on: www.the-times.co.uk
Our leaders must not be allowed to blame others for this crazy
war
It won't wash, Tony
By Matthew Parris
Who is the world's longest-serving leader? Does Fidel Castro not
hold that record: 30 years? Hanging in there with resilience is
Libya's Colonel Gaddafi, unchallenged (except by the world's
mightiest superpower) for some 29 years. Ho Chi Minh died
(peacefully) too early for his 15-year span in office in Vietnam
to approach that of Iraq's Saddam Hussein: 20 years at the helm,
and no less secure than the day we started bombing. Were one
advising a young would-be tyrant desirous of establishing a long-
term career as world bogeyman, one could do worse than suggest
he provoke an open-ended conflict with the United States and her
allies. These people form a sort of league. Last Wednesday
morning Bill Clinton spoke to the BBC after flying in to Germany
to discuss the Balkans. If I judged his tone of jet-lagged
realism aright, the United States is close to admitting Slobodan
Milosevic to junior membership of the league.
And Britain will follow. This has been, after all, an American operation from the
start, though if you listened to the puffed-up nonsense spouted by the British press
and British politicians you might have overlooked that
small truth. All our Prime Minister's defiant posturings and sub-Churchillian prose
now depart whither they were bound from the start: into the ether. All Captain
Ashdown's swashbuckling advice to someone who was never i
n charge anyway trails from "I tell you so" into "I told you so". William Hague's
semi-skimmed support for a Prime Ministerial position ("no ground troops") in which
even the Prime Minister did not believe, slinks into an
inglorious footnote to an inglorious chapter.
Oh, what a cock-up. What a stupid, stupid adventure. What a catastrophe. What an
unpardonably reckless blunder. What a misjudgment. What a bloody mess. Tens of
thousands of deaths which it is only self-deceiving rubbish t
o insist would have occurred if the bombing had never begun. Around a million deported
within weeks into abject poverty - exodus on a scale and with a speed and ferocity
which to suppose Milosevic planned before the bombi
ng, or could have achieved except under cover of the bombing, is a flight of pure,
self-serving fancy on Robin Cook's part. If it were true, what a massive failure on
the part of forward Allied intelligence and forward Al
lied planning, was that.
What purpose can it serve, to protest that the principal wickedness in all this is
Milosevic's? Of course it is. Nobody, nobody has ever said otherwise. There are many
terrible people in the world. To attack them without
any reasonable certainty you can beat them is moralism gone mad.
For think of the cost. What lunacy invades the ordinary calculations of rational men
when war comes! Thousand upon thousand of bombs and missiles, billions of dollars,
resources squandered - and all in the cause of the de
struction of what we ourselves must afterwards rebuild. It has been a sort of orgy.
One day, when this fever has passed, somebody will calculate the cost to Nato per head
of the failed defence of a population of a territo
ry hardly bigger than Devon, and the far, far greater cost of reconstruction of what
we have flattened. I wince at the thought. Nor is the cost only financial. For years
Britain and America have been insisting, against Ru
ssian doubt, that Nato was a purely defensive alliance. That whole patient military
and diplomatic effort at reassurance is gone - blasted away - almost overnight. It
will be decades before the Russians trust us again. An
d what message will India, Pakistan, Iraq, Iran, Libya, Israel, Egypt and Brazil
quietly have drawn from all this? Is it not obvious? If you have nuclear weapons, keep
them; if not, get them. Who would have suggested bomb
ing Belgrade if Milosevic had possessed nuclear weapons?
This immense damage to Nato's diplomatic posture would have been sustained even if the
bombing had worked. But it has not; and if, as I suspect, Nato is preparing to
retreat under cover of some fatuous claim that whateve
r ceasefire we negotiate is in fact a "victory", then to the damage done by the
spectacle of our aggression will soon be added the damage done by our patent failure
to win. It is hard to overstate the harm which will be d
one as realisation dawns that mighty Nato has failed to summon the consensus necessary
to invade and occupy a patch of Europe the size of a large English county.
I have finished arguing about this idiotic debacle now. I sense that beneath the
surface that argument has now been won. If you doubt it, just ask yourself whether, if
our leaders had their time over again, they would hav
e begun the war again. The Prime Minister must not be allowed to get away with this.
The whole Cabinet must not be allowed to get away with it. The Leaders of the
Conservative and the Liberal Democrat parties, co-belliger
ents with Mr Blair, must not get away with it.
I know how Mr Blair is going to try to wriggle out. He will put it about
unattributedly that this is all the Americans' fault. He was willing. He argued for a
land invasion. But Clinton's nerve cracked. So, sorry mate: Bi
ll let me down. Oh, and then there were those pesky backsliding Greeks, too. Plucky
British Premier betrayed by spineless continentals and timid Yanks. This won't wash.
