-Caveat Lector-
http://www.kingston.ac.uk/cusp/Lectures/Thompson.htm
Gaia Anti-Christ and the Ex-Files:
A Trawl through the Cultic Milieu
Damian Thompson
5 March 1997
Kingston University
At the end of 1995 the radical Jewish magazine New Moon
printed a long and disturbing news feature under the
inspired headline "The Icke Man Cometh". The article,
billed as a "special investigation", began as follows:
"It is has been hard in recent years to ignore the
popularity of almost everything that comes under the heading
New Age. Yoga, meditation, Kabbalah, Buddhism, alternative
medicine, environmentalism, self-improvement and New Age
therapies have all gained in popularity, as have all other
fringe interests like UFOS and the paranormal. But during
the past year, a dark side to the New Age message of
sweetness and light has become increasingly clear."
According to the authors of the piece, Matthew Kalman and
John Murray, a small number of influential New Age leaders
are embracing conspiracy theories which are heavily
influenced by the racist ideology of the far right. The
article singled out David Icke, the former Coventry City
goalkeeper and BBC sports commentator whose public
declaration in 1990 that he was a son of God, and henceforth
would dress only in turquoise, furnished the media with
perhaps the most hilarious news story of the year. Well,
you can stop laughing, said Kalman and Murray: for in the
course of his eccentric spiritual pilgrimage, David Icke
has turned into a fully fledged New Age Nazi.
Kalman and Murray went on to quote from a book published by
Icke in 1994 called The Robot's Rebellion in which his
well-established Green views are overlaid by a fantastical
tapestry of far-right conspiracy theories. Icke's villains
are Jews, Freemasons, bankers, the FBI, the gun control
lobby and aliens; indeed, he describes "Jehovah, the
vengeful God of the Jews" as "quite possibly an
extra-terrestrial." The Robot's Rebellion sold so well in
New Age circles that it went into three editions; a year
later Icke followed it up with a book called ... and the
truth shall set you free, advertised as "the most explosive
book of the 20th century", in which he proclaims that
"almost every major negative event of global significance
has been part of the same plan by the All-Seeing Eye cult to
take over the planet via a centralised world government,
central bank, currency [Eurosceptics please note] and army."
Icke also describes this cult as "the Illuminati" and "the
Brotherhood", but it soon becomes clear that he is most
interested in its incarnation as "a global Jewish clique".
Icke's antisemitism is of an exotic variety, increasingly
well entrenched on the far right, which in addition to
blaming the Jews for the First World War and the Russian
Revolution, also holds them responsible for the worst
excesses of Third Reich, including the Holocaust. Icke
accuses Jewish bankers of funding Hitler's rise to power; he
urges his readers to take Holocaust revisionism seriously;
and explains how anti-semitic persecution is the creation
of "thought patterns in the collective Jewish mind...
They expect it; they create it."
Kalman and Murray's purpose in writing their article, which
they followed up with a cover story in the New Statesman,
was not just to expose the egregious Icke as a Neo-Nazi.
Their point was that his views are representative of a
significant strand of thought on the New Age movement.
In his books, Icke enthusiastically plugs and Australian
New Age magazine called Nexus which carries article by US
militia leaders and dabbles in Holocaust revisionism;
its circulation is 130,000, more than four times that of the
New Statesman. Compare, too, Icke's distinctive brand of
antisemitism with an article in the British New Age journal
Rainbow Ark on the subject of modern Israel. "When a person
has a strong hatred of another race," it says, "their higher
self often (karmically) makes sure they incarnate in that
race to balance them out, thus many of the worst kind of
Nazis have already incarnated in Jewish bodies, explaining
therefore some of the fireworks which are going on in
Israel." Rainbow Ark, incidentally, often held public
meetings at the Battlebridge New Age centre in London's
Kings Cross. When interviewed by Kalman and Murray, the
centre's organiser, Julie Lowe, said she personally believed
in the authenticity of the notorious antisemitic forgery
The Protocols of the Elders of Zion. As she explained:
"I met two old Jewish men at Hyde Park Corner one evening
who told me... that if they didn't get their way in the
things they wanted, they were able through Philadelphia in
America to pull the money out of every city in the world.
