-Caveat Lector- from: http://www.socresonline.org.uk/socresonline/3/2/6.html <A HREF="http://www.socresonline.org.uk/socresonline/3/2/6.html">Kennedy: Coming to Terms with Contemporary Cap </A> --[2]-- The Law of Value, the Universal Equivalent and Capitalist Decline 5.1 One of the central messages in Marx's overall theory was that when labour in the form of wage labour dominates social production relations, the direct social production bonds, which may have characterised earlier societies, are severed. Ideally this defines the situation when the capitalist system reaches its highest potential. An additional ideal when capitalism is at a peak, is that the market system not only regulates social intercourse, but also ensures that social intercourse occurs at the level of individuality, not class. The legal relations established on the basis of Liberal notions of freedom and equality provide this ideal social content with an ideal political form and in so doing consolidate it; just as Utilitarianism provides capitalism with its ideal ethical form. 5.2 The best approximation in the real movement of capitalist history of the development towards such an ideal social and political arrangement, was the period between approximately 1830 and 1914. The crushing of the political aspirations of the masses in the 1848-50 revolutions in Europe and later in the Paris Commune of 1871, went hand in glove with other events such as the abolition of the English poor laws in 1834 (the last bastion of societal wide guarantees of social reproduction of labour outwith the market), and the defeat of the Chartist political movement by the mid nineteenth century. Although a heterogeneity of reasons lay behind much of these events, their ultimate result was that, both directly and indirectly, they facilitated the economic and political atomisation of labour at the hands of capital. In the case of Britain the political atomisation was to last until the development of New Unionism around the 1880s. Before this, however, British Parliamentary reforms of 1832 and 1868, which extended political suffrage to the bourgeoisie, in addition to the repeal of the Corn Laws (1846), confirmed the unbridled political rule of capital. Within this period too the market gained an ontological sovereignty over individuals and classes which was never to be surpassed in subsequent decades. As one historian put it, 'After the excitement of the first half of the nineteenth century. ... Things seemed to be somehow in a state of balance.' (Hopkins, 1979: p. 102). 5.3 Bearing in mind that capitalism subordinates not obliterates past social relations, then, of course, the ideal of the law of value as the dominating social identity is forever being compromised. Nevertheless, one can say with justification that the historic condition and balance of class forces prevalent between approximately 1830 and 1914 were the most conducive ever for the value relation to establish a peak capacity to alienate and exploit labour power. 5.4 The realisation and sustenance of such a capacity is materially substantiated by the development of a world universal equivalent expression of the value form (or, what is the same thing, world money) through the process of commodity fetishism. Commodity fetishism is the process whereby social relations between people create a market which systematically transforms use values into exchange values (prices). To do this systematically requires some common social identity to enable the particular exchange values and particular labour activity to express themselves as general social values and social labour activities, otherwise their relation would be accidental. As Marx proved against Samuel Bailey, the accidental claim is untenable.[11] The common social identity must allow for the negation of the two qualities of use and exchange value, so that each is preserved within the one form, or the one identity. The common social identity does not only ensure the continued transmission and social mediation of particular and private labour time expended into socially necessary universal abstract labour, it also, more fundamentally, ensures the continued dominance of value and profit over differential social needs; that is to say, ensures the continued dominance of the objective basis of commodity fetishism. 5.5 The State or supra State institutions cannot introduce just any universal equivalent (world money) on the basis of legal recognition alone[12], because, as Marx always makes clear, the universal equivalent is the result of the economic and social process of commodity fetishism. [13] Although Marx was not as clear on this issue as he might have been, his ontological presuppositions indicate very strongly that, for him, world money must be expressed by a rather special commodity, because only a commodity can ontologically express both the form (exchange value) and content (abstract labour) of the value relation at the heart of capitalism. It is in this sense that gold expresses the universal equivalent, because it is both the outcome of particular labour and the expression of abstract labour, and has value itself while also being the value form 'incarnate'. Thus the very presupposition of money as universal equivalent and so form of value is its ontological status as a particular value itself. Relative to the latter, the social ontological qualities offered by currencies can only be fictitious not real; in the same way that stock market speculations and the State's creation of money unrelated to present levels of surplus value extraction are (the latter being the essence of Keynesianism). 