-Caveat Lector- http://www.guerrillanews.com/media/cointel/doc484.html
Lapp�: Tell me about your book, "The Culture of Make Believe." Jensen: It started off as a ten-page introduction to an encyclopedia of hate groups. When I asked the question, 'What's a hate group?' the book exploded because the first thing that I did was I went to a KKK web site and I saw there that they declare themselves not a hate group but a love group. They love America and they love whites . . . and so this immediately raised another question. Either the KKK is not a hate group, or you can't trust an organization's own rhetoric . . . and if you can't trust their rhetoric, what then can you trust? If you go just by the numbers, then the largest segregationist racist organization in the country is the American judicial and penal system because it has achieved segregation of black males on a scale that the KKK can only dream about. There's about 33% of African American males between the ages of 20 and 30 are under criminal justice's supervision and in some places it's over 50%. Baltimore, for example, is 56% of those between 18 and 35 or 36. Lapp�: Wow. Jensen: And so I just started asking, 'What does that mean?' Does this mean that nation states can be quote 'hate groups?' - which, if you don't believe that, it drives you into an absurdity because that would mean that the American Nazi party with its paltry membership is actually a hate group while Nazi Germany was not. There were sites with thousands and thousands of women bound and gagged with captions like 'make these young sluts do whatever you want' - none of them were listed under hate watch organizations. Why? So I started to get really interested in perception. I am interested in why there are some forms of atrocity that we can perceive and other forms that we cannot. So the book really started to explode at that point. For example, where do women fit into this picture? I did a keyword search of the word rape on Alta Vista and the single most common type of site that I found was pornography . . . and this was not anatomy that I was looking up, it was action. There were sites with thousands and thousands of women bound and gagged with captions like 'make these young sluts do whatever you want.' The interesting thing about that is that none of those web sites were listed under hate watch organizations. I thought was really interesting, because if you had a bunch of white guys all bound with the caption 'nasty little breeders' or black guys bound with the caption 'make these young bucks do whatever you want', the hate watch organizations would be all over this . . . so why is it that they are transparent? One of the things that I came to pretty quickly was that any hatred that's felt long enough and deeply enough no longer feels like hatred, it feels like tradition, or religion, or economics, or the way things are. Lapp�: You quote Nietzsche who said, "One does not hate so long as one despises." Explain the meaning of that to you in this context... Jensen: Well, where that came from was I started doing an exploration of the rationale for slavery because I figured if anything is hate-based in its conception it's got to be slavery. And the rationale by the 19th century slave owners was religious: that if it was OK in the Bible, then it's OK for us . . . or it's historical: that civilizations are based on slavery (and they're right by the way of course) or it would be economic: if we don't have slavery then we're going to lose our livelihoods, or philanthropic: that we are actually doing them a favor by civilizing them, by bringing them under our wings . . . and there was also an argument that actually the slaves are better off than capitalist laborers, and you could make a strong argument that they were, because they were taken care of for life as opposed to the wage slaves in the North . . . but the point is where does hate fit into this picture? Looking back, before the Civil War there wasn't actually that much lynching going on . . . and the lynching that did go on was not really race-based - it was just rough justice. After the war, of course, there were literally tens of thousands of African Americans who were murdered by southern whites in the ten years following the Civil War, so how did that happen? The southern whites didn't hate the blacks so long as their entitlement to their labor wasn't threatened. This is where the Nietzsche quote comes in. I sort of stumbled upon it and then everything opened up for me. When I read his quote, "One does not hate when one can despise" I realized that if you have a system of entitlement in place and that entitlement is not threatened you merely despise or look down upon those that you feel entitled to exploit - but if that entitlement is threatened, then the hatred that was lying underneath springs to the surface. The southern whites didn't hate the blacks so long as their entitlement to their labor wasn't threatened. When entitlement was threatened they turned on the blacks with a kind of vengeance not seen previously. It was the same within my family. As you know in my book, "Language Older Than Words," I talked about my own family's abuse as a springboard to talk about the culture at large and as that relates here. The one time that my brother fought back, he got beaten harder than he ever did before. So there are very strict rules within our culture in which violence is only allowed to flow in one direction. And when it flows in the opposite direction . . . when it flows up the hierarchy, the victims are fetishized and those who committed the violence are demonized and tortured and killed, as with the lynching - even if there's no violence, if they just get up and if they threaten that entitlement. Once you've been metabolized into the system, you no longer resist and so there's not so much need for that grotesque violence. That's another thing that was really interesting. Why is it that African Americans aren't lynched here these days that often? Because clearly, all the