-Caveat Lector-
Environment
The FTAA draft, as it now stands, contains no safeguards for
the environment. The original mandate for the FTAA, drawn up
at the first Summit of the Americas in Miami in 1994, contained
a promise to promote economic integration of the hemisphere
in such a way as "to guarantee sustainable development while
protecting the environment." A major Summit on Sustainable
Development was held in Bolivia in 1996 in order to ensure
that the principles of the 1992 Rio Earth Summit would be
integral to the FTAA process. Out of that meeting (at which
civil society groups and environmentalists were notably
absent), came 65 initiatives know as the "Santa Cruz Action
Plan," and a new body, the OAS Inter-American Committee on
Sustainable Development.
However, the whole process was badly underfunded and had
no clear mandate for action; it has been widely regarded as a
failure. As a consequence, the whole goal of sustainable
development was completely dropped from the FTAA's new
mandate at the Santiago Summit in 1998, and the tracks of
trade and environment were completely separated. With
George W. Bush now in the White House, it is even more
certain that environmental concerns about the hemispheric free
trade deal will be set aside.
The Canadian government's recently published "position paper"
on the FTAA contains a reference to the environment in its
proposed Preamble. It calls for the FTAA to commit to "Better
protecting the environment and promoting sustainable
development by adopting trade and environmental policies that
are mutually supportive." However, Preambular language in
trade agreements is non-binding and unenforceable, so any
promise in this section of the agreement is fairly meaningless.
In any case, it is not possible to find compatibility between a
trade agreement that contains investor-state rights for
corporations and environmental stewardship.
Chapter 11
As briefly documented above (see Investment in "What's in the
FTAA?"), and well documented in a number of other sources,
the investor-state provisions of NAFTA have already had a very
serious impact on government environmental policy. Not only
have a number of health and environmental regulations in
Canada, the United States and Mexico already been
successfully challenged by the corporations of the continent,
Chapter 11 is used to create a "chill effect," whereby
governments are warned not to contemplate certain new
regulatory measures for fear of running afoul of the
investment provisions of NAFTA.
As legal trade expert Steven Shrybman explains: "The
investor-state suit provisions of NAFTA represent nothing
short of a radical departure from both the domestic and
international legal norms in at least three fundamental ways.
First, by providing corporations with the right to directly
enforce an international treaty to which they are neither
parties, nor under which they have any obligations. Second, by
extending international commercial arbitration to claims that
have nothing to do with commercial contracts and everything
to do with public policy and law. Third, by creating substantive
legal rights - concerning expropriation and national treatment
that go far beyond those available to Canadian citizens or
businesses."
Any new regulations that are brought to Parliament or any
provincial legislature can be challenged by American
corporations with interests in the sector in question. In
essence, governments have to be prepared to pay dearly for
the right to protect the ecological, human and animal health
concerns within their mandate. As trade lawyer Barry Appleton
explains, "They could be putting liquid plutonium in children's
food; if you ban it and the company making it is an American
company, you have to pay compensation."
To avoid this scenario, Canadian federal and provincial
governments now have to allow all prospective environmental
and natural resource protection regulations to be vetted by
DFAIT. In an October 2000 exchange at a Parliamentary
Environment Committee meeting, Liberal MP Clifford Lincoln
asked senior DFAIT officials Nigel Bankes and Ken Macartney
whether it was true that International Trade Minister Pierre
Pettigrew is fighting against the inclusion of the precautionary
principle in domestic environmental legislation, such as the
proposed new law to protect endangered species, so as to
ensure that Canada is in compliance with the WTO. The trade
bureaucrats confirmed that this was indeed so.
Environment ministers now have less power over their
jurisdiction than their trade counterparts. When the
environment ministers of the three NAFTA countries
announced in December 1998 that they were going to allow
the Commission for Environmental Co-operation (CEC) - the
NAFTA side deal that has become a toothless "environmental
watchdog" - to scrutinize these Chapter 11 cases, they
stepped way over the line drawn for them by DFAIT and its
sister agencies in Washington and Mexico City. Months later,
the environment ministers totally retracted the new powers,
reigning in the agency so far, in fact, that they stopped just
short of dismantling it altogether.
Given this track record, and the dropping of the goal of
sustainable development from the principles of the FTAA
process, there is little reason to believe that environmental
concerns will fare much better in the hemispheric trade pact.