5.6 Rosdolsky (1989) rightly implies that the establishment of gold as universal equivalent commodity money is the final movement in the full subsumption of differential social needs to exchange value. In fact 'value', 'commodities', 'money', 'having led an antediluvian existence' prior to capitalism, only become Capital within the capitalist mode of production once gold becomes commodity money. In this sense, the development of capitalism is none other than the development of the contradiction between use and exchange value, through its material mediations: as commodity, as value, as money, as capital in and through gold. Each mediation signifies specific social, cultural and political transformations, with the final link in the dialectical chain from commodity to capital, forged with the subordination of labour power to waged labour and mechanised production. Gold is the incarnate expression of this final victory of exchange value over differential social needs and of capital over labour. Thus it is no coincidence that gold as the standard bearer of capitalist ascendancy in circulation paralleled the real subsumption of labour in production. For Marx gold quite simply came to express, as no other form of money could, the substantive heart of the capitalist social relation (Marx, 1973: p. 125). 5.7 Gold figured as world money from 1800 when Sterling and then other national currencies became fixed in relation to it, until 1931, when first Sterling then other national currencies cut themselves adrift from gold. The date 1914, the year the gold standard was first undermined, is, thus, a very significant one. For it ushered in the already latent forces of capitalist decline, measured as a decline in the capacity to subordinate labour power and differential social needs to value and profit. Put simply coming of gold signified certain crucial social transformations within society and the class structure which threatened the ontological sovereignty of market relations. 5.8 Given the fundamental importance of gold, why did capitalism come off the gold standard in 1931? Relatedly, why, having come off gold, has capitalism not reverted back to a gold standard or some other form of universal equivalent in light of the break up of Bretton Woods and the Dollar hegemony by 1971? Finally, why have the European powers consistently found it so difficult to achieve monetary union - effectively a European based 'universal' equivalent - when they so clearly believe that such a move could potentially open the way to a capitalist boom? There are those who point to the inability to harmonise national and inter-state budgets, and the 'cultural differences' between European nations. But, arguably, these are the manifestations not the source of the reasons as to why European capitalism has thus far not been able to revive itself on the basis of monetary union. Indeed, as Thompson has recently pointed out, there was no general Keynesian era of consensus in international political economy, because each economy had to respond to local issues and institutional arrangements (Thompson, 1993). Yet a Keynesian consensus, albeit variably imposed in different nations, was, nevertheless, achieved on the basis of Bretton Woods the Dollar hegemony and its attachment to gold in 1947. In a similar fashion, there is at present no general neo-liberal consensus guiding the global capitalist economy, Europe included. Yet on this occasion there is no real consensus towards establishing a European monetary standard let alone a world money. Why might this be? An answer to this question brings one to the root of modern day manifestations of capitalist decline. 5.9 The key to at least some, but by no means all, of the answers to the questions raised above, lies with the limits imposed on the circulation and expansion of capital by the requirements of the material production of value and the social integration of labour. The very development of capitalist accumulation, in this respect, forces capital in general into a number of contradictory outcomes. Firstly, it leads capital to forsake its essence as circulation capital, as it becomes fixed in the developing forces of production. Secondly, it limits and ultimately reverses the ability of capital to expand value at a rate fast enough to prevent periodic and long term declines in the rate of profit, brought on by the multiple effects of a high organic composition of capital, the overproduction of commodities and recurrent fiscal/monetary crises (see Clarke (1994) for a systematic exposition of Marx's and Marxist theories of capitalist crises). The capitalist system was shaken to its foundations by this contradictory combination in the late nineteenth century, and again during the inter- war depression, and again during the mid nineteen seventies, when the post war settlement was brought to an abrupt end. Thirdly, and by far the most significantly, capitalist development leads to the development of a socially integrated and organised working class, increasingly capable of acting for itself. The history of labour struggle, the development of trade union collectivism and periodic actualisations of labour acting as a class for itself, has been a major feature of the late nineteenth and twentieth century. The most important periods in the West and Europe were the waves of revolutionary unrest in the early part of this century, culminating in the Bolshevik revolution in October 1917 and the global political and industrial militancy of the nineteen sixties and seventies, which were a response to falling investments and the termination of Labourism.