I've seen it happen in Sheffield, so I believe it."
New Age Nazis, as New Moon calls them, might seem too
contemptible and ridiculous to merit serious attention.
In fact, they go to the very heart of what I want to discuss
in this lecture, which is the astonishing capacity of ideas
rejected by society at large to make connections with other
ideas with which they appear to have nothing in common, but
which, for one reason or another, are regarded as beyond the
pale by the dominant forces in society. On the face of it,
Neo-Nazis and the New Age movement are poles apart,
politically and culturally; dig below the surface, however,
and we discover that the alignment of the poles is not what
we imagine it to be. (As we shall see, I use these terms
advisedly.)
It is well known, I think, that Hitler was a vegetarian
non-smoker, and that his regime's obsession with a Teutonic
mythic past of forests and mountains, together with its
distrust of capitalism, made it Europe's first
environmentally-aware government. For the most part,
this fact is treated by commentators as little more than
an unhappy coincidence: it hardly tars the Green movement
with the Nazi brush, and it certainly does not explain why
Green New Agers should be susceptible to theories of racial
supremacy. But the bizarre correspondence between the
views of Icke, Nexus and Rainbow Ark on the one hand and
supporters of the Third Reich on the other is not a matter
of simple coincidence; and it cannot be dismissed as the
sudden and inexplicable collective insanity of a few members
of an otherwise entirely beneficent movement.
A few years ago Nicholas Goodrick-Clarke's book The Occult
Roots of Nazism argued, as its title implies, that the
origins of the Third Reich lay partly in esoteric
speculation. Many leading Nazis are thought to have
belonged to secret societies which tapped into the West's
occult tradition; indeed, some of the racial theorists who
inspired the Nazis relied as much on occult fantasy as they
did on pseudo-science or Nordic myth. To give just one
example: Lanz von Liebenfels, a renegade Catholic monk who
as an old man was visited by Hitler, believed that there
were originally two breeds of people, heroes and apemen, the
one blond, athletic and clever, the other cruel, greedy and
stupid. As a result of miscegenation, the human race now
consisted mostly of mongrel mixtures of hero and animal:
the Jews, predictably, were virtually pure apeman, while
Aryans were the closest thing to pure hero.
The notion of races of men who existed before the dawn of
history, or even conventional pre-history, is (to use
a metaphor which would appeal to the far right) one of
the great leitmotifs of alternative science and history.
"Alternative", in this context, refers to theories which
lie outside established orthodoxy. In other words, we are
dealing with information that society rejects; and later
in this lecture I will explain what I mean by this rather
loosely-defined concept. But before moving on from the
New Age Nazis, I want to turn to a remarkable piece of
research which, by following the trail of one particular
"alternative" idea, gives us a very clear picture of the
strange cultural environment in which New Agers and
National Socialists overlap and mingle.
In his book Arktos, published in 1993, Joscelyn Godwin,
a British historian of esoteric thought who teaches in
America, reveals the extraordinary persistence of the
"polar myth" in various exotic subcultures. This myth
appears in many different versions, ranging from the
sophisticated to the sub-literate; but what unites most of
them is the striking idea that at some time in the distant
past the earth's poles have dramatically shifted. As a
result, a section of the globe which was once not only
habitable but, in some versions of the myth, a fertile
paradise called Hyperborea, has become the Arctic wasteland.