Energy
While there is no separate FTAA Negotiating Group on energy
or any mention of the subject in the Canadian government's
"position paper," there is a consensus to come up with an
"early harvest" agreement on energy at the Quebec City
Summit in April. In fact, it is highly likely that the FTAA will
mirror the controversial energy provisions that were integral to
both the Canada-U.S. Free Trade Agreement and NAFTA.
In these agreements, negotiators created an anti-environment,
anti-conservation, deregulated continental energy policy based
on short-term, high-cost, high-profit exports and controlled
by transnational energy corporations with little interest in rising
prices or the environmental consequences of their actions. If
this deregulated energy regime gets extended to the
hemisphere, it will have devastating consequences in the fight
to reduce the overuse of climate-warming fossil fuels in the
countries of the Americas.
In Canada, to comply with these NAFTA provisions, the
National Energy Board was stripped of its powers and the
"vital-supply safeguard" that had required Canada to maintain
a 25-year surplus of natural gas was dismantled. No
government agency or law now exists to ensure that
Canadians have adequate supplies of our own energy in the
future. (The United States, however, declared that its 25-year
reserve was necessary for national security purposes, and
maintained it.)
Export applicants, Canadian or American, were no longer
required to file an export impact assessment and the
all-Canadian gas distribution system was abandoned, setting
off a frantic round of North-South pipeline construction.
Export taxes on our energy supplies were banned, resulting in
the loss of a source of tax revenue for governments and giving
American customers, who don't have to pay the GST, a price
advantage over Canadian consumers.
Most important, the trade agreements imposed a system of
"proportional sharing" whereby Canadian energy supplies to
the U.S. are guaranteed in perpetuity. In an astonishing
surrender of sovereignty, the Government of Canada agreed
that it no longer has the right to "refuse to issue a licence or
revoke or change a licence for the exportation to the United
States of energy goods," even for environmental or
conservation practices.
This led to a spectacular increase in the sale of natural gas to
U.S. markets; since 1986, exports have more than quadrupled
to over 8.5 billion cubic feet a day. About 55 percent of total
Canadian gas production is exported to the U.S. where
American distribution companies, supplying a much larger
population, have been able to sign long-term contracts at
rock-bottom prices. Canadian consumers are left to compete
for their own energy resources against an economy 10 times
bigger with rapidly dwindling reserves and accelerating demand.
The story in oil is the same. Canada now produces 2.3 million
barrels a day and ships 1.3 of those barrels to the U.S.
The free trade agreements committed Canada to an energy
policy driven by massive, guaranteed exports to the U.S.,
corporate control of supplies and an economic policy more
dependent than ever on the exploitation of primary resources.
Because they exempted Canadian government subsidies for oil
and gas exploration from trade challenge, they ensured that
Canadian public funds would continue to pay for uncontrolled
and environmentally destructive fossil fuel exploration, a
process that has already destroyed habitats in the North and
that threatens the sensitive spawning grounds off Cape Breton
and Newfoundland, all to the benefit of transnational
corporations.
In the FTAA, these provisions will very likely extend to all the
countries of the Americas, who should be made aware of the
resulting loss of sovereignty over their energy supplies and
their environmental responsibility to husband those resources
well.
Water
Similarly, it is unlikely that the United States would not extend
the provisions of NAFTA concerning water to the other
countries of the hemisphere under the FTAA. these provisions
establish a continental water market in the case of the
commencement of commercial water exports; for the countries
of Latin America concerned about water privatization schemes,
this is an issue urgently needing attention.
Chapter 3 of NAFTA establishes obligations, including national
treatment rights, regarding market access for the trade in
goods. It uses the General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade
(GATT) definition of a "good," which clearly lists "waters,
including natural or artificial waters and aerated waters" as a
good, and adds in an explanatory note that "ordinary natural
water of all kinds, other than sea water," is included.
When the NAFTA deal, and its predecessor, the Canada-U.S.
Free Trade Agreement, were being negotiated, opponents
urged that water be clearly exempted from them altogether.
The governments said no, arguing that no water was being
traded commercially at that time in any of the NAFTA
countries; therefore, water in its "natural" state was safe.
Critics argued that any such protection was temporary at best
and that the moment any jurisdiction started selling its water
for commercial purposes, key provisions of NAFTA would
become applicable, putting public control of water in jeopardy.