[14] 5.10 What is most important to note is that the development of these three interrelated processes effectively destroyed the capitalist system's ability to function on the basis of a universal equivalent commodity money. National capitals, driven by the particularising logic of political, economic, military and social objectives, and by antagonistic classes, and in responding to the three processes described above; have sought to make deals and concessions which necessarily debilitate a specific national capital's capacity and will to remain hidebound by world commodity money, which as world money continually necessitates economic contraction and expansion on the basis of global socially necessary use of labour regardless of national tensions. It is on this basis one can agree with Hirst and Thompson's empirical observations that capitalist development internationalises itself in a process which is saturated with continuity and change for different national and international institutions. 5.11 Although the decline from gold was necessary to the survival of capitalism, it also facilitated the potential for the labour movement's identity as a class for itself to develop. Further still, in taking away the material repository for abstract labour - world money - the dominance of exchange value over social needs was weakened and, relatedly, the perceived 'naturalness' of the profit motive as raison d'etre of productive activity. In effect the decline from gold signifies the decline of the material basis of commodity fetishism which limits class consciousness. From this point on capitalism is in decline and the use of political atomisation to slow down and halt the potential development of a working class identity based on social labour and social need, becomes crucial to the system's survival. 5.12 For these reasons the decline of the value relation is the context for the emergence of finance capital as the dominant fraction within the capitalist class. As Ticktin (1986) has argued, although the tendency may manifests in different ways and to different degrees within national frameworks, one can say that as the basis of capitalist control of labour through commodity fetishism declines, finance capital is forced to take flight (due to the prior development of fictitious capital) into parasitic activity (eg, earning interest through secondary shares and various forms of financial speculation). This has contradictory outcomes for the capitalist system. On the one hand, it further enhance the process of decline by weakening the articulation between fixed and circulation capital thus laying the basis of 'short termism'. However, on the other hand, it also facilitates the development of Labourism (or Social Welfarism), a collective capitalist undertaking to control the working class politically by policing (through administration and bureaucracy) the development of social needs. This 'facilitates Labourism' in the sense that finance capital and related agents of social democracy are forced to make concessions in order to slow down the decline process, while the labour movement is forced to make concessions regarding social needs and productivity in the face of the threat and actuality of sustained unemployment, which parasitic financial relations imply. Labourism was in essence, then, the outcome of a general class compromise which favoured finance capital. 5.13 It was largely on this basis that the major Post World War Two political and economic reforms were made; reforms which in Britain guaranteed full employment and universal social welfare provision. Although I have characterised the process as Labourism, the systemic nature of reforms and regulation of capitalism, have also come to be known as Keynesianism, and/or Fordism.[15] The advantage of 'Labourism' is that it captures the Post War transformation as the subordination of capital through the development of new forms of control over labour. In this sense, the advance of such social mechanisms of control as 'Taylorism' and 'Fordism', and of bureaucracy in general (see, for example, Agliatta, 1979). throughout the early and middle decades of the twentieth century, can be understood as part of the imposition of controls over labour subject to the decline of value relations. Conclusion 6.1 It is the breakdown of Labourism since the mid 1970s that has precipitated the speed up of capitalism's global decline. The capitalist world system brought an end to Labourism as a form of bureaucratic control over social needs, because, beset by problems of declining rates of profit, the system could not afford it, and beset by the problems of a re-politicised labour movement post 1968, the capitalist ruling class could no longer tolerate it.