-Caveat Lector-
from: AMERICAN ATHEISTS
subject: AANEWS for June 11, 1999
A M E R I C A N A T H E I S T S
AANEWS
#586 ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ 6/11/99
http://www.atheists.org
ftp.atheists.org/pub/atheists/
http://www.americanatheist.org
---------------------------------------------
A Service of AMERICAN ATHEISTS
"Leading The Way For Atheist Civil Rights
And The Separation Of State and Church"
----------------------------------------------
In This Issue...
* Coalition under scrutiny, but other religious groups active
* N.J. Assembly passes "creator" bill
* Resources
* About this list...
IN WAKE OF IRS DECISION, IS COALITION FLOUNDERING OR STILL
A POLITICAL FORCE?
Opponents Blast Robertson, But Also Violate State-Church Separation
No sooner had the St. Petersburg Times newspaper reported that the
Christian Coalition would not receive an IRS tax exemption than the
pundits were pronouncing the 1.6 million member group dead and buried.
Former Coalition employees like Arne Owens, the group's communications
director until November 1998, declared, "This will be a surprise to
all the people who believed the Christian Coalition was what it said
it was, those conservative Christians who thought it was above
back-room wheeling and dealing." Over at Americans United for the
Separation of Church and State, the Rev. Barry Lynn -- who has,
admittedly, fought the good fight against Robertson's political vanity
and ambitions for power -- described the ruling as "a devastating
blow," adding that Pat Robertson's "crusade to politicize America's
churches is now almost certain to fail."
But is it? We sense two trends happening in the media coverage of the
latest Christian Coalition flap. The first is an utterly unrealistic
appraisal of where the Coalition and its principle backer, Pat
Robertson, stand in the contemporary political landscape. And we find
that "CC bashing" has rendered the Christian Coalition -- still a
dangerous political threat to civil liberties and the separation of
church and state -- a convenient "straw man" to distract attention
from the wider politicalization of America's religious community.
Robinson is taken to task, and rightly so, for his homophobic and
theocratic agenda. But there are a number of other religious
organizations including the National Conference of Catholic Bishops
and the Interfaith Alliance that engage in tactics remarkably similar
to those of the Christian Coalition, who seem to escape the scrutiny
of both mass media and, alas, many separationists.
CC-RIP: "Rest In Peace" or "Ready for Improved Polit
How accurate are suggestions that the Christian Coalition is "on the
ropes" of the political arena? In fact, the IRS decision which denies
a tax exemption for the Christian Coalition, may have little or no
effect on Robertson's long-term political strategy. The present
Christian Coalition is now morphing into two new entities, Christian
Coalition International and Christian Coalition of America. The
former is not "international," but as a for-profit corporation it will
finally be free "to endorse political candidates on a state and local
level (and) make financial contributions to candidates," according to
a media broadside announcing formation of this new group. The second
entity is Christian Coalition of America, merely a name-change for the
Christian Coalition of Texas which already has a tax exemption. CC
spokesperson Mike Russell told the New York Times that the CCA "will
be the principle vehicle for the operation of the Christian Coalition
in the United States," and be capable of doing "everything" the old CC
did in the past.
An unidentified tax specialist told the Times that "the new
organization (Christian Coalition of America) will do just what the
IRS said disqualified the old organization from getting a 501c4 (tax
exempt) status." But the IRS announcement striking any tax exemption
for the old Christian Coalition came after a ten-year fight to win the
dispensation.
In fact, many other religious groups -- a good number of them
representing liberal or moderate political causes -- issue voter's
guides, pump out a steady stream of advocacy materials, and do
essentially what Robertson and his political operatives have been
doing since the Coalition began in 1988. What distinguishes the
Christian Coalition is its distinct religious right agenda, and
Robertson's gaffes which have gotten the group into trouble with the
IRS and made it a convenient target for the news media. American's
United, for instance, was able to provide the tax agency with a speech
Robertson gave to a Coalition meeting in September, 1997 where he
urged members to emulate "the Tammany Halls ... and Chicago machine,
and the Byrd machine... This is what we've got to do. Now God has
put a mandate on us because the nation is in crisis." Robertson told
the "Road to Victory" conferees that he had a "detailed game plan" for
taking control of the White House, and urged them to form a "united
front" behind select Republican candidates.
