-Caveat Lector-

This guy is plugging his book at a local bookstore this Sunday afternoon..
prob'ly go check him out.
Got a feeling it may be a case of disclosing more obvious stuff & mebbe
spinning some cover or misdirection for other stuff- whether due to intent
of author or "extra co-operative" alphabet agency personnel...


Dave Hartley
http://www.Asheville-Computer.com
http://www.ioa.com/~davehart

Stranger than fiction
New book exposes secret government experiments on humans
http://www.mountainx.com/ae/991103moreno.html
by Melanie McGee

How far will a government go to be number one? In his new book, Undue Risk:
Secret State Experiments on Humans (W.H. Freeman and Company, 1999),
Jonathan D. Moreno � who directs the University of Virginia's Center for
Biomedical Ethics � penetrates classified documents and well-tended state
secrets to uncover some of the most horrifying experiments ever conducted in
the name of science.

The experiments perpetrated on concentration-camp victims during World War
II, though hardly a secret anymore, are of course mentioned, along with
startling revelations from the trials of the sadistic Nazi "doctors": Moreno
recounts defense lawyer Robert Servatius' attempt to use an experiment the
United States had conducted on its own prisoners (injecting 800 of them with
malaria) to weaken the prosecution's case, though ultimately that incident
could not compare with the Nazi atrocities inflicted on millions.

But many more examples of American shame lurk between the covers of Moreno's
book, including: The irradiation of prisoners' testicles in Oregon and
Washington state penitentiaries, from 1963 to 1973; the irradiation of
oatmeal at Fernald School, a home for mentally retarded children in
Massachusetts, in the '40s and '50s (which resulted in a $1.85 million
lawsuit after the disgrace came to national attention in the mid-'90s); the
injection of plutonium into low-income hospital patients in the '40s, to
determine how close association with the element would affect those working
on developing atomic bombs; the Army's intentional unleashing of Bacillus
globigii bacteria into New York City subway tunnels in 1966, in order to
study the potential biological weapon's dispersal patterns. And there are
countless other examples.

Due in part to a wholesale cynicism regarding government conduct that peaked
during the Vietnam War era, great strides have been made in protecting
citizens (especially those in the military) from such experiments, according
to Moreno. But he is careful to say that some controlled human
experimentation on willing volunteers is still necessary � especially in the
military � given the threat of biological and chemical warfare from foreign
terrorists.

"[Experimentation] has to be done with a minimum of risk, and there has to
be [public] trust. Someday, we may have that. ... But there is a tragic
element in this, in that there will never be a set of rules that can
[satisfy] everybody," Moreno noted in a recent telephone interview. What
follows is more of that conversation:

Mountain Xpress: Did you encounter much government resistance in researching
Undue Risk?

Jonathan Moreno: No. ... You have to understand the context through which I
got into [the research]. I was staffed with the President's Advisory
Committee on Human Radiation Experiments, and along with the executive order
the president signed establishing the Advisory Committee, he also ordered
the declassification of all relevant documents. The whole federal
bureaucracy was under orders, [including] the six agencies that were
particularly implicated: the Department of Defense, the Department of
Energy, the CIA, NASA, the Department of Health and Human Services and the
Veterans' Administration. So there was no resistance at all. Quite the
contrary. The people I dealt with, especially in the Pentagon, were falling
over themselves [to be helpful]. Of course, they were under orders � but
also, they were generally interested, and offended at the thought that their
forebears might have been abused [in human experiments]. Also, there was
concern about inaccurate information getting in the press, and [the book]
giving the impression that the armed forces had deliberately abused its
members in the past � had used them as guinea pigs. So there was certainly
concern about misrepresentation, and I tried to be very careful. [But] the
reality was that some of what was done was harmful, was wrong, and involved
people in the armed forces. But each of the cases has a somewhat different
flavor to it.

MX: For every case like Fernald that causes a public scandal and receives
widespread media coverage, are there many more such cases that may never
come to light?

JM: I'm very confident that we don't know all that might be in government
archives concerning biological- and chemical-warfare experiments and
activities. The Advisory Committee was really [concerned with] radiation
experiments; we didn't really get to go on to biological and chemical
experiments. Certainly, when we started to look at the radiation
experiments, we uncovered a larger number of [them] than we knew to be the
case before we started, so I think it's reasonable to suppose that the same
would be [true] for biological and chemical experiments. The major source of
information for biological and chemical experiments happened 25 years ago,
when Sen. Frank Church established hearings on secret government activities.
That's when CIA Director Richard Helms � much to the chagrin of his
colleagues � released a 600- or 700-page document outlining, for example,
the CIA's LSD experiments. [During the Cold War, the issue of mind control
was of particular interest to the U.S. government; as part of a project
called MKULTRA, LSD was secretly given to unsuspecting citizens, including
restaurant workers and military personnel]. So it's been 25 years since a
serious effort was made to look at biological and chemical warfare. When the
National Academy of Sciences, five years ago, published its analysis of the
mustard-gas experiments involving several thousand sailors in the second
World War, they also concluded that not all of the information about these
activities had [come out]. It's probably not the case that there's anyone
deliberately holding back, but it's very expensive to go through all of this
paper, [and] very time-consuming. Unless there is a political will to do it,
it just doesn't get done. In the case of the radiation experiments, there
was a public scandal [which] motivated [the attention].

MX: [The following question refers to Marine Michael Metzig's recent
dishonorable discharge for refusing to take an FDA-approved anthrax vaccine.
To date, 200 military personnel have similarly refused to be vaccinated.]
Although receiving the anthrax vaccination does not qualify as an
experiment, do you feel the Metzig incident, and others like it, point to a
growing dissension in this area?

