-Caveat Lector-

from:
http://www.socresonline.org.uk/socresonline/3/2/6.html
<A HREF="http://www.socresonline.org.uk/socresonline/3/2/6.html">Kennedy:
Coming to Terms with Contemporary  Cap
</A>
--[1]--

Kennedy, P. (1998) 'Coming to Terms with Contemporary Capitalism: Beyond
the Idealism of Globalisation and Capitalist Ascendancy Arguments'
Sociological Research Online, vol. 3, no. 2,
<http://www.socresonline.org.uk/socresonline/3/2/6.html>

To cite articles published in Sociological Research Online, please
reference the above information and include paragraph numbers if
necessary

Received: 19/1/98      Accepted: 13/5/98      Published: 30/6/98



Abstract

This article challenges the prevailing orthodoxy which suggests that
contemporary global capitalism is in the ascendancy. In the context of
an evaluation of the extensive literature supporting the ascendancy
argument and a brief synopsis of empirical evidence supporting a decline
thesis, a number of alternative theories of capitalist transition are
then assessed. It is argued that each theory, in different ways, offers
an inadequate explanation of contemporary capitalist development. On the
basis of this assessment, the article then contributes to a theory of
capitalist decline by examining and explaining the importance of the
Marxist conception of social law, the law of value and the role of gold
as world money, to an understanding of contemporary capitalism's
transition and decline.[1]

------------------------------------------------------------------------
Keywords:
Capitalism; Capitalist Ascendancy; Globalisation; Marxism; Social
Identity

------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Claims for Capitalist Ascendancy

1.1
The belief that the capitalist system is once again in the ascendancy
has been widely accepted in the present period. People have come to
accept it in a variety of discourses, from post modern to neo-liberal,
to neo-fordist. Without a doubt the most popular intellectual expression
of this discourse at present is the concept of 'globalisation'. It would
appear that no social science degree, scholarly journal or publishing
company would today be complete without the concept of 'globalisation' (
Overbeek, 1993; Sklair, 1995; Waters, 1995). One of the beauties of
'globalisation' is that it acts as a very convenient catchall for a
diversity of methodologies and a variety of substantive concerns from
finance, culture, changing working patterns, to the study of supra
national institutions. If there were any essential claim made by
adherents of 'globalisation' theory it would be that the above social
institutions and structures are losing much of their national/local
character and idiosyncrasies to the logic of 'globalisation'.
1.2
Of course it is a rare bird indeed who argues that the full logic of
'globalisation' can ever become a reality; for example, that
nation-states will reach the point where they become economically and
politically baseless, or that local cultures will disappear under the
homogenising effect of a 'global culture'. Nevertheless, those
expressing an interest in the processes of globalisation would support
the argument that nation-states and local cultural diversities are
becoming transformed beyond recognition by the juggernaut called
'globalisation'. Malcolm Waters, from his vantage point in Tasmania,
gives one a feeling for the hypnotic effect the 'globalisation' process
has on the minds of the academy, when he reflects:

If one can sit here at the spatial edge of human society, looking
northward across the vast desert continent of Australia and southward
towards emptiness and desolation, knowing that one is thousands of miles
from the 'global cities' of Tokyo, Frankfurt, or LA, and still feel that
one is a part of the world, then globalization truly is an impressive
process. (Waters, 1995).

1.3
As intimated above, 'globalisation' is not a self supporting concept,
but is associated with, and derives characteristics from, other concepts
such as 'post- industrialism, 'post modernism', 'post fordism',
'dis-organised capitalism', etc. Anthony Giddens (1990), for example,
has argued that 'globalisation' is linked to the modernist project of
rationalisation, militarisation and industrialisation; themselves the
result, in his view, of a very long historical gestation period. For
David Harvey (1989) the process of 'globalisation', although latent
within capitalist accumulation, is limited historically to The Condition
of Post Modernity, which is a late twentieth century phenomenon,
characterised by the compression of space and time. As Harvey explains,
transformations in, for example, communication, have led to a situation
where time and space become compressed and our conceptions of them have
to adjust as capital becomes 'real time'. For Lash and Urry (1987) the
development of 'globalisation' is synonymous with the 'dis-organisation
of capitalism'. In this scenario capitalism sheds its national
regulatory shell to extend its international domain and to subject
diverse cultures to the logic of consumerism and flexible working.