Robertson remains free to attempt all of this through his new
political entities like Christian Coalition International and
Christian Coalition of America. Some observers have suggested that
the Coalition's network of nearly 125,000 churches which have helped
to pump out the tens of millions of voter's guides in the past will be
less likely to do so as the year 2000 elections approach. So far,
however, there is no good evidence that this is happening, or that the
"new" Christian Coalition cannot find different ways of distributing
its guides. Besides, the Roman Catholic church has already crossed
the First Amendment line in advocating and opposing specific
legislative items by distributing political materials of its own
inside the churches, and even providing parishioners with preprinted
cards to mail to elected representatives outlining the Vatican's
position on issues such as abortion and voucher programs.
Another factor arguing against the collapse of the Coalition is
Robertson's enormous personal wealth, and the fact that the group has
enjoyed considerable success in the initial phase of its effort to
raise $21 million for use in the year 2000 elections. Robertson is
cash-rich thanks to the sale of his International Family
Entertainment, Inc. to Australian media mogul Rupert Murdoch, a deal
which netted Robertson at least $200 million or more. (Some estimates
run as high as $450 million, and one report even gave a total sales
price of $1.9 billion!) Robertson has embarked on several financial
deals including reopening the old Powerine oil refinery near Los
Angeles and a gold mining operation in Liberia. His joint-venture to
provide telephone and internet financial services with the Bank of
Scotland collapsed, but Robertson will recoup his initial investment,
and possibly much more since the BOS withdrew from the deal.
Robertson is far from broke.
What about the shakeup going on at Christian Coalition? Media reports
have talked about Robertson "clearing the decks," and have described
the internal situation at the group's national offices as
"convulsive." Indeed, Robertson's political boy wonder, Ralph reed,
left the organization in 1997 to be replaced by Don Hodel and Randy
Tate. Hodel is gone, Tate has been demoted to one of Robertson's vice
presidents to run the CC governmental affairs office in Washington,
and a host of lower level operatives have departed. They include
operations director Charles Cunningham and communications director
Arne Owens. There have also been defections of a number of key
Coalition chapter heads, including Nathan Sproul (Arizona), Winnie
Spence (Delaware), Brent Pickens (Wisconsin) and David Spady
(California). But as coalition insiders told the New York Times,
"attrition is common to nonprofit organizations and is not necessarily
bad."
Mark Rozell, a political scientist at Catholic University of America,
told the Virginian Pilot newspaper that the IRS decision will cause
the Coalition to "suffer a large financial setback," but cautioned "it
doesn't rule them out" from continuing to be a considerable political
player. Rozelle noted that the Sierra Club also was denied a tax
exemption several years ago, and like Robertson's group simply split
into two different organizations -- one to focus on education, the
other to solicit campaign contributions and make partisan
endorsements. "The Sierra Club has continued to thrive."
Violations By Other Groups Minimized, Ignored?
In late May, Vice President Albert Gore -- presently considered a
front runner for the democratic White House nod in 2000 -- called for
a "New Partnership" between the state and faith-based groups. While
paying lip service to the First Amendment separation of church and
state, Gore came out in support of "charitable choice" and other
schemes to subsidize religious groups to facilitate social services.
Gore described his "politics of community" as "neither government
doing everything, nor the churches and charities picking up the slack
when government scales back." He added, "A politics of community can
be strengthened when we are not afraid to make connections between
spirituality and politics."
Gore's call for a "New Partnership" raised concerns from some
separationists and even religious groups; but it typifies the growing
trend of political leaders and hopefuls "playing to a religious
audience" and peppering their speeches with references to "god,"
spirituality, "values" and other eligious metaphors -- all in hopes of
courting religious votes. No leading presidential candidate has
openly and proudly spoken of the need to defend the separation of
church and state; Vice President Gore's single reference to the
Establishment Clause treated it as a poor relation, even an
inconvenience, when he declared: "I believe strongly in the separation
of church and state. But freedom of religion does not mean freedom
from religion..."
Robertson may simply be more blunt and forthright than other religious
leaders when it comes to discussing the realpolitik of the American
electoral process. Major religious denominations maintain a powerful
lobbying and influence presence inside the beltway, distribute voter's
guides, advocate defeat or passage of specific legislative items, and
threaten political leaders with retaliation at the polls.
In Philadelphia, for instance, the Archdiocese will be distributing
voter's guides outlining candidates' position on issues of church
interest. Church officials have not attracted the opprobrium which
Robertson has even when they threatened to excommunicate any officials
who supported legalized abortion, or strayed from ecclesiastical
doctrine on other issues.