[16] The present period is one in which capitalism, although bringing an end to Labourism, has thus far been frustrated in its ability to acquire the ultimate global presence - world money - that it would most certainly require if it is to draw away from its tendency towards increasing parasitism. Without a basis in world money, capital will remain regional in essence. Indeed without even the basis of some form of 'sub'-world money, eg, the ECU, the trend from 'multi' to 'trans' national organisation will remain limited, dwarfed by the power of the true face of 'global capitalism' today, financial parasitism. However, and this is the crucial point, the will to move towards world money is no longer strong enough to overcome the evident political hurdles it would undoubtedly encounter. The capitalist system is trapped by the material contradictions of accumulation. For example, if capitalism were able to bring international monetary order via some form of world money and, on this basis, were to advance on another 'long wave' of global accumulation, then it would very soon run up against its own material and social barriers. That is it would retain vast amounts of capital in a fixed state in the face of the inevitable downward movement in the rate of profit and the potential challenge of a socially integrated, global, labour movement. The reality, for the foreseeable future at least, is that, in falling between the 'two stools' of 'multi- nationalism' and financial parasitism, the capitalist system has stumbled upon the only forms of control over world labour a declining system can muster: a widespread fear and insecurity based on social exclusion, human deprivation, insecure employment, chronic unemployment and, increasingly, direct political force and repression. 6.2 Given the latter, the prospects for the less 'developed' regions of the world look very bleak to say the least, while the more 'developed' regions can expect no respite in the dismantling of their social democratic foundations. The New Labour Government in Britain, for example, has taken up, not dismantled, the neo-liberal agenda from the previous administration, by seeking to 'balance budgets', isolate the trade unions, bring an end to the universal principle of welfarism, while actively advancing the proliferation of private pension schemes, which are designed more to satisfy the financial market's insatiable demands for fresh avenues of parasitic activity. In fact labour is being made to pay for capitalist decline throughout the Western industrialised hemisphere, as 'flexibility' and casualisation and permanent insecurity of employment are gradually taking on the proportions of a rather traditional form of control over labour across the European Union and the USA. Meanwhile in South Africa, the most 'developed' economy in Africa, the newly established Mandela regime has set about disciplining labour with a vengeance for the benefit of capitalism, via tight monetary policy, the denial of basic social rights in housing and health and the imposition of high levels of unemployment. While this process is in continuance, the dominant world powers, under the guise of the IMF, are busy exporting their neo-liberal model of labour degradation and capitalist decline to the South East Asian economies, where it is working people again who look likely to suffer the consequences of a declining capitalism. 6.3 Capitalism, in all its national variations, is in decline and is thus, by definition, in a state of profound social transition. The argument here has been that the law of value, as the imposition of capital over labour and surplus value over social needs, is in decline and transition. And that, far from the 'end of history' and the triumph of capitalism, or even the movement towards a 'Neo-Lockeian Hegemony', globalism is the manifestation of the attempt by global capital to assert market dominance over social need, in an epoch where exchange value is no longer substantiated by commodity money and in which capital has no other foreseeable systemic mode of control over organised labour except decline, insecurity and semi-depression. The most one can look forward to in the near future, if no real resistance materialises, is increasing parasitism for capital and deprivation for labour. The manifestations of this are the global and local social inequalities, cultural deprivations and increasing degradations of working life which this article briefly referred to earlier. 6.4 The left needs to come to terms with this situation if it wishes to act in a politically cohesive manner to work towards a socialist renewal. A fundamental first step is to move beyond the debate concerning the extent or otherwise of 'globalisation' as an empirical reality and towards addressing the issue of capitalist decline. It is only on this basis that one can salvage a politics of social need able to infuse a mass democratic politics capable of taking us beyond capitalism. Notes 1 May I take this opportunity of thanking the four anonymous referees for their helpful and constructive comments on an earlier draft of this article. 