1.4
Of course one can identity many more slender variations to the theme of
'globalisation'. Despite these variations, however, and notwithstanding
the very real disagreements amongst the theorists who hold to them, not
least as to whether 'globalisation' is progressive or negative, or even
a bit of both, there remains a unifying belief that 'globalisation',
above all else, signifies the ascendancy of global capitalist market
relations. In other words, although 'globalisation' may be seen as
either a cause of great concern, on the one hand, or as a basis for
gleeful optimism, on the other, very few appear to be in much doubt, on
both the right and the left of mainstream politics[2], that capitalist
market relations are extending the commodification of most areas of life
across all four points of the globe, and, moreover, that this is due to
something called 'globalisation'. Robinson epitomises the concerns of
much of the left when declaring that present day 'global capitalism', as
the culmination of 500 years of expansion, 'is tearing down all
non-market structures that, in the past, placed limits on the
accumulation...of capital. Every corner of the globe, every nook and
cranny of social life, is becoming commodified' (Robinson, 1996: p. 15).
The recent claim by Francis Fukuyama (1992) that history with a capital
'H' has come to an end, with the 'last man' standing an irredeemable
supporter of Liberal capitalism, signifies the breadth of this growing
orthodoxy concerning the ascendant nature of capitalism amongst
intellectuals of the right. Fukuyama has little doubt that global social
relations, as we approach the millennium, are the embodiment of Hegel's
zeit geist.

1.5
So powerful is the belief in the globalising ascendancy of capitalism
that many have now drawn the conclusion that there is no alternative. In
this respect William Keegan's (1993) analysis, which culminates with the
belief that The Spectre of Capitalism not communism now haunts society,
takes on the status of a truism. Paul Kennedy's (1996) recent
conclusions that we can either 'brace ourselves for what Schumpeter
termed the creative gales of capitalism'...or come up with 'a new global
Keynesianism', also epitomises the bankruptcy of the social democratic
left perspective when summing up the apparently limited options open to
humanity in the face of capital's global ascendancy; In short, it rarely
enters the discourse of academic reflection that 'globalisation' can be
anything other than an unleashing of the 'creative' gales of capitalism,
which one can attempt to 'regulate' or simply allow its head (depending
on political predisposition), but can never transcended.

1.6
One of the few notable exceptions to the globalisation thesis has been
Hirst and Thompson (1996). They argue that there are few substantive or
theoretical grounds for a 'strong globalisation' thesis (p. 195). For
Hirst and Thompson, globalisation is really the continued, if uneven,
development of inter- nationalisation, wherein the power to control
economic, political and social processes gyrates between national and
international actors and institutions (p. 195). They imply that
'globalisation' as a concept is materially rooted in the decline of Pax
Americana (p. 5), which has heralded the shift in power relations
between national and international actors and institutions, brought
about by the decline of Bretton Woods, the abandoning of exchange
controls and liberalisation of financial market. Hirst and Thompson
suggest that, contrary to globalisation arguments, Multi-national
companies (MNCs) with strong national linkages, not Transnational
companies (TNCs), remain predominant; while trade links, capital
investments and financial flows remain concentrated between Europe,
North America and Japan and so remain far from global in orientation (p.
2). In fact, on the basis of statistical trends in migration, trade and
capital flows, Hirst and Thompson can claim that our present
'globalised' world is less inter- national than it was in the decades
leading up to 1913 (pp. 26 - 27).

1.7
While perhaps too narrowly focused on its economic dimensions, Hirst and
Thompson's criticism of 'globalisation' is commendable. Their theme of
internationalisation, however, remains fully within the prevailing
discourse which suggests that capitalism is very much in the ascendancy.
 Hirst and Thompson are merely more nuanced in their proposition that
capitalism ascends through a combined and uneven continuity of
inter-nationalisation. Nevertheless, regardless of the depth of change
capitalism is subjected to; the open ended and contingent
transformations within national and international institutions and
processes is always and in every case a function of this ascendancy.
 Their adherence to an ascendancy perspective facilitates their
acceptance of a reformist politics which limits its horizons to the
rather abstract hope that 'International co-ordination, governance by
co-operation between the major trade blocs, and national mobilisation in
favour of such international objectives offer possibilities for creating
a newly ordered and prosperous world economy' (pp. 199 - 200). Empirical
evidence of capitalist decline (which is assessed briefly below and
which Hirst and Thompson choose to ignore in their emphasis on economic
evidence) suggests such a conclusion, however well intentioned, is both
abstract and politically naive.