It assumes a land invasion would have been successfu
l. Are we really so confident of that? Hardly any British commentary has allowed so
much as the possibility that the reason Clinton opposes the use of ground troops is
not personal moral failure but a settled military ass
essment that the strategy is unsafe. But even if one were sure Clinton was wrong, he
cannot be accused of backsliding. The US President is the man who has not shifted
position. Clinton said "no opposed land troops" at the
outset, he said so to Blair, he said so to the Allies, and he still says so. So what
was Mr Blair thinking of when he went into this war on Clinton's clear terms? Is it
seriously suggested as a defence of this Cabinet th
at they began a war, knowing its terms were potentially ruinous, but hopeful they
could bounce the other participants, including the major participant exposed to the
largest risk, into changing those terms later? If so, t
hat's no defence: it should be high on the list of indictments. It would be deeply
irresponsible.
To that irresponsibility must be added Cook and Blair's personal folly in upping the
stakes against the Serbian leader as an individual, with all their Old Testament
language and loose tabloid talk of vile dictators and w
ar crimes tribunals. In this, Blair has made a real contribution to the difficulties
of dealing with Milosevic as the present and perhaps future President of his country.
But deal with him somebody will have to: somebody
else, presumably the poor Germans. The depth of the unwisdom of this Government's very
un-British approach has yet to be fully appreciated, but will be. Cook and Blair's
stated positions, on the record, are now utterly in
compatible with their ever recommending the deal whose outlines have been taking shape
in Germany.
The only other defence our Cabinet might attempt is that the best advice they received
was that Milosevic would back down and step down so fast that it was unnecessary to
plan for any other contingency. But I cannot belie
ve that was the advice Blair was offered.
Except by William Hague and Michael Howard, of course. The Tories may get off lightly
for their abject failure to subject this war to intelligent scrutiny. They deserve to
be roasted alive. Patriotism is no excuse. While
it is (just) possible to believe new Labour were ignorant and Bible-happy enough to
think all you needed for a successful war was a few big bangs and an empowering sense
of moral purpose, no Tory can be excused such other
-worldliness. Hague and his team have known all along that this
war was crazy and they just didn't have the guts or the unity to
say so.
If the Tories have been craven, the Liberal Democrats have been
bizarre. Paddy Ashdown did know that on the basis on which the
Cabinet were insisting it be fought, this war was foolish. Mr
Ashdown understands war. He has always believed that in the
Balkans it must in the end be land force or nothing. He and
Menzies Campbell should never have supported a pure bombing
campaign, and to whimper that they did insist that more would be
needed is not an excuse, but a further indictment, for they were
in no position to insist: there was reason, and Mr Ashdown knew
there was, to doubt whether ground troops would ever be
available. In those circumstances his party should have opposed
the bombing. Liberal Democracy has lost a little bit of its soul
by its failure to do so.
When all this is over, and I think that may be soon, we must
shine a searchlight into the thoughts and actions of the men and
women who got us into it. In the meantime, let us stamp hard -
and now - on the defence the British political establishment is
preparing for itself. It wasn't Bill's fault for not going far
enough. It was their fault for going as far with him as they
did.
Copyright 1999 Times Newspapers Ltd.
A<>E<>R
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
The only real voyage of discovery consists not in seeking
new landscapes but in having new eyes. -Marcel Proust
+ + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + +
A merely fallen enemy may rise again, but the reconciled
one is truly vanquished. -Johann Christoph Schiller,
German Writer (1759-1805)
+ + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + +
Forwarded as information only; no endorsement to be presumed
+ + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + +
In accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. section 107, this material
is distributed without charge or profit to those who have
expressed a prior interest in receiving this type of information
for non-profit research and educational purposes only.
DECLARATION & DISCLAIMER
==========
CTRL is a discussion and informational exchange list. Proselyzting propagandic
screeds are not allowed. Substance�not soapboxing! These are sordid matters
and 'conspiracy theory', with its many half-truths, misdirections and outright
frauds is used politically by different groups with major and minor effects
spread throughout the spectrum of time and thought. That being said, CTRL
gives no endorsement to the validity of posts, and always suggests to readers;
be wary of what you read. CTRL gives no credeence to Holocaust denial and
nazi's need not apply.
Let us please be civil and as always, Caveat Lector.
========================================================================
Archives Available at:
http://home.ease.lsoft.com/archives/CTRL.html
http:[EMAIL PROTECTED]/
========================================================================
To subscribe to Conspiracy Theory Research List[CTRL] send email:
SUBSCRIBE CTRL [to:] [EMAIL PROTECTED]
To UNsubscribe to Conspiracy Theory Research List[CTRL] send email:
SIGNOFF CTRL [to:] [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Om