2 I say this notwithstanding Giddens' (1994) claim that politics is moving beyond the traditional demarcation of left and right . Giddens is correct in drawing attention to the end of an era when traditional Parliamentary Politics was defined in terms of delivering social democratic reforms on the basis of top down representation. However, for all intents and purposes, there remains a 'left' and 'right' political agenda defined by its degree of commitment to and belief in the market. In this sense the left has been marginalised from Parliamentary Polit ics, although not from its grassroots, as many of its original members who have sought to remain within Parliamentarianism have been drawn towards the right neo-liberal agenda; an agenda which underlies New Labour's commitment to the rhetoric of 'communitarianism'. 3 By 'parasitism', I refer to the capitalist systems systematic tendency to accumulate fictitious profits through the movement M - M' and, thus, its systematic tendency to by-pass accumulation of surplus value from the direct producers through the circuit M - C - P - C' - M'. Parasitism in this sense has reached a magnitude today never encountered in the history of capitalism. 4 According to Paul Kennedy (1994), 'by the late 1980s, more than 90% of this trading in the world's foreign exchanges was unrelated to trade or capital investment' (p. 51). 5 Walter Rodney (1972) produces a convincing argument. 6 See Hopkins and Wallerstein's (1996) thought provoking and empirically interesting work. All subsequent reference to Hopkins and Wallerstein relates to this book, particularly pp 1 - 10 and 209 - 243. 7 For an overview of some of the debilitating effects of Stalinism on Marxist method see Arthur (1987: pp. 111 - 15). 8 What springs to mind in this respect is the negative response to the work by Hillel Ticktin in the pages of New Intervention over recent years. The debate therein has simply failed to engage with the major substantive issues raised by Ticktin. 9 It is this kind of negative dialectic which characterises contemporary western capitalist society. Under such circumstances identity, often takes the alienated form of a search for 'identity' solely in difference, as is evidenced by post-modernist discourse. However the search for identity is an embedded human condition which does not simply evaporate due to unfavourable conditions. In the context of a decline in the popularity of class identity, individuals become attracted to other 'identities' such as 'gender', 'ethnicity', etc. To be absolutely clear; as necessary expressions of social differentiation they are positive emancipatory forces in society which should not and indeed cannot be overlooked or downgraded. However, as political, non class, identities, they can never of themselves eradicate humanities universal condition of alienation and exploitation. Often, for the best of intentions in most cases, the attempt to assert gender or ethnic identity can lead to the kind of political reformism which strengthens the material conditions sustaining the major social divisions in society. For an extension of this argument see Kennedy (1997). 10 One notable exception is the work carried out in the journal Critique in recent years. For example, see the articles by Hillel Ticktin (1991; 1994) and that by Istvan Meszaros (1991). 11 As Marx (1972) observed, Samuel Bailey's belief that value was something which buyers and sellers imagine in the accidental world of commodity exchange, failed to answer why one commodity - money - could systematically express the value of all other commodities. 12 An argument advanced recently by Geert Reuten (1988). 13 The dialectic between commodities, money, capital as a process of commodity fetishism is established by Marx (1983: chapters 1 - 3). 14 For a detailed assessment of Labourism, see Kennedy (1996). 15 For alternative definitions of Labourism see Gregory (1993) and Thompson (1993). 16 In the case of Britain this reflected itself in the emergence of Thatcherism supported by big business and right wing think tanks. As James Callaghan, ex Labour Leader and Prime Minister, observed on the eve of Thatcher's victory, '...there are times, perhaps once every thirty years, when there is a sea change in politics. It then does not matter what the public wants and what it approves of. I suspect there is now such a sea change - and it is for Mrs Thatcher'. Norris McWhirter reflects on the reasons for founding the right wing group the 'National Association for Freedom' (NAFF), 'In the dark days of 1975, with the IMF knocking at the door of 10 Downing Street, The IRA rampant in London, and 61/4 million fellow citizens inside (trade union) closed shops. ... What was needed was some kind of association which would defend our rights and liberties', both quotations cited from Cockett (1995: p. 286 and p. 221 respectively). References AGLIATTA, M. (1979) A Theory of Capitalist Regulation: The US Experience. London: New Left Books. ARTHUR, Chris (1987) 'Stalinism, Historical Materialism, and Marx's Method', Critique, no 21, pp. 111 - 15. BANK of ENGLAND (1992) Quarterly Bulletin, (November 1992). CALLINICOS, Alex (1994) 'Crisis and Class Struggle in Europe Today', International Socialism, (Summer 1994), no 63. COCKETT, R. (1995) Thinking the Unthinkable. London: Harper-Collins Publishers. COX, R. (1995) International Political Economy: Understanding Global Disorder. London: Zed Books. CLARKE, Simon (1994) Marx's Theory of Crisis. London: Macmillan. FUKUYAMA, Francis (1992) The End of History and the Last Man. London: Penguin Books. GEORGE, Susan (1991) How the Other Half Dies. London: Penguin Books. GIDDENS, Anthony (1990) The Consequences of Modernity. Cambridge: Polity Press. GIDDENS, Anthony (1994) 