Although the notion that the earth once sat upright in its
orbit around the sun dates back to the ancient world, the
myth of a polar paradise did not really take shape until the
19th century. It appears in its most baroque form in one of
the most influential of all esoteric works, The Secret
Doctrine by the indefatigable Helena Blavatsky. Madame
Blavatsky, an enormously stout dowager descended from
Russian aristocrats, thrilled Victorian society with her
tales of deepest Tibet, which she claimed to have spent
seven years exploring armed only with an umbrella. She was
the founder of the movement known as Theosophy, which aims
to create a universal brotherhood by disseminating the
wisdom of a hierarchy of Hidden Masters living in Tibet.
Theosophical ideas lie behind much of what is now classified
as New Age, including David Icke's effusions; but what
concerns us here is Blavatsky's belief that for many
millions of years the North Pole was covered by "an
Imperishable Sacred Land". This was the home of the
First Race of men, who had colourless ethereal bodies and
knew neither sickness nor death. But, during millions of
years of slow degeneration, successive races of man
gradually took on corporeal form and colour; continents,
including Atlantis, rose and sank; and the Sacred Land
became an icy fastness.
Madame Blavatsky's fanciful scheme was obviously intended
for her followers; no-one else could be expected to take it
seriously. Yet her insistence on a northern homeland for
humanity was neither original nor entirely controversial.
During the 19th century, many German scholars had developed
a hearty contempt for the Hebrew scriptures as a source of
information about man's origins. The fashionable
orientalism of the period drew them towards Sanskrit and
the Hindu tradition; as Godwin points out, "if the Germans
could link their origins to India, then they would be
forever free from their Semitic and Mediterranean bondage".
Friedrich von Schlegel (1772-1829) was convinced that
Indian veneration for a mythical northern mountain must
imply a tribal memory of the North Pole. Furthermore, their
language proved that they shared common origins with Nordic
peoples. They were, in short, one race, and Schlegel even
provided a name for it: borrowing an obscure term which
was previously applied to the ancient Persians, he said that
Indians and northern Europeans were all "Aryans".
It was not long before this classification acquired
racialist overtones, in which the intellectual superiority
of the Aryan race was contrasted with the degeneracy and
sloth of other races (and various convoluted explanations
were offered as to why modern Indians are not white).
We should bear in mind, I think, the uncomfortable fact
that until the early years of this century, racialist theory
represented scientific orthodoxy; it appealed to enlightened
people searching for a reasonable -- "non-judgemental",
in modern jargon -- explanation for inequalities between
peoples. But it is also the case that whenever an
intellectual discipline produces what appears to be an
important breakthrough in our understanding of the world,
whether it be racial theory or chaos theory, the chances are
that it will be appropriated by people whose most striking
characteristic is their lack of intellectual discipline.
So it was that ultra-nationalist Germans took the notion of
Aryan race and inserted it into a mythology largely of their
own invention in which the polar homeland was identified
with "Thule", a mysterious land visited by Pytheas of
Massilia in his voyages north of Scotland in the third
century BC. The violently racist Thule Society, an
aristocratic secret order based in Munich after the
First World War, urged its members to fight the Jewish
enemy "until the swastika rises victoriously out of the
icy darkness"; its working-class equivalent was the German
Worker's Party, which in 1920 became the Nazi Party.
Meanwhile, less sinister esoteric societies continued to
build vast imaginative edifices using the imagery of both
Hyperborea and Thule; the distinction between the two polar
sanctuaries was never clear, and indeed as the century
progressed and the mythology developed, the distinction
between supporters and opponents of Nazism among the
myth-makers was also blurred.
I want to make two points at this stage. First, that when
we try to follow the twists and turns of an esoteric idea,
particularly in the 20th century, we quickly realise that
the milieu in which is moves is inclusive to a quite
extraordinary degree. No conspiracy theory is so complete
that it cannot accommodate a new villain; no map of a
forgotten country is so detailed that it cannot squeeze in
an extra subterranean city or two; no scientific discovery
is so limited in its application that it cannot be given a
New Age gloss. Secondly, we are moving in an environment
in which the boundary between fact and fiction, to which
the world at large ascribes such importance, matters
very little. We all know that the history of literature
is littered with products of the imagination (such as
Gulliver's Travels) whose authors have given them the form
of eyewitness narratives. In esoteric circles, however, the
equation is often inverted: outlandish works of fantasy are
treated (or presented) as true stories which for safety's
sake have been dressed up as fiction.
