http://www.salon.com/politics/feature/2001/02/09/gifts/print.html
Hillary's mysterious bridal registry
And other myths a biased and credulous press corps has created around the
Clintons' exit.
- - - - - - - - - - - -
By Eric Boehlert
Feb. 9, 2001 | During the nearly month-long controversy surrounding the gifts
Bill and Hillary Clinton accepted last year, the political press has
established three details as fact and repeated them endlessly.
First, anxious to fill their new private homes, the Clintons received
$190,000 worth of gifts in the last year. Second, Hillary pursued this by
registering like a bride for gift at Borsheim's Fine Jewelry & Gifts. Third,
they moved fast, because once Hillary was sworn in as New York's new senator,
she would be barred from accepting gifts worth more than $50.
The first detail showed the Clintons were greedy. The second? That they were
tacky. The third, that they were duplicitous, plotting to circumvent Senate
ethics laws.
From the perspective of the press, just one of those items would have
constituted a good news story. A combination of any two was worth a running
commentary. But all three justified a bona fide feeding frenzy.
Problem is, none of them are true. The gifts in question were received over
an eight-year period, not one. Hillary was never registered at Borsheim's.
And the Senate gift ban would not have forbidden Sen.Clinton from receiving
all the generous items. None of that, though, has gotten in the way of the
press telling a story it likes.
On President Clinton's final day in office, in accordance with federal law
the couple disclosed that for the year 2000 they had accepted $190,027 worth
of gifts, including sweaters, lamps, golf clubs, china and glass sculptures.
That's an extraordinary amount, nearly double what the Clintons had received
during their first seven years in the White House, combined. (For some
context, during their four years in the White House, the least amount of
gifts George and Barbara Bush accepted in any given year was $21,000; the most
the Clintons accepted during their first four years was $16,000.)
An important clue for 2000's lofty price tag, though, was included right on
the Clintons' official Executive Branch Personnel Public Financial Disclosure
Report, which was distributed to the press: "This list includes gifts
received over the last eight years, but which were not accepted by the
Clintons until last year." (As gifts accumulate at the White House, first
families can wait until their final year before officially accepting them or
not.)
It couldn't be more simple; last year the Clintons officially accepted
$190,000 worth of gifts which they had received during the last eight years.
And how was it reported?
The Associated Press: "In the year before President Clinton left office and
Hillary Rodham Clinton entered the Senate, the first couple received $190,027
worth of furniture and other gifts."
New York Daily News : Friends "showered the Clintons with $190,027 in gifts
in 2000."
U.S. News & World Report: "The Clintons got gifts worth $190,027 last year."
(In an odd bit of schizophrenia, the Weekly Standard mocked the Clintons for
"rattling their begging bowls last year" for gifts. Then two sentences later
the magazine quoted from the couple's disclosure form, which stipulated the
gifts were received "over the last eight years.")
At least those news outlets put the gifts in terms of years. Others became
even more creative, narrowing the gift giving down from years to weeks and
even days.
The Orlando Sentinel : The Clintons accumulated the gifts "in the weeks
before" they left the White House.
NBC's Andrea Mitchell: The gifts poured in "during the First Family's last
days in the White House."
NBC's David Bloom: The Clintons left with "the treasure trove of gifts they
accepted in their final days in the White House."
USA Today: In an editorial, the paper suggested the controversy surrounded
"last-minute gifts."
The Kansas City Star: The gifts arrived "as the former president was leaving
office."
National Public Radio's Scott Simon: The Clintons accepted their 50-plus
gifts during "those few golden days between Sen. Clinton's election and her
oath of office, when Senate ethics laws would prohibit accepting such a
trousseau of treasures."
We'll get to that Senate gift ban, but Simon's sinister construction became a
common one: The gift giving was all a plot laid out only after Hillary won
her election.
The AP: There were "indications that some of the larger gifts rolled in late
in the year, just before the Clintons left the White House ."
The Washington Post: In an editorial, the paper suggested that "many of the
items were given after Mrs. Clinton was elected to the Senate in November."