There are three key provisions of NAFTA that place water at
risk once it is traded. The first is national treatment, whereby
no country can discriminate in favour of its own private sector
in the commercial use of its water resources. Once a permit is
granted to a domestic company to export water, the
"investors" - i.e., corporations - of the other NAFTA countries
have the same "right of establishment" to the commercial use
of this water as the domestic companies. This applies to
provinces as well; if British Columbia allows the commercial
export of bulk water, all provinces will have to allow national
treatment rights to the same foreign companies as well.
The second provision is Chapter 11, the investor-state clause.
It applies to water in two ways. First, if any NAFTA country,
state or province tries to allow only domestic companies to
export water, corporations in the other NAFTA countries would
have the right to sue for financial compensation. Second, if any
NAFTA government introduced legislation to ban bulk water
exports, by that act water would automatically become a
commercial "good"; foreign investors' Chapter 11 rights would
be triggered by the very law that excludes them, and they
could demand financial compensation for lost opportunities.
The third key provision is Article 315, "proportional sharing,"
the same provision that has created a continental market for
Canada's energy supplies. Under Articles 315 and 309, no
country can reduce or restrict the export of a resource once
the trade has been established. Nor can the government place
an export tax or charge more to the consumers of another
NAFTA country than they charge domestically. Canadian
exports of water would be guaranteed to the level they had
acquired over the preceding 36 months; the more water sent
south, the more water required to be sent south. Even if new
evidence were found that massive movements of water were
harmful to the environment, these requirements would remain
in place.
The proposed FTAA adds another threat to water sovereignty
and conservation. "Environmental Services" are included in the
list of services now being negotiated by the GATS. It is very
likely that environmental services, which include water services,
will similarly be included in the FTAA. This means that public
water services could be challenged under the national
treatment provisions of the proposed agreement, forcing
public services such as water delivery and wastewater
treatment to be privatized and contracted out to transnational
water corporations like Suez Lyonnaise des Eaux and Vivendi.
If any government attempts to maintain its water services in
public hands, these corporations would have enormous
compensation rights under Chapter 11.
This loss of public control of water is a very serious one for
Canada, and of even greater urgency for the countries of Latin
America, where water privatization, strongly promoted by the
World Bank, is spreading very quickly.
Combined with the TBT and SPS agreements of the WTO and
the plans for "early harvest" agreements in forests and
fisheries, the proposed FTAA appears to be a disaster for
ecological stewardship for the Americas.
Culture
No mention is made of culture or cultural exemptions in the
mandates of any of the Negotiating Groups. Canada does
mention culture in the Preamble to its position paper:
"Recognizing that countries must maintain the ability to
preserve, develop and implement their cultural policies for the
purpose of strengthening cultural diversity, given the essential
role that cultural goods and services play in the identity and
diversity of society and the lives of individuals." Again,
however, this Preambular language is largely decorative. It is
very likely that culture will either be fully included in the
hemispheric pact or there will be a cultural "exemption" similar
to the one that exists in NAFTA. And that is almost as bad as
having culture fully included.
The terms on culture were clearly set out in NAFTA Annex
2106. While one article (2005:1) exempts the cultural industry
from the agreement with the exception of tariff elimination,
divesture of an indirect acquisition, and transmission rights,
another (2005:2) puts culture right back in by giving the U.S.
the right to retaliate against Canada with measures "of
equivalent commercial effect" and to do so using sectors
unrelated to culture. Yet another (2011:2) permits the U.S. to
circumvent the dispute settlement procedure when it retaliates.
Other sections of the agreement, particularly dealing with
investment, competition policy and monopolies also infringe on
the right of Canadians to protect cultural policy.
This means that the U.S. has the legal right to unilaterally
decide if a Canadian cultural measure is "inconsistent" with
NAFTA, to retaliate against Canada and to select the nature
and severity of the retaliation. Canada has no legal rights
whatsoever. It cannot even request a panel to judge whether
U.S. accusations are justified and, if so, to ensure U.S.
retaliation is commensurate with the offence.
It appears from the mandate of the FTAA Negotiating
Committees that an additional risk to Canada's cultural
programs will find its way into the FTAA in the services
chapter. If cultural services are included in the definition of
services, as they appear to be ("universal coverage of all
service sectors"), and the principles of national treatment and
most favoured nation apply to these cultural services, as they
also appear to do, then government subsidies to the arts and
culture could not be allocated exclusively to Canadian artists,
publications, production companies and the like.