Godwin produces a classic example of this: Wilhelm Landig's
1971 novel Goetzen gegen Thule (Gods against Thule), a
"fiction full of facts" in which it is suggested that after
the destruction of the polar paradise of Thule, its cosmic
spirit survived in the hearts of a few scattered people --
of different races, interestingly -- who are mysteriously
transported back to the Arctic after the German defeat in
1945. Their role is to prepare for a new age, the Age of
Aquarius, whose harbingers are UFOs called Manisolas which
begin life as discs of pure light and then crystallise into
metallic form. The allies of the Thuleans include the
medieval Cathars, guardians of the Holy Grail; their enemies
are the Catholic Church, Freemasons, the United Nations and
the Jews, whose Ark of the Covenant was, it is revealed,
an astral accumulator designed to steal the energy of
the Aryans by filtering it through something called the
Hebraic Pole.
Landig stops just short of eulogising Hitler; he concedes
that the noble Thulean aims of the Third Reich were
perverted by the forces of evil. But the same cannot be
said of another Polar fantasist, Miguel Serrano, who during
the 1950s and 60s was one of Chile's most senior diplomats.
For Serrano, Hitler is the Tenth Avatar of Vishnu, who is
destined to bring about the end of the Kali Yuga and usher
in the New Age. I say "is", for Serrano reports that at
the end of the Second World War Hitler escaped in a flying
saucer and entered a hollow world inside the earth, in whose
secret cities the first Hyperboreans had taken refuge from
the disaster that reversed the Poles. This hollow world was
discovered by the Nazis during an expedition to Antarctica,
says Serrano; very much his own theory, you might imagine,
but in fact the theme of Hitler's survival at the South Pole
has flourished on the fringes of the New Age for many years,
ornamented by reports of disappearing submarines, secret
weapons, subterranean headquarters and, it goes without
saying, UFOs.
It also goes without saying, I think, that the people
who enjoy this sort of thing are as far removed from the
intellectual mainstream as it is possible to be. The world
of conspiracy theories is one we associate with cranks,
some of them well-educated but nearly all them personally
disturbed, and with people of little or no formal education.
That said, however, when we stare at the sort of bubbling
cultic soup cooked up by the likes of Miguel Serrano,
we can see, in addition to many poisonous creatures floating
around, remnants and strands of ideas which are still
considered respectable -- such as yoga, a great enthusiasm
of Serrano's -- or have only gradually become disreputable.
Take the hollow earth, for example. We can follow the trail
of this idea from the entirely reasonable speculation of
medieval monks, to the rather more daring conjectures of
the 17th-century scholar Athanasius Kircher, who based
his theory of a whirlpool at the centre of the earth on
an analogy with human anatomy; from there we can follow it
into the overheated imagination of the 19th-century American
eccentric John Cleves Symmes, whose petition to Congress for
an expedition to the lands inside the earth was greeted with
nationwide hilarity; and from there to Serrano. (I have
no idea if David Icke believes in a hollow earth, but I am
sure he would not rule it out.) In the same way, modern
scientific theories often undergo a journey from academia
or the laboratory to the wilder shores of sanity, a process
which, in our information-hungry age, can occur virtually
overnight. For example: within months of the scientist
James Lovelock outlining his Gaia hypothesis, in which he
introduced the idea of the planet as a living organism,
books had appeared which built highly speculative
philosophies on his thesis; and not long after that, an
angry earth-goddess called Gaia began to crop up in every
variety of New Age fantasy (including David Icke's).