Exposing the Myth of Ascendancy

2.1
The magnitude of claims depicting the apparent ascendancy of capitalism
may be considerable, however there is an unavoidable problem; the claims
simply do not square with the evidence. Despite the supposed 'triumph of
capitalism' after the fall of Stalinism, or arguments that reformist
policies are what are required, one is overwhelmed by evidence of
rapidly increasing levels of poverty and social exclusion, which have
spread into all parts of the globe; North, South, East and West. The
nature and extent of the evidence, far from signifying the vibrancy of
the capitalist system which evidence of sustained social divisions and
inequalities usually do, suggests that capitalism is in a chronic
structural state of decline.
2.2
The decline of the capitalist relation manifests in a variety of ways.
One can observe the decline in the parasitic activities[3] of the global
finance markets, whose institutions are more interested in 'investing'
in fictitious future markets and de-industrialising present ones than
advancing long term capital investments. According to a Bank of England
survey by 1992 almost one trillion dollars were traded daily in the
world's leading money markets; 90% more than the system requires to aid
valorisation. An increasingly high proportion of this trade is conducted
in transactions with a high parasitic content, for example, in exchange
derivatives such as 'swaps', 'futures' and 'forward contracts' (Bank of
England, 1992). The scale of the trade in money and money derivatives
far outstrips the physical trade of commodities and is increasingly
indifferent to the latter.[4] The City of London, which accounts for 30%
of total daily global money market turnover ($300 billion), witnessed a
120% increase in its 'futures' market (eg. parasitic contracts which
extract profit by gambling on the future relative values of currencies).
 While, according to the same survey, across the matrix of leading
financial centres, 'Business in futures and options...has increased
rapidly' (Bank of England, 1992). The scope, scale and power of the
international transactions conducted, have bent Western Governments to
the will of parasitic capital, forcing policy of an increasingly
irrational nature; as witnessed in the US in recent years with the
perverse raising of interest rates at the first sign of a substantial
improvement in the rate of unemployment! Currently financial
speculations are busy calling an abrupt halt to the so called Asian
Tiger economies; once the pride and joy of pro Western capitalist
commentators, now, apparently, the scourge of a (failed) neo-liberal
alternative.

2.3
More poignantly one observes the manifestations of capitalist decline in
the profound squalor, social degradation and abuse of human rights, not
only in those purposely under developed regions of the world,[5] but,
increasingly, in the heartlands of the industrialised West. According to
the World Bank the international base line figure for absolute poverty
is $370 (1985) per annum. Not withstanding the fact that this base line
for sustaining life is pitiably low (the average income of full time
workers in Britain is currently �385 per week!), the implications of
this indicator remain breathtaking. In percentage terms it is estimated
that 51% of the population (304 million people) of sub Saharan Africa,
37% of the population in South Asia and 25% of the population of Latin
America and the Caribbean will be below this poverty line by the year
2000! If this was not enough, while the populations of the purposely
under developed regions of the world slip further towards the social
abyss, their total external trading debt with the West continues to
rise, thus guaranteeing their continued decline into the abyss. For
example trade debt has risen from $100 billion to $1500 billion between
1970-92 (Real World Coalition, 1996). The Human consequences are tragic.
According to Susan George (1991), in areas of the third world, 'fully
half of the children can be expected to die of hunger- related illness
before the age of five', while 'in the world as a whole, easily a fifth
of all children..are judged to be malnourished', and, 'one of every
eight people in the world is literally starving'. Indeed, argues George,
'almost half [of the world's child population] suffer from malnutrition
of one kind or another'.

2.4
A not too dissimilar picture can be painted of the previously defined
'second world', especially the former Soviet Union, again after 'global
capitalist' intervention from the 'first world'. Russia, having opened
up its borders to 'globalisation', has recently faced a sharp increase
in economic and social crisis. Foreign direct investment fell by roughly
40% during the course of 1996-7. It is not hard to understand some of
the reasons why; against the backdrop of an outdated industrial
structure, wage debt escalated to 50 trillion roubles by March 97, while
inter-enterprise debt soared to 490 trillion roubles, or 25% of GDP. The
fall in foreign investment coupled with a rapid deterioration in the
income and capital tax base, has halved State revenues and spending
plans, thus precipitating a social welfare crisis of enormous
proportions(World Bank, 1997: p. 9). The massive decline in living
conditions have combined to reduce the birth rate, increase the
mortality rate and reverse the average life expectancy. As Boris
Kagalitsky (1994) explains, diseases thought to be conquered by modern
science and progress have reappeared with a vengeance in Russia, to
claim many lives.