economic numbers show that the racism is still very much still alive in this country... and the connection I was making there has to do with a quote by W.E.B. DuBois, he has this quote - 'It used to be it was the capitalists versus the laborers in America and what it is now is it's America versus the world.' What I took from that is that you have this expanding wave and at the exterior of that frontier you have the grotesque violence . . . and that's because people are resisting the threat to their - they're resisting that exploitation. But once you've been internalized - once you've been metabolized into the system, you no longer resist and so there's not so much need for that grotesque violence. Instead it happens because we buy into the system, and once we've bought into the system, then it doesn't need to use that spectacular terror against us. Lapp�: Right. So what does the term culture of make believe mean? Jensen: The simple metaphor for the book is Ham and Noah. One night Noah got drunk and passed out naked in his tent and Ham came in and saw him naked and then went out and told his brothers. And then his brothers came in and they walked backwards so they wouldn't see their fathers nakedness and covered him up and then walked back up. So then the next day when Noah woke up, he was furious and he cursed Ham forever. As a kid, this makes no sense to me, but as I was writing this book, I finally understood it. Because what it is is when you have a system of oppression, that system will fall apart immediately if you do what Ham did, which is if you see the patriarch, the one in charge, the oppressor - if you see that person naked and vulnerable. I think it's one of the most powerful stories in the Bible. It's a cautionary tale. It's saying OK don't do this. If you do this, you're going to be enslaved forever. If you don't you're going to get rewarded. And I think that's how the whole system works. And so we have this whole series of things you can't see. You can't talk about how we're killing the planet. The other day there was an article on page three in the San Francisco Bay Chronicle - Scientist says, We're Killing Planet! And on page two, implying equivalent importance in the same spread, was an article about Miss Celo being sued for fraud. So that's where the make believe really comes from. We make believe that our system isn't oppressive. Lapp�: Right. But for most Americans when they look at American culture they see American culture as the pinnacle of modern history of humanity - that we've achieved a level of wealth and democracy and security that no other culture has... I think we would probably admit that most Americans have this view of this country. Jensen: Well, first off I would say how did they get their land? And I'm not talking about them buying it from the person before, but how did whites get the land in the first place? They got it by conquest. And there's that great statement by John Marshall - and once again I'm butchering this - but if your whole system is based on conquest, conquest cannot be questioned . . . and so where do we think that. I mean this lifestyle is based on systematic exploitation. My backpack is made in a sweatshop and my automobile is made with steel that came from Brazil which means it's slave-tainted. It's a whole system. That's one of the things that I really liked about the nineteenth century slave holding philosophers is that at least they were honest - that our comforts and elegancies are based on the exploitation of others. And it's more than I can say for us. Everything that we have, my backpack is made in a sweatshop and my automobile is made with steel that came from Brazil which means it's slave-tainted. It's a whole system - and let's not even talk about global warming! When I used to teach and Washington University, I used to ask my students if we lived in a democracy and this is a conservative school, and they would - out of all the hundreds and hundreds of students I asked, you know what their response was every time? They laughed. I think that we believe the rhetoric on one level, but on another level, everybody knows that this isn't a democracy. Lapp�: Right. I think people have a cynical view, but if you asked them if America was the greatest country in the world, where you have the most opportunity, they would agree. But it's a good point because it gets to something I have been thinking about - there is a growing sense and a feeling, when we look at our popular culture in particular, there is something deeply wrong about it. And it was very interesting - I don't know if you saw this, Fox news commentator Bill O'Reilly did a special called The Corruption of the American Child - and I won't even go into the irony of Fox talking about corrupting other people when they invented Married with Children and Cops! and America's Greatest Car Chases . . . Jensen: Which by the way, I have to say that a lot of times when I am at the prison teaching, there is one class that has a TV in the room, and sometimes it's on when I go there... You would not believe how often they are watching Cops! I mean these are guys that are put away for life and they are still watching Cops! I can't believe it! Lapp�: Anyway he had this really fascinating look - basically a harangue in a sense - of popular American culture - from pro wrestling to gangster rap... basically critiquing the materialist, hyper-sexualized, hyper-violent culture that is out there which, in a sense, is the same culture that you are critiquing... Jensen: Well, I would add one thing. The thing I would add is that one of my favorite lines in the book are the two jokes: what do you get when you cross a long drug habit and a gun with a quick temper? Answer: two life terms for murder, earliest release date 2026. And question: what do you get when you cross two nation states, a large corporation, 40 tons of poison and 8,000 dead? Answer: retirement with full payment benefits. And so I would agree with him but I would take it much further because