I have only 3rd ed rules, but I think he may be right.
12.5 When several units attack several defending units
the attacker has the choice of how to divide combat
provided:
12.51 he attacks every defending unit he has moved
adjacent to,
12.52 all his units in enemy ZOC attack some enemy
unit,
12.53 each attacking unit is adjacent to the specific
defending unit it is attacking.
so it seems a combined attack could be OK
then in the Stuka rules
15.3 A Stuka can take part in a battle only if all the
Russian defenders in that battle are within 8 hexes of
the same German Army Group Headquarters counter. The
Stuka attacks by being placed on the defending Russian
units (if more than one stack of Russians are being
attacked together, the Stuka is placed on any of the
defending stacks). No more than one Stuka unit may
trace its range from the same Headquarters unit. On
the first impulse of the game the Stukas may be used
against any Military District in range.
winter.
So a Stuka can definitely effect a multi-hex defenders
--- banfus2 <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:
> Hi all,
>
> we are looking for a clarification on TRC rules.
>
> We are playing TRC within IV edition rule
>
> Rule 12.2 says:
> "Multiple attacking units in the same hex may attack
> adjacent defenders
> in different hexes"
> "Multiple defending units in the same hex must have
> their combat
> factors added in one combined factor."
>
> We have hex A with two 4-4 German inf army near to
> hex B (with one 4-4
> Russian inf army) and to hex C (with another 4-4
> Russian inf army)
>
> Now every German units need to attack and every
> Russian uint need to be
> attacked.
>
> My understanding was that we have TWO attacks 1:1
> and 1:1. If the Axis
> player uses a Stuka unit can improve one of two
> attack from 1:1 to 4:1
> The ohter one still remain 1:1
>
> My opponent wants to combine both attacking units
> and both defending
> units in ONLY one combat.
> 8:8 --> 1:1 with stuka 4:1
>
> Which are your comments?
>
> Thanks in advance
>
> Antonio Di Giacomo (Banfus)
>
>
>
Get the name you always wanted with the new y7mail email address.
www.yahoo7.com.au/y7mail