2.5
Of course capitalist decline is first and foremost a global process and
as such is all too evident within western economies. Since the
termination of the post war boom, for example, social inequality has
increased to a degree which lends empirical support to Marx's
immiseration thesis. Taking Britain as an example. between 1979-90 real
net income - after housing costs (that is, access to food, clothing and
cultural pursuits) - had declined by 18% for the bottom 10% of the
population, whilst the top 10% income bracket had experienced a real net
increase of 20%. In so far as the basic requirement of shelter is conc
erned, between 1978-93 those officially classified homeless had risen
four-fold. Moreover, according to the Town and Country Planning
Association, during the course of the past twenty years, the quality of
housing has deteriorated significantly, compounding all the associated
material and physical deprivations that the lack of basic human shelter
requirements brings in its wake (Real World Coalition, 1996: pp. 67 - 79
).

2.6
Other manifestations of capitalist decline in the West are the
capitalist system's inability to pander to the labour reforms and the
modicum of job security enjoyed after 1945 and often referred to
variously as Keynesianism, Fordism, and/or Labourism Today labour, under
the ideological ruse of 'flexible working', has been increasingly
reduced, once more, to the status of a commodity. For example, less than
a third of jobs created between 1992 and 1996 were full-time As Gray
(1995) reveals a vicious circle of 'flexploitation' is well underway,
whereby 'new forms of work weaken workers' capacity to organise, which
in turn facilitate further 'flexibilisation' and intensification of
exploitation'. Contrary to perceived wisdom which suggest that the
motive is either the benign or even malign logic of capitalist
ascendancy, this about turn from the Keynesian/Labourist compromises of
the past has been forced upon an ailing capital, for two reasons;
firstly, because of the downward pressure that this post war settlement
with the labour movement placed on the rate of profit; and, secondly,
perhaps more importantly, because of the tendency for the reforms
inherent to social welfarism to be transformed into real political
leverage for labour in the class struggle (see Kennedy, 1996). However,
whether forced on capitalism or not, one thing is clear, the
insecurities and inhumanities of such a recommodified status, both at
the workplace and the wider community, has come to the surface with a
vengeance in recent years, especially so after the defeat of the
mineworkers in 1984-5. The casualised, insecure and stressful nature of
work in the Dockyards of Britain, for example, with the abolition of the
National Dock Labour Scheme in 1989, reveals the dehumanising effect of
the recommodification of labour most starkly. In this respect the twenty
nine month lockout of Liverpool dockers is the latest manifestation of
capitalism's new callous attitude to labour (Lavalette and Kennedy, 1996
).

2.7
Of course Britain has not been alone amongst Western States in feeling
the force of capitalist decline. Despite continued resistance (which is
far from settled either way), French, German and other European workers
have experienced attacks on their living standards, as national capitals
have sought to cutback on their post war settlements with labour (
Callinicos, 1994). Across the Atlantic in the richest economy in the
world, social decay has advanced at a rapid pace. According to the US
Bureau of Census (1972), for example, 'at least 10 to 12 million
Americans are starving or sick because they have too little to spend on
food' (cited in George, 1991). The US as the originator of the
'downsizing', 'jobless growth' and the casualising of working life
associated with the process of 'flexploitation', has subjected the
average American worker to perhaps the highest degree of job insecurity
and work intensification within the industrialised west.

2.8
The evidence, if one were to continue to compile it, is overwhelming in
its condemnation of a global system out of control and rotten to its
core. As Hillel Ticktin has put it, 'The world disorder..seems to be
continuing and indeed gathering strength' (Ticktin, 1994). The scale of
such evidence of decline is matched only by the scale of assertion,
masquerading as argument, depicting the ascendancy of capitalism. One
might argue that the negative features described above are endemic to
capitalist expansion and have been since its inception, proving in many
ways that it is operating 'as normal'. While this is correct to a
degree, the argument here is that these manifestations are no longer a
by-product of antagonistic class relations in the quest to expand
capital, but instead are the grotesque features of contemporary
capitalist survival and stagnation. The manifestations are in fact the
product of an essential aspect of decline; capital is becoming
increasingly parasitic on its money form of existence and increasingly
incapable of meeting social needs of both global and local dimensions.
As argued later in more detail, the 'reciprocal' relationship between
the world of 'value expansion' and the world defined by social needs has
become strained to its break point. The profound squalor and social
degradation are the manifestations of a qualitative turn within the
capitalist system. The level of poverty and social exclusion, which the
supposed 'triumph of capitalism' leaves in its wake, has reached
astounding levels and can no longer be seen as a ('unfortunate') by
product of its growth and development (as will be explained below).