There are really only three forms of cultural protections left in
Canada in the wake of WTO rulings: government subsidies,
such as those given to the CBC or to book publishers of
Canadian titles; Canadian content quotas, such as content
regulations in radio and television; and investment policies,
such as investment controls limiting non-Canadian investment
in broadcasting, telecommunications and cable companies.
Under a regime that allowed the direct challenge of government
programs, all three could be deemed trade illegal. Just as in
social programs, any government support of a Canadian
"service" - in this case, cultural services - would have to be
applied in a non-discriminatory manner; American and other
corporations of the hemisphere in the entertainment industry
could demand equal rights to compete and receive government
funding. As with social programs, any government that
continued to favour the Canadian cultural sector could be sued
for compensation under Chapter 11 by transnational industry
corporations, from big-box retailers to movie networks.
If the proposed FTAA is adopted unchanged, Canadian cultural
diversity and Canada's cultural industries will become a relic of
a past time.
Agriculture and Food Security
Canada's farmers have already felt the full blast of global
competition, as the Canadian government has slashed farm
subsidies and farm income support far more and far faster
than have its major trading partners. As a result, 1999 and
2000 were the worst years for Canadian farmers since 1926,
the year that the Canadian government began to keep such
records.
By choosing the WTO agreements on agriculture (AOA) and
standards (SPS and TBT), the FTAA negotiators plan to give
new powers through this pact to curtail the traditional rights of
Canada's farmers and to downgrade Canada's food safety
laws. Under WTO disciplines, farmers can no longer collectively
negotiate prices for products with both domestic and foreign
buyers. And the elimination of domestic agriculture price
supports to protect farmers has left them at the mercy of
international prices.
Because the WTO prohibits import and export controls, only
the big - big farms, big countries, big corporations - can
survive. As a result, the WTO's Agreement on Agriculture has
almost exclusively benefited large agribusiness corporations
around the world no matter what their country of origin.
Furthermore, the WTO AOA assault on non-tariff measures,
such as environmental standards and supply management
programs, has been used to downgrade safeguards to public
health and protection for farmers. For example, through the
WTO, the U.S. has successfully challenged Japan's
health-related pesticide residue testing requirements for
agricultural imports. Countries can no longer maintain
emergency food stocks in anticipation of drought or crop
failure; they must now buy what they need on the open
market. "Food self sufficiency" now means having enough
money to buy food, not the domestic ability to produce it.
The WTO SPS agreement has had a terrible impact on the right
of the world's citizens to safe food. Canada and the United
States successfully used the SPS agreement to strike down a
European ban on North American beef containing harmful,
possibly cancer-causing hormones. The EU, deeply sensitive to
lingering concerns about mad-cow disease, implemented a ban
on the non-therapeutic use of hormones in its food industry,
citing many studies linking them to illness. The WTO panel
demanded "scientific certainty" that these hormones cause
cancer or other adverse health affects, thus eviscerating the
precautionary principle as a basis for food safety regulations.
The FTAA appears poised to promote a model of agriculture to
the hemisphere where food is not grown by farmers for
domestic consumers, but by corporations for global markets.
The results will be far-reaching indeed.
What Impact Will the FTAA Have on the Countries of
Latin America?
The countries of Central and South America and the Caribbean
are being given all sorts of promises about the FTAA: more
liberalized trade and investment will create the biggest trade
powerhouse in history, thereby spreading prosperity to the
many millions of the region currently without work or hope,
they are told.
Latin Americans should examine these promises very carefully
before jumping into this pact.
The reality is that Latin America has been living under this
FTAA model for over a decade. It is based on the Structural
Adjustment programs of the World Bank and the IMF that
Latin Americans know well. It was the deregulation and
privatization imperatives of structural adjustment that forced
most to dismantle their public infrastructures in the first place.
In order to be eligible for debt relief, many dozens of the
countries of the Americas were forced to abandon public social
programs, allowing for-profit foreign corporations to come in
and sell their health and education "products" to "consumers"
who can afford them.
Now these countries are allowed to maintain the most basic of
public services only for the poor; but these services are so
inadequate that the corporations aren't interested in them,
and many millions of people in the hemisphere go without the
most basic of education and health services. Not surprisingly,
Latin American countries are experiencing an invasion of U.S.
health care corporations, like Aetna International and American
International, who report a 20 percent growth in the region per
year.