JM: The Uniform Code of Military Justice says that you have to accept any
kind of medical prevention that will make you combat-ready. That's not only
for your own protection, so you can do your job, but so that other people
that you have to be working with and supporting are not put in harm's way.
Having said that, there is a question, I think, about whether the Uniform
Code applies in peacetime, and there's also a question about whether it
applies to reservists. Furthermore, in the case of anthrax, although the
vaccine appears to be protective if given soon enough, it's entirely
possible that a terrorist group � knowing what kind of anthrax strain people
were being immunized against � could develop a mutant strain. So the dose
response for a range of variations to the virus is limited. It doesn't make
inoculation futile, by any means, but it raises a question as to whether
it's really necessary, under the circumstances. ... What [Metzig and the
other protesters] are responding to is not the genuine effects of the
vaccination. I think what they're really concerned about, what's influencing
them, is the whole controversy about the Gulf War Syndrome [the name given
to a set of chronic debilitating symptoms that continues to plague soldiers
who were injected with pyridostigmine bromide, or PB (an antidote to nerve
gas), during the Gulf War]. Some of them have been quoted as saying, "We
know that these people were used as guinea pigs, and we don't want to fall
into that again" � but does [the Metzig incident] suggest a trend? I think
the modern soldier is much more inclined to be skeptical about authority
than was true decades ago. One problem, I think, that the armed forces
[have] now is this legacy of sloppy record-keeping, which is part of the
reason we're in this fix with the Gulf War Syndrome. Who exactly got
[vaccinated with] what, and how much [did they get]? So they're paying the
price for that, and now there's really a problem of trust.

MX: You note that people's attitudes toward scientific experiments on humans
tend to vary, depending on the general social climate of a country at a
given time. For instance, Americans were much more inclined to support the
idea during World War II, for patriotic reasons, and were bitterly against
it during the Cold War and Vietnam eras, when dissatisfaction with
government ran high. In your research, did you find that any particular
sentiment about the issue reigns today � or have opinions become more
polarized?

JM: It's sort of ironic, actually. In the civilian world, there's more trust
about medical experimentation than perhaps there should be, in the sense
that people think that you can't get state-of-the-art health care unless
you're in a medical experiment or trial. In some areas, that's true: For HIV
it's been true, for example. In other areas, like cancer [research], it's
not necessarily true. If you're in what's called a Phase I [cancer] study,
where they're just testing how toxic a drug is and not testing to see if
it's effective in shrinking a tumor, for example, then that's not true. So
in the civilian world today, I would say ... people are very willing to say
yes [to medical research]. In the military world, there's a lot more
skepticism. It's ironic, because right now, the protections in the military
are greater than they are in the civilian world. There are more levels of
review. It's sort of paradoxical to me. But one has to say, in fairness,
that most of the [military] medical research going on today that I talk
about in the book is on healthy people, healthy volunteers ... whereas many
people in the civilian world looking for help are sick, and so they have a
desire to find the best treatment they can. In the process, they are
somewhat less critical than I would like them to be about what they're
getting into.

MX:You also make a point of saying that the military personnel at Fort
Detrick [a facility in Maryland for Medical Research Volunteer Subjects, or
MRVS] are not the "passive guinea pigs" one might be led to expect.
Nevertheless, did you find any unifying personality traits among these
willing subjects?

JM: That's probably fair. You might say it's somebody who's got a level of
intellectual curiosity, a level of courage that I might not have [laughs] �
I think there's probably something to that. On the other hand, in some
places that are near a major medical center, some people, like unemployed
artists, will sign up for a drug study for [which they may receive up to]
$2,000. They probably have the same personality type, plus they have the
manipulation factor of the money. People who volunteer to be subjects of
studies might have some kind of personality structure that other people
don't have, and as long as that personality type isn't exploited ... as long
as people aren't going out and looking for people who have this "Type Z"
personality, then I think it's OK. And I wouldn't rule out real scientific
curiosity. ... The people at Camp Detrick are junior scientists, and they
are really interested in what is going on.

MX: Given the rate at which technology is advancing these days, is it ever
possible that computer models will be able to replace human subjects in
scientific experiments?

JM: Never. Well, at least not in our lifetime. Not until these computers are
science-fiction-style androids with a psychology chip [and] an emotion
chip � because so much of what is important occurs [during] combat, where a
psychological reaction can react with the drugs. For example, we just had
this study that came out by the Rand Corporation [a research company founded
in 1948 that focuses on matters of national security] about PB. The
conclusion that Rand reached ... was that, combined with the stress of
combat, PB could indeed have caused the kind of symptoms we are seeing that
it caused [in Gulf War veterans]. You're never going to get [a revelation
like] that out of a computer. But interestingly, you could never do an
ethical experiment to test for that [kind of reaction], either. So you're
sort of between a rock and a hard place.

DECLARATION & DISCLAIMER
==========
CTRL is a discussion and informational exchange list. Proselyzting propagandic
screeds are not allowed. Substance�not soapboxing!  These are sordid matters
and 'conspiracy theory', with its many half-truths, misdirections and outright
frauds is used politically  by different groups with major and minor effects
spread throughout the spectrum of time and thought. That being said, CTRL
gives no endorsement to the validity of posts, and always suggests to readers;
be wary of what you read. CTRL gives no credeence to Holocaust denial and
nazi's need not apply.

Let us please be civil and as always, Caveat Lector.
========================================================================
Archives Available at:
http://home.ease.lsoft.com/archives/CTRL.html

http:[EMAIL PROTECTED]/
========================================================================
To subscribe to Conspiracy Theory Research List[CTRL] send email:
SUBSCRIBE CTRL [to:] [EMAIL PROTECTED]

To UNsubscribe to Conspiracy Theory Research List[CTRL] send email:
SIGNOFF CTRL [to:] [EMAIL PROTECTED]

Om

Reply via email to