2.9
The scale of evidence for decline makes it all the more necessary to
develop a coherent political response from the global labour movement.
Developing a theory of capitalist decline and transition has a major
part in this process. Such a theory requires a predisposition to seeing
capitalism as a historically evolving and limited social form. It also
requires an analysis able to negotiate and throw light on how the
historically specific social categories of capitalism develop to a state
of transition.




Radical Theory and 'Capitalist Transitions'

3.1
The gross disjuncture between assertions about capitalism's ascendancy
and the clear evidence of its decline, has in many ways kept the embers
of a notion of transition, if not decline, burning on the margins of
academia both within and without Marxism. The school of thought
associated with critical international political economy has attempted
to contribute to our understanding of social transformations within
capitalism by conceptualising the nature of 'epochal shifts' which are
said to occur between societies and within capitalism. Robert Cox, a
leading figure within the school, suggests that a minimum but crucial
starting point is a theoretical commitment to a historical dialectic
 method, which enables one to grasp the dynamic of change within
(synchronic) and between (diachronic) social structures. Particularly
important to understand, argues Cox (1995), is the diachronic type
change (eg. the dialectics of the transition from one social system to
another).
3.2
The purpose of the historical dialectic in a diachronic account is to
reveal the limits of the present system and the ways in which it can and
is being transcended. However, despite the laudable commitment to theory
as a social praxis, Cox (1995) and other critical theorists remain
handicapped by an idealist conception of what constitutes a historical
dialectic. Hettne, for example, following Cox's explicit methodology,
suggests that an 'historical dialectical' explanation of epochal type
shifts within capitalism can be acquired through the construction of two
heuristic concepts which overlap in history; namely, the movement of a
'Westphalian' political order (brought into being in the mid seventeenth
century and based on the idea of competing, but independent sovereign
nation states) towards a 'post Westphalian' political order (based on
the more modern development of supra-national institutions).

3.3
In a similar fashion, Van de Pijl suspends the development of capitalist
social relations over a period of three hundred years, between two
conceptual abstractions; 'Lockeian' and 'Hobbesian' state/society
complexes. Apparently, the 'Glorious Revolution' of 1688 ushered in a
'Lockeian' political hegemony securing England's and later Britain's
free market/strong state road to international hegemony. Subsequent
capitalist development is then characterised by the hegemonic
development of 'Hobesian' state/society complexes. The latter's
commitment to strong state interventionism (and here, notably, one can
include social formations as diverse as Bismarckian Germany and the
USSR) eventually challenges the 'Lockeian hegemony'. Thus, according to
Van de Pijl, the collapse of Stalinism and the new global rapaciousness
of capitalism, which peaked together in 1989, becomes none other than
evidence of a second glorious revolution which finally establishes the
global and trans-state hegemony of the 'Lockeian' state/society complex.


3.4
Although by no means lacking explanatory value, heuristic concepts of
this ilk are profoundly ahistoric, in the sense that they fail to
substantiate themselves within the social categories of capitalism, and
specifically the manner in which such categories have transformed and
become transformed over the course of capitalist development by class
struggle (an issue we return to later). Can one seriously inform the
inhabitants of those African economies blighted by the re-imposition of
global trade, that it is all due to the emergence of a trans-state
configuration of a 'Lockeian state/society complex'?

3.5
The apparently more materialistic approach of, what has become known as
'World Systems Theory', also falls prey to the tendency to superimpose
upon historical development abstract generalisations which tend to
obscure more than they reveal. In a recent example of this approach,
Hopkins and Wallerstein (1996)[6] attempt a prognosis of the present and
future based on transformations within changing 'vectors' (social sub-
systems) of labour, state relations, welfare forms, knowledge
systems..etc. There are said to be six such 'vectors' in all, and all
are functions of the 'modern world system' which has been in existence,
argue Hopkins and Wallerstein, since the sixteenth century.