Mirroring the Christian Coalition, though attracting less media
scrutiny, are groups like the Interfaith Alliance which use similar
tactics but reflect a more liberal political agenda. Ironically, an
Alliance spokesman praised the IRS decision, telling the
Virginian-Pilot, "The Christian Coalition's partisan and deceitful
tactics have been bad for religion and bad for politics." Rev. C.
Welton Gaddy added, "We expect the Christian Coalition will
reorganize, refocus and redouble its efforts to maintain its political
power and influence in school boards, state legislatures and
Congress."
But Interfaith Alliance is one of numerous groups (albeit at the other
end of the political spectrum) which uses similar electioneering and
advocacy tactics, including what some critics say amounts to
"bullying" government officials to fund religion-approved social
programs. The Alliance has its own political agenda, publishes a
voter's guide which some may consider to be every bit as vague,
propagandistic and partisan as anything that Robertson has published,
and urges member congregations to get out the vote on election day.
Wisely, the Alliance posts a small-print notice at the bottom of the
guides saying -- much as did the Christian Coalition -- that they are
"for educational purposes only," and in larger typeface advises "Not
for Distribution in Houses of Worship."
One former elected official, though, told AANEWS that the Alliance is
every much as bit of a bully as the Coalition, and described one
meeting the IA called. "They invited candidates and elected officials
to sit up on a stage," said the former Vice Mayor of a major
Southwestern city. "Convention-style signs were mounted on poles
throughout the audience identifying the parish or church everybody was
from. It was like a grilling session, and we were told in so many
words that if we didn't vote for a specific spending program or
against a particular piece of legislation, we wouldn't be getting the
votes of such-and-such a church congregation on election day."
While Robertson recruited politically savvy operatives from within the
Republican party and elsewhere, the Interfaith Alliance leadership
reflects comparable backgrounds in organizations just as active and
politically astute. Some have been involved in head-to-head fights
with the Christian Coalition over control of local school boards. An
article in Mother Jones magazine notes that "locally based ecumenical
alliances are putting pressure on national religious groups to follow
their lead," adding that the national organization now boasts 46
chapters in 23 states. "The Interfaith Alliance is also getting into
the voter guide business, a staple of Christian Coalition..." noted
the magazine, and cited electoral races in Virginia and Oregon where
"two Interfaith Alliance chapters distributed 110,000 guides that
helped defeat the right-wing candidates."
A spokesman for the Alliance declared, "Our message is ... that
apathy is immoral. We are going to make it a moral imperative that
religious Americans vote."
Because of the participation of so many Roman Catholics, including two
Bishops, Interfaith Alliance remains neutral on the abortion question.
The Roman Catholic church has already staked out its own political
territory, though on that and other so-called "life issues," even
raising millions of dollars to defeat voluntary euthanasia proposals
in states such as Michigan. The National Conference of Catholic
Bishops has censured President Clinton for not agreeing to sign the
Partial Birth Abortion Ban (also a target of the Christian Coalition).
And some, though not all, "liberal" and "moderate" religious bodies
seem united in a desire to promote vouchers, or make faith-based
groups eligible for public funds in order to administer social
programs.
Bottom line: American churches are already heavily politicized, and
will likely become even more active.
Part of the problem stems from the vagueness of election laws.
Religious groups may address "issues" but may not endorse candidates.
That doesn't stop many charismatic church leaders from publicly
declaring their "personal" endorsement of a given candidate, or
placing their name and ecclesiastical title on a political ad.
Indeed, some have charged that in many cities, urban churches have
become pawns in an insidious game of political influence peddling
where local preachers often mobilize their respective congregations.
Black ministers in New Jersey have rallied on the footsteps of the
capitol for and against various legislative items, and -- with a "wink
and a nod" -- have endorsed specific candidates.
If anything, Robertson and the Christian Coalition do more openly, and
perhaps more brazenly, what many "houses of worship" and religious
leaders already do. They endorse candidates, stake out claims on
political and social issues while citing doctrinal authority and
correctness, and excoriate voters to follow their will. Some, like
Robertson, advocate issues which many separationists and atheists find
abhorrent; others seem to enjoy a certain immunity because they may
support candidates and positions with which we sometimes agree.
Part of the problem rests with vague elections laws, and a large gray
area regarding what nonprofit advocacy groups may and may not do. But
for many religious groups, despite what is likely only a temporary
setback for Christian Coalition, it will be "politics as usual," and
using doctrinal authority as a tool to regiment congregants when they
enter the voting booth.
