X-Loop: openpgp.net
From: Jim Choate <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>

> > You have some weird definitions. Blackmail: asking someone to pay you in
> > return of NOT divulging some information.
>
> That is a incomplete description. Blackmail is extortion. What you are
> extorting is money so that the party being threatened is not harmed. The
> fact that they are harmed by their own actions doesn't abosolve you from
> the guilt of your actions.

The difference between blackmail and extortion is that in the first, I'm
asking payment for something I'm legally entitled to do. [Since our first
emails about this, I have received some snail mail from Walter Block,
containing a bunch of articles about this. Some of them are webbed, I
think - you should look for them. You might learn something.]

Back to what I was saying: if saying something I know isn't illegal, and
asking money for a service isn't illegal, why is it illegal to ask money for
the service of NOT saying something?

> But not speaking is not what you're selling, the release from harm is what
> you're selling.

No. I'm no doctor. I'm selling my right to speak.

> You're simplistic and incomplete reasoning not withstanding.

It's "your", Jim.

Mark


Reply via email to