Whether it takes centuries or months, the movement of ideas
I have described so far is very clearly in one direction:
away from the mainstream of intellectual life. This is
important, not least because rejection of intellectual
orthodoxy so often reflects (or causes) alienation from
society in general; but I don't want to give the impression
that all irrational beliefs gravitate automatically towards
a lunatic fringe, or that movement is in only one direction.
The American sociologist of religion Robert Ellwood, while
accepting that there is much that is plainly ridiculous in
the New Age movement, argues that it is "a contemporary
manifestation of a western alternative spirituality
tradition going back at least to the Greco-Roman world.
The current flows like an underground river through the
Christian centuries, breaking into high visibility in the
Renaissance occultism of the so-called 'Rosicrucian
Enlightenment', eighteenth-century Freemasonry, and
nineteenth-century Spiritualism and Theosophy."
Ellwood is right, I think, to emphasise the historical
continuity of esoteric thought. I don't want to deny the
existence or even the validity of this tradition; on the
other hand, it is not the whole story. At this stage
I want to introduce the useful, if slightly cumbersome, term
"cultic milieu", which was coined by the sociologist Colin
Campbell to describe the highly eclectic (and constantly
shifting) cultural environment in which the New Age movement
operates. As I see it, this cultic milieu extends well
beyond the New Age, however broadly we define it: it has
the capacity to take in and transform almost any piece of
information that society rejects. Instead of an underground
river, it is more like a vast metaphorical lake which is fed
by many different sources. If we trawl the waters of this
lake, we will certainly pick up many life forms which have
been carried along by Ellwood's esoteric and occult stream;
but there will also be many others, perhaps equally strange,
which have been transported there by much more familiar
currents, such as Christianity and Hollywood.
Consider, for example, one of the most powerful and
dangerous ideas known to man: the belief that the world
(or the world as we know it) is about to come to an end.
For well over 2,000 years, apocalyptic believers of one sort
or another have lived in the shadow of the End. Each
prophet, and each sect, has outlined a different scenario,
in which the apocalypse is brought about by every
conceivable agent of transformation: earthquakes, tidal
waves, nuclear Armageddon, alien invasion and, yes, polar
shift. Yet despite this variety, it does not take a genius
to work out that most of these fantasies share a common
structure and dynamic. In almost every case, the End is
heralded by worldwide catastrophe, which may be natural,
supernatural or man-made; but however many millions perish
in the cataclysm, a group of believers is spared so that
it can populate either an earthly paradise or a heavenly
kingdom (and usually a mixture of both).
A couple of years ago I began work on a book called
The End of Time which compares three categories of
modern apocalyptic belief: fundamentalist Christian,
ultra-conservative Roman Catholic, and New Age. Up to a
point, I found what I was expecting to find: that is to
say, striking similarities in the way in which all three
groups interpret current affairs as evidence of the coming
apocalypse, and in the way in which their scenarios dispose
of the unrighteous. Gory fundamentalist images of
unbelievers roasting at Armageddon are no more
blood-curdling, it seems to me, than the prophecies of
the Native American author Sun Bear, in which the planet
"shakes itself like a shaggy dog full of fleas", and tens
of millions die in the resulting tidal waves; or those of
the New Age priestess Ruth Montgomery, whose New World is
littered with the bodies of those unfortunate people "not
adequately prepared in spirit".
What I did not expect to find, and what really persuaded me
of the reality of the cultic milieu, was pieces of
information that seemed to belong exclusively to one
tradition turning up in another. So, for example, it came
as a surprise to encounter the figure of the Antichrist, the
satanic figure who for two millennia has dominated Christian
apocalyptic, in so many New Age prophecies. Ruth Montgomery
believes the Antichrist is a young man presently being
educated in an American college. The couturier Paco
Rabanne, author of a wonderfully batty book called Has the
Countdown Begun? (answer: yes) has another candidate.