Perhaps Post editorial writers know something its reporters don't. Because in
three weeks of blanket coverage on this story no news outlet, including the
Post or the AP, has been able to identify a single gift, let alone $190,000
worth, given to the Clintons after the Nov. 7 election and before Hillary's
Jan. 3 swearing in.
Last week, the Clintons finally stepped forward and offered to pay for the
$86,000 worth of gifts they received in 2000, some of which had a strong
whiff of impropriety: $7,000 worth of furniture from Denise Rich -- the
ex-wife of Marc Rich, the fugitive financier Clinton pardoned -- and a
truckload of housewarming gifts from friends that had little to do with the
first couple's official duties. But at this point, the record was suddenly
clear; $104,000 of their $190,000 worth of gifts were not given "last year"
or in the "weeks" or "days" or "hours" before they left the White House.
Instead, the gifts were given between 1993 and 2000. Of course, no news
organization stepped forward to correct those earlier errors. Even if
reporters or pundits had simply overlooked the mention of an eight-year span,
a few phone calls to the Clintons' biggest gift donors would have helped set
the record straight. Yet there are indications that some reporters did make
the calls, but were not interested in writing up the facts.
When the Clintons' full-disclosure form was released last month, it included
a pricey $22,000 personal gift from glass sculptor Dale Chihuly. As the
controversy began to simmer, Chihuly's office started getting press inquirers
asking about the circumstances of the gift. Chihuly's assistant Janet Makela
says she explained to each reporter that although the gift was included on
the 2000 list, it was actually given to the Clintons eight years ago.
Yet an electronic search on Nexis shows not a single mention of that fact.
Speaking of Chihuly, the Georgetown alumni class of 1968 also gave the
Clintons a $38,000 Chihuly piece, which the couple accepted in 2000. In
reality, the gift was given in 1998.
And then there is New York furniture maker Steve Mittman, who, according to
the disclosure form, gave $19,000 worth of sofas, easy chairs and ottomans.
Going on nothing more than a hunch, New York Times columnist Maureen Dowd
wrote that Mittman's gifts were part of the Clintons' goodbye gift splurge
intended to stock their new homes. Actually, the items were given seven years
ago. Dowd made a similar error in referring to the timing of the $22,000
Chihuly piece.
Combined, the two glass sculptures, as well as Mittman's furniture, represent
nearly one-half of the Clintons' $190,000 gift total. Yet none of them were
given to the Clintons last year when they were supposedly stocking up on
goodbye gifts.
The Times' Dowd also played a starring role in creating the story that
Hillary had registered for expensive goodbye gifts at Borsheim's. Dancing
around the facts, she never came out and wrote that Hillary was registered,
but that friends were treating her "like a bride" with gifts from the store.
Borsheim's CEO, not to mention Hillary's spokesperson, immediately denied she
was registered with the store or that anyone had set up a registry for her.
It didn't matter. The press loved the limousine-liberal angle, and if Dowd
wouldn't say that Hillary was registered, others would.
NBC's Mitchell: "Mrs. Clinton registered her choices last November, just like
a new bride."
Syndicated columnist Mona Charen: "Hillary likes to shop at Borsheim's Fine
Jewelry & Gifts in Omaha, and according to Dowd, her china and silver
patterns are on the registry list there for those who wish to help out the
new homeowner."
New York Daily News: "Clinton had registered her choices for gifts in
November, just like a bride."
New York Post columnist Dick Morris: "Apparently, it was not enough for them
to establish a bridal-like registry to solicit almost $200,000 worth of
china, silver and furniture for their Chappaqua and D.C. mansions."
Keep in mind: The two parties involved, Hillary Clinton and Borsheim's, long
ago denied the existence of a registry and to date no reporter has been able
to come up with any other proof that one exists, yet the fact is simply
retold over and over. Why? The press likes the story.
Just like the press loves the Senate gift-ban angle, which introduced an
element of real wrongdoing. Once again, the notion was first floated by Dowd,
who wrote, "As a senator, Hillary won't be able to accept gifts worth more
than $100. But as First Lady, she can take gifts as long as she discloses
those over $250. So we have a nice window of opportunity before Jan. 3."