I would imagine unless I am - I would be totally surprised if his critique of violence included economic and environmental violence. Lapp�: Of course not, I am saying it was very particular in his target - he also brought up NAMBLA but the point is there is this interesting similarity on the fringes of what you could call traditional social conservatives, like Bill Bennett and O'Reilly, and liberals in the sort of feminist and sort of progressive humanism tradition, looking at America and what has become of American pop culture and the values that it is propagating to the world and our own youth, and are looking at it and saying, wait a minute - is it healthy? How do you explain the similarities between you agreeing with Bill O'Reilly or Bill Bennett? Jensen: Well, I would say that I don't . . . because I would say that one of the strongest mechanisms of propaganda is to take an underlying feeling and then put it in the wrong place . . . and I would say - I mean everybody knows that America is a really violent culture and if you could instead demonize these sometimes already marginalized people, such as youth - because also the facts just don't support a lot of the demonization of youth . . . Lapp�: But what I am saying is he wasn't demonizing youth - he was criticizing the people who are propagating this media... Jensen: Well, OK - then that's great, then just sort of excise the last thing I said . . .because the more important point is that there are 16,000 murders committed in this country every year and there are that many people that die every two weeks from preventable cancers. And so I would really like to see him rail against the tobacco industry executives and the chemical industry executives who have turned the entire world into a carcinogenic stew, because if you really want to talk about violence, then let's talk about the 15,000 Americans who die every year in automobile accidents - or 42,000 or whatever it is - that that is simply an accepted part of our life. So my point is that the place I would disagree with him is that there are some forms of violence to which he and most of us are almost entirely blind and I think that the forms of violence that we focus on oftentimes, can become distractions from the deeper issue, and I think they can take energy away from. It's like I have this inchoate feeling that there's a lot of violence in the culture - oh yeah, it must be Worldwide Wrestling Federation . . .and that gives me something to hang on to as opposed to hanging in there, doing the analysis and finding a deeper cause. Cont. Culture of Make Believe II Race, Murder and the Lies We Tell Ourselves Lapp�: Speaking of violence, you teach writing to inmates at one of the country's most notorious high security prisons (Pelican Bay State Prison, Cresent City, CA). What have you learned from them about violence in America? Jensen: One thing is that they are some of the most politicized people that I have ever met. There a very few patriots in prison, let me put it that way... and they frankly have a much more sophisticated approach to American foreign policy and American internal policy than most everybody else I have ever seen. And a more sophisticated approach to revolutionary violence also if I may be honest... that is some of them... and then some of them are crazy. My supervisor just said to me yesterday that the American prison system has become a repository for the insane and I think that's true. And I am not saying that all prisoners are insane by any means... I am just saying that there are a lot of them who have got some real psychological problems. And then another thing to say about all that is I've never actually been associated much with drug culture and it's not something I've ever thought about very much but I have become very politicized on that issue. 90% or more of my students are in there for drugs. Lapp�: Wow. Jensen: And a lot of them are in because of a drug deal gone bad and they killed somebody or whatever, but it's absolutely ridiculous. In fact, I think it was your mom who said to me that the penalty for somebody being caught with possession of drugs - they should sentence you to college. And I really like that! Lapp�: Well, now if you get caught in a drug felony, you can lose all of your federal grant money for college ... it's the exact opposite! Jensen: It's amazing. I mean a lot of these guys are really good guys... another thing is a lot of them have had really abysmal childhoods. I mean they make my childhood look positively happy. And there's also this culture of imprisonment because a lot of these guys are like, 'oh yeah, I got to see my brother the other day because he got transferred over...' I mean it's a family tradition. Their fathers were in prison, and their grandfathers...but if you want me to talk more about that, ask me a more direct question about violence... Lapp�: How is what you write about in this book influenced by what you learn from working with these inmates? He was like why are you always picking on whites? Why don't you pick on everybody else? Jensen: There are times when I would talk to them and they would bring up points that become chapters. Criminals and Killers, for example, was developed out of a conversation I had with one of my students where I was telling him about the book and he said, you know you're talking about this big economic violence but what about us? Frankly some of us are pretty nasty too and I think you need to talk about that...and of course he was right... He was like why are you always picking on whites? Why don't you pick on everybody else? So I was like, OK why do I pick on whites? So that's how all that developed... Lapp�: So what was your point in that chapter? Jensen: The point was that one of the reasons that I picked on white culture is because I am white and the old line by Jesus, better take the beam out of your own eye before you worry about somebody else's. And the other reason I deal with white culture is because it's killing the planet... and so