**
N.J. ASSEMBLY APPROVES "CREATOR" SCHOOL PLEDGE
Legislators in the New Jersey Assembly passed a bill yesterday that
will require all public school students to recite a daily passage from
the Declaration of Independence. The lines would be recited along
with the Pledge of Allegiance and include: "We hold these truths to be
self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by
their Creator with certain inalienable rights, that among these are
life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness. That to secure these
rights, governments are instituted among men, deriving their just
powers from the consent of the governed."
Republican Assemblyman Michael Carrol, who sponsored the measure,
declared, "These two sentences are the basis of everything that
America has become."
The measure passed 50-16 and moves on to the Senate. Even if it
passes there, however, Governor Christie Whitman may not sign the
legislation. Mentioned as a potential vice-presidential nominee for
the GOP, Whitman has staked out political turf as a moderate, and says
that she is undecided about the new bill.
New Jersey American Atheists State Director Dave Silverman has been
working against the proposal, and says that it has little or nothing
to do with equality and rights. "I think it's pretty obvious that
this is related to the school prayer issue," Silverman told AANEWS
earlier this evening. "Out of all of the founding documents, Carrol
and other supporters chose the one section that can be interpreted to
support religion in the schools. They don't talk about the Bill of
Rights, they instead emphasize that one line which mentions a
creator."
Some lawmakers objected to the measure, saying that this part of the
Declaration reflected Colonial-era values that often discriminated
against minorities and women. There were even suggestions to change
"all men" to something more politically correct, such as "all people."
Silverman described that move as a "smokescreen" to divert attention
from the religious elements in the legislation.
"The intention isn't to talk about diversity or equality, it's to get
religion into schools any way you can," Silverman said. "Any sort of
compromise about changing 'men' to 'people' is going to make it more
palatable for some groups, but it's also going to divert the focus
from the religion issue."
"These are same folks who brought us restrictions on abortion and the
Religious Freedom Restoration Act," warned Mr. Silverman. "The only
intention here is to segue prayer back into the public schools."
Silverman said that he would continue to organize against the
legislation when it moves to the Senate.
**
RESOURCES FROM AMERICAN ATHEISTS...
* For information about American Atheists, send mail to
[EMAIL PROTECTED] Please include your name and postal mailing
address.
* For a free catalogue of American Atheist Press books, videos and
other products, send mail to [EMAIL PROTECTED] Kindly include
your postal mailing address.
* The American Atheist Magazine is now on the web! Check out select
articles from the current or back issues, as well as special web-only
features. Visit us at http://www.americanatheist.org
* If you are a current member of American Atheists, sign up for our
e-mail discussion group, aachat. We have over 120 participants who
discuss topics such as Atheism, religion, First Amendment issues and
lots more! Contact Margie Wait, the Moderator, through
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
ABOUT THIS LIST...
AANEWS is a free service from American Atheists, a nationwide movement
founded by Madalyn Murray O'Hair for the advancement of Atheism, and
the total, absolute separation of government and religion.
You may forward, post or quote from this dispatch, provided that
appropriate credit is given to AANEWS and American Atheists. Edited
by Conrad Goeringer, [EMAIL PROTECTED] Internet Representative for
American Atheists is Margie Wait, [EMAIL PROTECTED]
----------------------------------------------------------------------
To subscribe, send a blank message to [EMAIL PROTECTED]
DECLARATION & DISCLAIMER
==========
CTRL is a discussion and informational exchange list. Proselyzting propagandic
screeds are not allowed. Substance�not soapboxing! These are sordid matters
and 'conspiracy theory', with its many half-truths, misdirections and outright
frauds is used politically by different groups with major and minor effects
spread throughout the spectrum of time and thought. That being said, CTRL
gives no endorsement to the validity of posts, and always suggests to readers;
be wary of what you read. CTRL gives no credeence to Holocaust denial and
nazi's need not apply.
Let us please be civil and as always, Caveat Lector.
========================================================================
Archives Available at:
http://home.ease.lsoft.com/archives/CTRL.html
http:[EMAIL PROTECTED]/
========================================================================
To subscribe to Conspiracy Theory Research List[CTRL] send email:
SUBSCRIBE CTRL [to:] [EMAIL PROTECTED]
To UNsubscribe to Conspiracy Theory Research List[CTRL] send email:
SIGNOFF CTRL [to:] [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Om