"I have seen the face of a young man now living in London,"
he says, "who has surprised important people with his
'magic' gifts. He is already extending his psychic
undertaking and his personal fortune. Is he no more than a
sorcerer with extraordinary powers, or is he the Antichrist,
already in ambush awaiting his hour?"
Everywhere I looked, I found evidence of cross-fertilisation
between traditions which are openly hostile to one another.
Ultra-conservative Catholics, for whom the apparitions of
the Blessed Virgin Mary signal the End, borrow biblical
arithmetic from fiercely anti-Catholic fundamentalists in
order to demonstrate that time is running out. Even more
surprisingly, fundamentalists, who ostensibly regard the
New Age as the province of Satan, cannot resist the lure of
some of its ideas. For instance: back in 1982, there was
terrific excitement in New Age circles at the approach of
something called the "Jupiter effect", an alignment of the
planets which a couple of maverick scientists predicted
would slow down the earth's rotation, leading to an
earthquake which would destroy Los Angeles. Leading
fundamentalists might be expected to scoff at this; instead,
they jumped straight on the bandwagon. Hal Lindsey, author
of The Late, Great Planet Earth, wrote that "what we can
expect in 1982 is the largest outbreak of killer quakes ever
seen in the history of planet earth along with radical
changes in climate". Not to be outdone, Pat Robertson
suggested that the chaos caused by the Jupiter Effect might
prove the perfect cover for a Soviet strike against the US.
But this prospect did not worry the Southwestern Radio
Church: it suggested that the Rapture might occur just
before the planetary alignment, that the earth would be
righted on its axis, and that pre-Flood conditions would
be restored.
How do we account for this cross-fertilisation? There is
broad agreement between social scientists that apocalyptic
beliefs of every variety are a response to disorientation
and stress. Moreover, although New Agers and fundamentalist
Christians tend to come from different social backgrounds,
they share a readiness to identify themselves as
"outsiders", people who consciously reject the values
of the society around them, often as a result of a
life-changing spiritual experience. There was a time,
of course, when fundamentalist Christianity in America was
simply the dominant religious creed of vast areas of the
country; but with the passage of time it is acquiring more
and more of the characteristics of a counter-culture.
I do not think we should be misled by the traditional image
of fundamentalists as blazer-wearing conservatives in
crew-cuts. When the New York lifestyle magazine Details
sent a feature writer to follow the trail of the Oklahoma
bomber Timothy McVeigh through the Bible belt, he reported
back that "die-hard redneck bigots now look like the
long-haired biker hippies killed by diehard redneck bigots
in movies like Easy Rider." Furthermore, individual
fundamentalists are often tremendously receptive to
unorthodox ideas, even those condemned as the work of
the Devil by their church leaders. Just as New Agers are
often fascinated by the biblical number 666, so born-again
Christians are more likely to believe in UFOs than the
population at large; and, like Ronald and Nancy Reagan,
they are more likely to interested in astrology. Even
supposedly conservative figures such as Pat Robertson flirt
with conspiracy theories of the most colourful variety:
in his book The New World Order he introduces us to "a small
secret society called the Order of the Illuminati" who first
gained control of the freemasons and then proceeded, through
the agency of Jewish bankers, to set in motion both the
French and Russian Revolutions. Now where have we heard
that before?
Perhaps the reason so many fundamentalist Christians are so
deeply immersed in the cultic milieu is that their religion
is far more radical and "alternative" than it first appears.
After all, most of them are required to believe that within
a few years the entire Church on earth will be carried up to
heaven in the Rapture (a doctrine which, incidentally, dates
back no further than the 19th century). Anyone who believes
that they will be plucked skywards while their unbelieving
neighbours die in the agony of Armageddon is likely to feel
that they are therefore set apart from the bulk of mankind.
Yet American fundamentalists do not live in a vacuum; they
watch television (and lots of it). The cultic milieu is not
a closed environment, in which only elements of religious or
esoteric belief combine and mingle. I've already mentioned
UFOs and science fiction; I want to conclude this lecture
by looking at the implications of living in a world in which
religion is increasingly the poor relation of mass
entertainment.