I want to take care of the more immediate threat. As I say in the book, if I were stuck in a room with five African American guys that really hate white people, I would suddenly become very concerned about black racism. But frankly that's not the thing that's killing the planet. It's not black people who have enslaved white people. It's not American Indian culture that's killing the planet, it's civilization that is doing this. And I also don't particularly want to say white culture, because it's not that... I mean it's all bound up with whites but that ends up getting too easily confused, but white culture is fine. Lapp�: Right. The number one selling book in America right now is Stupid White Men, which I think is a fascinating commentary on what's going on... So let's jump to the present - to the current political climate ion the war on terror. One of the fascinating things that you wrote about that I knew little about was the Espionage Act. What did it allow the government to do and how is it relevant to what's going on today? Jensen: There was a really strong socialist and anarchist movement in the late 1800s early 1900s and... frankly whenever I start getting too optimistic and start thinking our rhetoric is improving - all I have to do is read some of the labor rhetoric from the 1890s. The Wobblies were very racially and gender-integrated and their rhetoric was wonderful. What they were really after was abolishing the wage system - they recognized the wage slavery was a form of slavery. And nowadays all people want is jobs. So we've gone way backwards. Anyway, so the socialists were really strong, the anarchists were really strong. And the capitalists had to do something about it. Europe was on verge of revolution. You can make a strong argument that WWI was brought about to stifle the revolutions. In fact pre-WWI, Europe was on the verge of revolution everywhere. You can make a strong argument that WWI was brought about to stifle the revolutions that were going to break out any time all over Europe. And what better way to stop the revolutionary fervor than by a long and pointless war and just lots and lots of pointless destruction. So that was the backdrop and then United States went into war in great measure to salvage the American economy because the JP Morgan and Co. which had controlled the corporate economy of the United States had loaned massive amounts of money to France and England and when France and England were about to go under, that would have made the American economy go under so the United States had to get into the war. The war was extremely unpopular - extremely unpopular. They wanted something like ten million recruits in the first 3 months and they got 100,000. And socialists were out explicitly going against the war and those in power realized that this was a good opportunity to break the resistance to capitalism. And so one of the ways they did that was through the Espionage Act of 1916, which made it illegal to criticize the war. And it was really ludicrous. Lapp�: Yeah, I had the same reaction. I never knew any of those particular stories and how outrageous... Jensen: I loved the one about United States versus Spirit of '76. This guy was imprisoned for making a film about the American Revolutionary War because it showed our British allies in a negative light. And his movie was called The Spirit of '76. The court case was actually entitled United States versus Spirit of '76. And the guy ended up getting sentenced to 10 years in prison. I mean there were other people sentenced to ten years for saying Wall Street is behind this war. Lapp�: Karl Rove and Co and Bush and Co have essentially created a climate where anyone who questions the administration in our war on terror is "giving aid and comfort to our enemies"... which is essentially what we saw going on back then. But what similarities do you see between the level of squelching of dissent today and looking back at the lessons from the Espionage Act? Jensen: Well, a couple things. One is that we need to - as you know from my work - it's really important for me to attempt to show historical continuity. And If you were an Indian sympathizer, that could get you in big trouble back a long time ago... and then there wasn't much worse in the American South than being a nigger lover in the 1860s-1920s, and these days it's the terrorists. Lapp�: But Derek, no one is shutting down GuerrillaNews.com. Your book has a publishing run of 35,000, you have a national advertising budget, you're doing interviews all over the country. I mean... They didn't have social security numbers, they didn't have state identification systems. They didn't have satellites. Jensen: I was sort of building up steam... and so yes I think that on one level, yes this is much less egregious than the Espionage Act. But on another level they didn't have social security numbers, they didn't have state identification systems. The American prison system was not as large as it is today. The point being - yes that was more egregious, but remember also that we as people were not so fully metabolized. I mean I knew this guy who back in 1980, would never give his social security number because he didn't want to be tracked...and he could still do that. Today of course - and he was a teacher at a school and I mean it was not a big deal. Today, they ask for your social security number on a check when you buy tacos. And there's the quote by Colin Powell about using social security numbers to track down people, track down and capture Americans. Fingerprints. They didn't have fingerprint technology back then... So my point is that yes, the Patriot Act is not as egregious as the Espionage Act, but ... we also have to remember the First World War. Somebody asked John Stockwell why the CIA hadn't killed him yet, and he said, "Because they're winning." We have to remember the Nietzsche quote that WWI was a real war with a real enemy who was shooting back. And you know the United States pretty much kills with impunity. The