3.6
A particular ensemble of 'vectors' organised on the basis of 'long
waves' of accumulation are said to define particular 'long waves' in the
relentless development of 'the modern world system'. Is the present
neo-liberal period merely another long wave in its down phase, or does
it herald some kind of terminal crisis? According to Hopkins and
Wallerstein, the 'modern world system' has both 'cycles and trends'
which restore equilibrium, but also move society continually away from
equilibrium. This 'dialectic' they suggests, must at some point in the
system's development bring about a profound crisis, heralding a long
period of transition towards a new system. Yet, despite a detailed
account of the changes within each 'vector' during the period 1945 to
1990, Hopkins and Wallerstein remain ambiguous as to what the future
will be. They consider two possibilities, but remain non committal;
 either the system will revitalise itself, or it will terminate due to
the successful challenge to it from a number of trends, including
anti-statism, anti- scientism, anti-secularism and a pro ecological
movement. One can recognise the complexity and degree of openendedness
of contemporary capitalist society, while still expecting a clear
prognosis which does not slide into deterministic causal prediction.

3.7
Questions have to be asked of a theory which can posit both the
possibility of systemic renewal and terminal decline. Specifically, one
has to enquire into the concept of 'world system' deployed. One should
not be surprised to find that it is in fact a highly mechanistic and
functionalist concept, constructed, not out of historically specific
social relations between real individuals, social groups and classes,
but out of smaller mechanical 'sub-systems' called 'vectors'. Given such
a 'systems analysis', one can easily re-arrange the social actors as
well as the 'systems' themselves, to conceptualise any number of
scenarios. Of course the scenarios one constructs are limited by
empirical rigour (which is why Hopkins and Wallerstein limit themselves
to two scenarios). Nevertheless, whether one has two or two hundred
scenarios, they are ultimately fashioned out of conceptual acumen and
not the historically specific social relations from which they ought to
be derived if future social trends are to be clearly discerned.

3.8
Modern Marxism has fared little better than some of the radical theories
described above. Often they have fared worse, especially when exuding
the 'atomistic' ontology so rightly rejected by critical international
political economy. The atomistic ontology which has sunk itself into
Marxism reveals itself when Marxists refer to capitalist decline as
something 'ebbing', 'shrinking', or dwindling'..etc. Indeed, when these
words refer to manifestations of capitalism such as declining rates of
profitability, balance of payments crises..etc, they are adequate
expressions. However, as I hope to explain below, such words do not
capture the deeper meaning of decline implicit in Marxism. Ultimately
they deal in the more superficial conceptual currency of 'long wave
theory' (see for example Mandel, 1975); or debates surrounding
'Post-Fordism/Post Capitalism (eg. Agliatta, 1979; Hall and Jacques,
1989; Jessop, 1992) or, with theories linking, in one way or another,
capitalist decline with developments of divisions within and between
capital which led to imperialism and eventually the parasitic dominance
of finance capital (see, for example, Hilferding, 1981; Ingham, 1984;
Hobson, 1988; Overbeek, 1990; Lenin, 1996). While they are valuable
components of a complete theory of decline, they do not amount to a
theory of decline as such. Like the radical theory above, they amount
only to a discussion of either 'cycles' or 'shifts' within the
expansionary logic of capital.

3.9
Bearing in mind the reification suffered by Marxist theory at the hands
of Stalinism,[7] one can understand the suspicion raised by Marxists and
radical theorists when confronted with theories of decline which
continue to embrace laws of development and laws of decline/transition.
It is of little surprise that Marxists who do write about decline find
themselves either ignored, or else, openly disparaged by those closest
to Marxism.[8] Nevertheless, one has to say that, in dismissing and/or
deriding notions of, what are at base socially constructed, 'laws' tout
a feit, such people operate with a misconception of Marxism which
seriously hinders their wider understanding of the negative
manfestations of contemporary capitalist decline outlined earlier. It is
of paramount importance to overcome the deafening silence which has
gripped Marxists and socialists on the subject of social laws and,
relatedly, capitalist decline. The denial of the explanatory power of a
Marxism based on social laws has made much of modern Marxism at best
evasive about the future and at worst mute in the face of arguments
celebrating capital's global ascendancy. The remainder of this article
is given over to highlighting the explanatory power of Marxist notions
of social law and, on the basis of this, drawing out the kind of theory
of capitalist transition and decline which explains the empirical
evidence and which contemporary Marxism should be focusing on.