I should say immediately that I am entirely convinced by the
growing body of research, such as Jim Schnabel's excellent
book Dark White, which establishes a direct correlation
between reports of UFO encounters and the treatment of the
subject by popular literature and Hollywood. Invariably,
the fictional representation has always preceded a wave
of sightings. I don't think this should surprise us.
There are strong reasons to believe that the esoteric
secret societies which flourished at the turn of the century
borrowed their cosmology from early science fiction;
and it also seems likely that some of the "moral panics"
of the past, such as the evangelical crusade against
the white slave trade in the 1920s, originated either
in sensationalist fiction or in those fascinating oral
traditions we now call urban myths.
The transformation of fiction into quasi-religious beliefs
raises many complex questions; and unfortunately there isn't
time to address them all here. Let me just say that I don't
think we are dealing with a single, easily-identifiable
psychological mechanism. Just as the sources of these
beliefs are extremely varied, so are the forms in which they
manifest themselves: simple credulity, profound religious
belief and serious mental disturbance. On the other hand,
this process of transformation confirms everything we know
about the cultic milieu, and in particular the way in which
openness to one piece of unorthodox information (fictional
or otherwise) can produce a new mind-set in which a vast
range of information rejected by society is potentially
accessible.
Of course, this isn't the purpose of mass entertainment,
which is directed not at New Agers, or fundamentalists,
or the feeble-minded, but at the general public. What,
then, are we to make of the fact that so many of the
entertainment's industry's most successful products deal
with what might be called "the unexplained"? The 1990s
have seen the development of an apparently insatiable public
appetite for films, television series and books which
explore mysteries and mystical traditions. It is not easy
to say whether this reflects deliberate manipulation of a
market or a response to a deep-seated spiritual yearning:
probably a bit of both. What is abundantly clear is that
Hollywood, the television companies and publishers
everywhere do not need to be told about the cultic milieu;
they may not have heard of it, but they seem to have a
pretty good idea of how it works, and how to make it work
for them. There is no better illustration of this than
The X-Files, which in the course of three series has
trawled one stretch after another of our metaphorical lake,
collecting pieces of folklore, urban myth, religious
tradition and pseudo-science and joining them together to
form patterns which are not only immensely entertaining, but
which are immediately recognisable to conspiracy theorists
everywhere -- and, perhaps, to the conspiracy theorist who
lurks inside all of us.
I am sorry if this sounds disapproving and puritanical.
In fact, I'm not remotely offended by television shows
which draw on the cultic milieu; but I do think we should
recognise the dangers of becoming addicted to forms of
entertainment in which the strands of myth, fiction and fact
are so difficult to disentangle. In America, for example,
one has to wonder about the effect of television series
built round an imaginary government conspiracy on a culture
where the paranoid tradition is still so influential: just
look at Pat Robertson. We can only guess what David Koresh
would have made of the X-Files or Dark Skies; but what we do
know is that in reinventing himself as the messiah of Waco
he drew heavily on popular culture, and particularly on
a sci-fi movie called The Lawnmower Man, in which computer
software is fed into a retarded man's brain and he becomes
a power-crazed genius. The Branch Davidians at Waco were
forced to watch this film many times over by Koresh, who
used it as the text for day-long sermons; in the end, it was
as much a part of their religion as the Book of Revelation.
As it happens, I don't believe that the Branch Davidians
bear most of the responsibility for the Waco tragedy.
I do believe, however, that apocalyptic cults pose a growing
threat to law and order throughout the world; and that the
cultic milieu is absolutely central to this threat. There
are, for example, literally thousands of new religious
movements in Japan which not only build on local traditions
of evil spirits, but reach out to elements of Western
culture which one might think were entirely foreign to them.
