On 6/15/07, Kirill Ponomarew <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:
On Fri, Jun 15, 2007 at 06:55:20PM +0400, Andrew Pantyukhin wrote:
> On 6/15/07, Kirill Ponomarew <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:
> > Andrew, please stop sending such kind of comments to
> > ports-committers@ alias, in this case it really should be sent
> > privately. But, frankly speaking, even if I get it privately, I'd
> > smile. You should really *think* before you mail your comments to
> > ports-committers list, these above comments are inappropriate here.
> >
> > Please move all you technical items for commits whether to ports@
> > and discuss it there, or privately, depending how *important* is
> > your comment. Inserting the coins for every commit and do it in
> > ports-committers@ is not what I expected while discussing technical
> > review explanations.
>
> I'm the one who sends most messages, but this is not
> a one-man effort. Many people read them, some comment
> on them - and we all learn. And this is the point:
> making committers aware of the amount of problems in
> our commits, discussing them together. I'm not an
> automated process, we must all learn from each other's
> mistakes, broadcasted to a list, because we just don't
> have enough human resources for private lessons.
Sorry, but it's high level crap to discuss here stuff like Approved
by: "pointyhat via kris", "pointyhat", "portsmon via linimon" or
just "portsmon". I don't want to see here the "yet another policy
and discussion how to write Approved by: line", should I write pav@
or just pav, "via" kris or just kris. Andrew, I'm just repeating,
these are crap comments and they shouldn't belong to
ports-committers list.
I get your message, I'll try to raise a bar a bit
for qualifying comments on this front.
> As for the mailing-list, I think ports-committers is
> the most appropriate one because this is primarily an
> inter-committer process.
You can't even really imagine how many users read ports-committers
list just to know the changes in the ports tree. They're not
interested in the above notes. So, please respect our users as well
and don't think only about committers guys.
Try to use threaded mode or something. You're right, a lot
of people are subscribed. I expected some of them to be
extremely annoyed by my "spam". I'm sorry for that. Right
now I'm just happy that you're the only one who have voiced
it.
_______________________________________________
[email protected] mailing list
http://lists.freebsd.org/mailman/listinfo/cvs-all
To unsubscribe, send any mail to "[EMAIL PROTECTED]"