An Outline of the Ontological Presuppositions of Social Law

4.1
According to the reviewer of Marx's first volume of Capital for the May
1872 edition of The European Messenger, St Petersburg, Marxism's
principal and ultimate objective is to disclose through scientific
investigation:
the special laws that regulate the origin, existence, development, death
of a given social organism and its replacement by another and higher
one. (Marx, 1983: p. 28).

4.2
Marxism is intellectually indebted to both Aristotle and Hegel for
defining the ontology nature of the 'special laws' of society referred
to above (Meikle, 1985). In taking account of this two- fold
intellectual debt it would seem fitting to identify the Marxist approach
to social laws as being that of dialectical essentialism. Central to
dialectical essentialism are its defining concepts; 'essence',
identity/difference', 'dialectics', 'law' and 'negation'. The
relationships pertaining between these concepts are central to an
understanding of the kind of thing Marxism has in mind when defining and
explaining 'social laws', especially the 'law of value' and its
development, decline and transition within capitalist society. We
therefore need to consider, briefly, the relationships between the
concepts.

4.3
Identity and difference, for Marxism, refers specifically to the
contradiction between identity and difference which provides the inner
dynamic, so to speak, of social laws. The ultimate contradiction for
humanity is that individuals in so far as they are social beings must
derive their individual identity in and through society, while at the
same time, to salvage individuality, they must also strive to maintain
some semblance of their difference vis-a-vis society. This is a
necessary condition of social life, with the important caveat that each
society particularises its perceptions of identity and difference and
the contradictory modes of their existence. In class bound societies,
for example, individuals experience a double identity, as both members
of a class and as species beings of society. For Marxists, this
'doubling' of identity is the basis of alienation, because it is only in
and through the lived experience of class that individuals can mediate
their species, or society identity and, in the process ground their
individuality.

4.4
As one might expect, this alienated form of mediation restricts the
development of individuality, because it restricts an individual's
capacity to assert their differences with each other and the social
totality in a variety of ways. This explains some of the reasons why
individuals are reluctant on most occasions to identify themselves with
a class (their alienated form of identity), even though acting as a
class is foundational to abolishing the very condition of their
alienation. Thus, only on certain occasions can individuals be drawn to
act as a class on the stage of history, usually because their lives have
become insufferable. This is one major reason why most complex versions
of Marxism do not assume and need to assume that classes stalk the
historical stage on a daily basis.

4.5
The class bound nature of society, then, sets in a double negative for
individuals: in so far as their social (class) identity is the basis of
their alienation, it becomes a condition to be denied, misconceived or
shirked at the cultural and political level; this, in turn, sustains and
facilitates the economic basis of class divisions, making any meaningful
non class identity an impossibility. The overall result is that species
identity is often seen as unobtainable and is denied as 'essentialist
mythology'.[9]

4.6
A further theoretical clarification is to suggest that social law is the
movement of the contradiction between identity and difference. In other
words, social laws are dialectical movements generated by individuals as
they strive for difference through identity. More specifically still,
social laws of development, decline and transition, refer generally to
the movement of the social contradiction between, on the one hand, the
identity imposed by determinate social production relations and, on the
other hand, the condition of difference imposed by the need for
individuals to freely express their powers and capacities.

4.7
Although social production relations (generally class relations) impose
an alienated social identity on individuals, this imposition has its
limits which are set by the degree to which the system can provide for
at least some expression of individuality. This is the measure of the
system's development, decline and transition. In the developmental phase
the system offers a majority of individuals a sense of freedom (no mater
how attenuated by class position), especially relative to the
limitations of a previous social system. In the decline and transition
phase, the system suffers a double loss: it loses both its capacity to
impose its own mode of alienated class bound identity and it loses any
capacity it may once have had to provide adequate expression for even
the most narrowly defined, attenuated individuality.

4.8
In capitalist society, specifically in its developmental phase, the
capacity to impose an alienated form of social identity is realised
through the process of commodity fetishism, wherein the movement of
humanity through identity and difference is established through
commodity production and circulation. For those who own, manage, or
exert some control over their own work and other people's work, the
standard of living attained and the sense of 'freedom' realised in the
market place, does provide space for a limited sense of individual self
expression. For the majority the limits to freedom are even narrower.

