-Caveat Lector- http://www.seattletimes.com/news/local/html98/cops_19991201.html Posted at 11:27 a.m. PST; Wednesday, December 1, 1999 Police switch to new strategy by David Postman and Mike Carter Seattle Times staff reporters After losing control of downtown Seattle to renegade protesters Tuesday, police admitted they were caught off-guard despite months of warning. Today, they switched strategies and banned demonstrations in the heart of downtown - an aggressive tactic that carries its own risks. Both approaches are politically touchy for a Police Department that failed to do what it promised: Allow the World Trade Organization to meet in safety, and allow protesters a peaceful platform for dissent. As Seattle police tried to restore peace today, aided today by National Guard troops and the State Patrol, their actions have invited a new round of criticism. Retailers, residents and international visitors are questioning how police let themselves be outsmarted by protesters who, for at least nine months, had made it clear they planned to disrupt the trade talks. Now, constitutional experts are questioning the legality of today's aggressive counter-response by police, who were enforcing a restricted downtown zone of more than 50 blocks. Seattle Mayor Paul Schell has issued a string of apologies since yesterday, admitting the day had not gone as planned. "The last thing I ever wanted to be was the mayor of a city where I had to call out the National Guard, where I had to see tear gas in the streets," said Schell, who pointed out that he was an anti-war protester during the 1960s. "It makes me sick," he said. And by this morning, police officials widely acknowledged they had failed to do an adequate "threat analysis" and were caught off guard early yesterday. The original police strategy focused on clearing streets so that WTO delegates could attend opening ceremonies, even if that meant letting vandals run uninterrupted just blocks away smashing windows, spray-painting walls and tossing newspaper boxes and garbage cans into the streets. "We made a calculated decision to keep the city as safe as we possibly could in the downtown core," said Police Chief Norm Stamper. It's not that police, who had months to plan security for the WTO meeting, did not have warning that things might not go as planned. The demonstrators held a press conference Monday to discuss how protesters would break off from yesterday's planned marches to lock up the city. In a training camp in September, they practiced nonviolent protest, including ways to stop police from breaking up demonstrations. Opposition leaders publicly acknowledged that some demonstrators wouldn't abide by agreements between most organized WTO opponents and the police to avoid violence. "The people we met with did everything they could to follow through on those agreements," said Deputy Chief Ed Joiner. "But quite frankly, we were besieged by a number of others who had no interest whatsoever in going with the program. "Based on the threat analysis we had at the time and the feedback we got from the various groups that were going to protest, we didn't have any way to gauge this kind of behavior, obviously." Chief praises police work Stamper said the police, including departments from throughout King County, did an extraordinary job against difficult odds. The protest organizer most visible in the past months said police should not have been surprised. "Every single meeting I had with the police, I made it very clear that there were lots of groups coming to Seattle, many of which I wouldn't have any control over," said Mike Dolan, deputy director of Global Trade Watch. Dolan said protesters also made it clear that while the organized demonstrations would be nonviolent, that didn't mean they would be law-abiding. "The police told us they would actually wait until the cameras were rolling to film arrests to allow for the choreography of the confrontation to unfold in a dramatic way," Dolan said. "We sat in the City Council chambers and at the Labor Temple and they told us, `We've done this so many times' and regaled us with stories of peaceful arrests and easy street actions." Stamper said those plans couldn't be followed: "The demonstrators, particularly those bent on violence and destruction, used techniques that made it extremely difficult for us to respond in the moment with anything resembling mass arrests." Police officers yesterday showed restraint and personal compassion in some instances. Some helped wash tear gas from the eyes of demonstrators, and a few were seen comforting protesters who had been detained. Yesterday, Schell and Stamper praised the peaceful demonstrators. But in the end, nearly everyone on the street - violent and nonviolent protesters, as well as bystanders - got gassed. Protesters locked arms to prevent WTO delegates and others from crossing key streets. To ensure that delegates could make it safely to opening ceremonies, police used several nonlethal tactics, including shouting through bullhorns; shooting at crowds with gas, pepper spray and rubber bullets; and driving armored trucks through the streets and motorcycles down the sidewalks. Trying to clear a corridor to the