number of casualties in the World Trade Center - not to demean those individual lives - but the fact is that's peanuts compared to a. what the U.S. does routinely, and b. what happens in a real war . . . with you know WWI there was a lot more Americans that died. In Vietnam, a lot more Americans died. The point is that if anybody actually started fighting back. Somebody asked John Stockwell why the CIA hadn't killed him yet. He's a CIA guy who exposed them. He said, "Because they're winning." So I have no delusions about that, that I can keep doing my stuff. Eugene V. Debs wasn't arrested. He ran for president a few times and he wasn't arrested until there was a real shooting war going on. Do you see what I am getting at? That yes, you're absolutely right - the Espionage Act is way, way, way worse. But the groundwork has been laid for a much more intrusive system. They didn't have satellite tracking systems back then. I saw this article a few years ago back when Timothy McVeigh was still alive, basically slamming McVeigh for being crazy because he thought somebody put a chip in his head and then right next to it was this article how the technology is now available to put chips in pets. That was pretty clear to me that whoever designed that page was doing that on purpose. Lapp�: Right, and if it's available to veterinarian, it's been available to the military for thirty years. Jensen: And I am not saying that McVeigh had a chip in his head. I am saying that that technology is there. The capacity for repression is far more extreme than it was at that point. Lapp�: So to wrap it up, take me back to "The Culture of Make Believe" . . . Jensen: One of the things I hit in the book but I don't know if I hit it hard enough... but it just blew me away when I read it - was one of the things that the Nazis did very successfully was they co-opted rationality. And what they did was they made it so that every step of the way, it was not in the interest of the individual Jews or homosexuals or whatever group to resist. So it was rational . . . OK so do I need to get a national ID card or do I need to resist and probably get shot? I think I'll get an ID card. Do I need to move to the ghetto or resist and get shot? And actually many of them didn't resist until the doors shut on the showers and by then of course it was too late. But that's the only time they would start resisting... and it was not any sort of character flaw, it was because at every moment it was rational to not resist. There's a great line from Zygmunt Bauman that says rational people will go quietly and meekly into gas chambers if only they're allowed to believe that they are instead bathrooms. And I think that that's something else that we need to really strongly think about: that every step of the way it is in my interest to not resist the system. I mean God, can you imagine getting along without a social security number? That would be a big pain! Lapp�: And in the War on Terror, if you are an American, would you rather roll the dice and trust that the government is looking out to protect us, or get up there and from your point of view, critique your possible protectors? I hate to bring up Goebbels but that's what he was talking about - that if you can attack your opponents by being unpatriotic, it's the ultimate weapon . . . Jensen: Absolutely. I will admit publicly that I am not a patriot. I mean our government is a government of occupation and it's not just our government but the whole culture has been a culture of occupation. I mean any government of occupation would not destroy its land base . . . and would also value the lives of its citizens over production. But it clearly values production over lives. All we can do is to see those in power for who they are - see them naked and vulnerable and then to talk about it and that, one hopes, will lead to some form of action. You know we all have a choice every day where we are faced with the same choice that Ham had, which is we can either go along with the system and pretend that we don't see, or we can see and we can talk about it - and the wonderful thing about talking about it is that, when you live in a culture that is based on lies, that is based on this making believe, when someone does finally tell you the truth, it's like this huge weight goes off your shoulders. It's like, oh my god I can finally breathe! I have had certain writers who have done that for me and it feels so good. And I think that that is one of the most important things that we can do. Because it's very expensive to maintain a lie, very expensive psychically and very expensive economically and they have got money but they don't have truth . . . Lapp�: Excellent, let's leave it at that. Thank you very much. <A HREF="http://www.ctrl.org/">www.ctrl.org</A> DECLARATION & DISCLAIMER ========== CTRL is a discussion & informational exchange list. Proselytizing propagandic screeds are unwelcomed. Substance�not soap-boxing�please! These are sordid matters and 'conspiracy theory'�with its many half-truths, mis- directions and outright frauds�is used politically by different groups with major and minor effects spread throughout the spectrum of time and thought. That being said, CTRLgives no endorsement to the validity of posts, and always suggests to readers; be wary of what you read. CTRL gives no credence to Holocaust denial and nazi's need not apply. Let us please be civil and as always, Caveat Lector. ======================================================================== Archives Available at: http://peach.ease.lsoft.com/archives/ctrl.html <A HREF="http://peach.ease.lsoft.com/archives/ctrl.html">Archives of [EMAIL PROTECTED]</A> http:[EMAIL PROTECTED]/ <A HREF="http:[EMAIL PROTECTED]/">ctrl</A> ======================================================================== To subscribe to Conspiracy Theory Research List[CTRL] send email: SUBSCRIBE CTRL [to:] [EMAIL PROTECTED] To UNsubscribe to Conspiracy Theory Research List[CTRL] send email: SIGNOFF CTRL [to:] [EMAIL PROTECTED] Om