4.9
Even in such developmental phases, however, capitalist production
relations, through the intrusion of the value form (of which more below)
- and its manifestation, the market - polarise humanity's expression of
social identity and difference as no other society has done before. The
fetishism at the heart of this (in)human relation is revealed in its
most stark theoretical form in neo-classical economics; jointly, in the
concept of 'consumer sovereignty' and 'rational homo-economicus'.
Nevertheless, in so far as capitalism unleashes the forces of
production, it at least lays the potential for a more thorough
assimilation of social identity and difference; a process implicit in
Marx's depiction of communism as 'freedom from necessity' (note, not the
abolition of necessity, as per post-modernism). By the same token,
capitalism's decline phase would be signified by the loss of its
capacity to impose control through commodity fetishism and its capacity
to guarantee even the narrowest definitions of 'freedom' and
'individuality'; in other words signified by social exclusion,
deprivation and financial parasitism.

4.10
Up to this point we have assessed identity and difference as the basis
of 'social laws' and contradiction as the inner dynamic of social
opposition and social unity. However, the more adequate dynamics of
'social laws' (their development and decline) can be understood by
referral to the concept of essential mediation. Essential mediation is
the real ontological foundation in and through which identity and
difference gain their existence. Without the capacity of mediation the
relationship between identity and difference could be mistaken as
discrete and mere externality; in a word, without contradiction. As
Hegel (1975) observes, 'So long as the one is fixed as one, it is
certainly impossible to regard its congression with others as anything
but external and mechanical'. For Marxism, alert to Hegel's warning
regarding atomist ontology, the essential mediating social category
grounding social identity and difference in capitalist society is
abstract labour. Specifically, abstract labour is the substance of value
relations (eg. social relations expressed in alienated form through the
market), while money (especially world money) is the formal expression
of value relations (see Rubin, 1973). The point to stress here is that,
for Marxists, the content and form of value relations effectively limits
real substantive freedom by ensuring that the acquisition of
differential social needs, as the basis for the fulfilment of social
identity, is systematically subordinated to the status of commodity
ownership in the pursuit of surplus value.

4.11
It is the above general ontological position on social law, or something
very similar to it, which guides a number of recent Marxist attempts to
locate a theory of capitalist decline and transition.[10] Ticktin (1991)
, a leading advocate in the development of a theory of capitalist
decline, puts it thus; 'If we start from the proposition that capitalism
must be understood in terms of its laws of motion, then it is the law of
value which is in decline and hence the social relations underlying the
law of value' (p. 155). I wish to extend this and further insights made
by Ticktin in the following section, by briefly examining the connection
between the law of value (as the capitalist systemic form of social
identity) and capitalist decline (as the emergence in embryo of an
alternative form of social identity based on differential social needs).
 This further elaboration requires that one explain something that
rarely gets attention: the central developmental relationship between
abstract labour and the role and capacity of Gold as commodity money and
the subordination of the realisation of differential social needs. One
must begin by explaining briefly the essential ontological
determinations of the law of value and the social derivation of money
and, on this basis, develop an understanding of the centrality of gold
as the social expression of capitalist relations and the implications of
this for a world set adrift from the Gold Standard.
--[cont]--
Aloha, He'Ping,
Om, Shalom, Salaam.
Em Hotep, Peace Be,
Omnia Bona Bonis,
All My Relations.
Adieu, Adios, Aloha.
Amen.
Roads End
Kris

DECLARATION & DISCLAIMER
==========
CTRL is a discussion and informational exchange list. Proselyzting propagandic
screeds are not allowed. Substance�not soapboxing!  These are sordid matters
and 'conspiracy theory', with its many half-truths, misdirections and outright
frauds is used politically  by different groups with major and minor effects
spread throughout the spectrum of time and thought. That being said, CTRL
gives no endorsement to the validity of posts, and always suggests to readers;
be wary of what you read. CTRL gives no credeence to Holocaust denial and
nazi's need not apply.

Let us please be civil and as always, Caveat Lector.
========================================================================
Archives Available at:
http://home.ease.lsoft.com/archives/CTRL.html

http:[EMAIL PROTECTED]/
========================================================================
To subscribe to Conspiracy Theory Research List[CTRL] send email:
SUBSCRIBE CTRL [to:] [EMAIL PROTECTED]

To UNsubscribe to Conspiracy Theory Research List[CTRL] send email:
SIGNOFF CTRL [to:] [EMAIL PROTECTED]

Om

Reply via email to