For example: almost none of these cults are Christian, but
that does not stop many of them borrowing bloody psychedelic
images from the last book of the bible. I am thinking of
one group in particular whose theology incorporated the
following elements: the Book of Revelation, Tantric yoga,
Nostradamus, the Age of Aquarius, nuclear physics and the
Roman Catholic prophecies of St Malachy. A comically
eclectic mixture, I am sure you will agree; but when I tell
you the group was called Aum Shinrikyo you will understand
why such beliefs need to be taken seriously.
What about the implications for this country? It is true,
I think, that Britain's political culture is so stable,
and its apocalyptic tradition so marginalised, that the
potential for violent disorder is limited. In our
post-religious society, part of the appeal of material based
on "the unexplained" lies in the fact that it invites us
to toy with highly unorthodox and subversive ideas without
requiring us to incorporate them into our belief system. On
the other hand, are we perhaps too confident of our ability
to distinguish truth from fantasy? Fictional TV dramas are
one thing; quite another are books such as Fingerprints of
the Gods which explain the configuration of the pyramids in
terms of a long-lost Antarctic civilization and then go on
to top Britain's non-fiction bestseller lists for months.
The popularity of such perniciously trashy works can only
mean that we have lost faith in the ability of orthodox
history and science to describe the world in which we live.
The same goes for many New Age therapies for serious
illnesses, which undoubtedly shorten the lives of some
sufferers and which recently provoked the Science Editor of
The Daily Telegraph to issue an impassioned denunciation of
what he called the "X-Files mentality".
Let me end with a cautionary tale. About ten years ago,
extremely distressing reports of Satanic activity began
to circulate among Britain's born-again Christians. It
appeared that an organised network of Satanists were holding
covens in which small children were sexually abused; in some
cases, women were being impregnated so that they could give
birth to foetuses which could then be sacrificed in gruesome
rituals. As the stories spread from church to church,
"survivors" of this Ritual Satanic Abuse came forward,
just as they had in America a couple of years earlier.
Their evidence was tantalisingly insubstantial: it mostly
consisted of memories which had been "recovered" in therapy.
But it was enough to win over significant numbers of social
workers, who began to receive specialist training from
so-called experts in Satanic Abuse -- experts who, on closer
inspection, turned out to be fundamentalist Christians.
The rest of the story is no doubt familiar to you: small
children were removed from their families and effectively
forced to incriminate their parents or other adults.
A terrible fiction was created; lives and families were
destroyed.
All this could have been avoided, I would argue, if society
at large -- the professions, the press, the churches --
knew anything about the way in which similar moral panics
have arisen in the past, or knew their way round the
territory we have been exploring today. They might then
have spotted that the recovered memories of Satanic
abuse survivors bore an extraordinary resemblance to the
testimonies of victims of alien abduction, even down to
the smallest anatomical details of the alleged abuse. A
coincidence? If you believe that, you'll believe anything.
.
DECLARATION & DISCLAIMER
==========
CTRL is a discussion and informational exchange list. Proselyzting propagandic
screeds are not allowed. Substance�not soapboxing! These are sordid matters
and 'conspiracy theory', with its many half-truths, misdirections and outright
frauds is used politically by different groups with major and minor effects
spread throughout the spectrum of time and thought. That being said, CTRL
gives no endorsement to the validity of posts, and always suggests to readers;
be wary of what you read. CTRL gives no credeence to Holocaust denial and
nazi's need not apply.
Let us please be civil and as always, Caveat Lector.
========================================================================
Archives Available at:
http://home.ease.lsoft.com/archives/CTRL.html
http:[EMAIL PROTECTED]/
========================================================================
To subscribe to Conspiracy Theory Research List[CTRL] send email:
SUBSCRIBE CTRL [to:] [EMAIL PROTECTED]
To UNsubscribe to Conspiracy Theory Research List[CTRL] send email:
SIGNOFF CTRL [to:] [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Om