Paramount Theatre for delegates, police in body armor fired tear gas to clear intersections. But blocks away, no police were in sight as packs of young people smashed windows at NikeTown, Nordstrom and other stores, spray-painted graffiti and tossed garbage cans and newspaper boxes into the streets. The black-clad, masked gangs of anarchists even flattened the tires of empty police cars and spray-painted objects with their trademark circle "A." Local police draw blame At the height of the morning's action, U.S. Secretary of State Madeleine Albright and U.S. Trade Representative Charlene Barshefsky were holed up in the Westin Hotel. Federal law-enforcement officials said the streets of Seattle were too dangerous for them to travel the few blocks to the opening ceremonies. A federal law-enforcement source and a White House official put the blame on local police. "If you invite delegates to your city, you are obligated to provide them with a safe venue," said the official, who spoke only on condition of anonymity. "It's pretty obvious that didn't happen here." Demonstrators began gathering at 7 a.m. yesterday at two sites downtown. But small groups of protesters, called affinity groups, broke off from the march route and headed for key intersections, chaining themselves together at three locations before police arrived. The affinity groups planned their own events. There was no central organizing effort. When vandals began blocking streets, the peaceful protesters responded with anti-violence chants. Stamper insisted his officers' tactics were forced by vandals and anarchists who committed illegal acts behind lines of peaceful demonstrators. At Sixth Avenue and University Street, where about six protesters were locked together, a demonstrator talked to police through a bullhorn: "These people are locked down and cannot move. Do not gas them." The gas came anyway. At intersection after intersection, the protests melted before the gray clouds of choking and stinging fumes. At times, it was difficult to tell what caused the police to move in. "It didn't make any sense. They gassed us to move us back five or six feet," John Harvey, a grass-roots organizer from Boston, said last night. "When this stuff was happening, they didn't do anything," he said, gesturing to broken windows. By early yesterday afternoon, Stamper admitted that the demonstrators had the upper hand. "There were those who were saying they would shut down the city of Seattle, and they managed to do that today," Stamper said. `The last thing you want' Four hours later, when Schell asked Gov. Gary Locke to send in the National Guard, Stamper said that was his only option. "From a public-safety viewpoint, the last thing you want to do is declare a state of emergency." Even as the mayor and police chief announced the state of emergency in late afternoon, officers on the streets began "rolling up" the crowds by blanketing the streets with tear gas and pushing the thinning crowd east toward Capitol Hill. A handful of demonstrators responded by throwing rocks and bottles. Sticks from protest signs also flew into the police lines. The standoff on Capitol Hill continued through much of the night, with dumpsters set on fire and firecrackers thrown at police. Stamper said there were more violent protesters than "anybody could have predicted." "They did some things they should not have done and that reflected badly on everyone," he said. Schell added: "This was a planned demonstration. Obviously, we're not happy with the outcome. We're urging people to give us back the streets for tomorrow. The point's been made." Copyright � 1999 The Seattle Times Company ======================= Robert F. Tatman Computer Help Desk Desktop & LAN Services Systems Department Philadelphia Newspapers, Inc. [EMAIL PROTECTED] 215.854.2729 215.854.2788 The contents of this message represent the opinion only of the writer, and may not be construed to indicate the endorsement of Knight-Ridder, Inc.; Philadelphia Newspapers, Inc.; The Philadelphia Inquirer; or the Philadelphia Daily News. "Artificial intelligence is no match for natural stupidity." DECLARATION & DISCLAIMER ========== CTRL is a discussion and informational exchange list. Proselyzting propagandic screeds are not allowed. Substance�not soapboxing! These are sordid matters and 'conspiracy theory', with its many half-truths, misdirections and outright frauds is used politically by different groups with major and minor effects spread throughout the spectrum of time and thought. That being said, CTRL gives no endorsement to the validity of posts, and always suggests to readers; be wary of what you read. CTRL gives no credeence to Holocaust denial and nazi's need not apply. Let us please be civil and as always, Caveat Lector. ======================================================================== Archives Available at: http://home.ease.lsoft.com/archives/CTRL.html http:[EMAIL PROTECTED]/ ======================================================================== To subscribe to Conspiracy Theory Research List[CTRL] send email: SUBSCRIBE CTRL [to:] [EMAIL PROTECTED] To UNsubscribe to Conspiracy Theory Research List[CTRL] send email: SIGNOFF CTRL [to:] [EMAIL PROTECTED] Om