Under the FTAA, this process will accelerate, wiping out
traditional medicine, education and cultural diversity. In fact,
worldwide economic and cultural harmonization is the goal,
says one top U.S. WTO official, who adds, "Basically, it won't
stop until foreigners finally start to think like Americans, act like
Americans and - most of all - shop like Americans."
The last decade of trade and investment liberalization has
already caused great suffering in Latin America. Interest rates
on debt payments have soared from 3 percent in 1980 to over
20 percent today. Latin America, as a region, has the highest
rate of inequitable income distribution in the world. After
swallowing its free market medicine, it now has a poverty rate
higher than it was in 1980 and the buying power of Latin
American workers is 27 percent lower. Eighty-five percent of all
job growth has been in the precarious sector with no benefits
or protections.
Mexico, eight years into NAFTA, now has record-high poverty
rates of 70 percent; the average minimum wage lost more than
three quarters of its purchasing power in those years. Ninety
million Latin Americans are now indigent and 105 million have
no access to health care whatsoever. Child labour has grown
dramatically; there are now at least 19 million children working
in terrible conditions. Massive environmental degradation has
resulted from the region's desperate rush to exploit its natural
resources and the use of pesticides and fertilizers has tripled
since 1996; there are now 80,000 chemical substances
produced and used in the Americas.
The exploitation of Latin America's natural resources by
Canadian and U.S. corporations now taking place would
dramatically increase under a hemispheric pact. Transnational
mining, energy, water, engineering, forestry and fisheries
corporations would have new access to the precious resource
base of every country and the investor-state right to challenge
any government that tried to limit their access to them. The
ability of governments to protect the ecology or set
environmental standards regarding the extraction of natural
resources would be greatly reduced, as would the right to
ensure local jobs from any activity of foreign corporations.
Joining the FTAA under these circumstances would be
"tantamount to suicide," says the coalition of trade unions of
the Southern Cone countries. In December 2000, the major
unions of Argentina, Brazil, Paraguay and Uruguay held the
MERCOSUR Trade Union Summit where they called upon their
governments to submit the FTAA to national plebiscites, which
they believe would result in its defeat. The FTAA process is
deepening the already growing poverty of the region, the union
leaders said, putting "limits on national institutions that should
decide the future of each country, while pushing aside the
mechanisms that allow society to ensure a democratic
administration of the state."
Conclusion
If the terms and recommendations of the FTAA Negotiating
Groups are the substantive basis for a hemisphere trade pact,
the whole process is totally unacceptable and the citizens of
the Americas must work to defeat it entirely. In spite of
government protestations that they have negotiated these
new trade and investment rules in full collaboration with their
citizens, the proposed FTAA reflects none of the concerns
voiced by civil society and contains all of the provisions
considered most egregious by environmentalists, human rights
and social justice groups, farmers, indigenous peoples, artists,
workers and many others. Every single social program,
environmental regulation and natural resource is at risk under
the proposed FTAA. As it appears to stand now, there is no
possible collaboration to make this trade pact acceptable.
That is not to say that the citizens of the Americas are
opposed to rules governing the trade and economic links
between our countries. In the wake of the failed MAI, Canadian
civil society groups held a national inquiry called Confronting
Globalization and Reclaiming Democracy, in which hundreds
of groups participated. The results show clearly that, based on
a different set of fundamental assumptions, such as the United
Nations Universal Declaration on Human Rights and strong
environmental rules, Canadian citizens would be prepared to
enter into a process to develop closer ties with other countries
in the Americas and around the world. However, it cannot start
with the assumptions and goals of this FTAA.
This process must begin by revisiting current international
trade agreements like the WTO and NAFTA; it is time for a new
international trading system based on the foundations of
democracy, sustainability, diversity and development, and
much good work is being done on these alternatives. As a
beginning, Chapter 11 must be removed from NAFTA; water
must be exempted; the energy provisions rewritten with an
emphasis on conservation; and culture must be truly
exempted.
Most important, the world of international trade can no longer
be the exclusive domain of sheltered elites, trade bureaucrats
and corporate power brokers. When they understand what is
at stake in this hemispheric negotiation, the peoples of the
Americas will mobilize to defeat it. That is the fate it deserves.