Because no first lady had ever left the White House and gone directly into
elected office, this issue had never come up before. Plus, the Senate gift
ban is relatively new. But following Dowd's lead, the press, just as it was
sure all the Clinton gifts were given last year and that Hillary had
registered like a bride, was utterly confident about the Senate gift ban.
The Providence Journal: "The recent acts of generosity were rushed to avoid
congressional rules forbidding such freebies that would have gone into effect
for Mrs. Clinton once she took the oath of office as New York's junior
senator."
NBC's Mitchell: "The gifts were donated by friends and Democratic Party
contributors just before Mrs. Clinton was sworn in, to avoid violating Senate
ethics rules."
The New York Post: "Now that she is a senator, Hillary Clinton is covered by
much stricter gift rules -- she can't accept any item worth more than $50 or
a total of over $100 worth of presents from an individual in a single year."
Problem is, that's not what the law actually says. Yes, senators are
forbidden from accepting gifts valued at more than $50. But according to the
Senate Ethics Manual, "The Gift Rule contains 23 exceptions: the following
gifts are expressly excluded from the Rule's limitations: 4) anything
provided by an individual on the basis of a personal friendship."
Senators may accepts gifts if they are given based on personal friendship and
where "there is no potential conflict of interest or appearance of
impropriety." Any such gifts worth more than $250 need a waiver from the
Senate Ethics Committee. "Thus, gifts motivated solely by personal friendship
between the giver and the Member are permissible. However, where the gift
giver does not personally pay for the gift, or take a tax deduction, or gives
similar gifts to others in the Senate, or seek reimbursement, the gift is
unlikely to come within the personal friendship exemption."
Most of the gifts given to the Clintons last year would seem to fit all those
waiver criteria since nobody has suggested any of the gift givers didn't
spend their own money, or were seeking a tax deduction or reimbursement.
Nobody has suggested their friends have legislation pending before the Senate
or pose any other conflict of interest. And nobody has suggested they gave
similar gifts to other members of the Senate.
What about Denise Rich and her $7,000 worth of gifts? If they were given to
the Clintons after Jan. 3, Hillary could have, in theory, sought a waiver
since the pardon of Rich's husband, which Hillary had nothing to do with, was
already a done deal. Therefore, no conflict of interest with the Senate
existed. The Gift Rule contains another relevant exception: spouses.
According to the Senate Ethics Manual: "Unlike the previous Rule 25, spouses
and dependents are not separately subjected to the gift limitation. Rather
under the current rule, a gift to a family member is considered a gift to the
Member only if it is given with the knowledge and acquiescence of the Member
and the Member has reason to believe the gift was given because of the
official position of the Member."
Does anyone really think the Clintons were given their gifts because Hillary
was about to become a senator? Indeed, with $104,000 worth of gifts coming
before last year, most gift givers gave before Hillary ever won the election,
let alone announced her intention to run. And even if old friends waited
until this year to give the Clintons expensive housewarming gifts, because
Bill is arguably just as much a recipient as Sen. Clinton, Hillary could ask
for waivers based on the spouse exemption.
Meanwhile, the gift store just keeps on giving. After assigning three
reporters and four researchers, the Washington Post reported on Monday that
some of the gifts the Clintons took may have been given to the White House,
and not to them personally. The Clintons insist there was a clerical snafu
and that any gifts intended for the White House would be returned. By Monday
afternoon, the White House's nonpartisan usher and executive manager, Gary
Walters, assured CNN the Clintons had not erred in taking their gifts.
"Everything that belongs to the government is still here," he said.
New York furniture maker Mittman, whose gifts were in dispute in the Post
story, subsequently told reporters he's glad the Clintons took his furniture.
More important, he thinks the whole gift tale is trivial.
He's not the only one.
- Re: [CTRL] Hillary's mysterious bridal registry William Shannon
- Re: [CTRL] Hillary's mysterious bridal registry Prudence L. Kuhn