'Brave New World: The New Context of Politics' in D. Miliband (editor) Reinventing the Left. Cambridge: Polity Press. GRAY, Anne (1995) 'Flexibilisation of Labour and the Attack on Workers' Living Standards', Common Sense, no. 18, p12. GREGORY, E. (1993) Labourism and the English Genius. London: Verso. HALL, S. and M. JACQUES (1989) New Times. London: Lawrence and Wishart. HARVEY, David (1989) The Condition of Post Modernity, (Oxford: Blackwell. HEGEL, G.F. (1975) The Shorter Logic. Oxford: Clarendon Press. HILFERDING, R. (1981) Finance Capital. London: Routledge. HIRST, Paul and Grahame THOMPSON (1996) Globalisation in Question. (Cambridge: Polity Press. HOBSON, A.J. (1988) Imperialism: A Study. London: Unwin Allen. HOPKINS, Eric (1979) A Social History of the English Working Classes. London: Edward Arnold. HOPKINS, T.K. and I. WALLERSTEIN (1996) (editors) The Age of Transition, Trajectory of the World System 1945-2025. London: Zed Books. INGHAM, G. (1984) Capitalism Divided? London: Macmillan. JESSOP, B. (1992) in J. Holloway and W. Bonefeld (editors) The State Debate. London: Macmillan. KAGALITSKY, Boris (1994) 'Russia: From Crisis to Catastrophe', New Intervention, Oct/Nov, vol. 5, nos. 3/4. KEEGAN, William (1993) The Spectre of Capitalism. London: Vintage. KENNEDY, Paul (1994) Preparing For the Twenty-First Century. Cambridge: Fontana Press. KENNEDY, Paul (1996) New Statesmen and Society, (31st May, 1996), pp. 28 - 29. KENNEDY, Peter (1996) 'Decline of Capitalism and Rise of Labourism in Britain: A Theoretical Perspective', unpublished PhD thesis, University of Glasgow. KENNEDY, Peter (1997) 'Reflections on the Dialectic Between Identity and Difference and the Politics of Social Needs', Common Sense, no 20. LASH, Scott and JOHN Urry (1987) The End of Organised Capitalism. Cambridge: Polity Press. LAVALETTE, M. and J. KENNEDY (1996) 'Casual Lives? The Social Effects of Work Casualisation and the lock out on the Liverpool Docks', Critical Social Policy, vol. 16. LENIN, V.I. (1996) Imperialism the Highest Stage of Capitalism. London: Pluto Press. MANDEL, Ernest (1975) Late Capitalism. London: New Left Books. MARX, Karl (1972) Theories of Surplus Value, Part 3. London: Lawrence and Wishart. MARX, Karl (1973) A Contribution to the Critique of Political Economy. London: Progress Publishers. MARX, Karl (1983) Capital: Volume 1. London: Lawrence and Wishart. MEIKLE, S. (1985) Essentialism in the Thought of Karl Marx. London: Duckworth Press. Meszaros, Istvan (1991) 'The Communitarian System and the Law of Value in Marx and Lukacs', Critique, no. 23. OVERBEEK, Henk (1990) Global Capitalism and National Decline: The Thatcher Decade in Perspective. London: Unwin Allen. OVERBEEK, Henk (1993) Restructuring Hegemony in the Global Political Economy: The Rise of Transnational Neo Liberalism in the 1980s. London: Routledge. REAL WORLD COALITION (1996) The Politics of the Real World. London: Earthscan Publications. REUTEN, Geert (1988) 'The Money Expression of Value and the Credit System: A Value Form Theoretical Line', Capital and Class, no 35, Summer. ROBINSON, William I. (1996) 'Globalisation: Nine Theses on our Epoch', Race and Class, vol. 38, no. 2, p15. RODNEY, Walter (1972) How Europe Underdeveloped Africa. Nairobi. ROSDOLSKY, Roman (1989) The Making of Marx's Capital. London: Pluto. RUBIN, I.I. (1973) Essay's on Marx's Theory of Value. New York: Black Rose Books. SKLAIR, Leslie (1995) Sociology of the Global System. Baltimore: John Hopkins University Press. THOMPSON, Graeme (1993) The Economic Emergence of a New Europe: The Political Economy of Co-operation and Competition in the 1990s. Aldershot: Edward Elgar. THOMPSON, W. (1993) The Long Death of Labourism: Interpreting Political Culture. London: Pluto. TICKTIN, Hillel (1986) 'Towards a Theory of Finance Capital', Critique, no. 17. TICKTIN, Hillel (1991) 'The Decline of Capitalism', Critique, no. 23. TICKTIN, Hillel (1994) 'The Nature of an Epoch of Declining Capitalism', Critique, no. 26. WATERS, Malcolm (1995) Globalisation. London: Routledge. WORLD Bank (April, 1997) Transition.Washington DC. Copyright Sociological Research Online, 1998 ----- Aloha, He'Ping, Om, Shalom, Salaam. Em Hotep, Peace Be, Omnia Bona Bonis, All My Relations. Adieu, Adios, Aloha. Amen. Roads End Kris DECLARATION & DISCLAIMER ========== CTRL is a discussion and informational exchange list. Proselyzting propagandic screeds are not allowed. Substance�not soapboxing! These are sordid matters and 'conspiracy theory', with its many half-truths, misdirections and outright frauds is used politically by different groups with major and minor effects spread throughout the spectrum of time and thought. That being said, CTRL gives no endorsement to the validity of posts, and always suggests to readers; be wary of what you read. CTRL gives no credeence to Holocaust denial and nazi's need not apply. Let us please be civil and as always, Caveat Lector. ======================================================================== Archives Available at: http://home.ease.lsoft.com/archives/CTRL.html http:[EMAIL PROTECTED]/ ======================================================================== To subscribe to Conspiracy Theory Research List[CTRL] send email: SUBSCRIBE CTRL [to:] [EMAIL PROTECTED] To UNsubscribe to Conspiracy Theory Research List[CTRL] send email: SIGNOFF CTRL [to:] [EMAIL PROTECTED] Om
