-Caveat Lector-

>
>              www.nytimes.com/2001/01/10/politics/10COUN.html
>
>              January 10, 2001
>
>                2 MEDIA GROUPS MOVE TO EXAMINE FLORIDA VOTES
>                By FELICITY BARRINGER
>
>             After weeks of negotiations, the organized
>             effort by news organizations to examine uncounted
>             Florida ballots has resulted in two independent
>             projects. A consortium of eight news
>             organizations, including The New York Times, The
>             Washington Post, The Wall Street Journal, the
>             Tribune Company and CNN, announced yesterday that
>             they had retained the National Opinion Research
>             Center to examine and report their findings on an
>             estimated 180,000 overvotes and undervotes across
>             the state.
>
>             Another effort, led by The Miami Herald and
>             joined yesterday by USA Today, has been examining
>             undervotes by county for more than three weeks.
>             Several efforts to get the groups to join forces
>             foundered on questions like which ballots to
>             count, how many counters there should be and how
>             the group would be governed.
>
>             But even in its bifurcated form, the media effort
>             to examine the Florida ballots is one of the
>             largest joint projects ever mounted in a business
>             where competition is acute and exclusive reports
>             are among the most highly prized features. The
>             three major television networks declined to
>             participate.
>
>             It is also a project that was shunned by the
>             country's largest accounting firms, who rejected
>             the news organizations' requests that they serve
>             as the independent third party doing the actual
>             examination of the ballots.
>
>             "All of us at the outset were surprised that we
>             were even engaged in these discussions with
>             people we historically compete against," said
>             John Broder, the Washington editor of The New
>             York Times and a spokesman for the larger
>             consortium of news organizations. "The initial
>             reluctance was overcome by the cost of the
>             effort, which we now estimate will run in excess
>             of $500,000, and the sheer logistical challenge
>             of arranging to examine ballots in 67 counties in
>             a large state."
>
>             Republicans yesterday offered muted criticism of
>             the effort, focusing on the issues of the
>             difficulty of finding a single standard to use
>             for such a project and the confusion that could
>             result from a review that might cast doubt on the
>             legitimacy of George W. Bush's election.
>
>             "I think there is some question about whether
>             this will simply add confusion upon confusion,"
>             Ken Lisaius, responding to a call to Mr. Bush's
>             transition office, said. "There are some concerns
>             about how some of these groups -- either one of
>             the two -- are going about this. About whether
>             they're looking at everything they need to look
>             at if they want a complete and accurate
>             assessment of the situation."
>
>             Methodology was the central issue in the
>             breakdown of talks between The Herald, which has
>             retained the accounting firm BDO Seidman to
>             examine the ballots, and the larger consortium,
>             which also includes The Associated Press, The Los
>             Angeles Times, which is owned by the Tribune
>             Company, The Palm Beach Post and The St.
>             Petersburg Times.
>
>             For one thing, The Herald's original plan called
>             for an examination of 60,000 undervotes, or
>             ballots not counted because no presidential
>             choice was discerned in the original counting.
>             The consortium -- in particular representatives
>             of The Wall Street Journal -- insisted that
>             120,000 overvotes, or ballots uncounted because
>             more than one presidential choice was recorded,
>             also be included.
>
>             For another, the Seidman group allotted one
>             person in each county to examine the ballots as
>             presented by county elections officials. The
>             National Opinion Research Center will commit
>             three examiners to the process.
>
>             The research center was hired after several
>             accounting firms, including KPMG, declined to
>             participate.
>
>             David Nestor, a spokesman for
>             PricewaterhouseCoopers L.L.P., said yesterday,
>             "We see very little value in another unofficial
>             vote tally that in any case would not change the
>             outcome of the election and at worst would only
>             serve the cause of bitterness and acrimony."
>
>             But Dan Keating, the database editor of The
>             Washington Post, said unofficial tallies were not
>             the object. "Our absolute purpose was to build
>             the definitive historical archive of these
>             records with statistical validity and social
>             science methodology and utter transparency," he
>             said.
>
>             The ballot examiners from the National Opinion
>             Research Center, which is based at the University
>             of Chicago, will fill out questionnaires that
>             divide ballots into categories. In counties with
>             punch-card voting, for instance, the categories
>             will include blank ballots, ballots with chads
>             entirely punched out, and a variety of
>             intermediate situations: dimples, dimples through
>             which light is visible, misaligned punches and so
>             on. The final database will be made available to
>             anyone interested.
>
>             "We are hiring a highly respected independent
>             research firm with no agendas and asking them to
>             do a double- or triple-blind procedure so it is
>             not subject to biases or errors by a single
>             counter," said Alan Murray, the Washington Bureau
>             chief of The Wall Street Journal. "That is as
>             close as anyone will get to describing what's on
>             those disputed ballots."
>
>             Martin Baron, The Herald's executive editor, said
>             that since his organization took steps to examine
>             ballots, he was called by Joseph Lelyveld, the
>             executive editor of The New York Times, and
>             Leonard Downie Jr., the executive editor of The
>             Post, each suggesting collaboration. No agreement
>             came from these talks. Later discussions between
>             the publishers of The Times and The Post, Arthur
>             Sulzberger Jr. and Boisfeuillet Jones Jr., and P.
>             Anthony Ridder, chief executive of Knight Ridder,
>             The Herald's parent company, also came to naught.
>
>             "We felt that The Miami Herald as the largest
>             paper in the state of Florida should do this
>             story," Mr. Baron said. "This was a project we
>             should run; we shouldn't just be a bit player in
>             a consortium of every large news organization in
>             America where our role would be very unclear, to
>             say the least."
>

<A HREF="http://www.ctrl.org/">www.ctrl.org</A>
DECLARATION & DISCLAIMER
==========
CTRL is a discussion & informational exchange list. Proselytizing propagandic
screeds are unwelcomed. Substance�not soap-boxing�please!  These are
sordid matters and 'conspiracy theory'�with its many half-truths, mis-
directions and outright frauds�is used politically by different groups with
major and minor effects spread throughout the spectrum of time and thought.
That being said, CTRLgives no endorsement to the validity of posts, and
always suggests to readers; be wary of what you read. CTRL gives no
credence to Holocaust denial and nazi's need not apply.

Let us please be civil and as always, Caveat Lector.
========================================================================
Archives Available at:
http://peach.ease.lsoft.com/archives/ctrl.html
 <A HREF="http://peach.ease.lsoft.com/archives/ctrl.html">Archives of
[EMAIL PROTECTED]</A>

http:[EMAIL PROTECTED]/
 <A HREF="http:[EMAIL PROTECTED]/">ctrl</A>
========================================================================
To subscribe to Conspiracy Theory Research List[CTRL] send email:
SUBSCRIBE CTRL [to:] [EMAIL PROTECTED]

To UNsubscribe to Conspiracy Theory Research List[CTRL] send email:
SIGNOFF CTRL [to:] [EMAIL PROTECTED]

Om

Reply via email to