Maude Barlow is the Volunteer Chairperson of The Council of
Canadians, Canada's largest public advocacy group, and a Director
with the International Forum on Globalization. She is the best-selling
author or co-author of 12 books. Her new book, Global Showdown: How
the New Activists are Fighting Global Corporate Rule, co-authored with
Tony Clarke, will be published by Stoddart in February 2001.
SOURCES
Free Trade of the Americas, Canadian Government Release:
Canada's Proposals for the FTAA Agreement, Department of
Foreign Affairs and International Trade, December 13, 2000,
Ottawa.
The State of the FTAA Negotiations at the Turn of the
Millennium, Paper prepared for the conference, "Trade and the
Western Hemisphere," organized by Southern Methodist
University, Dallas, Texas, March 25, 2000, by Sherri M.
Stephenson, Deputy Director for Trade, Organization of
American States.
Report to the Trade Negotiations Committee, Restricted
Document by the FTAA Negotiating Group on Services
outlining its mandate, leaked in October 2000.
Services and Trade in the Western Hemisphere: Liberalization,
Integration and Reform, Collection edited by Sherri. M.
Stephenson, Brookings Institute, Washington, 2000.
Social Exclusion, Jobs, and Poverty in the Americas, Paper
prepared for the Americas Civil Society Forum, November
1999, Toronto, by the Hemispheric Social Alliance and Common
Frontiers-Canada.
Forgotten Promises and Forgotten Lessons: The OAS, the
FTAA and Environmental Protection, Paper prepared for the
International Centre for Democratic Development Workshop,
Windsor, June 5, 2000, by Christine Elwell of the Sierra Club of
Canada.
Navigating NAFTA, A Concise User's Guide to the North
American Free Trade Agreement, Barry Appleton, Carswell,
Toronto, 1994.
MAI, The Multilateral Agreement on Investment and the
Threat to Canadian Sovereignty, Tony Clarke and Maude
Barlow, Stoddart, Toronto, 1997.
Whose Trade Organization? Corporate Globalization and the
Erosion of Democracy, Lori Wallach and Michelle Sforza, Public
Citizen, Washington DC, 1999.
GATS: How the World Trade Organization's New "Services"
Negotiations Threaten Democracy, Scott Sinclair, The
Canadian Centre for Policy Alternatives, Ottawa, Ontario, 2000.
The World Trade Organization, A Citizens' Guide, Steven
Shrybman, The Canadian Centre for Policy Alternatives,
Ottawa, Ontario, and James Lorimer and Co. Ltd, Halifax, Nova
Scotia, 1999.
Invisible Government, the World Trade Organization: Global
Government for the New Millennium? Debi Barker and Jerry
Mander, International forum on Globalization, San Francisco,
2000.
Also, with research on services from Ellen Gould, Vancouver;
on E-commerce from Sarah Anderson of the Institute for Policy
Studies, Washington; and on Latin America from Karen
Hansen-Kuhn, of the Development Gap, Washington.
Print Frame
The Council of Canadians
502-151 Slater Street, Ottawa, Ontario, K1P 5H3, Canada
Telephone: 613-233-2773, 1-800-387-7177 - Fax:
613-233-6776
www.canadians.org - [EMAIL PROTECTED]
<A HREF="http://www.ctrl.org/">www.ctrl.org</A>
DECLARATION & DISCLAIMER
==========
CTRL is a discussion & informational exchange list. Proselytizing propagandic
screeds are unwelcomed. Substance�not soap-boxing�please! These are
sordid matters and 'conspiracy theory'�with its many half-truths, mis-
directions and outright frauds�is used politically by different groups with
major and minor effects spread throughout the spectrum of time and thought.
That being said, CTRLgives no endorsement to the validity of posts, and
always suggests to readers; be wary of what you read. CTRL gives no
credence to Holocaust denial and nazi's need not apply.
Let us please be civil and as always, Caveat Lector.
========================================================================
Archives Available at:
http://peach.ease.lsoft.com/archives/ctrl.html
<A HREF="http://peach.ease.lsoft.com/archives/ctrl.html">Archives of
[EMAIL PROTECTED]</A>
http:[EMAIL PROTECTED]/
<A HREF="http:[EMAIL PROTECTED]/">ctrl</A>
========================================================================
To subscribe to Conspiracy Theory Research List[CTRL] send email:
SUBSCRIBE CTRL [to:] [EMAIL PROTECTED]
To UNsubscribe to Conspiracy Theory Research List[CTRL] send email:
SIGNOFF CTRL [to:] [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Om